Facebook PixelCatLadyBox Subscription Box Review - September 2020 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

CatLadyBox Subscription Box Review – October 2020

Ragan Buckley
ByRagan BuckleyOct 12, 2020 | 10 comments

4.4 overall rating
36 Ratings | 4 Reviews

CatLadyBox is a monthly subscription box for cat ladies (or anyone who is crazy about cats)! The $34.99 per month CatLadyBox has 2-3 cat-themed items – wearables, items for the home, books, etc. The $39.99 per month Crazy CatLadyBox contains everything from the CatLadyBox plus a few items just for cats.

This is a review of the $39.99/month “Crazy” CatLadyBox.

My Subscription Addiction pays for this subscription. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

About CatLadyBox

The Subscription Box: CatLadyBox

The Cost: $39.99 per month + free U.S. shipping. Save with longer subscriptions.

ACTIVE DEAL: Limited Time Only! Get 20% off your first box

The Products: Unique and exclusive cat lady finds, from cat-themed jewelry and clothes to accessories, home décor, books, and more.

Ships to: The U.S. (free in the contiguous 48 states), U.K., Canada, and Alaska and Hawaii ($12.95)

CatLadyBox October 2020 Review

CatLadyBox is always full of fun, cat-themed lifestyle items. Let’s see what was in store for October:


I love how the information cards have custom artwork every month. And the back has more information about the items in the box. This month has a black cat theme. We love black cats!

On to the items:


Squishy Black Cat Pillow - Retail Value $22.99

This is indeed very soft and squishy and I love it. Right now it is on a shelf because I don't want it to get covered with Monkey hair (it wouldn't be black anymore!). But I'll use it from time to time when I need a bit of back support on my super deep couch, and other times I'll just admire it because I think it's very cute.


Peeping Cats Shirt - Listed Value $21.99

I am living in CatLadyBox t-shirts right now since I've been working from home (which started in MARCH). So it's nice to have another one in my collection. This is soft and fits me loosely enough to be comfortable for sleeping, exercise, and everyday wear (yeah, I don't change my clothes as often as I did when I had to go into the office...). It looks good after having been washed, too. Monkey "helped" me photograph it.


Black Cat Cuff Bracelet - Retail Value $19.99

I often have trouble with cuff bracelets because I have a tiny wrist for an adult, but this one has a narrow enough opening that it stays on my wrist. There's a little give so you could wear it on a larger wrist as well (this hangs on me like a bangle, fairly loosely, but I wouldn't want to speculate about a maximum wrist size). This will be great for casual wear and should match quite a lot of shirts.

Deco Cat Ears - Listed Value $12.99

I found a couple of cat ears headbands when I cleaned out my closet recently but I don't have any with this design. This is a fun little bonus item and I might wear it to the Whole Foods just for the heck of it (I mean, no one can see my face behind my mask anyway!).

Cat-o-lantern Catnip Toy - Listed Value $4.99

This is a catnip plush toy and the boys (Madison and Monkey) both enjoyed rubbing their faces on it. It's on the small side and that's great as my cats tend to prefer smaller toys. It seems well made so I think it'll last for a long time, too.

Mewnicorn Catnip Toy - Listed Value $6.99

This toy is a kitty dressed up for Halloween. There are a lot of different parts here and they were all interesting to my cats, with the tail, in particular, standing out. I think this is adorable and creative and my cats mostly care that it is a catnip plush.

Gratuitous cat photos:


Madison is the black cat, Sneaky is the calico, and Monkey is tan and white (I was asked in another review which one was which).

Verdict: I calculated a value of about $89.94 for the October 2020 "Crazy" CatLadyBox. I feel like this was a pretty good value for the price. The shirt is immediately useful and my cats liked the toys, the cat ears will be fun for a little while, I can actually wear the bracelet (we've received cuffs in the past that were a bit too big for me), and I just love the pillow because I think it's cute. (Not everything has to be practical!)

