MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box Unboxing #2 + Giveaway!

PS Asst 1-027

UPDATED! We now have received all of the variations of the POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box from POPSUGAR to show what you may receive in your mystery box.

Here are the 8 different boxes:

popsugar-all-star-mystery-box-1

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box 1:

Dominique Ansel: The Secret Recipes – Retail Value $35 (From the November 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

Wine Glass Writer – Value $10 (From the November 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

Tarte Cosmetics Beauty & the Box Eye Shadow – Retail Value $22 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard – Value $7.30 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Deepa Gurnani Katie Crystal Headband – Value $56 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Capri Blue Mercury Jewel Box Candle in Rain – Value $18 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Total Retail Value: $148

popsugar-all-star-mystery-box-2

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box 2:

Capri Blue Mercury Jewel Box Candle in Rain – Value $18 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Govino Go Anywhere Wine Glasses – Value $22.95 (From the POPSUGAR Today Show Box)

Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard – Value $7.30 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Barr-Co Fir and Grapefruit Bubble Elixir – Value $32 (From the POPSUGAR Today Show Box)

Tiny Prints Thoughtful Heart Stationery – Value $15 (From the November 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

Deepa Gurnani Katie Crystal Headband – Value $56 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Total Retail Value: $151

popsugar-all-star-mystery-box-3

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box 3:

Capri Blue Mercury Jewel Box Candle in Rain – Value $18 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Tarte Cosmetics Beauty & the Box Eye Shadow – Retail Value $22 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Barr-Co Fir and Grapefruit Bubble Elixir – Value $32 (From the POPSUGAR Today Show Box)

Tiny Prints Thoughtful Heart Stationery – Value $15 (From the November 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard – Value $7.30 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Deepa Gurnani Katie Crystal Headband – Value $56 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Total Retail Value: $150

popsugar-all-star-mystery-box-4

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box 4:

Wine Glass Writer – Value $10 (From the November 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

Tarte Cosmetics Beauty & the Box Eye Shadow – Retail Value $22 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Capri Blue Mercury Jewel Box Candle in Rain – Value $18 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard – Value $7.30

K. Hall Simpatico Ambergris Shea Butter Cream – Value $22 (From the November 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

Deepa Gurnani Katie Crystal Headband – Value $56 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Total Retail Value: $135

popsugar-all-star-mystery-box-5

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box 5:

Deepa Gurnani Katie Crystal Headband – Value $56 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Barr-Co Fir and Grapefruit Bubble Elixir – Value $32 (From the POPSUGAR Today Show Box)

Govino Go Anywhere Wine Glasses – Value $22.95 (From the POPSUGAR Today Show Box)

Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard – Value $7.30 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Tarte Cosmetics Beauty & the Box Eye Shadow – Retail Value $22 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Capri Blue Mercury Jewel Box Candle in Rain – Value $18 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Total Retail Value: $158

More Popsugar Mystery Boxes-100 (1)

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box 6:

Spark Joy by Marie Kondo – Retail Value $18.99 (From the January 2016 POPSUGAR Box)

Nima Oberoi Lunares Geo Stopper – Value $24 (From the December 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Not Soap, Radio Bath and Shower Gel Gift Set  – Retail Value $22 (From the January 2016 POPSUGAR Box)

Isaac Jacobs Acrylic Magnet Photo Frame Value $36 (From the October 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

Happy Socks Value $12 (From the October 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

Mine Chalkboard Soy Message Ceramic Candle – Value $24 (From the October 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

Total Retail Value: $137

More Popsugar Mystery Boxes-093 (1)

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box 7:

Isaac Jacobs Acrylic Magnet Photo Frame Value $36 (From the October 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

k. hall designs Shea Butter / Olive Oil Soap – Value $10 (From the October 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

Tarte Cosmetics Beauty & the Box Eye Shadow – Retail Value $22 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

ACME Party Box Company Chevron Straws – Value $7 (From the July 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

Patchology FlashMasque Trio – $20 Value (From the January 2016 POPSUGAR Box)

Pehr Designs Pebble Speck Bin – Value $40 (From the January 2016 POPSUGAR Box)

Total Retail Value: $135

More Popsugar Mystery Boxes-080

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box 8:

