Let me tell you - my little pup can be very particular about his toys these days. It seems like he’s chewing through each and every toy I can find at my local pet shop within a day or two, so I decided to start looking around for durable, tough toys that last.
I came across both Super Chewer and Bullymake on my quest and decided to order both and let Winnie decide which is best before buying more. Initially, I thought they’d be similar toys and both do the trick, but boy was I wrong… here’s my full analysis of Super Chewer versus Bullymake.
If you’re looking for *truly* durable toys... Super Chewer
This is easily the most important factor for me (and Winnie). I gave my pup both toys for an entire day at a time to assess how fast they would deteriorate, as he is notoriously a fast and hard chewer. After the first few hours with the Bullymake toys, he was already starting to rip them apart, which wasn’t great. They felt like toys I’d have to buy every week to keep up with Winnie’s demand. Bullymake does have a satisfaction guarantee, but I’m not a fan of having to buy and replace toys every few days.
Super Chewer's toys practically looked brand new after toy-destroyer Winnie had at them for an entire day. Even after three full days, they looked untouched. So I really liked the fact that Super Chewer’s toys didn’t fall apart quickly, were very durable and tough, and kept Winnie busy hour after hour. A+, Super Chewer.
If faster shipping makes a difference... Bullymake
Honestly, toy-wise, and product-wise in general for that matter, Super Chewer is miles ahead of Bullymake. But, Bullymake does offer faster shipping. Super Chewer offers to ship your toy box out ~2 days after you place your order, whereas Bullymake promises to ship it out next day.
With that said, I did order both on the same exact day and they both arrived 3 days later. So it’s really not much of a difference-maker, but probably the one and only edge Bullymake has over Super Chewer.
If your pup likes themed and ultra-fun boxes... Super Chewer
I’ve got to give it to Super Chewer - their toys are so fun and unique. I ordered the JackPAWt box and instantly fell in love with their creativity. Winnie loved them too. He seemed very surprised by how fun and cheerful they were – his favorites clearly were the Texas Tug Em and the Chewlette Spin.
I can’t tell you exactly why he loved the two casino game-themed toys, but he sure did. He spent weeks on end with both of them. He also loved bringing them to the park with him, against my wishes and showing them off to his pup buddies.
I also really enjoyed how all of the full-sized bags of treats in my Super Chewer Box get a personalized touch from their designers. Everything from the bag design to the shape of the treats themselves is on-theme for that month’s box and brings my pup maximum joy.
The ultimate winner... Super Chewer
After experiencing both what Super Chewer and Bullymake have to offer, it became clear to me that Super Chewer is just miles ahead of Bullymake. Super Chewer’s toys are much more durable, last for weeks on end, and have awesome themes in each box
I definitely recommend giving Super Chewer a try. You can even get double the toys in your first box – their Double Deluxe Offer – when you shop here.
