MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

BoxyLuxe September 2020 FULL Spoilers!

We have a full spoilers for a few variations of the September 2020 BoxyLuxe box!

  • Eloise Beauty The Queen Eyeshadow Palette – $46
  • 111SKIN Rose Gold Brightening Facial Treatment Mask – 5 Pack
  • Pur Cosmetics Signature Travel Essentials 12-Piece Cruelty-Free Brush Set with Cup
  • Fenty Beauty Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter
  • Byroe Tomato Serum – $150
  • GRAVITY Weighted Sleep Mask Grey
  • Keratherapy Deep Conditioning Masque
  • Persona Cosmetics Season One Lip Gloss

  • HipDot Zion Eyeshadow Palette – $30
  • 111SKIN Rose Gold Brightening Facial Treatment Mask – 5 Pack
  • Pur Cosmetics Signature Travel Essentials 12-Piece Cruelty-Free Brush Set with Cup
  • Fenty Beauty Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter
  • Kate Somerville ExfoliKate Intensive Exfoliating Treatment – $58
  • MILK MAKEUP Matcha Detoxifying Face Mask
  • Kitsch Ice Roller
  • Persona Powerbrush

Source: mistygg1982

  • HipDot Zion Eyeshadow Palette – $30
  • 111SKIN Rose Gold Brightening Facial Treatment Mask – 5 Pack
  • Pur Cosmetics Signature Travel Essentials 12-Piece Cruelty-Free Brush Set with Cup
  • Fenty Beauty Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter
  • Kate Somerville ExfoliKate Intensive Exfoliating Treatment – $58
  • TAN-LUXE The Gradual Illuminating Tanning Lotion
  • Persona Cosmetics Season One Lip Gloss
  • Keratherapy Deep Conditioning Masque

  • HipDot Zion Eyeshadow Palette – $30
  • 111SKIN Rose Gold Brightening Facial Treatment Mask – 5 Pack
  • Fenty Beauty Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter
  • Farmacy Cheer Up Brightening Vitamin C Eye Cream with Acerola Cherry – $45
  • TAN-LUXE The Gradual Illuminating Tanning Lotion
  • Keratherapy Deep Conditioning Masque
  • Persona Powerbrush
  • Cuccio Somatology Yogahhh Clean Plus Calm Epsom Salt Hand and Body Wash


  • HipDot Zion Eyeshadow Palette – $30
  • 111SKIN Rose Gold Brightening Facial Treatment Mask – 5 Pack
  • Fenty Beauty Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter
  • Byroe Tomato Serum – $150
  • Cuccio Somatology Yogahhh Clean Plus Calm Epsom Salt Hand and Body Wash
  • Persona Cosmetics Season One Lip Gloss
  • TAN-LUXE The Gradual Illuminating Tanning Lotion
  • AHAVA Deadsea Water Mineral Hand Cream Sea-Kissed

Your September box may include:

HipDot Zion Eyeshadow Palette – $30


Eloise Beauty The Queen Eyeshadow Palette – $46


111SKIN Rose Gold Brightening Facial Treatment Mask – 5 Pack OR Pur Cosmetics Signature Travel Essentials 12-Piece Cruelty-Free Brush Set with cup


Fenty Beauty Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter or Killawatt Foil Freestyle Highlighter (Shades will vary)

The choice items for September were:

  • Kate Somerville ExfoliKate Intensive Exfoliating Treatment – $58
  • Farmacy Cheer Up Brightening Vitamin C Eye Cream with Acerola Cherry – $45
  • Byroe Tomato Serum – $150

  • TAN-LUXE The Gradual Illuminating Tanning Lotion
  • SKIN CAMP Hydra-Gel Rosy Hearts Eye Mask (Set of 5)
  • MILK MAKEUP Matcha Detoxifying Face Mask
  • MILK MAKEUP Melatonin Overnight Serum
  • FRANK BODY Original Coffee Scrub
  • OSEA Atmosphere Protection Cream
  • GRAVITY Weighted Sleep Mask Grey

What do you think of the spoilers? 

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, the regular Boxycharm box is $25 a month. BoxyLuxe is a once-a-quarter upgrade option you can add to your existing $25-a-month Boxycharm subscription. So for an additional $24.99, you’ll get the Luxe items, and be paying a total of $49.99 for that quarterly box. 

If you haven’t signed up for BoxyCharm yet:

Use this link and coupon code ADDMORE6ALL09 to get $6 popup store credit when you sign up for a subscription!

