Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I know 200$ seems steep for a box but Clare v fold overs are gorgeous they retail starting at 235$ plus tax In store.
Liz have you heard anything back from the people of the vogue box? Just wondering if there will really be any bonuses.
Reply
Traci Rhein
I don’t think people are questioning the price as much as they are questioning the vagueness of what you’re getting. Lots of people on here are already schilling out a lot of money on all sorts of things and are willing to pay for value but after Oprah scammed people for $200 they are a bit gun shy to be scammed twice. Even if the initial cost is covered by the bag people are having tons of problems with subscription boxes not sending things or having ridiculous cancellation policies that are impossible to get out of. Just my take
Reply
Starla
If someone walked up to me and handed me $200 and said “waste this money”, I STILL wouldn’t buy this! :/
Reply
Traci
Holy cow, just went and read the entirety of the Oprah subscription scam and all I have to say is…..WOW! Sorry Vogue, being vague with a bunch of people still applying their Vaseline from the Oprah burn may not be the wisest business venture right now…….unless you’re planning on sending Preparation H as a “surprise!”
Reply
Kimberli
Ok, someone please fill me in on the Oprah incident.
Reply
Luna
It looks like if you type “Oprah” in the Search field there are some MSA reviews on the Oprah Circle of Friends subscription box that was around last year. I don’t know the story, but am curious too, so I’m going to read the reviews now. 🙂
Reply
S
This sounds like the Oprah box that was a complete disaster! A clutch and non descriptive “exclusives” lead me to a big ‘ol.. NO WAY!!
Do they not realize that there’s PS that frequently includes clutches AND several items for $40?
Reply
Krista
Exactly what I thought of too.
Reply
Constance
Is this for reals? $200?! No thanks.
Reply
Rachel
A magazine subscription? Like we don’t have the Internet? Hahaha! This isn’t going to take off
Reply
Serena
I seriously see no appeal here. A clutch and some magazines, really? Whoever put this together is very out of touch.
Reply
rosalita
I got the email about this and still can’t figure out how they think they are going to get people to spend $200. They keep trying to get me to renew my mag subscription for Vogue and W for $10 each per year. What do they plan on sending to equal $190?
NOPE.
Reply
Heather
Someone at Vogue actually thought this was a good deal! WOW. I might have made some silly sub box purchases in the past, but this one is not even interesting in the slightest for $200.
Reply
Barbie
I don’t think this one’s for me, even if I did have the funds to sub.
The clutch is gorgeous, but IMHO it’s not worth $200 to me to have it. A magazine subscription is almost worthless as you can get tons of free magazine subs from all over (including Vogue). I’ve never seen their special editions, so I can’t comment on those, but the q & a’s – Who’s to say that they will ever get to one of your questions. The exclusive gifts & offers, I’m sorry, they almost HAVE to be more forthcoming as to what kind of perks & gifts they’re offering.
At this price point, they are going to have to be off the charts FABULOUS, and they are going to have to promote the crap of it to make enough people want this enough to pay that much up front.
Reply
Sara
I do love Clare V, so it’s rather unfortunate that Vogue chose to spotlight this clutch with this crazy “deal.”
Reply
Stephanie
Hahahahahahahaha………No.
Reply
Beth
That was my exact reaction!
Reply
Kat
Hard pass on this one. Curious to see your take on it, Liz.
Reply
Liz Cadman
Right now I think it only makes sense if that clutch alone is worth the cost of the subscription to you. We really need specific details on what these other bonus gifts will be! I’ll try to find out more. 🙂
Reply
Krista
The “special gifts and offers” thing makes me think of the Oprah mag subscription, and I’m pretty sure that was a special bust.
Valerie
ahhhh, no
Reply
Angela L.
Their wording = Exclusive gifts, offers and experiences…. My husband’s wording = If I was to spend that kind of money for a VIP sub, the only thing I will be looking forward to is an “exclusive experience” of lodging in the doghouse!!!! Um no, just sadly not the sub for me….
Reply
Kat
me too Angela L.
Reply
Jamie M
I’d put myself in the doghouse for making a purchase like that one lol.
Reply
Jamie M
I have a closet full of clutches just like that one, most of them were freebies. A bunch of magazine subscriptions… yawn. I don’t know many people who even read paper magazines anymore, people mostly go to blogs for free. And a Q&A with the editors. Wow, they really think highly of themselves, don’t they, to think people are so plebian to get psyched to talk to them on facebook lol. Reddit AMAs achieve the same purpose for free. Get with the times, Vogue. Sorry for being so negative, that $200 price tag made me put my sassy pants on.
Reply
Jett
You aren’t being negative, you’re being honest. As an author/ writer/ ghost writer (former blogger) the state of publishing is in the toilet. it’s cheaper to use staff writers who don’t know how to research, rehash the same stuff over and over and aren’t interested in a new “voice”. The clutch, feh. I can buy high end designer, Italian made hand last shoes for less on sale and they’ll last me decades. A clutch isn’t exactly practical, and even the most expensive one I own by a high end designer is big enough to hold double and a heck of a lot more stylish, while paying (one of the few times I paid full price) maybe $150 more,l
Do,
K
M
Reply
Jet
I give up. Can you please delete my responses? This thing is making stuff up and I don’t see it until after posting! I actually proofread three times before hitting submit, ARRRRRGGGGHHH! (Now I’m a pirate?) ⚡️Jet
Mary K
Phew…. I was afraid I’d need to have it, but nope.
Reply
TiffanyLC
even the model looks stupefied about it!
Reply
Anna
Wow, I was excited… New sub box, then I saw what it was… And I’m not excited anymore.
Reply
Christina
Ditto
Reply
Lucy's
I may be crazy for sub boxes, but NOT THAT CRAZY! ??
Reply
Valerie
This is reminiscent of the Oprah subscription which turned out so horribly.
Reply
Mamo
I concur!
Reply
Lin
And another ditto!
Reply
Sara
That’s what I was thinking too! lol. $200 for a clutch and a magazine??
Reply
Laurie
And experiences! Don’t forget the, um, experiences!
TheTinTiara
That is exactly what I thought when I saw this too!!
Reply
Joy
Exactly!!! Lots of ambiguous promises at a really high price point. Liz is so generous and diplomatic and I remember the Oprah sub as the first that she really had to struggle to pay any compliment to.
Reply
Kara
That is precisely what I was thinking!!!!
Reply
Lauren
That’s exactly what I thought when I saw this!
Reply
Meri
Ditto
Taya
They must be crazy
$200? I’d want that clutch plus at least 6 full size semi-high value items for that price ??
Reply
Imcoffeegirl
I’m waiting for Lix to postman update that says she meant write $20, not $200…
Reply
Imcoffeegirl
Damn you, auto-correct! *waiting for Liz to post an update* is what I meant to say!
Reply
AmyM
I do love a Clare V clutch and this one is gorgeous. But, everything else is just too vague. I *might* have done it for $100, just for the bag, but this is too rich for my blood.
Reply
Jillian
A sub to Vogue and a fold over bag? For $200? What?
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.