Swing Design Nova Blue Mist Jewelry Box – Value $36 (From the December 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Project & INC Summer Snow Sugar Free Gum – Value $2 (From the January 2016 POPSUGAR Box)

Stowaway Creme Lipstick Trio – Value $30 (From the December 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Mine Chalkboard Soy Message Ceramic Candle – Value $24 (From the October 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

k. hall designs Shea Butter / Olive Oil Soap – Value $10 (From the October 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

LUV AJ The Rose Gold Ombre Bracelet – Value $65 (From the December 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Total Retail Value: $167

 

UPDATE! Not pictured:

POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box 9:

Capri Blue Mercury Jewel Box Candle in Rain – Value $18 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Govino Go Anywhere Wine Glasses – Value $22.95 (From the POPSUGAR Today Show Box)

Terrapin Ridge Farms Pecan Honey Mustard – Value $7.30 (From the November 2015 POPSUGAR Box)

Barr-Co Fir and Grapefruit Bubble Elixir – Value $32 (From the POPSUGAR Today Show Box)

Tilo Modal Gradation Scarf in Raisin – Value $125 (From the September 2014 POPSUGAR Box)

Kocostar Foot Therapy – Value $10 (From the May 2016 POPSUGAR Box)

Total Retail Value: $215

 

FYI – this box was $19.95 and no longer for sale.

What did you get in your POPSUGAR Must Have All-Star Mystery Box(es)?

And now it is giveaway time! We’re going to put a lot of these items together for a Super POPSUGAR Must Have Box Mystery Box!

Enter the giveaway below and good luck! (Winner will be contacted by email – make sure to enter with an email account you check frequently).

If you do the refer-a-friend entry option in this giveaway, you’ll get the entries for that once the friend has entered the giveaway. Giveaway is open only to US residents 18 and over.
a Rafflecopter giveaway

POPSUGAR Must Have

How do subscribers rate POPSUGAR Must Have?

Shipping
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Curation
Ease of canceling

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about POPSUGAR Must Have!

Enable notifications () to get the latest POPSUGAR Must Have spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.


Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in POPSUGAR Must Have Box Reviews, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women| Tags: POPSUGAR Must Have Box | 237 comments

Comments (237)

  1. I finally got my box – I was so excited to finally get it (my original shipment was delivered to the wrong house and ‘irretrievable’ as per USPS) – popsugar was kind enough to send another. This was my birthday treat. I haven’t subscribed to popsugar in a long time so was excited for a box that I could afford. I am grateful but so wondering if I would’ve liked the other box better. I just don’t like most of this. I don’t drink wine… And my box has: 1) lands end wine bottle carrier (I already got this v’s gifted way back when) 2) wine glass writers 3) wine bottle stopper 4) happy socks 5) the Gurnani crystal headband – the one thing I might use. Anyways you win some, you lose some!

  2. Hey! I got box number 2 but the mustard came broken so I emailed popsugar and they told me my replacement mustard is on the way. 15 days later I get a box from popsugar that isn’t mustard. (I’m not complaining!!)
    In my box I got
    -Beyond cleansing- spongelike papaya yuzu buffer
    – lunares Apple “plate”(?)
    – NCLA cuticle oil
    – K.hall designs peony candle
    -Briogeo Rosario milk, leave in conditioning spray
    – Kendra Scott Ella white pearl earring. ($55)

    I don’t know the total value but I’m pretty sure this is an amazing box! I have pictures if you would like.
    (My first box came from New York and this second box came for California)

  3. My boxed shipped on 7/15 from California 3.2lbs. Still haven’t received it!! I’m in Hawaii. Anyone know what I’ll be getting? Thanks in advance!!

  4. I caught the mailman in time bagging the Popsugar boxto return to Company because it is leaking fluid. He was upset because the box did not label fragile items inside. I told him, I’ll take the box and I’ll contact them about the problem. I open it up and it was Box 2, the soap was not bubble wrap so it broke and everything was covered in soap. Waiting for replacement box, been 07/21. Anybody received their replacement box yet??

