Posted by on in POPSUGAR Must Have Box Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: | 150 comments

POPSUGAR Must Have February 2016 Box – FULL SPOILERS + Coupon

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2016-01-28 at 12.32.17 PM

We have the FULL SPOILERS for the February 2016 POPSUGAR Must Have box thanks to mini2z in the forum:

Screen Shot 2016-02-01 at 8.50.16 PM

Tilo Heart Print Scarf (Value $125)

Beauty Counter Nourishing Cleansing Balm ($50)

JewelryStorm Endless Arrow Ring ($29)

Fringe Studio Hello Beautiful Square Tray ($14)

Victoria’s Secret Coconut Milk Hydrating Body Lotion ($18)

Foodstirs Heart Cookie Mix (Value $12)

A $20 Victoria’s Secret reward card AND Sport Socks (Bonus Items)

UPDATE: We have more pictures thanks to Vianny!!!!

psmh1 psmh2 psmh3 psmh4 psmh5 psmh6 psmh7

What do you think of the spoilers? This looks like a FANTASTIC February box to me!

If you haven’t signed up yet, use coupon code MUSTHAVE5 to save $5 off your first box. (Check out our POPSUGAR Must Have reviews to see what has been in past boxes!) FYI – the February box is still available, but I’m guessing it will sell out very quickly now that the spoilers are out!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. Very happy with this box. I had been a bit disappointed in the boxes recently, but this one shows they still have it.

  2. Thanks for the spoilers. Signed up yesterday

  3. I gave up on them over the summer but continued to monitor the boxes to confirm my decision to cancel. I have never been sad about it. And after reading all the horror stories of broken items, poor customer service or simply just not getting the box I was happy not to be apart of this….until this damn box. I caved and ordered. Fingers crossed that I actually get this exact box but talk about a real gamble.

  4. I kinda wish the tray had pink or some other color on it instead of the blue… but it wouldn’t be a Popsugar box without something blue of course!

  5. I just ordered 1 month subscription as a gift (so website said it’s one-time purchase and won’t renew). How can I be sure that they send me February box? My confirmation email didn’t say that:(

    • AND I am so excited to get this!! $20 for VS? I shop there sometimes so that brings the price of the box down to $18 – yessss:D

    • Log into your account and at some point it will tell you. It is SUPER likely you will get this box. Indeed many who ordered toward the tail end of a month (for a 6 month deal) were surprised to find the box from the previous month at their door.

      Basically if you order in the month of the box you will likely get that month no matter what they say is “sold out.”

      They want to get this one out a bit earlier for subscribers so it is a good bet. Stalk your account and see.

      • Thank you so much for your reply! Indeed I clicked here and there in my account and saw the sweet words: “First Box: February 2016 Must Have”. Yay!!

  6. This may be my favorite box ever! I love everything. The only thing I wont use is the VS lotion and thats only because I already have it!!!

  7. So excited for this one, except maybe the scarf. Symbol prints just aren’t my thing, but the color is lovely.

    As for the rest of PSMH, just finally got my Target box today, and the JawBone is missing, because of course. Just hope they replace it or give me the money back!!

    • The hearts on the scarf is only at the end of it, the middle is plain grey with a a heart here and there. Its really not overwhelming.

      • Oh awesome, good to know. Thanks!!

  8. I don’t own a scarf and don’t wear them so I’ll be putting mine up for swap when I get it. I have allergies also so I’ll probably be putting up the lotion as well. I don’t wear gold jewelry either so that will most likely go up. With all of that said, this is my first regular popsugar box and im pleased with the value overall. I will most definitely use the rest I’m sure 🙂

  9. Excited to try the Beauty Counter cleanser. My friend swears by this line, and I love that it’s free of all yucky stuff.

  10. Woohoo! Now this is a much better box then let’s say, December? I am so excited! Of course the ring won’t fit but, I don’t really wear gold anyway. Keep it up for next month PSMH!

    • If it helps, it fits my right hand ring finger perfectly, and I wear a size five on that finger. it’s identical in size to my other rings that I’ve had resized to a five.

  11. Love this box but I will probably put the scarf and cleansing balm up for swap…really excited for the rest tho 🙂

  12. Looks like it might be exciting.

  13. Love this box! It’s the best one yet. Now I’m anxiously awaiting shipping notification. The more excited I am for a box the longer it seems to take. I think this means I need to join BAA…especially if they offer a welcome box!

    • So I’m a little confused…what is BAA? Thanks!

      • Haha! It’s silly, I left a comment saying that I want to start a box addicts anonymous group (BAA) because I need help with my sub addiction. I really do need help!

        • Thank you so much!

          And my name is Michelle, and I have a subscription box problem…?

