Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I want the palette! I have the natural face, but these ones seem to be a bit more in my shades! Now watch this not be our choice items again… Hopefully I don’t space and log in for choice on thursday!
Reply
Jamey
I already have the face pallette and the two faced bronzer…I wish they would send items that have not been out for a long while where most people have already bought them during a sale, or whatever over the last couple years.
The eye cream I have enough of to cream my whole neghiborhood and miles over , and really I do not think they work, and when I use my face cream I just use that under my eyes too.
Also, not too hyped up over mascara. I’m wondering with everything that’s going on in the world if these boxes dont think to step up their products. I know they are planned a tear or so in advance, but they have to have a game plan to move things around in case of emergencies right?
Reply
Chelsea
Is anyone else checking these spoiler pages over and over out of boredom? Every time I see new comments I get excited just for something read lol
Reply
Honey
Lol yes out of boredom and anticipation
Reply
JB
Haha yup! I looked up all these products and I was kind of meh about some of them at first but now I think I would be thrilled to try any of them out!
Reply
Lori
Yes! I kinda wish they had a “share what you got” or “box first impressions” post just so we can discuss so I don’t have to keep finding the old spoiler post.
Reply
Jamey
They used to have “forums” here that were very , very amusing to just read, but I thi k people started getting upset and feelings hurt and then others were screaming for someone to come in and babysit the forums, which was insane since it was supposed to be adults but seemed more like a free for all where parents didnt teach the whole “sticks and stones ” saying…lol. I never participated just read but it was fabulous and anybody could create a forum to talk about things. No photos to share.
If someone was smart they would create an app like the hush one was where you would but makeup, but the hype was the networking and posting pictures and chatting and asking question about looks etc but was way more intimate then youtube.
Yessy
Ok, I really want the too faced palette and the Kevin acquon mascara. (Did I spell his name right …lol… I don’t think so.) April box was crap and such a huge let down for me so I’m just gonna sell the box so someone will be very happy. 🙂
Reply
Debby
Yes !! I’m excited about this box. You’re right, the April box was a huge dud.
Reply
Denise ponce
If i cancel, so I lose my charms or get them back if a sign again in the future ?
Reply
Christa H.
I cancelled all my Boxycharm boxes and my charms were there for over a month. They are actually the reason I signed back up. I saw the Moroccan oil spray and signed back up just to use my charms to get it. I had cancelled Boxycharm back in February and resubscribed on April 2nd. I had 3800 charms
Reply
Tara W
For Base Boxy I got January, cancelled for February and March and re-signed up for April and my 300 charms from January are still there. So, the charms did stay there for me.
However, I would not feel confident relying on that, if you know what I mean.
Reply
Jamey
They have always stayed thee for my roommate. Even after they cancelled for a year, they resubbed and points were still there too. This was over 2 years now.
Laura
You lose any charms when cancelling. They won’t be reinstated if you sign up again, so use any prior to cancelling or you’re SOL unfortunately
Reply
JB
I cancelled one account that I had quite a few charms on and they constantly email me to sign back up and use my charms, so I think they do stay for a while
Kristin
Can’t wait for swaps to reopen I want the palette!
Reply
Toni Marie
I love the skin & co products that I have received before.. I would.likento try the eye cream..
Reply
Oja
Me too, I got their cleansing oil in a Fabfitfun box and it was wonderful. I ended up trading for another one and used it up too. I’d love to try more of their products!
Reply
Victoria
Anyone want a pharmacy honey mask?? I will trade for the barbie palette
Reply
Kate
I got the barbie palette and want the farmacy!! How do we swap with the site down? We’re not supposed to give our email address in the comments. I did link my website. You can contact me through that. I’d keep the barbie but I bought it 4 months ago. It’s so freaking pretty!
Reply
Kristina
Back before I did subscription boxes, the Too Faced Natural Matte Eyes Eye Shadow Palette was my go to for neutrals. It was the first palette of eyeshadows that I ever used where I felt comfortable to experiment. Hit pan twice with this palette.
And I know, I can hear people say what? Experiment with subtle neutrals? That’s right. Sometimes when you work in an ultra-conservative office setting, it’s about knowing where your guardrails are and pushing those boundaries…
Reply
JB
I know what you mean, I get so excited for neutral palettes in my boxes so I can actually try them out for work!
I’m not super excited but I don’t hate anything either lol
Reply
Ginger
If you sign up for premium, does it replace base box, or would I get both base and premium? I’m liking these spoilers
Reply
Lena
If you sign up for premium, you will get both boxes unless you cancel the base box (which you can do after the first month and keep just premium).
Marion
I don’t do Too Faced, so I’ll probably cancel. I’ll see what the choice items are.
Reply
Rachael Caraballo
So I paid for my base and then got approved for premium 2 days later and charged. Can I cancel base now
Reply
Brittany Bolton
Im so over too faced palettes! Their all the same! Rather see colourpop palettes or anything different! I thought them having manny muas palette was a great change up of something different!
Reply
Marion
Yeah, I kind of hoped for the Life’s A Drag palette, but didn’t get it. I do see that the Lunar Beauty Strawberry Dream palette is on sale (clearance?) at Sephora, so maybe Boxy should try & get their hands on some of those! I personally think that one’s even prettier than Life’s a Drag.
Toni Marie
I agree…. it would have been nice if the regular customers got that palette and not just the boxycharm influensters. I got a decent box.. I just dont like the coverfx primer because i keep getting primer.all of the time.