  5. How cool is this? I got a random package in the mail from POPSugar that contained a Pehr Bin with a note saying “Thank you for being a valued customer”! I got a Pehr bin in one of my Mystery boxes and ended up loving it and this little extra just made my day! I know POPSugar has had a lot of complaints for various reasons bust so far, they have been fine by me! I think I read that someone else got a special package that had the wine glasses in it as well. How cool!

    • Great to hear! And those Pehr bins are the best!! 🙂

  6. I got box 7 yesterday. Does anyone know if the straws are reusable or one time use? I think they are adorable I hope we can reuse them, my girls will love them. Tia

    • One time use. But, they are really cute!

  7. I got box 7 and I couldn’t be happier about it (unless they had made a mistake and also slipped in one of the headbands 😉 )

  8. I’m very happy! Mine finally arrived today. I got #7 and I will use everything. ? This was a great deal for my first box from them.

  9. Got box #7 with purple colors for the tart eyeshadow. My box weight was 3.1

  10. I got box #1, and I have to say that I’m super disappointed about the cookbook. I got the cookbook in the November 2014 box and I literally can’t give it away. I’ve tried. Now I have two. Boo. The rest of the stuff in the box seems pretty good, though!

  11. I really wanted the cookbook, it doesn’t seem like many got it.

    • I got it…didn’t want it lol

      • I didn’t want the cookbook either, but I still got it … 🙁

  12. I got box number 2! My headband arrived broken and I emailed them and almost right away they emailed me back and said a replacement would be on the way. First experience with customer service was great!

  13. I know I am late to the party but my box just arrived. I’m on east coast and I have the 3.1 box from CA. It’s box #7 and I am just thrilled with everything in it. I was so worried with this 100 degree heat that I’d open the box to see melted wax or mustard over everything but I received the one box I really wanted with nothing to spill or melt. I still can’t believe this was only $20! I will use everything: the frame, soap, masque trio, straws, and the pehr bin which will go perfectly in my powder room.

  14. I Don’t Receive Any Subscription Boxes but I Always Said that if I Could the 2 that I Have Always Wanted to Try the Most Would Be the Julep Maven Box b/c I Just Think Their Polish is Beautiful and the PopSugar Must Have Box b/c They Have All of My Favorite Things Like Makeup, Beauty Products, Things for the Home, & Even Books, Which is My Favorite Part Next to the Makeup! Thanks So Much for Giving Me the Chance to Try it Before I Buy it, LOL! I Think it’s Very Kind of You & I Really Appreciate it! Thanks Again, Have a Safe & Happy Summer! – Jana

  15. I was supposed to get Box 2 but I checked the tracking and FedEx has it listed as Damaged and deliverable. I contacted PSMH last week and they have yet to get back to me or refund my money. Any suggestions??

  16. I received Box Number 8 and unfortunately was the only one I was hoping not to get. Would be willing to swap the entire box for another one if anyone is interested!

    Would love Box, 5, 2, 3, 9 (even without scarf) and even consider 1 and 4.

    just let me know 🙂

    • I got box #1 and hated it, I already used the headband though but I would be willing to send you everything else for just the jewelry box in yours.

      • Oops, I forgot I used the eyeshadow too :/

  17. I got boxes 6 and 7 and will put a few up for swaps but I really like most of what I got. I got 2 of the frames, will put one for swap, its really nice. It would make a great gift. Surprisingly, the candle didn’t melt.

  18. I got #8. Wonderful value, I just would never use the bracelet or jewelry box I’ll have to gift those. The candle smells really perfumey and would probably gift as well but it melted some in the sun and the box has a stain on top. I really wanted the headband or mustard or wine glasses. Oh well can’t really complain! I’ve never been to the swap site does anyone think I could get something nice for the box or bracelet or candle?

  19. Got my 5.1 lb box from NY today ! It was box #2 ! Everything intact but the original tape was cut and re-taped . Strange ! Doesn’t look like anything was missing so all good ! ?

  20. Funny – the only jewelry they sent was the Love AJ bracelet. They have had lots of other jewelry pieces in their boxes.
    Maybe they will do this again with a jewelry surprise box.

