My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyCharm October 2021 Box – Full Spoilers!

BoxyCharm February 2021 Choice Time!

ByMSAJan 11, 2021 | 42 comments

BoxyCharm November 2019 beauty and makeup subscription box review

4.3 overall rating
1982 Ratings | 228 Reviews

February 2021 BoxyCharm base box choice is now open!

The choice items for February are:

  • Brow Bar By Reema – Bombshell Brow Kit in Light, Medium, or Dark
  • Ace Beautè – Nostalgia Palette
  • Wander Beauty – Getaway Eye and Face Palette

What do you think of the spoilers?

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, the regular BoxyCharm box is $25 a month.

Check out our reviews of Boxycharm to learn more!

BoxyCharm ($25 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 4-5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and established brands, with a total retail value of over $100 in every box. The beauty item... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



I just went back to what I picked and I’m not too happy with myself. I apparently pick the Ace palette. Which is a great formula but those shades are not user friendly for me!!!

I wanted the Brow Bar! I must have been hitting the mmj a little hard that night!


Anyone order a mystery base box with the it Cosmetics moisturizer and get 2 shipping notifications for it? Both shipping emails are over 1.1 lbs?


Where are spoilers for February??


The only hint I’ve seen is the boxycharmsneakpeak page on Instagram and YouTube. But none of the spoilers have been confirmed yet. I feel like there’s usually more spoilers by now!


Good question…makes me very afraid it is going to be a box of junk.

Donna R Spagnolo

I want the Ciatte Palette and Pure and Eyeliner.I have 2 boxes already and have 4 of the same repeat items.Love BoxyCharms but it would be nice to choose your variation Boxes.I have to purchase on addons.Great variety of makeup and skin care products for the Value.


If I cancelled today would I be able to miss this box? I chose the brow item even though I don’t do my brows. I mean maybe once a year I get them done if Ulta is having a brow day. I love my thick brows.
The palettes just aren’t me. All items are of value but just not my taste. There was nothing in add ons either.
I would love to just skip but I can’t find that option.

Steph H.

Yes. As long as you cancel before the first of the month.


I’ve been really happy with my boxes each month…I understand that I won’t live every single thing but the box is more than worth it for what I’m paying. When you have really high expectations for a sub box, you are def going to be disappointed. But I’m choosing to be happy to get over $120 worth of items in the base box for $25. So I’m happy!


Thats exactly how I rated my box a couple months ago. I kept my expectations low and ended up loving the majority of my box. As long as I get even a couple of the items I see in all of these unboxing videos, I will be happy.


I chose the brow kit I looked up reemas website wasn’t meant reviews but there were all 4-5 stars and I wasn’t excited but maybe this brow kit is really all that for 42 bucks it should be lol Idk I’m super excited to be back with boxy I used to get it and stopped for like a year almost 2 so everything is new to me and I really need to up my game on products with covid I’ve used up so much products I haven’t really been able to buy anything this past almost year so I do think boxycharm is great to up your beauty products fast and affordable but I do see many repeats from past boxes as I was doing research on things so I see your frustration ladies!


Did anyone get a base box yet for 1.8 lbs for January? I hate how they put in addons items that are coming in the box for the same month. Especially what most of us haven’t even received our box yet. I want to purchase the palette from addons and no clue if it will be in my box and that sucks because I dont need 2. What happened when the items would go into addons for the following month. It makes no sense anymore.


My January box was 1.8 lbs-
Ciate London eyeshadow palette
Qveen eyeliner duo
Lifestyle mist spray
DrBrandt eye cream
Farmacy daily greens mouisterizer
I hope you get what you’re after!💙


My January Base box was 1.8 lbs on its own – avant micellar water choice. I received the VV Olive palettes, the Farmacy gel moisturizer, the Seraphine lip mask and the Trust Fund gloss. The gloss isn’t my favorite formula but I was happy with this box!


Agree…that irritates me too. All the need to do is move it back a month.


Mine was 1.5 lbs / 0.68 kgs and I got VV olive palette.


I got the olive palette, too. I think the colors are really pretty! Somewhat dark, but look really nice! I’m excited to try them.


Thank you! I am hoping for that one too. I should be hoping for the other one tho so then I will get the Olive palette lol. Do you like it? How is pigment?


It will not let me pick my item. I guess because I cancelled to soon so I wouldnt get charged for next month. So first box I didnt get to pick and now the last one. What a bunch of crap!!!! ispy getting my money!!!


