Beauty Box 5 Subscription Review + Coupon – September 2016

ByLiz CadmanSep 17, 2016 | 22 comments

beauty-box-five-september-2016-001

Beauty Box 5 is a subscription box that sends 5 deluxe & full-sized products to your door each month. You receive a mix of products ranging from makeup, hair care, skincare, nail polish, beauty tools, and fragrances. Luxury, drugstore & Indie brands are included.

This box was sent to us for review purposes. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

beauty-box-five-september-2016-002

The Subscription Box: Beauty Box 5

Cost: $12.00 per month, $30 for 3 months & $99 for 12 months. Shipping is free if it's within the US and $3.00 shipping for Canada

COUPON: Receive a free bonus Marsk Mineral Eyeshadow in your first box! ($24 value). No coupon needed, just subscribe here!

Products: 5 deluxe & full-size makeup, hair care, skincare, nail polish, beauty tools and fragrance products

Ships to: the lower 48 United States and Canada. Currently unable to ship to AK, HI, APO, and overseas.

Check out all of our Beauty Box 5 reviews and our Beauty Subscription Box Directory for more beauty boxes!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

beauty-box-five-september-2016-003

Each Beauty Box 5 comes with a description card. This month's theme is Staff Picks!

beauty-box-five-september-2016-004

Now, onto the items!

beauty-box-five-september-2016-005

Pur-lisse Blue Lotus Essential Daily Moisturizer - 15 ml (Travel size) Value $20

(Good to know for swaps - inner foil seal)

This is a great daily moisturizer with SPF 30. The formula is gentle and non-greasy, too. I get a lot of Pur-lisse in subscription boxes, but I've been impressed with every product I'm sampled from them, so I'm always happy to see more!

beauty-box-five-september-2016-007

Be a Bombshell Smooth Criminal HD Finishing Powder - 4 grams Value $7

beauty-box-five-september-2016-008

This powder is made from 100% silica powder, and the formula is a super fine powder that goes on smoothly. Be a Bombshell cosmetics isn't my favorite cosmetics brand (usually, the ingredients/packaging can seem cheap), but this formula seems on par with my more expensive finishing powders! It helped mattify my skin, and it set my makeup well.

beauty-box-five-september-2016-009

Simple Cleansing Facial Wipes – 7 wipes Value $1.25

I’ve sampled these before and I'm happy to have more. The wipes are gentle on my skin and remove makeup well.

beauty-box-five-september-2016-010

Happy Hair Turban - Value $18

This is a terry towel hair wrap that helps with drying your hair and preventing frizz.

I've sampled a similar towel before thanks to the Summer Box of Style, and I really like it! It's also great for applying hair masks to make sure the mask stays in place while you wait!

And here is the spoiler gif from Beauty Box 5 showing how to put it on:

happy_hair_turban_peek (1)

Go Smile Teeth Whitening Gel - .5 oz Value $4.25

(Good to know for swaps - inner foil seal)

FYI - this is just whitening gel, not toothpaste, so to use they recommend combining equal parts of this gel and toothpaste to a dry toothbrush. I've used this gel before, and while I can't say I noticed any whitening differences, I like using products like this to help fight tea/coffee stains.

Verdict: This month's Beauty Box 5 has a value of about $50! I think that's great for a $12 box, and I can see why these products are staff favorites. Even though there weren't many new discoveries for me this month, I'll use everything in the box!

What do you think about the September Beauty Box 5? Did you like this month’s box?

Starting at $12.00

Active Deal

Receive a free bonus Marsk Mineral Eyeshadow in your first box! ($24 value)

Subscribe Now

Beauty Box 5

3.3 overall rating

204 Ratings | 52 Reviews

Beauty Box 5 is one of the most inexpensive beauty and makeup subscription boxes. It's $10 a month for a 3-month subscription, or $8.25 a month with an annual subscription.

Read customer reviews >

Posted in Beauty Subscription Boxes, Makeup Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Read More By Liz Cadman >

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Notify me of follow-up comments by email

22 comments

Teena in Toronto

My box arrived today!

Kay

I broke down and ordered 3 months, hopefully I get the September box as I signed up before the 21st and the bonus item. The turban is what I am looking forward to! Quick question – is the shipping box size comparable to Birchbox or Allure? My mailbox is relatively small, so hopefully it fits.

Jessica

The boxes I have been getting a small size. they are shaped like the boxes you would get new checks in from your bank. but they are bigger. they have jam packed them full so far when the turban came the box was overflowing.