Alice
Unlike most, this is really my style of products. LOVE the truffle therapy.
Reply
Irene Davis Johnson
The base box looks better than the premium so far I have both of these too faces items they are ok base shows spoilers for glam glo mask Elemis pads and hourglass highlighter which seems more premium in my opinion
Reply
JackieCupcake
Not appealing to me at all, which is good – it will give me an excuse to cancel my Premium box.
Reply
Maggie
I don’t know about this box. The palette does look really pretty, but I don’t really need it. I’m going to have to see what the other spoilers are.
Reply
Joanna
I am gonna cancel the premium. Tried the Expert mascara, and not impressed. The Volume Mascara by Kevyn Aucoin is the real bomb though.
Reply
tammy g.
oh yes, I want them all…
Reply
Michelle
Really hope this is choice, the only thing I’m interested in is the mascara.
Reply
Jade
It seems like this premium box is getting less and less premium.. not thrilled by the spoilers.
Reply
Laura
Same with the luxe. March Luxe was by far the worst yet. Boxycharm have REALLY fallen off in terms of quality in the past few months. Just one more BBSS that is driven by pulling in new subs instead of actually having any customer service.
I’m still trying to get a product that was apparently shipped the first week of February. They’re so useless I could actually scream.
Reply
Jade
I agree. I actually cancelled luxe last month.
Jennifer
Omg I agree! It started strong with everyone getting the same box and now some get Natasha denona and others get cheap brushes and wander mascara🤨
Reply
Toni Marie
They gave me the natasha denona blush, the brushes and the wander mascara.. the blush is pretty but I’m going to gift it. I also got the too faced lip gloss, farmacy honey and And coverfx primer which will be given away also.
Kristi
No kidding!! I got the cheap brushes and Wander mascara and some other crap in my April Premium box! Not impressed!
Christina
Agree, very meh.
You can’t skip with Boxy, right? You have to cancel?
Reply
Jade
You have to cancel
Angela
Don’t need more mascara that looks like a mini bronzer I have one just like it and that palette is boring
Reply
Pamela Burris
I got the farmacy I agree its getting so prem is worse than box but not any of it is hitting on much i have received last months add-ons finally yesterday but still don’t have the month before I spend almost 100 a month I get boxy and prem and lux when available instead of my boxy. I want all I have paid for and I’m done its bad I stayed to get popup and add-ons but I can’t seem to find my package also I have emailed daily I get the same computer response and 1 human time I think I’m sick of it they don’t care what they do last month I also got more in my boxy than prem I was shorted 2 products and did not get my choice yet any sucks why ask us what we want and give what we ask u to not give us anything like saying so what u paid for what u did not want, and we made u think u could pick 1 or 2 products its like they only send me what I said I did not like I have spent 250.00 the last 2 months in add-ons and I have not seen the first months, and they don’t care I referred 3 ppl got nothing I would like to trade mask for palette or something I love wander mascara but sick of not getting anything I want I did not get a makeup eraser. pam
Reply
StlMissJ
Hey there Pamela Burris…. just wondering…..
When you email and get the automated email reply do you reply to that email? It states in that email that you need to reply if your question has not been answered and a person will reply back to you within a day or so. Everytime I have emailed they do respond to my reply within a couple hours, so I am wondering if you possibly missed that important step in the process.
Other than that you can always go to there Facebook, Twitter or other social media pages and comment on a post there about your issue. Someone will definitely reply to you and reach out. Also, you can choose one of your products each other which I am sure you are aware of. Choice for luxe and premium members is this Monday I believe. There is not a set time of day it opens but if you follow people that are boxy charm reviewers on YouTube like glam with Susan or others they post on their social media accounts as soon as it opens so you can get notification through them on when the choice time kicks off and be one of the first to pick so your chances of getting what you want are higher.
I personally think they do a great job in comparison to other subscription makeup/skincare boxes in the market. If I do not like a product or two I just save it and gift it for birthdays or Christmas. For me it’s not a huge upset. I do not always get what I wished for in the boxes and I subscribed to all 3 levels. But, I think the value is out of this world in comparison to buying products retail. Do I need another this or that right now? No maybe not but I save big in the long run. And, to be honest I would have never known about or bought for myself a lot of these higher end skincare lines or palettes. $50 or a $100 for one item that you find in the boxes is seriously pretty freaking amazing in my opinion when you are paying $25, $35, or $50 for the whole box. But, who am I? Everyone has an opinion mine is just different than a lot of the posts here.
Carissa
Why do you think it’s a mini? It looks exactly like the one I have.
Reply
Toni Marie
What kind of palette did you receive? If you dont kind me asking?
Reply
Shannon
I am a too faced junkie so this looks awesome☺️
Reply
Svetlana7e
This is very nice palette, but I already have this one and shimmer one 🙁
Reply
Lori
Meh.
Reply
Amy D.
Oh these look great I am actually pretty excited for the eye shadow pallete
Reply
Christa H.
Dang! I already have this palette…but it is a wonderful palette for those who don’t own it😊❤
Reply
am2cents
I am really interested in the eye cream. Everything else isn’t doing it for me. I don’t wear neutral colors and I don’t need bronzer for my skin tone. And well, mascara thanks to my three glam bags, I am stocked for the next 5 years at least.
Reply
Christa H.
👍
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.