Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Such a bad bad box. Got the morphe pallette and it looks like it’s either made funky (maybe that’s why boxy got it cheap) some of the pans arent filled all the way, others looked like they have been used.
Then I got the kush plump something that looks like a mascara
The brow bar thing
And the toner byro or whatever….
A hair mask
Wow. This is the wors box I have EVER got. This is a damn shame. I
Could have saved this money and bought 1 high end decent item.
Boxycharm should be ashamed in themselves and the junk they are sending. I wanted the hour glass shattered stuff because if it works for me, I wanted to buy other colors and i dont live near a place to see them….i always get the lowest/junk variety. I dont want any hair items. I dont mind pallettes at all. I collect and have 200 plus, but this looks like it’s used… man oh man, if my base box ever shows up it better be an good one…this company needs to get its stuff together. The backdoor issues constantly, not making pop up sales right…then claim they have no more products, but then have them as add ons right after instead of sending the items lost in the mail due to them shipping 20 items in 1 small envelope. Q
Reply
Kat
The lipsticks were bad, ugly colors I don’t wear. I wished I had the Lord Jones in my box, as I love their products. The Morphe palette was okay, colors were good, cuticle oil also good, but I’m picky about the colors for the lipsticks, please no more unless you send me a color choice.
Reply
mamaflesher
Yes! What the heck is this?!?! I would have rather paid less and got the sol de janeiro! Premium…yeah right…
Reply
TabbyO
this box is crap. once again, the base box is baited with more premium products than the ACTUAL premium box. wth, bc?
Reply
Lindsay B
I just googled the cuticle oil and it’s $11.95 and the Morphe palette is $16 with a 20% coupon. That Trio matte lipstick s $40- but I’ve NEVER heard of this cheap looking brand. Almost the worst box I’ve ever received by BoxyCharm. Then I have to wait 30+ days to get it. Anyone else not get their add ons yet? It’s been exactly a month since I have ordered them.
Reply
Mary
my July Ipsy plus is way better than this premium and $10.00 less. I am getting tart mascara, Sunday Riley Luna sleeping oil, glow pill serum , magnetic eyeshadow and case, ciaatee watermelon primer. Boxys premium this month is just bad
Reply
Camilla
Honestly, trash, all of it. Just throw the whole box out 😩😭
Reply
Maggie
Saturday skin is the only thing I think I would want from this box… So I will probably not get it. I agree, just throw the whole box out and skip to August box. Also, it’s the 9th and my box hasn’t shipped yet. Seems like it’s going to be another end of the month box. =_=
Reply
mamaflesher
Have you gotten your box yet? Mine still hasn’t come.
Ali
What the heckkkkkkkk!!!!! This is the first time I’ve scoped out any spoilers.. & tf? Base box is so much better! I stuck w. Premium & cancelled the base.. regretting it now. I mean base has frickin hourglass scattered light eyeshadows (something ppl have talked up for forever & I’ve always wanted to try!!) & sol de janeiro shampoo & conditioner!! Meanwhile premium (which costs MORE) has some haircare brand I’ve never heard of.. & frickin MORPHE? A brand I’ve never tried & never had any interest in trying.
Ugh I’m obviously way too heated over this!! But it’s not like I can just sign up for a base box now.. because as we all know, any new subscriber just gets a bunch of old repeat items & NONE of the actual things that were spoiled.
Reply
Jamey
Well, my guess is they will have the majority of the scattered hour glass as add ons, as well as the morphe pallettes and who knows what else….so it could be in the sale coming up…
Reply
Tiffany412
Yikes, that’s awful
Reply
tammy g.
can’t wait for this box..
Reply
April
I’d use everything in that variation. I like everything in Premium last month and July’s box so far. I’m happy I stuck w Premium subscription.
Reply
Jodie
I have been unable to pick anything in my boxes.
Reply
Marion
The Nelson J mask is something I got in base Boxy literal years ago. It’s one of the reasons I initially canceled in the first place, lol. Despite being sealed, it made my entire box REEK of coconut.
Actual full spoilers for Boxy Premium are up in the Review tab. (Or you can see them on Reddit.) It appears that one of the items is a “$20” jelly pouch that appears to be the exact same bag that came with the Sephora Sun Safety kit in 2017.
Reply
Anna
Base box is the winner this month in my opinion, hoping next month is more of winner for me
Reply
Jennifer
I am so upset! This is just not fair anymore..
Reply
Liz
Well this is a super underwhelming box. Sigh. Like unbelievably underwhelming. Sometimes it’s so great and sometimes it’s one good item and a lot of crap.
I’ve never even used or cared about the choice palettes and was kind of annoyed that the choice was ONLY palettes. Like…give us some variety pls.
Boxy is progressively getting worse and worse over the last half a year or more
Reply
Chelsea
I may be in the minority but these look like fun boxes to me. They have products that I’d never normally buy for myself but would like to try out and experiment with.
Reply
Alice
Just how do we end up with a $7 cuticle oil in this box…
Reply
Jan Isaacs-Wade
I don’t get it either. The base box has Huda beauty, Clarins and Hourglass! Maybe the sales dropped off and that’s why they’re building up the base box. Last month I only received two makeup products! Time to rethink premium.
Reply
Marion
I prefer it to the off-brand brushes & private-labeled products of dubious origin they’ve been using as box fillers lately.
Reply
Alice
I do find use for the cuticle oil too and much prefer it to off brand brushes. But this is such a cheapso product to be included in a premium box, along with makeup bag…
Alice
Since spoiler for August is featuring my holy gail, I am staying for another month… But how is base box once again featuring more premium items then premium…
Reply
Jenniger
No FOMO on my end.I am glad I cancelled and haopy with my base box. I used the money from Boxycharm premium to get things I wanted instead.
Reply
Alisha
Right, base box has the SDJ shampoo and conditioner. I get both boxes so I could possibly end up getting it but with how my boxes have been lately I highly doubt I will but once can hope.
Reply
Rachel
This doesn’t look good to me. Like others, I wish everyone got a Lord Jones lotion. I’d gladly give up the two (!!) worthless palettes for one LJ lotion.
Reply
Jennifer
Me too
Reply
Marion
Same!
Reply
Jade
I totally agree. What a ridiculous box. How is this premium when there is hourglass, fenty, sol de janeiro and alamar in the base box.
Reply
Tina Ames
They would not have a lot of people canceling,if they would of gave everyone a toner and the Lord Jones body lotion.
Reply
Marion
Heck, I would have stayed subbed for just a guaranteed lotion! If they had made that category the choice item, think they wouldn’t have lost so many of us!
Reply
Candi
I cancelled also, I regretted it at first, but now I’m happy I did . I subscribed to fortune cookie soap box in its place, so excited to try something different!
Reply
Lori
So glad I cancelled! Base box was way better.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.