Facebook PixelBoxyCharm February 2023 Subscription Box Review | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

BoxyCharm February 2023 Subscription Box Review

Megan K.
ByMegan K.Jul 12, 2023 | 10 comments

4.3 overall rating
1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

BoxyCharm is a $27.99 monthly beauty and makeup subscription box. They always provide a great value compared to the cost of the box and include 5-6 beauty items that include nail care, skincare, makeup, haircare, fragrance, and more. (At least 4 of those items will be full-sized). If you are a makeup addict – we recommend this box!

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the editorial guidelines to learn more about how we review boxes.)

First Impressions

Boxycharm usually arrives with a cute card detailing all of the products inside and listed retail values but this time we received a more general note promising new things on the horizon.


Now, on to the items!

Beauty Bakerie Proof is in the Pudding Eyeshadow Palette – Retail Value $38


This brand always makes me smile with the adorable baked/dessert theme and cute packaging. I have found that their eyeshadow formulas are also quite nice, and deliver pigment and buttery soft smoothness. This color story is pudding-themed (YES. SO CUTE.) and includes a mix of warm neutrals from vanilla to cinnamon. It's a great curation for everyday looks though some of those more burnt oranges certainly bring drama too! I kind of wish this palette had a banana smell but I love bananas much more than the average person so that might not be the best idea, but I would still be into it!

The Better Skin Co. Eye Bright Now Serum, 30 mL - Retail Value $38


I think we all know that the skin around our eyes is thinner, more sensitive, and prone to darkness depending on genetics and stress levels. I don't always use an eye product but when I do, I want it to be lightweight, anti-aging focused, and full of peptides to strengthen my skin. This gel serum certainly fits the bill with multiple peptides, hyaluronic acid, and antioxidants. The formula absorbs quickly and doesn't leave a residue behind. Another bonus? You barely need a drop for each eye, meaning this bottle will last for a long time.

Goldfaden MD Vital Boost Even Skintone Daily Moisturizer, 2 fl oz– Retail Value $85


I feel like this moisturizer is overpriced for what it is (which, tbh isn't uncommon in beauty products) but I do believe it makes a nice option for anyone wanting a very lightweight daily moisturizer. My other big issue is that it has no SPF. I truly believe that if a moisturizer is meant for AM wear, I need it to have sun protection for it to ever make it anywhere close to a daily product in my rotation. This cream leaves behind no trace and does give my face a tighter feel after application, but I find that I need a little more.

Benefit Cosmetics They're Real! Magnet Extreme Lengthening Mascara, 8.5 g – Retail Value $28


I have loved Benefit for years and I am always pleased to try a new offering from this fun and quirky brand. I remember when this mascara launched but never got my hands on it until now. The premise here is that the brush itself is magnetized and the mascara has magnetic particles infused into the formula. As a fan of the original They're Real mascara, I have to say that it was better than this one. It is almost an 'if it ain't broke, don't fix it' sort of deal for me. I didn't notice any difference in curl or length, in fact, I think the original performs better in both categories. In fact, I couldn't tell if there was any magnetic power here at all! The good news is that this is still a solid mascara and I liked the way it looked on my lashes. I just don't think you should be expecting anything groundbreaking from this tube.

Give Them Lala Hydromatte Liquid Lipstick in 'Booty Call' - Retail Value $16


I don't know if I could have chosen a worse lip shade for my skin tone than this tan-orange 'Booty Call' color. I applied it for testing and Will actually laughed at me. I also didn't think the formula was all that great either, but I don't generally gravitate toward matte finishes, but this one seemed pretty standard. It took a long time to dry down but stayed moderately flexible and not super flaky.


This month's BoxyCharm delivered a total value of $205 which is good for the cost of the subscription. The curation was a little hit or miss for me, but it is hard to argue with a value like that. At the very least, I am loving the eye serum and eyeshadow palette and the rest will be regifted.

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

Value – Was This Box Worth It?

The Cost: $27.99

Value Breakdown: Each of these 5 items had an average cost of $5.60. Here is how that breaks down per item:

  • Eyeshadow Palette $5.19
  • Eye Serum $5.19
  • Moisturizer $11.61
  • Mascara $3.82
  • Liquid Lip $2.18

Other Things You Should Know

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Yes, your first box should be the February box.

What do you think of the February 2023 BoxyCharm Box? Which variants are you getting?

Starting at $30.00
Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

Megan K.
Megan K.
I love natural/vegan beauty products, Korean skincare, unique jewelry, and weird candies from far away places. When I am not waiting for my next exciting box you can find me painting or taking photographs of interesting people. I never leave home without pug hair somewhere on my shirt and a bold lipstick on my smile.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



A lot of people are sensitive to spf and, frankly, I don’t like when moisturizers add it. I’m always happy to find a good moisturizer without an spf added. People can always add the sunscreen of their choice.

Reply ButtonReply


But – thank you for your thorough review as usual. I look forward to reading your posts; they’re my favorites!

Reply ButtonReply


On another note, it would be nice if they would also review Tribe Beauty Box like they used to. Maybe even do a comparison between it and BoxyCharm. I got an amazing palette in Tribe Beauty this month!

Reply ButtonReply


They still haven’t done anything with that Honeylove ad. Yuck!

Reply ButtonReply

Subscription Snob

Why are there no comments allowed on the honey posts?

Reply ButtonReply


seriously? you’re offended over that!?probably should stay off the internet.

Reply ButtonReply


M, honey, you have no idea what kind of stuff I’m into on the internet. I’ve probably watched stuff you wouldn’t even dream exists. That being said, this particular site it *not* where we should be seeing this content, and since a lot of us visit this site from our workplaces, this should be marked NSFW, both for the thumbnail and for the booty being shown once you open the link. Now, kindly get lost with your snarky comment.



Reply ButtonReply


Oh, I see. It’s just a girdle ad, but I can see it being offensive if you work in a conservative office. I think the dildo ads need to be clearly and boldly marked.


MSA still hasn’t marked the Honeylove ad as NSFW. No comments are allowed on that post (of course), so I mentioned here thinking that maybe someone at MSA would see and do something about it, but apparently not.