Posted by on in Featured Deal, ModCloth Stylish Surprise News, Subscription Box News | Tags: | 46 comments

ModCloth Stylish Surprise is Available Now!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2016-01-04 at 12.15.46 PM Screen Shot 2016-01-04 at 12.15.51 PM

ModCloth Stylish Surprise is available now! (Thanks Kerry for the head’s up!)

Good to know: All Stylish Surprise items are Final Sale. These sell out VERY quickly – make sure to buy ASAP if you are interested!

More details:

Stylish Surprise – Dresses, $20, available in sizes XS-4X

Stylish Surprise – Apparel, $15, available in sizes XS-4X

Stylish Surprise – Shoes, $10, available in sizes 5.5-10

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.


  1. My box came today and ohhhhhh myyyyyyy. It was bad. Really bad. I ordered two dresses and 1 pair of shoes. The dresses were the exact same, except one was peach, and the other was mint green. They were a stunning off the shoulder, solid lace, junior prom style of gown that in no way would look good on this 30-something-mom-with-a-couple-of-kids kinda gal :/ The shoes were multi-colored flats that for $10, I might give a whirl. I know that you take a chance with mystery boxes, but I can’t help but feel slightly ripped off…….

  2. My SS box came today. All Summer items. 3 sandals, 3 summer dresses ( one with watermelons, one with ocean items, and a peach lace one), a summer tank top shirt, a ” sock hop” tight shirt. Peach flats, multi colored flats, and black Patten wedges. I’m assuming that there will be another sale soon.

  3. I got mine Saturday, it shipped super fast. I got a pair of ugly librarian shoes, that I don’t even know if they’re worth trying to swap. And a striped dress which is kind of cute; but just like one I already bought from Modcloth. I was hoping for a cute pair of boots like last time lol.

  4. Ummm… So I just received my surprise dress today… It certainly was a surprise… I got a bridesmaid dress?? Full on gown with sparkles. Ugh.

  5. I was able to snag 4 shoes and 4 apparels on the day of the sale. I just got an email from modcloth that due to an oversale, I am not getting any shoes……boo =(. They did gave me a 10% coupon code and I used it on the big sale today. But i really wanted to see what shoes I could get!

    • You might have gotten lucky with the shoes and saved yourself some money.

  6. The apparel item that I ordered for my sister is scheduled to arrive tomorrow. My order has not shipped yet. Am I the only one?

    • I have not received any info for shipping. I ordered about 10 items, maybe the smaller orders go out quicker?

    • Update…WOW, Modcloth has awesome customer service. I noticed my order was still in pending status. I was a little worried, so I live chatted with a CSR. He stated they were a little backed up due to the holiday, but my order will be shipped today. It is 7 am here. My concern was addressed within seconds.

  7. I did the apparel one last year and got a black Steve Madden coat. Too bad I had purchased a wool coat that was almost identical to it about two months before. I sold it for $20 at a consignment sale so I got my money back & someone got a nice deal.

    I gave in and ordered two of the apparel surprises this time. Fingers crossed that I get something good.

  8. I just purchased a dress in size M. It’s my first online “blind” purchase so while I’m excited, I’m also nervous. I just hope whatever I get fits! Though it’d be nice if I liked it too

    • Worst fears came true. Not only was the dress ugly and very cheap, but it didn’t fit (too tight on the bottom too loose on the top). On top of that, it arrived ripped!

      Contacted Modcloth and received a store credit. If nothing else, their customer care is worthwhile.

  9. I was a one-and-done on Stylish Surprise. I did it once and nothing I received fit or was remotely my style. Someone shopping Goodwill got very lucky, though! ๐Ÿ˜‰

  10. I purchased one pair of shoes. Last time I bought two pairs. Though the shoes weren’t what I normally would pick for myself but I like them.

  11. Thank you for the Notification that popped in my inbox, I hopped right on and got 1 pair of shoes and one xl dress (though with the dress and the comments above I hope its not too small!). Fingers crossed that I like them….took less that 4 days to break my no frivolous spending in 2016! hahaha!

  12. SOMEday I’m sure I will be online when this happens. ::sigh:: (I’m a plus size, and they always sell out first.)

  13. Wow the shoes except for size 6 and 6.5 went fast! I got a dress in XL (their sizes sometimes run small) and 2 apparel in size L. I hope it fits because the sizes larger were already gone. I have been happy with what I have gotten in the past, although had some sizing issues with apparel and shoes, but for the price, its worth it because I was able to give them as gifts.