It might be the same thing that happened to me earlier today. I logged out, cleared cache & cookies, relaunched Chrome and then I was able to pick. Of course maybe they are not letting you choose…
Related: Ipsy bought BoxyCharm, which may improve things or make them worse. I suppose we’ll see.


where do i find the page where you choose? This is my first box.


It’s my first box too well I’m waiting for Jan I signed back up to boxy but with a new email so technically I’m a new member but this isn’t my first box I think you have to go to add ons log in you should have a 10$ credit to use as a add on and when your done with that you’ll be taken to the choice option. I didn’t spend anything extra on my add ons this month and you can get a nice free gift with the 10$ code (I got a Saturday skin face wash for 9$) so use that code girl theres tons of items 10$ and under but after you do you’ll be directed to your choice option just go log in side swipe to shop and under that is the option for choice I believe as well so you can try that too I totally forgot if not go through that process either way you can do it. I chose the brow kit I don’t have anything like that and i looked it up all the reviews were good same for the ace beaute pallette but I figured I would get the brow kit for 42$ retail I’m thinking it could be a really good product and may lessen up the time I currently take to get the “perfect brow” have fun tho I know I am its been years since I got boxycharm but my money situation changes and boxy is a sure way to up your beauty products game in a short period with a VERY affordable option so I’m so excited to get mine again! I wanna try ipsy again too at some point but one thing at a time right? Ps sorry for the book just wanted to point that out because I wasn’t sure if we could do choice for the first time but you certainly can!

Denise Atkinson

I never got my 10 dollars I was promised when I signed up. I bought stuff anyway but it never showed up there either. Now I’m wondering if the elemis will actually show up in my box. I couldn’t get in touch with anyone either.


I believe they dont let you choose for your fist box.


This is crazy, no matter which choice I pick, I get this error: “OOPS… Your Choice isn’t confirmed! One of your items has reached its Choice quota. Please make a new Choice”

Sounds like I don’t have a choice! I’ll try to contact them but I don’t expect a timely response.


P.S. I didn’t contact them before I tried clearing cache, cookies, etc. and then I was able to pick one. I hope the options get better.


Wow! Really bad choice and add ons! No skincare choices at all and 2 palettes. Ipsy plus has been much better!


Glad I cancelled, nothing exciting.


no wonder there were no spoilers for choice. cancelled right after i saw the options.


Just resubbed to Boxycharm on a 3 month base membership and already regretting it… the choices were a meh for me. If boxes doin’t look good in the upcoming months I’m going to just stick with my ipsy plus, you get to choose 3 items in the bag as oppose to 1 in boxycharm for same price.


The Wander palette is no longer available. The other palette is nothing I want, and I was thoroughly unimpressed with the last brow bar kit I received. Guess I’m finally canceling.


Terrible choices and last 2 boxes were not for me. Canceled.


I chose brow palette.


I love Ace Beauté and so excited to get their pallet!


I love Ace Beaute too! I just picked up the 3 palettes in add ons and OMG. I think people only get excited for “Name Brand” but I have been loving Indie brands because the quality is actually better in most cases, for eyeshadows at least. I ended up picking the brow bar thing because I love brow products. But I am not super excited about it tbh. I am really hoping the next spoiler is good. And really staying subscribed for Pop Up


I would agree these choices are lame. Hopefully the other spoilers will be better.


These choices are NOT exciting me.


I chose the Brown bar, I have nothing like it and it has very good reviews, I did not like the palettes at all, I will wait for the next spoilers to know if it is really worth the February box, if they do not convince me I will cancel.


Bye boxycharm! Cancelled premium last month and now this month I’m saying goodbye to base box!


No great choices this month. I picked the Ace eyeshadow but may cancel at the end of the month.


I remember these same items to pick just a few months ago..cause I got the blush/eye shadows…I guess its time to cancel this box as well..choices are terrible….and no new items..

You Might Also Like

FabFitFun Winter 2021 Box Spoilers: ‘Tis the Season Part 1
FabFitFun Winter 2021 Box Spoilers: ‘Tis the Season Part 1
October 19, 2021
Birchbox October 2021 Review + 50% Off Coupon
Birchbox October 2021 Review + 50% Off Coupon
October 20, 2021
Trendmood Volume 13 Box: Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4
Trendmood Volume 13 Box: Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4
October 23, 2021
FabFitFun Winter 2021 Box Spoilers: Fantastical Finishes
FabFitFun Winter 2021 Box Spoilers: Fantastical Finishes
October 21, 2021
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.