  14. So far I like the 2016 boxes(Jan, Target) . This box I like everything but the ring, I don’t wear gold.

  15. Looking forward to those scarves to show up on swaps 🙂

    • Ugh! I was too but I cannot justify swapping retail for a high $ item that came in a $40 box along with 6 other items. Never fails that when I do request they want all of my best Luxor box items!!! Yeah, not going to happen. I caved and bought a box!

  16. What material is that scarf?

    • 100% Modal

      • Thanks for the spoilers 🙂

        • You are very welcome 🙂

      • Thanks!

  17. I’m on the fence about this. I really like the scarf but everything is else is kinda “meh” for me. Is anyone planning to put their scarf up for swapping?

    • Hey! I have mine up for swap…I got two boxes! 🙂

  18. What a fantastic box! I’ll use everything but I’m most excited about the cleansing balm. Yippee!

  19. Not really my style 🙁 how many scarves can one person use??? Why is there one in nearly every box? I like the ring but doubt it will fit on my fat fingers 🙁 The tray is cute and I can always use lotion and socks lol. I’m excited about the Foodstirs! I just read about it in a magazine and was wanting to try it.

    • PSMH hasn’t had a scarf in over a year. The last one was in Dec 2014.

      • Erm, there was one in August 2015….

      • There was one in August 2015.

        • Oh yeah!!! Totally forgot about that one. Probably because I never wear it.

    • First scarf in 6 months….yeah, that’s the same as getting one every month.

    • You could always wear the ring as a midi ring. They’re super in right now. That’s what I’m planning on doing!

  20. Love this box ! Best box in my opinion in awhile. I love that the gift card this month is to an actual store instead an online shop.

    • My thoughts exactly!

  21. Wow!! This box is singing to me! Can’t wait to get it. Normally I don’t love heart print anything, but this is subtle enough to actually be wearable, especially on a nice, neutral background. This is 2 months in a row I will use everything in the box. Keep it going, PopSugar!

  22. Finally the first box in months i have actually liked.

  23. Does the lack of a comma on the tray bug anyone else? 🙂

    Nice box!

    • Yes, yes, yes!!!!

  24. I’ll swap a few of the items, but I think the curation is great. January’s was one of my all-time favourite PS boxes, so they’re off to a great start this year. I can’t wait to make the cookies!

  25. Not feeling it. The scarf is pretty boring, they had some gorgeous, colorful ones on the site, but this one is pretty uninspiring. Cleansing balm? I’m pretty well stock on that stuff. The ring won’t fit, the tray is a little too “young” for me (though perhaps my teen can use it), lotion is lotion and cookie mix is cookie mix.

    Not one thing I’m excited about. Plus Bernie is down in Iowa, which makes me sad 🙁

    On the plus side, my 11-yo just made a cake from scratch for dessert, all by herself.

    • Lol Nana, Your Funny!! I did read reviews on the Cookie Mix & it sounds good!! Congrats to your daughter on her cake yayyyy! Do you think the ring will be adjustable? If not it probably won’t fit me either so I’m sure that will go on my Swap page!! And your only as old as you think you are!! Get that tray & enjoy it, everyday when you wake up look at it we are ALL beautiful ??

      • Nana!! Tell Bernie hi I’m in Iowa too!! 😉

  26. This looks fantastic. I asked my hubby for this box for Valentine’s! Hopefully he comes through!

  27. Great box!!!

  28. Of course I had to buy a second box after seeing these spoilers. I love you Liz, but I hate myself right now. I’m starting an organization called BAA: box addicts anonymous. I have a serious problem and need professional help.

    • I would completely join BAA. I definitely caved with this box.

    • Do you get a “welcome box” when you join the support group, because then I’m totally joining. ?

      • No welcome box but an awesome bunch … mini2z

      • Ha ha… yes, definitely count me in if there’s a welcome box too! Or maybe even a really good coupon! But really all it takes for me anymore is reading one of Liz’s reviews… and then I’m magically signed up for some box even though I thought I was going to try to “cut back”!

      • LOL!

    • I was SO close on buying a second box and talked myself off the ledge and made myself repeat…I will use everything, one of each is enough, don’t buy a second box…lol. BAA.
      great box.

    • Omg I would so join BAA too! I’m currently saving money for a house and a wedding and yet here I am like “take all my money” every time I see Liz post a spoiler ??

  29. I’ve always wanted to try something from Beautycounter and I love that it’s a cleansing balm. The scarf looks very delicate and the heart print is subtle and not at all cheesy or over the top. I’m so glad it’s a grey tone and not pink or red. Everything else fits the box theme perfectly. Very happy.

