Facebook PixelBoxyCharm October 2020 Full Product List! | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

Boxycharm August 2022 Base Spoiler #1, Spoiler #2, Spoiler #3 and Spoiler #4

BoxyCharm October 2020 Full Product List!

MSA
ByMSAOct 7, 2020 | 52 comments

BoxyCharm November 2019 beauty and makeup subscription box review

BoxyCharm
4.3 overall rating
1949 Ratings | 195 Reviews

Here is the full product list for the October BoxyCharm base box:

  • HIPDOT - Color Change Pink Sponge Duo - Pink
  • HIPDOT - Color Change Pink Sponge Duo - Blue

  • SYMBIOSIS LONDON - Tightening & Resplendent Eye Mask
  • Frank Body - Glow Mask

  • tarte - Maracuja Miracle Mist Setting Spray
  • Sol de Janeiro - Brazilian Kiss Tinted Cupuaçu Lip Butter

  • Ace Beautè - Draw It Lip Liner Duo - Be Peachy So Gorgeous
  • Lavaa Lashes - Charm Faux Mink - Black/White

  • LUXIE - Wonderlust Set - Periwinkle
  • Beauty Bakerie - Breakfast In Bed Eyeshadow Palette

  • Pretty Vulgar - Nesting B!#%h Face Palette
  • Spongelle - Body Wash Infused Buffer - Cherry Tonka Musk

  • RODIAL - Soft Focus Glow Booster Drops
  • Dose of Colors - Meet Your Hue Concealer

  • Murad - AHA/BHA Exfoliating Cleanser
  • Grown Alchemist - Matte Balancing Moisturizer - Acai Berry & Borago

  • FARSÁLI Privé - Quench Moisture Replenishing Serum
  • REALHER - Ultimate Glow Getter Cheek Trio
  • Ciaté London - The Editor Palette - New England

What do you think of the spoilers?

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, the regular Boxycharm box is $25 a month:

Use this link and coupon code CANDY6ALL to get a $6 coupon for Add-Ons when you sign up for a subscription!

Check out our reviews of Boxycharm to learn more!

Starting at $30.00
Subscribe Now

BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.

MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

52 comments

Jenna

Did anyone get box #93? Mine didn’t ship out and boxy is saying it got returned to sender and resending me #93. I don’t want a box of leftovers :*(

Reply ButtonReply

alex

following because that is happening to me too

Reply ButtonReply

Jenna

Have they sent your box out yet Alex? They told me it could take up to 2 weeks to ship out my replacement. If I knew it would be a good box I totally wouldn’t mind but it is Boxycharm!

Steph H.

Anyone get a 1.1 lbs box?

Reply ButtonReply

Brandy-lee Nunes

I just received my base box this morning! Wieght:1.3lbs variation #76.
Farsali prive quench was my chioce. Also received:
Beauty Bakerie breakfast in bed palette
Luxie eye brush set
Frank Body glow mask
Lavva lashes
Really love this box although I won’t use the lashes,was hoping to make a trade for the Tarte’s Maracuja setting spray?

Reply ButtonReply

Sarah

I got my Ipsy GBP and Boxycharm both on Saturday, and was impressed by BOTH!! That NEVER happens!!

Reply ButtonReply

Becca

Very happy with my box! #74. I love everything!

Pretty Vulgar Palette
Tarte Maracuja Setting Spray
Farsali Quench
Symbiosis Eye Mask
Hipdot Sponge Duo

Reply ButtonReply

Shelly

Base Box
Variation 66 WEIGHT 1.5 lbs / 0.68 kgs DIMENSIONS 9x7x3 in.
Pretty Vulgar Palette
Rodial soft focus glow drops
Murad Cleanser
Sol De Janeiro lip butter
Lavaa Lashes
171.99 Value

Reply ButtonReply

LisaFalana

My only real want was the Farsali which I got along with:
the Editor palette,
Brazilian Kiss the lip tint,
Rodial glow drops which I liked from another box a while back,
Spongelike, which are always good for travel.
Overall a good box for me!

Reply ButtonReply

Rachel

Mine weighed 1.2 pounds and contained:
Farsali serum (choice)
Hipdot sponges
Nesting B*tch face palette
Tarte mist
Symbiosis eye mask

Reply ButtonReply

Mel

My choice was farsali as well. And I would be happy with a box like yours 🙂 thanks for sharing. Mine should be here Monday!

Reply ButtonReply

Ves

Just got mine today. No shipping notification via email or on boxycharm site. So, Yay, happy Friday surprise! The Murad Cleanser was my choice item.

Variation 68:

-Murad Cleanser
-Bakerie Palette
-Grown Alchemist Moisturizer
-Sol De Janeiro Lip Butter
-Spongelle

Reply ButtonReply

Alice

Nice items!

