MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Surprisly Baby Clothing Subscription Box Review – February 2020

Surprisly February 2020 box

Surprisly is a monthly baby clothing subscription box that exclusively sends 100% cotton or organic fabrics. They offer outfits in sizes 0-18 months.

Surprisly February 2020 packaging

They also use 100% recycled packaging and donate clothing to children with every sale!

This box is being reviewed by popular demand!

My Subscription Addiction paid for this box. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Surprisly February 2020 all items

About Surprisly

The Subscription Box: Surprisly

The Cost: $69 per month. Save with longer subscriptions.

The Products: “Every month you will receive three outfits for your baby’s day out, playtime and snooze.” Sizes 0-18 months available.

Ships to: The US (free shipping) & International (shipping is extra)

Surprisly February 2020 Review


Peter Pan Collar Dress & Legging from Imps & Elfs – Estimated Value $40 (based on similar styles)

This is the “day out” outfit in my box. I’m having a hard time finding if this brand has its own website, and can’t find this specific outfit, but based on similar items found online, I guesstimate a retail value of about $40. That being said, I really adore this outfit! The organic cotton fabric feels nice and thick and stretchy, and the print is little tiny fruits? I think? Apples, oranges, pears with smiling faces and arms and legs. Whatever it is, it’s cute and I love the Peter Pan collar and the fact that the back closes with snaps all the way down. It’s a cute detail. It fits her perfectly, too.


2-Piece T-Shirt and Legging Set, Pink Dove Print, from the Bonnie Mob – Retail Value ~$41 (£32)

This is the “play” outfit for this month. What an adorable outfit! I love the rainbow dove/peace-themed print. The organic fabric feels soft and almost slinky. One really cool thing about this outfit and brand is that they use a sustainable printing method! I didn’t realize that traditional printing was particularly wasteful and harmful to the environment. This brand uses a process called “zero-D” printing that uses 90% less waste than traditional printing techniques and the small amount of water waste created actually goes to irrigate a vegetable garden on the factory’s land!


Lavender Hedgehog Organic Cotton Zipper Pajama from Milkbarn – Retail Value $42

This is the “sleepy time” outfit in my box. The print is so cute but this was just way too small on my daughter. The tag says 3-6 month but I think this fits more like a true 3 month. Although, my daughter is quite long and the arms and legs fit pretty well – the problem is the body is too short for her. It was difficult to pull the shoulders up over hers to zip it. The other two outfits are 3-6 months and fit just fine. I’m so bummed!

I reached out to Surprisly about this problem and they responded quickly with the solution to send a replacement pajama and a prepaid package to return this too-small one. It arrived quickly and is a size up – you can see it below.


Included with the pajamas (as a set) was a drawstring bag made of the same fabric! The tag suggests it’s perfect for wipes and up to 4 diapers. I love getting this as a little extra – what a cute way to keep spare diapers and wipes on hand. I can see myself using this to keep baby stuff together and easy-to-grab once my baby’s a little older and I can switch from a formal diaper bag to a smaller purse again.


Milkbarn Organic Footed Romper in Rose Doe – Retail Value $34

Here’s the replacement pajama that Surprisly sent me. It arrived very quickly and I love it! It’s a size up, 6-9 months, And it fits her! She has some room to grow, for sure, but that just means she’s got some time in it.

Verdict: I am really enjoying my Surprisly subscription. It’s so fun that they specifically send three categories of outfits (playtime, snooze time, and day out). I have also been impressed with the quality of everything they have sent. The items I’ve received from them have been some of my favorites and are reached for over and over when dressing her. They’ve stood up to wear and washing really well and I can tell they’ll last a long time. This is really important to me because I feel like I’m getting the quality I expect from the price of the box and the retail values of the brands they send. The priority here is truly high quality, exclusively natural materials, and sustainability. This month was the first time I’ve had any issues with the fit and I was quite satisfied with how quickly they turned around a replacement item for me.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Each box is created specifically to your baby’s gender, age, and clothing size so there’s a wide variation between boxes.

Value Breakdown: This box costs $69 + free shipping. The retail value of all four pieces is about $123. That’s a good discount — a savings of ~44%! Alternatively, it’s about $17.25 per item.

Check out our other Surprisly reviews, and for more boxes for your little one, swing by our list of the 10 best subscription boxes for babies!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think of the items in my February Surprisly box?

Written by Haley Faye

Haley Faye

Haley Faye first discovered the wonderful world of subscription boxes in 2012 and began writing for MSA in 2014. Over the years, she has found many subscriptions to love. Now a mom of three, her favorite boxes are ones that dress her kids, help her get organized, feed her family, send her snacks, and offer educational fun for her children.

Posted in Subscription Boxes for Babies, Surprisly Reviews| Tags: surprisly | 10 comments

Comments (10)

  1. The Bonnie Mob is sold at saks 5th Avenue, some of their one pieces go for $88. I was quite shocked to see them in a subscription box!

  2. Look at her in that rainbow outfit, how adorable! Her grin made me smile, too! I love seeing what you get every month and I just have three fur babies. The prints are so darn cute and you can tell the quality is wonderful just through the photos – even the replacement they sent you was excellent (and what great customer service). Can’t wait to read more! 🙂

    • Aw, thank you so much for reading, Gabbi! I’m looking forward to more boxes too, haha.

  3. Awww come on, you could put a puke yellow green sack on that baby and it would look magical.

    • Haha, this made me laugh. Thank you <3

  4. Omg what a stinking cute baby!!!

  5. Haley where have I been I had no idea you had a daughter????

    • Jessica! She’s new! hahaha. She is almost 5 months old. 🙂

  6. I love your reviews of this subscription. Your daughter has to be the happiest baby I’ve seen. She’s gorgeous. I love this subscription and ordered it for my sweet grand daughter. Thanks for the great review and I think your daughter has a future in print ads. 😀😀

    • Kristine, thank you! She’s definitely the happiest baby of my three so far. I’m loving this subscription too! Thanks for reading! 😀

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.


Never miss another deal

Sign up for our newsletter for exclusive discounts, news and more