BoxyCharm November 2020 Spoiler Round #2!

I hate how they say its 25 dollars not it’s not let’s be honest its 40 for canadians…so is it worth it now?

I know! I keep checking back and no spoilers!

Wish we would of gotten one of her palettes that was like 3 of her metallics and 2 mattes…Her metallic shimmer shades are the true winners they are so rich and so gorgeous, plus easy to work with..

I hear you! Seems they push a lot of orange on us, must be a closeout colors or something. Ive been disappointed w boxy lately. Ive had multiple missing items & because it takes so long to hear back, my issues never get resolved. It becomes a bit exhausting. One of the only reasons I continue w them, is because of the skincare items. Im just so tired of them showcasing items that I never end up getting. The good variations seem to go to influencers or someone, because its sure not me.

it looks nice on people with brown skin

I wouldn’t count on this being the actual ND formula. Boxy has a bad habit of collabing with expensive brands and using a cheaper formula

I usually have a community makeup sale in my own town….I recover some cash, unload some product, plus can safely pass on something like a mask I tried for free……I squeeze everything onto applicators….lol but it totally works!!!! You be surprised how many will ask and show up, just do it safely!

I doubt this will be the actual ND formula. Almost every time boxy has collabed with a brand it hasn’t been the brands normal formula.

Yeah, it happened several days ago.

I also have a warm complexion and would love to get this! Nice fall palette!

Honestly, just wait until one of her palettes you like goes on sale at Sephora if you really like something, or on her website. I got 2 of her palettes through huge sales on Sephora. I got the mini Lila palette for like $13 CDN (orig. $33, clearance price was $16.50) and the Tropic palette for around $68 CDN (orig. $162 CDN, clearance price was $81). Both palettes were on clearance and I think I also used a 15% or 20% discount. And that’s additional off the already reduced price. ND palettes can be bought at a nice discount, if you look for the right sale. Right now they still have her blush and contour palettes on clearance. Use an additional discount and you can get either palette for $40 or less. Plus, that way you know you’re getting a true ND formula, not one made just for Boxy which might have questionable quality like other collabs.

I cancelled all my Boxy boxes in the summer, and haven’t really been tempted to come back at all. I was so sick of the bait and switch (showing great products – like this ND palette, only to get something else entirely not even advertised. Very few people actually get the advertised items – mostly influencers and the lucky few “normals”), getting mini products instead of full size, not to mention the major quality issues, having to deal with horrible customer service, cancelled pop-up and add-on orders, COD charges, etc. Plus the bonus gifts for signing back up have been so lame. Mostly $6 or $12 coupons to use in add-on/pop-up. Right, so then the order can get cancelled again? Maybe I’d sign up again if they offered the Park Ave Princess palette again. Maybe.

Now I just look for sets and deals that I want from Sephora, Brands themselves and other shops like Shoppers, and actually get the items I want with the quality I want. And I tell you what, Sephora has excellent customer service for the few issues I’ve had. I’ve also gotten great deals from Urban Decay and SDM. Plus, honestly a lot of the stuff you get in Boxycharm, you can find in your local Winners/Marshalls/TJMaxx.

If you have never had a ND palette you wouldn’t know how amazing they wear regardless of skin tone , I have every ND palette and those ridiculous looking colors are easily incorporated into an everyday lifestyle!

Exactly! And it’s not going to be in every box

I was just thinking that! I compared the ingredients of the story book cosmetics palettes a few weeks ago. Their palettes made in the US have minimal ingredients. The ones made for Boxy have a huge list of ingredients.

Exactly

I doubt this will be an “influencer” exclusive partly because it says it’s a BoxyCharm Exclusive Palette, which usually means just about everyone gets it whether they want it or not. Either way, I’m expecting to see it in my box because despite not being an influencer, I usually get surprisingly good boxes. If there really is a good box list, I’m somehow on it, and I’m terrified of screwing that up.

Yosef says A LOT of things that end up not being true. In the 3+ years I’ve been a member I’ve learned to never trust what he says.

OMG yes…. these colors are horrible

Agree 100%