  14. I got a couple of each! There are quite a few girls in the family, so if something doesn’t suit someone, it’s bound to work for another. haha ๐Ÿ™‚

  15. I ordered two apparel!!:) Think I’m the only person that doesn’t like their shoes lol

  16. Took a chance on two pairs of shoes in an eight. This is my first time, so hoping they fit and I like them.

    • Received my shoes the other day. They fit. Not what I was expecting. A pale peach pair of plastic/rubber flats and pale yellow flats with pastel green and blue stripes with a peep toe. Wow. Not sure if I will do that again.

  17. I was so happy to not miss out on this as I did last time. I was able to find a 2X and size 10 shoe… Hopefully I’ll love what they send me… If not I’ll list the goodies for swap.

  18. I was in class when this went live and missed out on my sizes. But after last time, I am super glad I missed this. They had one thing I liked and a bunch of stuff that was just flushed money.

  19. I’m so excited I finally caught this! I got 2 XS apparel, and 1 size 7.5 shoes. I love retro and mod clothing styles (think Zooey deschanel) so I’m really excited to see what I get. Some boots would be amazing ?

  20. Ugh, I swear every single time they do this I’m stuck in a meeting and they are out of my shoe size by the time I can get in. Guess I’ll try again next time… ๐Ÿ™

    • I know. I am working on a database program and just missed my shoe size. Luckily, there is always the swap site!

  21. Oh thank goodness they finally sold out of my size shoes! I checked about 4 times and each time felt my resolve to not buy crumbling. I wish the best of luck to those who did take the leap.

  22. I got two pairs of the shoes. I loved the shoes I received last time! I will not buy any of the dresses or apparel again. They looked terrible on me!

  23. Ahh- someday I’ll finally get my size 10 shoes. Scored two L apparel – the dresses are really hit or miss for me so I abstained (tall people problems).

  24. I purchased two of each category.

  25. I got one of each… the last 2 surprises I’ve received have been horrible. I feel like I should learn from the past but I’m a sucker for surprises!

  26. Four pairs of size 8.5 shoes for me just like last time! They were all perfect last time so here’s hoping do the same luck. I don’t bother with the clothing anymore lol

  27. Whew..glad I checked my email on break! Got 6 pairs size 8 shoes, 3 xl dresses and two apparel. Hope the clothing fits. Their sizes run kinda strange. Hoping for boots!

    • I got one dress and three apparel, fingers crossed! If you don’t like the shoes let me know! Size 8 and missed out ๐Ÿ™

      • I will let you know. I will post them on here, and then email you pics of the ones I will not or can not wear

  28. My shoe size (9.5) was sold out, so I sized up to a 10 and got two pair! Thick socks it will be! ๐Ÿ™‚

  29. Wow, I actually got shoes this time before my size (8) sold out! Woot! 5 shoes, 2 apparel.

  30. thanks so much for the heads up! this is my first time buying anything from modcloth- i picked up 2 1x dresses. i figure if i end up wearing one it will at least be a wash. and maybe both work out!

  31. I adored everything I got last time, so I picked up one of each. My bank account is also a little cross with me today!

  32. The decor one went in five minutes I got the last two. Plus 4 clothes, 2 dresses and 2 shoes. I just happened to be on my phone when the app notified me of the live listing.

    • Hope you get them! Sometimes the system gets multiple orders at once and they may cancel something you bought as “oversold”

  33. Woohoo! I got 2 apparel and 4 shoes. I’m really hoping for cute boots. Between this and the Target beauty boxes, my bank account isn’t liking me so much today haha.

  34. Oh my gosh this wasn’t even on my radar! I was thinking I still had to wait til March. Phewf! THanks for emailing this out~~~!!
    I got 3 Apparel, 2 Shoes, 1 Dress. Can’t wait to get it!

  35. Woohoo I just happened to check out MSA and saw this post. I wish they had the decor stylish surprise or the accessories one. But I got a dress and a pair of shoes for $30. I got an awesome pair of boots last time, hoping things fit again this time!

  36. Thanks for the post Liz! I got an order in when they still had my sizes!

    I got 3 apparel and 3 shoes! Where the dresses always $20? I know I got dresses before (a LONG time ago) and I don’t think I would’ve paid that much for a mystery dress.

    • Yay! I think a year or two ago the prices were different, but these prices are the same as the last time they had a Stylish Surprise. Hope you get some awesome shoes and dresses!! ๐Ÿ™‚

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!