  21. If anyone has boxes #1-5 that they’d like to sell, I’d be interested in buying one. Bonus points if you’re in VA/DC so I could drive to pick it up! ([email protected])

  22. I got box 7 but with the purple version of the Tarte eyeshadow palette (“Eye Candy”) which I am looking to trade for something of equal value (maybe the stationary and something else small or the shower gel set?). Retail value on the shadow is $22.

    I am unable to post on the swap section of this site since I am currently on the waiting list but it anyone wants to work out a trade, let me know!

  23. I got box 2 I’m debating if I will keep, swap or sale

  24. I received my 2 boxes today, I got 6 & 7 ?

  25. Still waiting for my box. Its 3.1. I wish I new what box it was. Wow so many variations.

  26. I got box #6 and #7 both came from California and I’m in Austin, TX. The candle arrived perfectly, glad it wasn’t melted or broken. I wanted the headband soo bad, oh well, ended up with two picture frames. I suppose those can be given away for gifts. Guess I’ll try and find the headband on amazon. It was still fun to get two mystery boxes.

    • If you head over to the Saks Off Fifth in the Gateway shopping center (183/360) they have TONS of Deepa Gurnani headbands!!

  27. Today I got 4 pound box from Cali and it was Box 6 from pictures.

  28. Mine came today,it was 3.1 from Gilroy CA; its box #7 and I love it. I was hoping for #7 or #8

  29. Mine was 5.2 lbs from NY. It turned out to be Box #1!!! That’s the one I wanted because its came with the pastry cookbook and the Tart makeup! Sweet!!! I’m so happy. This and box #9 were the two boxes I was drooling over.

    • I want to add that I live in CA. The eyeshadow, mustard and candle were all wrapped in bubble wrap and nothing broke in transit. The candle was sweaty though.

      Surprisingly what I ended up liking the most is the headband. It’s gorgeous!

  30. Just my luck, I get the one box out of the 9 I didn’t like after seeing the spoilers. Oh Well, will think 2x next time because I won’t use anything out of mine. I got a candle that is soft and melted.

    • Was there a particular item you were really hoping for?

  31. I got boxes 6 and 7 today, and I am thrilled! They were the ones I wanted, and everything was in good shape despite the heat!

  32. My box FINALLY arrived!!!! I received box 2. Mine came from NY it was 4.9 but changed to 5.1. I am thrilled and SHOCKED nothing was broken or melted and everything was wrapped in bubble wrap. I am so happy the glasses and bubble bath are new items for me. I LOVE LOVE LOVE the mustard so happy to have more. The cards are useful and the headband will be great to gift or keep incase my first one ever breaks! I wear it all the time. I am one happy girl!

  33. I got box #2 and nothing was wrapped. But everything was in perfect condition. So pleased! But so sad I only bought one. Oh well, if they do it again I will order more. Maybe in a couple of years? Oh and my sister turned her headband into a wrap bracelet. She cut off the elastic and sewed narrow ribbons to each end. It looks adorable!

  34. I finally got mine yesterday! #7 I wanted a candle so bad, but I actually love everything. The bin is amazing. The eyeshawdows or gorgeous. So happy. One of the target boxes is waiting for me at home. I also have amazon arriving tomorrow. 3 days in a row presents for me! YAY!

  35. I got #7. This was my first popsugar box. Was really hoping for the jewelry box once I saw this review..if anyone has it and wants to trade for something in #7 just let me know ?

  36. Update: I received mine by mail (not FedEx but USPS) today, Sat 23rd instead of Mon 25th..box was 3.1 lbs and I received all items from #8:
    Jewelry box, bracelet, candle, lipstick trio, soap, & gum. Delivered from Gilroy, CA. to here in HOT HUMID Louisiana with all items intact.. ☺ good luck ladies on hopefully receiving the box you want!!

  37. I would love to receive bubble bath, a pehr bin, gum, or the raisin scarf. Pretty much any box besides 1, 4, or 5 would be great. I ordered two, both are coming from California: 3.1 and 4.

  38. I received Boxes #1, 2, 4, 7 and 8. All in all a win for me! I was hoping to get the organizing book but alas, no. I did get the Dominique Ansel book and I can’t wait to start baking!
    This was a smart move for Popsugar, it got everyone on the forum excited, they generated a good amount of revenue and got rid of old inventory.
    This could have gone either way for them but thankfully, the items sent were good quality and curation of the boxes were solid, homogenous to an extent that we can know what to expect, the variations were predictable so nobody felt the awful FOMO or “box envy”. There will always be people who are always disappointed, if they win $1 million in the lottery they will be upset that they didn’t win $2 million. 🙂
    For $20 per box, there is really no way to lose. Thanks Popsugar!

