Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
If anyone would like to swap for the Polar Bear eyeshadow, please let me know! I have a lot to swap and will be generous for this palette (my dad’s name is Day Bear in Norwegian, so I have a thing for Polar Bears!). Hoping swapping starts at some point soon – I’ve been shipping for my business with no issues at all.
Reply
Mary GT
I would love to get one of the Shared Planet palettes, especially the Polar Bear! But I definitely don’t want an orange/brown palette.
Reply
Dani
Same here! But with my luck I’ll get the orange one or the other orange/pink/red palette that would look hideous on me. I’d love to get the Purlisse IF they send the right shade. I got a sample size from Ipsy and really liked it. I’d be fine with the Smashbox spray too. But I really really want one of those Shared Planet palettes.
Reply
Laurel
I would love either of the Shared Planet pallets! And the fact that they donate to helping at risk animals makes it even better for me!
Reply
Laurel
I rarely see other people named Laurel! Hi, fellow Laurel animal lover 🙂
Reply
Kate
OMG the polar bear palette! Nice to see a “cool” palette. So many warm ones going around. But with my luck I’ll wind up with the hideous orange!
Reply
Jenngwen
I know!!! But with my luck I’d get the orsnge AND more black eyeliner (somehow!!!)
Reply
Catalina
I love it!! This is a step up for me. I was with ipsy plus and it was 🤮. So glad I switched to BOXYCHARM.
Reply
Beccah
I’m excited for these items! I love that boxy has brands I’ve never tried it seem in other boxes! Shared Planet has great reviews and I hope I get the polar bear palette!
Reply
Beccah
*Or seen*
Reply
Shari
No, none of these really worth it to me. Maybe I just have to much. I have really been enjoying Ipsy though.
Reply
Rose
LOL! Yes, after subbing for a few years, it’s easy to get a massive stockpile of skin care and makeup. I still can’t believe how much I have…I’m going to donate a huge haul to a young lady who is interested in learning how to use makeup (with the permission of her mother). I can’t wait to hear about her adventures.
Reply
Maggie
That polar bear palette looks like a nice color story and I wouldn’t mind the setting spray or the bb cream. So far it looks better (to me at least) than April and May. But only if I get the polar bear palette… not crazy about the other two. I was thinking about staying on luxe waitlist (I had cancelled my luxe for March because it was so bad looking and went with base box), but I have no guarantee that I will get the tarte palette and so may just choose to get off waitlist depending on the choice options.
Reply
Carrie
I thought I heard that everyone is getting the tarte palette in Luxe…
Reply
Maggie
Are they? I assumed it was going to be another variation just because I can’t play the sound when at work xD must have missed that. Hmm, on the side though I still think I like the other items in base box more than the other items aside from tarte palette in luxe! The more I look the more I like that polar bear palette. If I can choose it in choice, then I will stick with base box still I think.
RAR
Go redo your complexion quiz on their site. (I forgot I set mine to yellow tones with a preference for pink lipsticks.) I’ve done much better since.
Reply
Annie
WOW, Boxycharm is going in the toilet. I guess I’m going to have to cancel all 3 of my subscriptions. The hell is SHARED PLANET?
Reply
ASHLEY
I have canceled the regular box and currently only have the premium. I was at first impressed by premium but that too is starting to suck. Im Canadian so with the exchange and shipping, I’m paying about 50 dollars a month for premium. Boxycharm has changed. I’ve been a “charmer” for 3 years now, and I think its time I let it go.
Happy nurses week to all my fellow nurses!
Reply
Cb
I really want that bb cream. I’ve been looking into buyin one so I will wait
Reply
Kat in CT
I have it, it’s amazing just like everything I’ve tried from Purlisse. I’m getting the concealer in my ipsy this month and can’t wait!
Reply
Lori
I love it! It’s one of my go-tos on no makeup days!
Reply
Dianne
No job, no money, no buy, maybe June I can. I miss you Boxycharm. When I can get it again I’ll be so happy. So happy 🤗😄😲
Reply
Liz
I really want to love this sub. They are doing better including more variety with skincare etc, but ever since I resubscribed, I have gotten a palette every. single. month. I’m turning into the crazy palette lady, passing them on to every person I know. Surely not even the junkiest makeup junkie can use all that eyeshadow… right?! Or maybe I just need to get more creative with them. Can they double as artist pastels? 🤔
Reply
Indy Grr
I’m sick of all the palettes that I don’t chose. TWICE I have gotten some ridiculous cheap palette instead of my choice item. They refused to send me a Murad and Elemis product that I chose and was confirmed and gave me cheap ugly palettes instead. Both of those boxes were completely useless to me. This feels like I was lied to and robbed. THEY DO NOT FIX THEIR MISTAKES…even though they clearly advertise you get a choice. Also, I make all my choices within minutes of choice opening and I still don’t get my choice.
Reply
Alice
They absolutely can! I use shadows in my art often.
Reply
Kate of Spades
That was always my main question to BC subscribers…how do you use that sh*tload of palettes you get?
Reply
Hallie
I love getting palettes. I collect them so I’m happy to have them. I buy so much on Sephora but, boxycharm gives me variety of things I may not think to try.
Jamey
This is why I am with Boxycharm. I WANT all the eyeshadow pallettes. They all have different formulas and you can try different things with difficult brands and get to know what you like and what you dont and then feel comfortable buying more from a brand after that,
I’m sick of all the hair junk and the skincare. Waaaay to much. Boxy was better when it was just a makeup box.
Lisa
This is why I come and go to BoxyCharm. I really do love getting full sized items versus tiny items like from ipsy. However, I get really tired of getting palettes every single month. I would love more foundations or skin care. Or Hair stuff. Just please no more palettes. A good palette can last me a year!
Carla
not super excited and the ORANGE palette is horiffic to me
idk my year is up soon i may not renew
Reply
Christa H.
This is very meh to me…. Anyone else?
Reply
Kate of Spades
Orange palette…I’d wear only to beach parties we do not exist right now
Reply
Kate of Spades
*which* not we
Shared planet looks fine though, it’s 50$ on their website!
Ash
Super meh. Waste of money honestly. Cancelling.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.