  30. Finally a scarf! I love this box…can’t wait to get mine 🙂

  31. I really hope the ring fits me. I’m betting it will be too small even for my pinky. I love everything in this box!

    • I feel the same about the ring. I’m sure it won’t even fit my pinky 🙁

  32. Soooo excited! Awesome box! Way to go POPSUGAR, let’s stay on this path lol 🙂

  33. Absolutely amazing box! I ? it!
    Also, I purchased those VS lotions and they’re actually really nice. The Acai scent was sold out for weeks at my local store and the coconut smells delicious as well ?

  34. This is like the old Popsugar again! Yay! I’m so excited for this box.

  35. OMG, cannot wait to get mine!

  36. Love (most of) it all! The “fragrance”-free balm is very much appreciated. Needless to say, the VS lotion will be up for swap. Happy V-Day to me 🙂

  37. I really like this month! I bit the bullet and signed up again!

    • Me too! Everything looks good!

  38. Wheee! I just bit the bullet and signed up for this today before I saw the spoilers. Boy, am I glad that I did! I am new to subscription boxes and this is the first box I’m getting with this kind of variety. I don’t even own a scarf! I can’t wait to get this in the mail!

  39. It’s unlikely, but it would be nice if there were variations in the scarf colour. Grey looks awful on me, which is a shame because otherwise it seems delicate and pretty.
    I hope I feel differently when I have the box in my sticky little hands, but I think only the VS card will be used.
    Maybe the socks will be pink for Valentine’s Day!

    • Update – it all looks so much better in Vianny’s pictures!
      I intrigued, what’s the folded fabric tied with ribbon next to the cleansing balm?

      • A muslin cloth. (:

      • The cloth came with the balm, when you rinsed your face you are suppose to do it with the cloth to wipe off the balm. It also comes with a spoon to scoop the balm out

        • Lol, I’m definitely swapping that then. Makeup wipes and twice a week exfoliating in the shower is quite enough for me.

  40. I liked last year’s February box better I think (I use that cutting board all the time!) but this looks great, too! I’m excited about the tray. I don’t wear jewelry very often but that ring is super cute so I might wear it. And everything else I know I’ll use!

  41. Haha I guess my reveal has gone places 🙂
    Liz I don’t know if you have pics of all the items but I can send them to you.
    Also the ring is not adjustable,it is a pinky or mid finger ring

    • OMG that would be amazing! Thank you! ??? (my email: [email protected])

      • Okies, sending now!

    • Wait, the ring is *intended* to be a pinky/midi ring?

      Well dangit.

      I hate my stupid big hands.

      • @Tamara, I feel your pain! I have “man hands”…Please tell me that you’ve seen that Seinfeld episode!?! 🙂

      • It fits my pinky fine, the card says its intended to be a midi or a layering ring , it is pretty though

      • Yeah for small, feminine hands!! It might fit on my ring finger.

  42. Wow

  43. OMG I CAN’T WAIT! Best Valentine’s… I mean February box, ever!! Everything is perfect! Yay!

  44. Ooh I can’t wait for this one. I love it!

  45. Looks pretty awesome to me!

    We ARE getting the cookies from the theme pic!! We have to make them ourselves, but still…

    I LOVE trays for your vanity/night stand/etc.

    The ring looks potentially cute – and adjustable (?), so even I might be able to wear it on my big man-hands.

    I can’t see the scarf week enough to know if I like it yet. But I’m hopeful!

    And socks from VS will actually fit me! That thought didn’t even occur to me.

    Wheee!! XD

  46. Great value but nothing I’m excited about. I keep waiting for Popsugar to make me regret cancelling, but it hasn’t happened yet. These boxes aren’t worth the headache that is their horrible customer service.

    • YES! Their customer service is horrible. I still haven’t received my January box, even though it was shipped on the 15th. Their customer service rep literally said, “Uh, it’s FedEx SmartPost, it should be expected.” And that Popsugar has NO desire to change at this time. I live in Alaska, so I know things take a little longer to get to me…but it’s been 2 weeks since it was dropped off with USPS in Washington state and it’s still not here. I like my boxes, but I’m constantly wondering if they’re lost or what. The guy was just a super snarky jerk.

  47. Can’t wait to get mine!

  48. Wow, this looks good.
    I didn’t get a tracking number for my January box but it shows up at my office. I am not sure if I will receive a tracking number email for this box…

  49. Now this will sell out fast 🙂 It’s a great box and I can’t wait to receive mine …. is it wrong that I’m excited about the socks?

    • If it is, were can be wrong together. 🙂

    • That’s a 6 pack of socks????? The link goes to a multi pack?

      • One pair of socks. Not six. The link shows the socks but you don’t get all 6.

  50. Just ordered it! As good as last year’s feb box yay!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!