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Officially your subscription would start with November's box if you order before the cutoff on the 26th, but way back when I signed up, I was contacted to say there were a few of the current month’s boxes left over and asked if I’d like one of those. So it may be worth inquiring.

ACTIVE DEAL: Limited Time Only! Get 20% off your first box

Value Breakdown: At a price of $39.99 for this box, you are paying approximately the following per item:

  • Cat pillow $10.22
  • Shirt $9.78
  • Bracelet $8.89
  • Cat ears headband $5.78
  • Cat-o-lantern toy $2.22
  • Mewnicorn toy $3.11

Check out our other CatLadyBox reviews and find lots of other great boxes for cats, along with the best subscription boxes for women.

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think of the October CatLadyBox? Do you subscribe to any cat boxes?

Starting at $39.99
Active Deal
Get 20% off your first box
Use Coupon Code FLOOFY
Subscribe Now
Treat yourself to a monthly box of the most unique and exclusive cat lady finds. Cat-themed jewelry, clothes, accessories, decor, books and more for you, delivered in a box your cat can keep (of course).
Ragan Buckley
Ragan Buckley
Ragan stumbled across My Subscription Addiction in late 2013 and immediately subscribed to way too many beauty boxes. She's now focused on boxes for her cats and dog, vegan/vegetarian food boxes, and craft subscriptions (and she didn't give up beauty boxes entirely).

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



This box always tempts me. And I love the gratuitous cat photos too:)

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Amy in KC

This box is always a delight. The pillow is my new favorite thing. I’m an adult woman who sleeps with a couple of stuffed animals and cute pillows :D, and this kitty one is now a proud resident of my bed. It’s unbelievably soft. I find it so comforting!!

The bangle is so cute; I like the subtle design. I have small wrists too and I was able to adjust it by gently squeezing it. (@SheriH – your daughter might try that??)

@Sharon Hines – I’m sorry you were disappointed in this box. I was able to customize my t-shirt color/design as well as the metal finish of the headband (I chose gold). Maybe this is a feature only for long-term subscribers? I have been a CatLadyBox subscriber for at least three years now, maybe four. I find their items are always super practical and good quality.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Sharon Hines

Subscribed and this box made me immediately cancel. Carnival type trinkets with a true value of maybe 20$. Did not get a Halloween t-shirt, got one of one of a cat looking out a window not like the one shown, and it was ugly. So disappointed. Would have been happy if there was at least one nice item. Huge thumbs down.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


That should have been wear. 😜

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


We love the Cat Lady box! My teen daughter and I fight over that cat pillow. It is so soft and squishy. She loved the car ears and the tee. They both fit perfectly. However I wish they would allow subscribers to order a small or large. My daughter is a size 0 and the bangle is too big. I suggested she were it up on her arm like Cleopatra. 😁 The cats LOVED the cat toys as usual. Two of the kittens we foster were fighting over the cat in the unicorn suit. (We volunteer with a feline rescue group, so we usually have several kittens and/or cats).Thanks for the review, Ragan.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


And my friend’s black cat is named Cleopatra!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


I, too, love the squishy pillow. My cats don’t appreciate it as much as I do — they keep growling at it!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


I used to wear cat ears once a year, to open the door on Halloween when the neighborhood kids came up the driveway and I handed them the chocolates. Then I lost my cat ears so I’ve been wearing a witch’s hat for the candy-handing-out. It’s a nice process in our neighborhood, and I enjoy it. One or two of my black cats may sit outside in the driveway, too, to support the image and give the younger kids a thrill.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Ragan Buckley

No candy handing out this year for us because of COVID. Actually I let my husband do that most years anyway because I don’t interact well with children…

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


Same here Ragan, I’d rather hang out with my cats! We haven’t had any trick or treaters in our neighborhood since we moved to our current home years ago. I loved this box, my kitties loved the toys, and I hope the other colors of the shirts show up in the shop past boxes section. I chose the yellow, but I’d like to get the blue too.

Like This CommentLike