Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
For a limited time, click here and use coupon code MARCHEMATTENESS to get a free Zoeva Matte Spectrum Eyeshadow Palette OR Zoeva Cream Contour Spectrum Face Palette with your first BoxyCharm box!
If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, the regular Boxycharm box is $25 a month.
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
This was a terrible box. I have only been back for two months for Boxycharm and it is terrible. I got lashes in this box and some horrible pink lipgloss. The Boxy pallett is hideous. I like the Murad eye cream but honestly, this was terrible. I’m cancelling.
Reply
Peggy
I just re-subscribed, and my box weight is 2.02 lbs including (or supposed to include) the free cream using the promo code for subscribing. Anyone have any guesses? Also, would you recommend the Luxe Starter Box? if I add that on now, it’s an additional 4-5 products it says, taken from the Luxe items for this month, but I don’t want to get duplicates of what’s in my base box, and not really sure it’s worth it, if those items are any better than the base.
Reply
Brandy
instead of the smaller box, they send one larger box so you don’t get duplicates. I love BoxyLuxe.
Reply
blondie1021
I received mine and I am not going to say it was good, kinda wish I would have waited. boxy pallet (ok) hair yogurt mask, kvd highlight, mini straightner and a lip gloss.
Reply
Nand
I received the Boxy palette in this months BoxyCharm, and it truly is the most hideous thing ever. The colors are chalky, the color story is inconsistent, and they’re just ugly. If this was my first Boxy ever, I’d immediately delete my account with them.
Reply
Ashley Schweigert
Did anyone have the 1.4 lb w/ 11″×9″×4″? What did you get?
Reply
Tanya
I have unsubscribed and I’m so glad. I have been disappointed for awhile, but one of my items was a 3-pack of invisibobbles.
Things I don’t like:
Becca highlighter stick (yet another highlighter, my least favorite item to get)
Dark Pink/Purple Nars shade lip pigment
Invisibobble 3-pack
Earrings (they are too heavy for me, but I’ll give them away)
Sol De Janeiro mini duo – I like the bum bum, but had the coco one
pmd – I have 3 others, but it will be a nice gift
Things I like:
Murad for eyes – My choice
Hello, Charmer Palette – I don’t usually like palettes, but the colors are very pretty
Reply
Ashley
I got mine today. This is my first box and after seeing what could have been included in my box, I am beyond disappointed. I got:
I’m pretty sure this is the worst curated box I have ever received from any sub!
Reply
Jenn
I got the
H and h palette
Farmacy
Becca lip definer
Chella Tweezers
And the curling wand
Decent box but the tweezers seemed like an afterthought
Reply
Tanya
My box this month is an insult. It’s a bunch of crap I can’t use and I don’t know honestly who I could even give it away to. I also have the premium box, which has never even mailed out! Boxycharm used to be great but honestly I’m looking for a different beauty box subscription now.
Reply
tammy g.
well my box sucked this month…I tell them I want mostly skincare…I get one item..the one I picked out…what’s wrong with these people..
Reply
Jerica
Disappointed in what i got this month, 4 items, a Kat von d brow, qms lip corrector, Becca gloss and a boxy charm branded eye palette. I’m probably gonna gift most of it expect the gloss
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
You are missing an item. Be sure to contact their C.S.
Reply
Lissete
My Luxe box was horrible! Looks like everything that didn’t sell in the pop-up was tossed in there. The only thing that I received from the regular box spoilers was the Boxy Palette. I got TWO palettes in this box with similar shades.
My Luxe box:
Tarte Palette
Boxy Palette
Sol de Janeiro Bum Bum & Coco Cabana duo (Mini size)
NARS Powermatte lip pigment- in a horrid dark purple almost black.
Becca Skin Love Glow Glaze Stick
Deborah Lippman Nail Polish Set of 2 minis- 2nd time receiving, did not like
Stainless Steel Straw Set
PMD Beauty smart Facial Cleansing Device – The only thing that I think I’ll like and/or I have not received in previous boxes.
My February box was useless as well. I need to use up my charms and will likely take a break from Boxy.
Reply
Shaunna
My box didnt look luxe AT ALL.
boxy palette
murad eye cream
earrings
the bum bum cream/coco cabana duo
nars liquid lip
PMD cleansing brush
Becca Love glow stick
like it looks like something is missing…. i’m so disappointed.
Reply
Tanya
Well, at least we will suffer with our box at the same time.
Lanie
Anyone receive a box that is 9x7x3 in. and 1.4 lbs? If so, can you share what you received. TIA.
