My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query

Creepy Crate Reviews

Is Creepy Crate Right For You?

Updated October 26, 2021 | Verified Since 2021

Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Creepy Crate Overview

About the Brand

Creepy Crate is a horror and true crime subscription box filled with spooky collectibles, macabre accessories, and terrifying goodies. Each bi-monthly box is filled with over $85 of terror and includes at least one horror or true crime book. This box delivers dread to your doorstep for just $39.99, with free shipping.

Key Info

Creepy Crate Reviews

User Reviews

Subscriber Ratings

1.6 overall rating
0
1
0
0
4

Subscriber Reviews

Write A Review
Melanie Bingle Marsh
Melanie Bingle Marsh
Aug 5, 2017
For my upcoming birthday, my co-blogger got me a subscription to Creepy Crate. As you may know, lately there seems to be a monthly subscription box for just about everything. From books, to barbeque sauce, to razor blades, and now one for horror fans. This makes my black little heart ecstatic! Before now, I really didn’t have any desire to subscribe to any sort of box thing. I have enough bills already and I’m not generally a fan of paying for stuff without knowing what I’m getting. I’m just weird like that. This review is for the first shipment. The 2nd shipment wasn't nearly as exciting. It had a little bit of cool stuff, but not like this one. Let me just tell you how excited I was when I opened my first Creepy Crate. Very. I was like a kid on Christmas morning. It takes a lot for me to get excited about stuff, but this blew me away. Inside was a variety of things obviously. There was a super cute limited edition pin, a strawberry flavored eyeball lollipop, a coupon code for a free horror book and 3 month subscription to the online horror channel, Shudder. But my 2 favorite items in the box were the Blood shower gel in a blood bag and the serial killer cards. YES FREAKIN SERIAL KILLER CARDS!!! I don’t actually know how much stuff is in the average subscription box because I don’t have experience with those, but I’ll tell you, the items in this box may not have been plentiful, but I can’t even tell you how much excitement those damn cards have given me. I even took them with me to one of my book events. There is one card that is blank and I keep telling my husband if he keeps it up, my picture is going on it! I’ll never use the shower gel, it goes on my horror shelf, and I let my kid eat the eyeball (she said it was delicious btw). So overall, my Creepy Crate experience was great. I now have something to look forward to every other month and I know each box will have the kind of disturbing things in it only twisted people like myself can enjoy!
Report
Elijah Reinhardt
Elijah Reinhardt
"If you wanna spend 40 for useless stuff this is the box for you"
Jun 25, 2021
I was shipped junk for $40
Report
redbecca@gmail.com
"sending ARCS for a $40 subscription box isnt' cool "
May 27, 2021
the first box I got from them was pretty good, but I noticed that the main book in the second one was an ARC, which is not cool for a $40 subsciption box. I suspended my subscription after that, and renewed it because of their recent Shudder cross-promotion. However, I was very disappointed in the contents of that box - no print book at all. I won't be reactivating this time.
Report
Maudaevee Ross
Maudaevee Ross
"Very hit or miss box"
May 21, 2021
I received my second Creepy Crate today and will be canceling. The first box was quite good, it definitely was worth the $39 but the second box was so far from good, the items in it were cheap promotional items (like what you get free at promo events) there was no print book in box (I didn't even get the little partial book others got in their box) and I felt like dumping it all in the garbage.
Report
Kathy
Kathy
"Not worth it "
Apr 23, 2021
I signed up for this hoping for a good book and maybe some household items or something cool. I have had other horror subscription boxes in the past that were more for kids so I was really hopeful for this. I feel ripped off, this was a box full of garbage. I didn’t even get a full book out of it, supposedly they’re going to email you a book download but I don’t read digital books because they hurt my eyes. Just very disappointed.
Report

The Best Deals Delivered

enter your email for cool stuff

Privacy Notice

About MSA

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. It's our goal to help you discover new and exciting products, serving as a trusted partner in your online shopping experience. Our team is dedicated to providing honest and thorough product reviews, but also empowering the community to learn from each other through trusted reviews of your own. Read our editorial and community guidelines to learn more.