Details: Valid for new subscribers only, or those who canceled before August 1, 2020. Receive your $6 coupon via email within 48 hours and use credit in September Add‑Ons online store by Friday, Sept. 18 or while open. Quantities limited. Shipping restrictions may apply.

Check out our reviews of Boxycharm + Boxyluxe boxes to learn more!


How do subscribers rate BoxyLuxe?

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BoxyLuxe!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BoxyLuxe spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in BoxyLuxe Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxyluxe | 62 comments

Comments (62)

  1. im pissed I only got brushes. Highlighter and a serum

  2. I only got 4 items in my Luxe box. Is that normal?

  3. I got it actually! And the duel brush which was disappointing because I certainly didn’t need both. But I ALSO Got the 111skin masks. I see it says either or but I got both.

    • I have way too many brushes but even I’m hoping for that set because I like things that match. You’re the first I’ve seen that has gotten both so that gives me a little hope. Plus I have so many sheet mask and barely ever use them.

      • I got the brush set and the 111 skin masks. So did my best friend. We got variation 22. It was 3.1 lbs. I absolutely loved my variation. I saw a bunch of variations on youtube that had both too. Some of the face ones aren’t dense enuff imo, but i do like most of them.

  4. I’ve been with Boxy for about 4 yrs now. I have never had a box take this long to ship. It’s the 25th and I still dont have a shipping notification and it’s still showing in my acct that its waiting to ship. They have not responded to me in anyway, even though I’ve tried contacting them 3 different ways. I got my Premium box almost 2 weeks ago. My Luxe usually first.

    • Same. I just tracked mine and it says it will be here the 29th. Usually I’m in the middle of the month looking at spoilers for the next because I’ve gotten everything and anxious for the next. Never had it take this long.

  5. I would like my box just to ship! Ugh. Still no shipping label or update.

    • I just got my shipping info now.

  6. I’m a little disappointed with my box (#29)
    I received the following:

    Eloise eyeshadow palette…beautiful palette but not sure if the colors will work for me.

    Tomato serum…my pick and I didn’t really want it. My choices were awful.

    Milk overnight mask…my 2nd pick and I really wanted this

    Some super ugly orange/brown lip gloss (straight in the give away or donate box).

    Fenty highlighter in copper and orange….nope. I will try it as an eyeshadow.

    Those dreaded 111 Skin sheet masks…NO

    Some random hand soap…meh

    And an even more random tumbler.

    I guess it was my turn for bottom of the barrel stock. And what’s up with comparing Boxy to FFF? Two separate boxes. They both probably got a really good deal on some products.

  7. Am I the only one who still hasn’t received the BoxyLuxe? I don’t even have a shipping number yet and I have been a subscriber for over a year. Thanks!

    • I haven’t received mine and no tracking number on my account yet. I have been a subscriber for several years and usually get my boxes within the first 2 weeks of the month.

    • I just got my email for tracking but it hasn’t moved. My add ons come tomorrow is that possible? It still says it hasn’t shipped when I go in my boxy acct.

  8. I’ve been subscribed since May 2018. My annual subscription just ran out. I cancelled Luxe because nothing interested me. Finally done with Boxy. No regrets yet.

  9. I personally didn’t care for the items I received this month.
    For starters boo to all the FabFitFun repeats.
    Also boo to the two eyeshadow palettes which were all wrong for me. I’m super fair and these palettes look like they were formulated for African American complexions. If you go to the Eloise IG page it is 90% African models. I am all for supporting Black Businesses and Im glad to see items like this being offered but they certainly aren’t sending them to the right people. There should be makeup options for all races in these boxes.They are obviously not paying attention to our quizzes because the lip gloss I received was also super dark and in the same color family as my palettes. This would have been a good box for somebody else. I feel like I’m throwing away money because my intent isn’t to buy these boxes just to give away the product.

    • The eyeshadows are Dollar General quality and look awful on except for the light purple shade. I received both palettes, Hipdot has some decent matte shadows but nothing complexion-appropriate. Eloise was fun to play with for an 80s blast but very poor quality, they look like Dollar Store items on. I got this box on Friday, the regular Boxycharm today with mixed feelings. I have to agree about the business support, white bashing is a big trend right now and you are not the only person who has noted that beauty subscription companies are basically sticking to the wrong people by sending out useless products. It’s a big publicity trend, we see a lot of it in publishing at the moment. I love/hated both packages, the formula is 2-3 quality products and the rest junk to cut the cost. The eye roller came with the cheaper box and it is great, the brushes and holder are lovely! The Fenty junk I can’t even give away to black women I work with, they’ve passed on this highlighter and an expensive Moroccan eyeshadow collection from the spring I got from Fashionsta. Her company’s concept of inclusiveness is cool, but I have been disappointed with every single product I’ve tried because Wet and Wild is actually a lot better. The Marc Jacobs lip gloss is about a 4 out of 10 at most, lousy color although the dual strobe effect was interesting.

