.JPEG)
As someone who’s tried almost every health and fitness gadget under the sun, I’ve learned that not all body scanners are created equal. When I started looking for a tool that could help me track real progress - not just a single number on the scale—I tested three of the most talked-about options: the Hume Health Body Pod, the Withings Body Scan, and the Oxiline Scale MD Pro.
Each has its strengths, but after weeks of using all three, Hume’s Body Pod stood out as my clear favorite. Here’s why.
If you want simplicity with maximum insights…Hume Health
The Body Pod is as easy as it gets: step on, grab the handle, stand still, and in 30 seconds you get over 45 different metrics. The process is straightforward and intuitive, without complicated instructions.
Winner: Hume’s Body Pod
If you want clinic-grade accuracy without leaving home… Hume Health
Accuracy is what sets Hume apart. With 98% DEXA accuracy, the results feel clinic-level but without the time, appointment, or expense of an actual scan.
The Withings Body Scan is also highly accurate and offers cardiovascular health tracking, which is a unique feature. The Scale MD Pro, while affordable, often felt closer to an estimate than a precise reading.
Winner: Hume’s Body Pod
If you want advanced cardiovascular tracking… Withings
Here’s where Withings deserves credit: it’s the only one of the three that offers cardiovascular health insights. For users with specific health concerns, that feature can be a game-changer.
That said, it also makes the Withings Body Scan more complex to use - and more expensive. Still, if heart health data is your top priority, Withings wins this round.
Winner: Withings Body Scan
If you want to track more than just weight… Hume Health
Most scales focus on weight or BMI, but Hume goes deeper. It tracks:
- Fat and muscle mass
- Hydration
- Visceral fat (the kind you really need to watch)
- Progress over time with daily and weekly charts
Withings Body Scan does offer segmental fat analysis, which is useful, but I found Hume’s broader mix of metrics far more practical for everyday life. The Scale MD Pro was too limited, more of a “budget quick check” than a real analysis.
Winner: Hume’s Body Pod
If you want everything in one place… Hume Health
Hume’s app integrates seamlessly with Apple Health, Google Fit, and Fitbit, pulling everything together in one hub. For me, that convenience meant I could keep my entire health routine connected.
Withings Body Scan’s app is polished, but more locked into its own ecosystem. Scale MD Pro’s app is functional, but too basic for long-term tracking or deeper insights.
Winner: Hume’s Body Pod
If you want the best value for your investment… Hume Health
Hume is HSA/FSA eligible, which makes it cost-effective if you have those benefits. Considering its clinic-grade accuracy, breadth of metrics, and app integration, I see it as an investment in my long-term health. Plus with their 40% off offer, it’s only $229.
Withings Body Scan is positioned as a premium device - and priced accordingly at $499.95. While impressive, I didn’t see enough extra benefit to justify the higher cost. The Scale MD Pro is the budget option at $199, but you are also sacrificing depth and accuracy.
Winner: Hume Health
My Verdict
After putting all three to the test, my choice was clear: Hume is the best balance of accuracy, simplicity, and value.
The Withings Body Scan shines in one area - cardiovascular tracking - but comes at a higher price point. The Scale MD Pro is fine for basic check-ins. But for me, someone who values clinic-grade accuracy, actionable insights, easy integration, and stress-free use, Hume is the one that actually fits into my lifestyle.At the end of the day, I don’t want to simply weigh myself. I want to understand my body, track meaningful changes, and feel healthier. Hume gives me that in 30 seconds flat - and THAT’S why it’s my go-to.