  39. My box finally arrived today, box #2. Govino vine glasses are the only repeats for me. I actually got the govino flutes before and brought these on amazon right after. My candle exploded like a lot of others did, so I emailed them pictures. Hopefully they will send me out a new new soon.

    • *wine*

  40. My box number is seven showed up today. It was the one that I wanted until I saw box number nine. ? I was excited especially for the tarte eyeshadow but I ended up getting one that has greens and instead of browns. ? That might be too far out of my comfort zone. I’m kind of disappointed that pop sugar decided to send out one box that was worth so much more than the rest of them.

    • What is the name of the green tarte quad? I got eye candy and apple of my eye.

      • Mine is eye candy. I just opened it and was wrong. It is pink and brown tones. Much more in my wheelhouse. Somewhere online it shows eye candy as the green palette.

  41. I got box #8 which was 3.2lb today.

  42. I received box #7 and I’m super happy. Love the bin & photo frame for the new house we’re moving into in 3 weeks & the kids will love the super pretty straws & I’m pleased with the soap, masks, & eye shadow. LOVE. I SO wish I had ordered 2 boxes.

  43. I got box 2 and am very happy about it! Would have preferred 2 for the Tarte eyeshadow. This is my first experience with popsugar and I’m very happy! Nothing broken in my box. LOVE the Barr Co bubble bath- had my eye on it for a while. Also love the headband and candle. Lots of great things for a good price!

  44. I received box 8. It’s was a horrible experience and will not buy from them again. With all the damage it going to cost me, this company and box is not worth it. I live in phoenix, 100° and above and you send me a candle. REALLY!!! I was coming home from work and I picked up my mail. I set it on the passenger seat. Who had wax all over the sit?!? This girl!!! When I noticed I threw it down where your feet go, but damage was done. :'(

  45. I received #7. I really wanted the bracelet,the headband,the mustard or the Not Soap bath and body gel. Oh well…you win some, you lose some.

  46. Got #7 today – glad I ordered the headband off of ebay since it wasn’t in my box. Now I’ll just have to track down the candle and buy some mustard and I’ll be all set 🙂

    So much for a $20 box LOL – buying all the stuff I ‘could of had’ is going to add up!

  47. I got mine from California yesterday. 3.1 and 4 lbs, and they were #6 and #7

    I feel like I’m the only person (especially with more than one box) that didn’t get mustard or the headband. HAHA!

    • I got my boxes and I got the same as you! I really wanted that headband and the mustard. My candle arrived melted all over but everything else is in good condition. I emails CS to see if I could get a replacement candle or a headband…..fingers crossed. The Texas heat was no match for the candle even though I got my boxes as soon as the mailman arrived! I’m happy with my boxes and can gift or swap items.

  48. Love this site! I check it everyday!

  49. I got one box (6) on Monday and it just seemed meh, so much practical stuff not much luxury. Received my second box (4) today and was much happier even though I already had four of the items, can’t explain it. Very happy to have the wine writers and hand cream. Had previously received other items at the holidays (I think they had a sale on the November box?) and when they did a sale after the new year so I guess I have a lot to swap? I had hoped desperately for a cookbook but oh well. Now to figure out the swap thing! 🙂

    • I received both my boxes today. Box 6 and 7. (3.1 and 4.0 from California, forget which is which) I personally like 7 better, the bin is gorgeous and very thick material, it’s just beautiful! My 14 year old already claimed the things she wants, lol. The makeup of course and she wants the candle. I told her she should read the book hahahaha. I was hoping for the headband, mustard or jewelry but oh well can’t get everything, overall I’m pleased. I would buy more if they ever offer this again.

    • I have never swapped before. I got the cookbook box and will use nothing. It had stuff I didn’t like the first time I received it. My luck I get the 1 out of the 9 I was praying I didn’t get. Maybe we can do a trade or something. Just an FYI book is heavy

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.