    • Oh my, just because a company is blacked owned, doesn’t mean it’s only for black people. I don’t understand that rationale here. Maybe they are more pigmented to show on darker skin, but how you can’t use an EYESHADOW palette because it’s for black women, I just…?? I’m white and love brands like Julia’s place because the pigmentation is unreal. It’s not white bashing (like omg what???) to put black owned brands in beauty boxes. This is just the wildest thing I’ve read, goodness. I’ve seen many reviews with people of darker complexions getting complexion products that are for fair to medium skinned people. They can’t use that at all. You’re complaining about eyeshadow, that you can use, but think the colors are not for white people? Ridiculous

  10. I think I might take a break from boxy for a while as I haven’t been impressed with the boxes for quite a while. I hung in there hoping they would improve but they haven’t. I actually enjoy the pop up sales, not so much the boxes.
    I was disappointed with both Luxe and Premium this month. I was hoping I wouldn’t receive those crappy overpriced 111 skin masks – (yup I got them). I still have 2 unopened boxes from FFF that are probably expired by now. I just dont do sheet masks. Plus this brand is totally overrated. At least the version we get in sub boxes is inferior.
    And another Ahava mineral hand cream (sigh) – FFF has been sending these out on and off for 3 years. I still have multiples from them.
    Also received Frank Body Scrub which I received in my FFF fall box. This one was open and leaking.
    That left
    * Fenty highlighter in a terrible shade
    * Mark Jacob’s lip gloss in Raspberry Beret – looks neon purple – looks like they raided Ziggy Stardusts make up bag
    * Persona lip gloss in candy bar brown
    * 2 eyeshadow palettes – 1 in each box – brands I don’t recognize- not wearable for me – too many purples and shimmers in both.
    * Tomato serim – my choice – meh
    * Self tanner – excited to try
    * KITCSH FACE ROLLER – meh filler
    Over all huge disappointment – maybe I can sell on ebay and recoup my money.

    • Try Poshmark and Mercari to sell stuff you don’t want. That’s what I’ve been doing.

  11. Mine were the first box shown as well and I’m also very excited. I missed the chance to pick any of my items this month so I wasn’t sure what I’d receive but I’m thrilled with my box! There’s alot I’m interested in trying. The only thing I’m giving away is the highlighter, that’s going to my 15 year old niece. Great box this month!!

  12. I would love to have the Queen Pallet and the travel brush set, but I almost never get what I want. Honestly, I am not one that like surprises, all these different variations are not for me. I went with a box that everyone receives the same, just different shades of some things. I like that, I am never disappointed.

  13. Just got my box and I’m really happy with it (variation 74. I didn’t know they went that high.) The only thing I wanted and didn’t get was the Eloise palette. Got the Hipdot one instead but my box was so full I don’t think the Eloise palette would have fit in its place.

    – Kate Somerville ExfoliKate Exfoliator (pick 1)
    – Osea Atmosphere Protection Cream (pick 2)
    – HipDot Zion Eyeshadow Palette (pretty but I’ve already got lots of palettes just like this)
    – 111SKIN Rose Gold Masks (I’m just glad it’s a mask set instead of a single)
    – Pur Cosmetics 12-Piece Brush Set with Cup (Yes please! I’m so happy with this.)
    – Fenty Beauty Highlighter in 7daywknd / poolside (gorgeous for eyes but how is it highlighter?)
    – Persona Cosmetics Season One Lip Gloss (feels great and smells great so I’m happy)
    – Keratherapy Deep Conditioning Masque (whatever. I have dry hair so might as well.)

    All in all the things probably getting the most use will be the Brush set definitely, Fenty Highlighter as eyeshadow, and Osea followed a little by the Exfoliator and lip gloss. All in all, I’d say this month was worth it.

  14. I got version 29. I did not choose my first item. I chose milk overnight serum for my second item so I got

    Byroe serum
    Eloise queen palette
    Personal lip gloss in toffee
    Fenty highlighter ginger/Moscow
    Cuccio hand wash
    111skin masks
    Teami tumbler

    Happy with most of what I received

    • This is what I got as well. Tumbler seems very out of place clearly some extra item they had laying around.

