Macy’s Beauty May 2022 Box Full Spoilers

First box, no pouch, no primer, no subscription from me! I like LM, but I’m not up for dealing with crap/shotty service. Just get me what was advertised, no substitutions. Figure it out Macys!

This one was terrible. If this box doesn’t get better next month I have to cancel as I get better size items for free when I order from ulta or Sephora. The samples were tiny foil packs. Not worth the money

Like everyone else, I got an Oops note, no primer, and no substitution. I also didn’t get the pouch pictured in the insert. I am tired of eye creams and scented oils. The last rose oil they sent me leaked everywhere! I also feel cheated by little foil packets and sample cards like you get for free just walking through the beauty section at the store.

Where’s the perfume sample?!

Just got my box. No primer and no sub either. Confusing as there is nothing on the oil in the leaflet. Don’t really care about the lack of make up bag; I have too many. I like the other objects they give. Yes not a great box.

Trying to cancel. Is there some special nack to it because it won’t let me cancel under the manage subscription. I have been on hold for about 54 mins. Let me know..thanks.

Thank you, LANNF! Without your detailed instructions, I couldn’t have found it. It seems that each color circle represents another Macy’s subscription box!

I echo what everyone else is saying. Oops note and no substitute that was in my box. No primer ( I really wanted that – I am a primer lover). I really have to think about if I keep this subscription. It feels like from their video on the Macy’s website like it is false advertising for the value we got. $51 value promoted and when you get the box with the printed card it states clearly a $31.51 value. Thats a -$20 less than advertised. I wonder if they thought we wouldn’t notice? We did. Just sad.

I used to love Macy’s box but it has been pretty disappointing of late. Now this box with little samples is pushing me towards canceling.

I just received my box today and this one is underwhelming and super confusing!
1. I received an ‘oops’ note, but no substituted product that I can tell.
2. I am missing the canvas primer
3. Inset card says it’s a $31.51 value, not $51.
4. Insert card shows a LM makeup pouch on the front. I did not get, dont know if I should have.
5. Insert does not show the eye cream stick, video does however.

I feel Macys completely missed the mark. If i am paying for sample products and they are sending foils and/or card samples, they should send more and not just the normal ‘5’ products.a fold pack or a card does not equal one ‘paid for’ sample in my eyes.

yeah… hopefully there will be some “oops” and substitutions with more full or at least, deluxe size, items… this is a bit disappointing considering the YSL curated box was SO AWESOME recently…

Yeah it’s a rip off they get all those samples free and so should we!

I like the eye and face cream. Can’t wait to try it.

Box sounds good. We need more boxes like this here it is all one brand with various products. Can’t wait for mine.

I was very sad to miss last month box and signed up with the hope to receive it. Getting this one instead and Im thrilled.

I like that Macys is the only box that resembles the good old BB days with the inclusion of genuine brands you can actually buy at the beauty counter.

For me, this is the best discovery sub in the less than $20 price tag.

Packets? how does Macy’s even value those

I will wait until I get this months box…small samples and 2 foil samples. The powder is a foil sample. Not cool. If it is not great I will cancel and find another box. I am loyal but this just feels bad. They could have really blown it out of the water with the Laura Mercier. Especially after last month’s box with a shower cap. Trying to be Zen about this.

$15? For samples? That’s insane.

I just got billed. I had cancelled but I guess I missed the cut off date. Bummer.

Ooh, this is a nice one! I mean, I already have multiples of everything from various gift sets anyway 😊, but I think this is a nice curation. That’s so rare these days.

Not a good month. All tiny samples. No perfume samples which I love. On the Macy’s order email the pic shows a cute Laura Mercier bag in the video it shows a lip instead. Would have wanted the bag instead

I don’t know. I don’t want to sound negative but everything is so tiny!