Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Boxycharm August 2022 Base Spoiler #1, Spoiler #2, Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4

BoxyCharm November 2020 Full Product List!

ByMSANov 6, 2020 | 44 comments

BoxyCharm November 2019 beauty and makeup subscription box review

BoxyCharm

4.3 overall rating

1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

Here is the full product list for the November BoxyCharm base box:

Natasha Denona - Peak Palette
Beauty Bakerie - Breakfast In Bed Eyeshadow Palette
111 Skin - Hyaluronic Acid Aqua Booster

Dr. Brandt - Antioxidant Spray Toner
Peach & Lily - Power Calm Hydrating Gel Cleanser
Volition Beauty - Snow Mushroom Water Serum
Earth Harbor Naturals - HELIOS Anti-Pollution Youth Ampoule

FARSÁLI Privé - Quench
Murad - Hydro-Dynamic Ultimate Moisture for Eyes
Jouer - Essential Lip Enhancer
Milk Makeup - Kush Waterproof Mascara - Black

Benefit Cosmetics - Gimme Brow + Volumizing Eyebrow Gel
YENSA - Pumpkin Turmeric 2-In-1 Radiance Polishing Mask
Half Caked - Game Changer Lip Fondant Trio
Beauty Creations - Esmeralda I

Beauty Creations - Esmeralda II
Beauty Creations - Boudoir A Eyeshadow Palette
Beauty Creations - Cali Glow
INT Cosmetics - Lip Oil

Jecca Blac - Liquid Corrector 2.0
Moda - Ultimate Eye Sculptors - Rose Gold
Alamar Cosmetics - Pero Primero, Primer! Long Wear Sticky Pigment Base
Bodyography - Eye Pencil Duo - OnyxBlack Walnut

What do you think of the spoilers?

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, the regular Boxycharm box is $25 a month:

Use this link and coupon code QUEENSRULEALL to get free Eloise The Queen Palette and a $10 credit for the BoxyPopUp when you sign up for a subscription!

Check out our reviews of Boxycharm to learn more!

Starting at $30.00

Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm

4.3 overall rating

1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

Spoilers

Deals

Reviews

Read customer reviews >

Posted in BoxyCharm, BoxyCharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers

MSA

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Read More By MSA >

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Notify me of follow-up comments by email

44 comments

Alyssa

I got this same exact box, and I ordered in late November. I was actually surprised that I received both the Milk Mascara and the ND pallet. I absolutely love it though.

Hannah

Box 14, 1.7 lb. New subscription so also received the Eloise The Queen palette.

-Beauty Bakerie Breakfast in Bed Eyeshadow Palette
-Volition Snow Mushroom Water Serum
-Milk Makeup Kush Waterproof Mascara
-bodyography 2 pack eye pencils (brown/black)
-Int Cosmetics Lip Oil (Red)

Pretty happy with the box. I would have been upset I didn’t receive the ND palette but my friend didn’t like the colors so she gave it to me two days ago.

Barb

We are box twins! I just got my box. I am pretty pleased with what I got. I got two palettes because I got the Eloise for resubscribing missed choice for Nov
It’s all makeup except for the serum and I needed a good serum

Robin

Hmm. I’m beginning to wonder if those of us who Subbed/resubbed for November, and possibly also missed choice got that exact box.

I had high hopes for the Mascara, and love the container, but I’ve tried it twice now, and It has just ended up under my eyes where I already fight dark circles. 🙁 From there, it suddenly lived up to it’s more waterproof reputation. That’s typical in my experience, but I’m still hoping to find something that lets me actually wear mascara. Especially since I think I finally stumbled upon an eyeliner that stays where it belongs on me! (It only took 46 years! lol)

Robin

Best of both worlds. Gotta love that. Lol

We’re box twins! The first I’ve seen with my exact products. 🙂

How do you know which # variation it is? Did a spoiler lost them? I’m very new to all this.

Dayan

Got box 53… Hated it so much…
The only thing I’ll use is prob farsali and may be able to gift the brow product (which I picked it with gifting in mind).
So many variations… With my luck, even with profile completed, it’s been months that I could use 100% of box items…
Gonna try till end of year then it’s keep or bye bye sigh…

Makeup86

I have never hated a box this much from Boxy.