Reply ButtonReply

Joy-Not the Other One

I just received mine. I never received an email saying it had shipped but here it is! 🙂

VERSION 73

Pretty Vulgar Palette
Grown Alchemist
Murad Cleanser
Sol de Janeiro Lip Butter
Hipdot Sponges

Reply ButtonReply

Mel

Has anyone got their box or seen an unboxing with the farsali yet?? My box is shipping I just got the email today. It’s 1.4 lbs so I’ll probably have spongelle in it but I’m ok with that. I’m really curious as to what the other items could be.

Reply ButtonReply

Tanya

I got my box yesterday and loved it! I got the brushes (always need them), SDJ tinted lip butter (WOW LOVE), Spongelle (love), my pick Dose of Colors concealer (too light, even after I used the website’s recommendation and watched youtube videos. BOO), and the Ciate palette (nice enough).

Reply ButtonReply

Amanda

I’m going to type out my wish list and come back and tell how close they got it. It will go by what I have on my profile. Guarantee you they will so far off, like always.

Farsali- I chose this
Sol de Janeiro lip butter
Cavaa Lashes
Spongelle
Mourad Cleanser or Grown Alchemist

I won’t be too happy with anything else really because the options just suck. I don’t use blush, bronzer, glow drops, ugly colored lip liners, or bad low quality palettes. Those sponges will suck. Most of us use only beauty blender sponges. Do any of us really need more brushes from Luxie? Let’s be real here. We don’t. Maybe they should give brushes to newer people who don’t have 100 already. I guess the Tarte spray wouldn’t be too bad. But watch, I’ll come back and say I got lip liners, sponges, and blush.

Reply ButtonReply

Amanda

I got
Farsali: chose this
Ace Beauty lip liners- unusable colors
Pretty Vulgar face palette- I NEVER use highlighter, bronzer, etc. At least Ipsy would let us choose one type of item to be exempt.
Frank Body Glow Mask- I should have included this on my list because I do have body products chosen so this is good.
Grown Alchemist- Good!

So I only got 2 things that I have selected on my profile not to get, lip liner and face palette. I’m happy with the Grown Alchemist, Farsali, and Frank Body. Not bad really. Could have been a lot worse.

Reply ButtonReply

Steph H.

🙋‍♀️ I do! Gimme all the Luxie brushes. I have a lot of them already but would never complain about receiving more. Luxie has excellent quality brushes that hold up amazingly.

Reply ButtonReply

Jamey

I am curious what Amanda got in her box vs what she listed!! That would be an interesting thing for people to post each month, and then what they got!!

Reply ButtonReply

Jamey

I’ll take ALL the one sided (I dont like double ended brushes) they will send me!!! I love and will have 500 brushes and think I’m so slick..then when it comes time to wash them…..hahaha. but luxie are great brushes and hold up well washing them.

Wish they would send us some GOOD large face brush sets

Reply ButtonReply

Makeup86

Look at the handles on your Luxie brushes and note how many are badly warped. They are the worst at that. There bristles are good but since brightst aren’t disposable, it’s a good place for them to switch to plastic.

Laura

Why stay subscribed? Just curious, since you don’t sound exactly excited…😂🤷‍♀️

Reply ButtonReply

Caroline

right…

Danidee

Thank you so much for saying this❤️ ☝🏻I was biting my tongue….hard. 🤣

Julie b

Got my box today and I’m okay with it. I’m a palette junkie and the Beauty Bakerie colors look right up my alley. I got the Luxie Wanderlust set of brushes (don’t need any more brushes…ever), Dose of Colors concealer, Symbiosis London eye mask (worth $93? We’ll see…), and Ace Beaute lip liner duo. Could’ve been worse.
It was .9 lbs, version 28

Reply ButtonReply

Mary

Oh man, this is the exact box I would want except switch out the lip liners for the tarte spray! I always get the absolute worst variations and none of the good stuff always paraded all over YouTube/instagram spoilers, it’s so frustrating. If I don’t get the tarte spray and the beauty Bakerie palette after all the hyping up they did I’m going to be really upset.

Last two months I got none of the stuff that they were hyping besides the palettes everyone got. I didn’t get the Marc Jacobs lip gloss (which was in EVERY unboxing, I thought it was 100% everyone was getting it), didn’t get any of the Sunday Riley, didn’t get any of those big trestique sets, didn’t get Huda matte/metal, and out of the like NINE different shades of fenty highlighter they had available, EIGHT of them would have been workable with my skin tone in some way shape or form (and they are well aware what my skin tone is)- take a wild guess which one I got :/ yep, the ONE that doesn’t work in any way for me, the very darkest one. I’ve been so disappointed every time I do an unboxing since I resubscribed a few months ago. The only thing keeping me from unsubscribing is the opportunity to buy add ons and pop up. Otherwise I’d be so gone. It’s so frustrating, I really wish they’d go back to MUCH fewer variations. Especially if they are going to continue to COMPLETELY disregard the info we give them about our complexions and preferences.

Reply ButtonReply

Monica

If I get the beauty bakery palette I’ll be happy to swap with you, I really don’t use eyeshadow and I have millions of new palettes sitting in my vanity

Marion

Premium full list is also up.