  15. Did anyone else redeem Charms for the Rituals body wash and have their order canceled?

    • Yep. 🙁

  16. I noticed alot of FFF repeats in this box!

  17. I don’t love my box I don’t hate it. I do however feel that it’s mostly influencers that get the best items. I really hate the amount of variation and the fact that they don’t even come close to making sure that boxes are even. I have a very similar box to variation 27 but I have a full additional item. They also clearly have way more subscribers than they can handle so they put out spoilers which a few select boxes get and then fill all the other boxes with old miscellaneous stock.

    • I think I agree with you about my box after looking at it more. It’s a fine box, with value, and really the only item I am mad about is the soap (really??) which just doesn’t feel like a luxe item. When I look at my box by itself and judge it for its own merits, it isn’t so bad. However, when I compare it to influencer boxes, I feel disappointed. Trying to focus on the positives and view my items in isolation (I can put those towels in my car for the kids, for example…)

  18. I am very happy with my variation. I received…
    – PUR Brush Set
    – 111 Skin Rose Gold Masks
    – The Queen Palette
    – Milk Matcha Mask Stick
    – Persona Lip Gloss in Honey
    – Ahava Hand Cream
    – Fenty Highlighter in Sand
    Castle/Mint’d Mojito
    – Farmacy Cheer Up Eye (I chose to match the serum I received in popsugar and was saving)
    I love everything. Most excited about the Fenty & Queen Palette and the least for the lip gloss. Overall I am living this box!!

  19. Mine was the exact bottom variation, and I’m pretty pleased with it. I got the queen palette in my premium box, so I’m happy with the zion palette. I got the highlighter in ginger binge/moscow mule, which works very nicely on my skin tone as an eyeshadow and/or blush, and I got a shade of the lip gloss that works well with my skin tone, too. I already had a bottle of the hand/body wash from another box, but I’m almost out of it, and while it’s not exciting, one can never have enough hand wash in this pandemic, so it’s fine. I actually like those rose gold masks (I’d never buy them, and I think they’re way overpriced, but I do enjoy them), so I’m not mad about those, and the hand cream will definitely get used at some point this fall/winter. Overall, not a super exciting luxe box, but everything will get some use (I’m wearing the highlighter and lip gloss as I type this!).

  20. Glad I removed myself from the waitlist, while the value is there, the products are not calling my name. Went with Premium and base this month and much happier with the selections I got.

  21. The only item I did not like in mine was the highlighter, it is too dark. Will see if it works as a bronzer or shadow.

  22. Hoping for one of the boxes with that brush set. I rarely get the thing I would most like from BoxyCharm though

    • It looks like the brush set will be selling at add-ons for $9, so even if you don’t get them in the box, you’ll be able to get them for cheap.

  23. Where’s the Alamar palette? Which box does that come in?

    • The base box.

  24. I cancelled my Premium box a couple months ago and have only kept the base box and luxe. I’ve been contemplating cancelling altogether and just keeping FFF and Ipsy. The only items I’d really want out of this box are the Pur container w/brushes and the 111Skin face masks and unfortunately I’ll only receive one or the other. The rest of the items I won’t use. It’s been a waste, especially since they NEVER pick items for me based on my quiz and I do that quiz at least once a year. Lastly, I haven’t been able to actually CHOOSE a product that I want for the last couple boxes because for whatever reason, I never receive their emails on dates to choose or pop up /addons. I emailed them about it and all they said was “add us to your address book or check spam” and I’ve done both and still nothing. Their customer service has dwindled down along with their boxes.

    • You may get the brush set and the masks. I did.

      • So did I. Except for a too dark highlighter I received a solid box.

      • I received both brushes and the masks

    • I got mine today and I got both the 111 skin masks and the brushes. In fact, I got the brush set AND a single brush. Why would they include two of the same type of items? I REALLY wanted the hair mask. 🙁 Disappointed in this box.

  25. This is my first boy luxe and I’m Beyond excited❤️❤️❤️ So glad I finally got it. I’ve been getting the base box since 2016 and never wanted to change to luxe and missed out on the base. This time my sister is getting the base so I felt it’s ok to try the luxe. How are they turning profit lol

  26. So glad I cancelled right before billing! Lots of repeats from old FFF boxes and lots of unusable colors (the eyeshadow palette, lipstick, highlighter… none of these would work for me). The value is there but if you can only use 1 or 2 products then it’s definitely not worth it.