The only color cosmetics were crap wood eye pencils, which I never use because they skip and look terrible. The rest was skin care and a lip enhancer (fancy chapstick.)

Just teased me with that Natasha Denona palette and besides not getting that, I got no color cosmetics! They had a dozen eye palettes available and couldn’t be bothered to send one to me. Or a blush or any makeup.

I like skin care, but not as 100% of my box. Wood eye pencils do not count as anything but cheap sh** filler. After over 5 years subscribing they pull this bull? If my premium box is this crappy, I’m screaming.

And I’m really starting to think that 111 Skin brand is an overpriced fake brand to make the box look more valuable. The price they list for it is higher than brands that I’ve actually heard of. I feel scammed.

I recommend that you go into your preferences and change to the “all makeup” option to avoid getting so much skincare. I changed mine and put palettes as a top choice when I saw the ND palette. I ended up getting the ND and Ciate palettes this month.

Steph H.

I’m really happy with the variation I received! My box weighs 1.1 lbs and I received variation 20♡. My box contains:

Natasha Denona Peak Palette
Dr. Brandt Antioxidant Spray Toner
Jouer Lip Enhancer
Half Caked Game Changer Lip Fondant Trio
Moda Ultimate Eye Sculptors

I chose the Jouer and it’s great! Very moisturizing and long lasting. The liquid lip trio are wearable colors including the red which I normally don’t use. I love toners so I’m excited to try, and needed one more than any other type of skincare. The eyeshadow palette is perfect for fall and are colors I normally use. Plus, they go well with the liquid lipstick. At first I was meh with the Moda brushes but I primarily use blending brushes so these will definitely be used. Very happy with Boxycharm!

Becca

I got box 26. I picked milk mascara and received

Natasha Denona palette
Dr. Brandt spray toner
Half Caked lip trio
Alamar eyeshadow primer

I’m happy with what I got

Sara

I got the same one too! Was your mascara dried out like mine? I didn’t really like anything in this box. Holing out for December’s Luxe box.

Sara

Except the toner…

Kim T.

I GOT 2 BOX for one base box subscription today(11/11/2020): I got two variations and I’ll put the info here if it helps anyone. I am not on any social media platform, so being an “influencer” is out of the question.

1. #53: 111 Skin, Farsali Preve(Quench), Gimme Brow(which I picked), Half caked trio lip fondant, and Jecca Blac liquid corrector

This is definitely my box since I picked the brow thing. This came in a 9x7x3 box weighing in at 1lbs 0.45 oz

2. #39: ntasha denona peak palette, volition beauty snow serum, jouer cosmetics lip quencher, beauty creation cali glow, Bodyography eye pencil duo

I like this box way better. This came in a 9x7x4-5inch box weighing about the same.

I think they should have only 10-20 variations and let people pick the variation they want. These boxes are not at all fair or even in products. This would be more transparent and then people can pick what they need.

Sara Slick

Super disappointed in this months box. The lip shades are not pretty, and I’m not a fan of the ND palette. The toner looks nice and I’m excited for the milk mascara. I was really disappointed with the choices for next months luxe box as well. Hopefully the rest of the box will make up for it… considering going back to ipsy in January if Boxy doesn’t woo me.

Mim

I don’t love my box but I don’t hate it either. I got the Natasha denona pallet which I know a lot of people wanted. I don’t use warm tones like that so it’s not useful for me but it’ll be a nice gift. I like the serum and I don’t mind the eyeliners. I chose the Jouer lip treatment but then I also got the lip oil which I wish I would’ve been replaced by some thing else so I wasn’t getting two similar items. Value is definitely there and even though it’s not useful for me it’s nice to finally get a popular spoiler item.

Jayme

I would be happy to trade, I really wanted the Natasha Denona palette and ended up with both serums.

Christina

I’m not seeing anyone with my weight box. 🙁 I’m so curious to know!!
its been “pending” to ship since Friday *facepalm*\
any one?

WEIGHT
1 lbs
DIMENSIONS
9x7x3 in.

Stacey

Mine is 1 lb also and has been “pending” since Friday. 🙁
Waiting impatiently. Lol

Robin

Ok, I got my first box. The good news is for me, once it ships it’s only about a 7 hr car ride away so Fedex brought it pretty quickly. Hopefully that will be the norm.