You can get more sneak peeks at what will be available in add-ons next week by which products appear with slashed prices (as seen with the Rodial drops + Ciate Editor palette in MSA’s screencaps).

Reply ButtonReply

DB

I’m not over the moon about anything I see in the box – but its such a fantastic deal for $25.00 that I can’t complain. With Christmas coming I will have lots of homes for items that are not useful..I really hope 🙏 that I don’t receive those dang sponges or the Ciate London editor palette again. Also on my list of don’ts is lashes, eye or lip liner, mascara and sheet masks. I’m pretty happy with most other products. Love Spongelle and its a scent I’ve never seen. Hope I get one.

Reply ButtonReply

Merlisha

Boxycharm has a premium unboxing on their IG live just now.

Illuminati X Isa pallete
Fenty brow pencil
Clarins primer (?) product
Kosas blush/hilighter
Laura Geller lip product (6 shade variations)

Pretty sure all of these were mentioned on MSA though

Reply ButtonReply

Merlisha

And Go-to exfoliating pads

Reply ButtonReply

Rach

I knew these items would be in the box. I was sent a survey months ago and it showed these items. I also know about upcoming items.

I don’t want the beauty sponges, Ace Beaute liners, lashes, Real Her palette or Spongelle. I can’t use lashes, because I’m allergic to adhesive. I’m highly allergic to strong scents. I’ve received several sponges from Spongelle. The scent takes over my box and I’ve experienced nausea from opening the box. I’m not impressed with the quality of Real Her. I also have enough liners and sponges to last a lifetime.

Reply ButtonReply

Dianne

Ulta has a Beauty Box Caboodles Edition. Got mine yesterday. Did a YT video. X

Reply ButtonReply

Dianne

Ulta has a Beauty Box Caboodles Edition. Got mine yesterday. Did a Youtube video. X

Reply ButtonReply

Hallie Gottlieb

I laughed when i saw caboodles were back and then my make up box broke. I got the pink one with the ulta coupon, rewards and birthday discount. What a steal. I will probably gift most of the make up to a niece but i really like their eye primer so keeping that!

Reply ButtonReply

Suzanne

Does anyone else have a problem with leaving a product review on the Boxycharm site? I’ve tried repeatedly and all I get is a frozen screen and a spinning heart as soon as I click on submit.

Any help would be greatly appreciated!

Reply ButtonReply

Maggie

this happened to me too. all I had to do was allow popups on the site.

Reply ButtonReply

Suzanne

Thanks for the advice, easy peasy. I was able to leave my first review today. Thanks again. 😁

Inge

That happened to me once few months ago. I choose “open in new tab” the review there. Not sure if it’s just temporary glitch or that fixed it but I could leave review that way.

Reply ButtonReply

zo

I’m a little sad I cancelled after many years but with my luck I would have gotten eyelashes, lip liners, glow mask, setting spray (and I have the latter). I’ve gotten to the point now where I just throw in a little eyeshadow and mascara since I wear a mask quite a bit. And with glasses that fog up constantly I have to wear waterproof mascara because it runs otherwise. I have to remind myself every time I see one of these posts and I want it, want it, want it.

Reply ButtonReply

Gabrielle Gilbert

Some great brands! Believe it or not I still haven’t tried a spongelle ;))))))

Reply ButtonReply

Luna

I’ve never used a Spongelle either(!), and I probably have at least 6 in various shapes, sizes, and scents in my stash from boxes. I’m working my way up to them, lol. They sure do make the container I store them smell good though!

Reply ButtonReply

Luna

I think you guys are convincing me to move it up in my queue 😀

Alice

You’re going to love them!

Comicbookfangirl

Don’t postpone happiness Luna, go ahead and give one a try, I think you’ll like it!

Jana

I LOVE Spongelle! Have been buying them up during add ons! I gave one to my daughter to use when she came to visit last month and she loved it as well! I so hope I get another!

Reply ButtonReply

prettypony

I am so excited to try the Sol De Janeiro. That is my favorite brand hands down. I was going to order the lip butter on my own, but I really hope I get in my boxy charm this month!

Reply ButtonReply

Christa H.

I just got my SDJ lip butter in day before yesterday and the scent is so strong. I’m not one where the scents bother me, but I can’t wear it comfortably. It is a great lip balm minus the scent 😊👍 Good thing yall are getting it in Boxycharm as an item and not paying the $20 for it like I did🙌

Reply ButtonReply

prettypony

This exactly, now I hope I get it. Getting something I want from these boxes is half the battle! I have the original Brazilian Kiss Lip Butter and I love it. I am hoping these have the same scent. I have loved every SDJ product I have ever tried.

Jenn

To me the SDJ lip balm smells like play doh with some vanilla thrown in LOL

Courtney

Just got my email yesterday saying mine has been shipped which is early this month, I normally get my notifications around the 10th but I’m happy!

Reply ButtonReply