    • I haven’t received my box yet, but I am honestly not excited for any of these things. I believe I am just having a bit of burn out. I currently have Ipsy base bag and glam bag plus, boxy base and luxe, allure and then I add Beauty Fix if I want the box. I LOVED Beauty Fix in the beginning (about 6 or 7 years ago), but it’s not much more than tiny samples now. With Allure’s new pricing, I am canceling and will buy which boxes I want through Amazon. I’m sick of Boxy and Ipsy….they rotate the same products or brands over, and over, and over. They both use a lot of junk filler and it’s hard to decide if you want a box or not depending on spoilers. Here’s the thing: I did not receive one single spoiler in my last Boxy box. The box was ripped and taped and it contained the correct number of items but there was not one brand that I recognized. I understand the use of “may be included” is saying nothing more than “don’t get mad if you don’t get these items”…there is no bait and switch unless it states that every box will have an item and you don’t get it. I suppose it’s rant over. All of these boxes were amazing in the beginning and they have slowly declined across the board. I hope you guys all have good luck and get the item/variation you want.

  27. I finally pulled the plug on Boxycharm after being a subscriber for over 3 years and having all 3 tiers. I thought I would regret it but every time I check the spoilers I don’t. Way too many variations and mystery brand fillers that I’ve never heard of. Boxycharm used to be amazing and the best subscription out there. They failed themselves when they started all these variations and different tiers of boxes. Greed got them.

    • I totally agree with you!!! I cancelled base and luxe this month. Cancelled premium in June. Seriously.., what happened to Boxy?

  28. Yuck. Way too many variations and subscription box repeats. Quite a few items have already been in other boxes.

  29. I’m so glad I got out of BC. Finally came to my senses last month. Its as if a switch flipped and im examining every cent. Too many variations. Too much unusable product. The value wasn’t there for me.

  30. My box has shipped. How do you know what variation number you got or how many variations there are? I see my package is 3.1 lbs in the tracking details.

    • There’s no way to know for sure in advance. Check out @boxysneakpeeks on instagram. She posts variations and gives box shipping weights to help people figure out what they might be getting. Hope you get a good variation!

    • Mine was 3.1 lbs

    • mine is 3.1 pounds too. It’s helps if u know the dimensions. My best friends box weighs 3.1 but her dimensions were 11x?x4 n her box was BEAUTIFUL. mine weighs 3.1 too but my dimensions are 16x15x1 and I cnt find this anywhere!!!

  31. I received Variation 19
    -HipDot Zion Eyeshadow Palette
    -111SKIN Rose Gold Brightening Facial Treatment Mask
    -Fenty Beauty Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter (in the bronze-y Afternoon Snack)
    -Kate Somerville ExfoliKate Intensive Exfoliating Treatment
    -Persona Powerbrush
    -Cuccio Somatology Yogahhh Clean Plus Calm Epsom Salt Hand and Body Wash
    -AHAVA Deadsea Water Mineral Hand Cream
    -Frank Body Coffee Scrub

    All in all I am fairly happy. Certainly isn’t my favorite box, but the value is there (minus the ridiculous face mask price point).

    • Variation 19 🤣

      • I’ve yet to see anyone who got the PUR brush set. 111Skin is a super expensive brand so you would think less of that would go out bit everyone seems to have an abundance to give away.

  32. I am so disappointed in my variation (27) that I received today. It contained:

    *Byroe tomato serum (I picked it, happy to have)
    *Eye mask pack (again, my pick, I like it)
    *111SKIN Rose Gold Brightening Facial Treatment Mask – 5 Pack (fine, but already had in FFF)
    *Fenty Beauty Killawatt Freestyle Highlighter in Penny (will be very hard to use this dark color)
    *Persona Powerbrush two sided brush (this brush is low quality and I really wanted the PUR set)
    *HipDot Zion Eyeshadow Palette (ok, but wished it were the Queen palette)
    *Cuccio Somatology Yogahhh Clean Plus Calm Hand and Body Wash (ugh, another FFF repeat)

    This was my first Luxe box and I expected so much more. Instead, I feel like I wasted my money. I think I’m going to cancel Boxycharm or at least Luxe.

    • I received a couple things in past boxes which were too dark for me. I emailed boxycharm and let them know that I filled out quiz and I’m fair skinned. Boxy got right back to me and they immediately added charms in the value of the products. I’ve never had any issue with customer service. Hope this helps.

    • I am with you, I finally received my first Boxyluxe I am ticked off. I got 4 repeat 4 items I feel I was gipped will stay for one more box and then if it isn’t great canceling.
      1. Canvas bag
      2. BYRON Tomato serum
      3. A loose bronzing shimmer
      4. Make up brushes.

      • I got just four items in my Luxe box. My daughter got one more like the first one shown. Im disappointed in my Luxe box to say the least

  33. My box matches the very first one. I am more than happy with this months boxyluxe!!!!

    • That is the variation that I am hoping to receive!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.