Kay

Thanks Jessica! I think it will fit my small mail box 🙂

Jessica

I really like this box. I signed up for a bunch of beauty boxes (ipsy, boxycharm, glossy box, sephora, walmart, target, allure, birchbox- and probably a few others I’m not thinking of). This has actually been one of my favorite boxes to get mostly because the items have been useful as a whole for me compared to other boxes where I may only like one or two things. In any case, i have already cancelled birchbox, boxycharm, and allure. I will probably also be cancelling sephora (will give one more month to try). In any case, because of how useful i’ve found this box, i went ahead and signed up for a year to make it a bit cheaper. I think this box is totally underrated and it’s too bad, because I think it’s a great value.

Kim

Is it too late to subscribe for the September box?

Angela

If I were you I wouldn’t subscribe!!!!! They have poor customer service I received the August box and I cancelled on my account page for me not to receive the boxes anymore and come September i received a box contacted my bank and found they took out the money for the box so I contacted customer service and they told me that I have to email them in order to cancel the subscription so I asked why is that not specified and why is there a cancel my account button then so after two hours of going back and forth I called 4 times and never got anyone on the phone and never got a call back I think it’s outrageous what they did I will not sure subscribe to them again!!!!! Very very bad experience with them!!!!!

Kim

Nevermind, I just found the answer. If you sign up by the 21st, you can get this month’s box!

Trish

I tried the Be a Bombshell Smooth Criminal finishing powder and I have no complaints! It set my under eye concealer no problem and looked great. I use a turban towel everyday either to dry my hair or to protect it from getting sprayed in the shower on days that I’m not washing my hair.
Great box this month!

Alice

Oh wow this box is stepping it up while some of the other subs are cascading downward. Interesting…I need to decide what to cancel before I sub tho!

MzBev

That’s where I am with this! Either Boxy or Play! will need to go before I take the plunge. I have FOMO with both granted less of it with the Play box.

Wendy

I received my first box today. I got the bonus eyeshadow. I don’t know anyone who would pay $24.00 for this. Mine is a horrible white and has an awful feeling formula with super cheap packaging. The be a bombshell finishing powder is chalky feeling, also with cheap packaging. The turban is worthless for waist length hair. So I will be using nothing from this box. Everything is cheap and a huge let down.

Ragan

This box has been looking a lot better lately. Back when I subscribed they sent me two sets of toe separators in three months.

For BaB products, at least in my experience, it seems that the dry powder products are all right — or even pretty good — and it is the wet(ish) ones (like those awful One Sticks or the stinky mascara from that one ipsy bag) that I don’t care for.

Donna

I was going to sign up for 3 months because of the free eyeshadow deal but I didn’t see any mention of it. I used the link too. Decided to wait, I sent them an e-mail to double check.

I used the link to sign up for my subscription and I received the eyeshadow in my box. Unfortunately, the shade is literally white (it’s called Vanilla Frosting) and doesn’t work for me because I have a very pale complexion and the color doesn’t show up.

JenMags

Does everyone get the same box or will there be box envy like Sephora and Birchbox?

lilsmomxo

Everyone gets the same stuff! Occasionally they will send out various shades of a product (eyeshadow, lipstick etc.) But everyone recieves the same items! One of the things I love about this sub!

bunnygirlbrem

I decided to cancel Sephora and get this instead. There just hasn’t been anything I’ve liked in Sephora since I’ve been getting it.

I used the link above for the free eye shadow and didn’t notice anything about receiving it. Hope i do!

carey

Yep, you will receive the eyeshadow in your next box. I was worried when I first subbed and didnt see note of it I emailed and they got right back to me with that response and it was in fact in the next box. I have been subbing to this all year and I really really like it. They have a great value and if you don’t want the item they usually swap pretty well.

For the price you cant beat it. lol I have literally tried EVERY beauty box out there and this one I have kept which says something. Customer service has been top notch too. 🙂

Christi

Where do y’all swap your items? I’m fairly new to this. I’ve only been subbing to boxes for 6 months but in those 6 months I’ve come across tons of stuff I know that just won’t work for me or I won’t use. And I keep seeing people talk about swapping but I have no clue what they mean by that or how they are going about it. Lol

bunnygirlbrem

Good to know! Thanks!

Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Beauty Box 5 Subscription Review + Coupon – September 2016

Advertise With MSA

Information

Company