I got the Eloise The Queen Palette for signing up then these box contents:

-Beauty Bakerie Breakfast in Bed Eyeshadow Palette
-Volition Snow Mushroom Water Serum
-Milk Makeup Kush Waterproof Mascara (glad I didn’t buy it in the pop-up)
-bodyography 2 pack eye pencils (brown/black)
-Int Cosmetics Lip Oil (RedY?)

Barb

I just resubscribed. I’m getting the Eloise palette as a gift. Other than that I’ll have to wait and see. I got an email telling me it shipped. It’s 1.9 lbs but I don’t see it anywhere. I really hope it’s a great box!

Robin

I have to say kinda loved seeing people on here talking about the weights of the boxes. I appreciate the clever and obsessive nature of that. It seems like a very me thing, but I’m not sure this one would have occured to me. It made me smile for sure. 🙂

I got the Eloise Palette too. My box says 1.7 lbs. I had to look for where it even says that. Not that I have any idea what that might mean. Lol

TANIA

La mía pesa lo mismo estoy ansiosa por saber si viene la paleta de ND
podrías decirme que la recibiste en tu caja ?

Robin

Thank you Barb. You too!

It says actually 1.79 I think. And it’s 9x7x4. That would be with the Eloise palette though, so it may not exactly match standard November weights or dimensions.

Barb

Yeah, mine was on the FedEx tracking link under details. I am surprised that it shipped so soon.The palette looks so pretty. Gl on the contents of your box.

Kenley

I received mine today. My variation was 31 with box dimensions 9x7x3 and weighed 1.2 lbs.

I got:

Natasha Denona Palette
Milk Makeup Mascara
Peach & Lily Gel Cleanser
Yensa Pumpkin Tumeric 2-in-1 Polishing Mask
Jessica Blac Liquid Corrector

Crystal

I received mine today! Happy with everything. O got Variation #15, weighed 1.1 lbs

-Natasha Denona Peak Palette
-Farsali Preve Quench Serum
-Jouer Cosmetics Lip Enhancer
-Half Caked Game Changer Lip Fondant Trio
-MODA brush set

Megan

Just got mine! It’s not bad. I really wanted that spray and the half caked trio, but but I got box 17…

The ND palette (looks better in person!)
Gimmie brow in #4
Yensa Polishing Mask
Snow Mushroom Water Serum
Jecca Blac Liquid Corrector

Laura Cohen

How can you tell what number box you got? I have just returned to BC but haven’t gotten anything really good yet!

Marion

Full spoilers for all the Premium items are also up now!

Bethani

I thought this was a makeup sub box, not much makeup considering you only get one pallet and most of the makeup featured is pallets.

Julie

Just got my box, I’m pretty happy! I chose the Milk mascara.

I got the ND palette, Volition beauty snow mushroom serum, INT Cosmetics lip oil, Alamar sticky pigment base. Variation 13, 1.2 lbs.

Lanie

My box is 1.2 lbs too. I hope I get the ND palette. What were your box dimensions?

Julie

Lanie
9x7x4
Good luck!

Audra K.

Mine is 1.2 pounds as well! I chose the Benefit tinted brow gel. I’m really hoping I get that ND palette!!

Jessica

What a great box! Enjoy.

Ranee'

Does anyone else have the problem of boxycharm never giving out shipping info..I don’t even know when its coming..I never get an email? Thanks

Robin

It was in my app, right on the tab for whichever bag it’s for.

Robin

My apologies, I somehow thought the question was about Ipsy.

Under Account, My Items in Boxy, it just says “Shipping November 2020,” so far. I am new, so obviously can’t yet speak to how the status may or may not update in there.

Marion

Slashed prices tell you which things are going to appear in the PopUp shop. 😊

Angie

Really want the dr Brandt , volition and 111 skin but knowing my luck I won’t receive even one of them lol

Dayan

Same. I would be super happy if 4 out of 5 items I receive are skincare products.
If they can’t honor our preferences, why even bother to ask??

Pink5

That’s what made me quit Boxy in the first place.

reeb

There’s a 99.9% chance I’m going to end up with that Bodyography eye pencil duo, since I have three others that I never opened.

Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

BoxyCharm November 2020 Full Product List!

Advertise With MSA

Information

Company