Reply
Lanie
Thanks, guys. I got mine today. I received:
*Farmacy Green Clean cleanser (I love this stuff so much – I am working through a jar I purchased previously)
*Hank and Henry palette (the layout is driving my OCD crazy…I hate it)
*Project Beauty Hairgurt in Almond Honey
*Vintage Jessica Liebeskind Lipgloss
*Murad – Hydro-Dynamic Ultimate Moisture for Eyes
I am satisfied w/my box. it was worth it just for the Farmacy cleanser and Murad eye cream. I am sorry to see so many people disappointed in their boxes. 🙁
Reply
Christine G
I did and I’m not happy. I got:
-Site curling wand (my choice)
-H&H palette
-Project Beauty Hairgurt in Almond Honey
-Vintage by Jessica Liebeskind Sparkling Lip Gloss in Pink Sequin
-Kat Von D (no, not KVD) Lash Liner in Trooper Black
My box had no foam, no card, ripped open on the bottom and smashed… I’m pissed! I really miss Boxycharm before the BoxyLuxe and BoxyPremium came to be. When they sent boxes they could be proud of and seemed to give a d*mn about their subscribers. What’s more, they charged a card I removed from my account 3 days beforehand. I didn’t even want any of it to begin with. Was hoping for the Boxycharm palette as a saving Grace because swatches are amazing, but nope. RIP Boxycrap.
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
I did. I posted contents in a comment down below.
Reply
shari
This was the worse Boxycharm I have ever received canceling
3 lip products
Murad
Boxy eye pallet
So over Boxy
No card in box most likely this variation doesn’t exist
Reply
Sara
Exactly what I was thinking. I didnt get a card either!
Reply
h
It’s always a little fun to wonder “what will it be?” according to weight. Mine is 1.7 lbs.
Reply
Sara
Easily my best Boxycharm box ever!
Murad Hydration Hydro-Dynamic Ultimate Moisture for eyes
BECCA Glow Gloss – Tigerlily
Spongelle’ French Lavender Body Wash Infused Buffer
Farmacy Very Cherry Clean Makeup Meltaway Cleansing Balm
Boxycharm Eyeshadow Palette
Reply
Jessica
Honestly I think I’m cancelling boxy luxe after this one. It was AWFUL and mostly looked like they threw random things in, nothing like the normal box (would’ve preferred items from there) looks like it’s all about boxy premium and luxe is not cared about. I got
Tartiest pro remix Amazonian clay palette
Mini Sol de Janerio Brazilian bum bum cream and Coco Cabana cream
Boxy hello charmer palette
PMD facial cleansing device
NARS lip pigment
Elizabeth moth show me your cheeks blush
Spongelle body was infused sponge
Appeal cosmetics gel liner
In the past boxy luxe had a few items from the regular box plus some awesome upgrades. This felt like it had a few items that were all after thoughts.
Reply
Kyra
My Luxe box was ridiculously awful this time; the only things I think I’ll actually use are the Spongelle (after I already bought 4 extras in the “pop up” shop) and the Murad Eye Cream. Also got a Smashbox matte lip in a horrible dark shade that will make me look like a vampire, MORE travel sizes of the Sol de Janeiro minis, some weird Zoeva blush/highlighter combo when I’ve gotten pretty much the same product from other brands as recently as last month. I can’t even be bothered to get out of bed to remember the other awful products, and even when counting each SdJ mini as it’s own product, it’s still only 9 products, aren’t Luxe supposed to get 10? Isn’t that the reason why we’re paying double for those months? Ipsy Glam Bag Plus has been SO much better, so this will likely be my last Boxy box. Also, bought the day and night StarSkin 7 second mask things for morning and night during the “pop up,” tracked the batch numbers. and both products were made in 2011. Absolutely no chance I will put 9 year old crap on my face. Ugh, bye Boxy.
DK
Do you know what the weight was?
Thanks!
Reply
Sara
1.6 pounds
Tonya Bailey
Oh I know first it was the 54 different kinds of mascara now it is eyeshadow and highlighters seriously lol . I haven’t received skin care products in quite some time ugh I really miss it 😔
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
My version (I didn’t get a card so I don’t know which it is) has:
Murad eye cream
Farmacy Very cherry
Hairgurt almond honey instant repair hair mask
H&H In Living Color palette
Vintage lip gloss.
I feel like it’s probably one of the best versions for me personally. I doubt I will use the gloss, but I can donate that. Everything else will be put to use. Glad I canceled my Luxe as base box was more suited to my preferences this month
Reply
Emily
I got the same box! Absolutely love it and will use every single thing. Murad AND farmacy.. just awesome
Reply
Zo
This was my box as well. I feel like I hit the boxy jackpot this month. I also cancelled luxe and am so glad i did.
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
I am glad I did too. There wasn’t anything that I HAD to have and I’m sure I still would have found value in it if I hadn’t canceled, but I have lost 2 huge pet sits and numerous dog walks over the Coronavirus. To the tune of several thousands of dollars so I am happy to be saving money wherever I can right now. :/
Mel
That’s what I got, too. The gloss is pretty great! I was pleasantly surprised.
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
Same here!
Danielle
What was the weight of the box, would love this box! ❤️
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
Mine was 1.4 as well
Amber
I got the exact same box; h&h palette, Farmacy, Murad, lipgloss, and honey hair masque, and the weight of mine was 1.4 lbs. 🙂
h
If I get a 4th QMS lip corrector, I think I’ll scream. The BC palette is great for the horrible orange-yellow look for this cool-toned person. Can’t wait to look like a roving zombie. There isn’t any beauty in these boxes any longer. I’ve unsubscribed. Just can’t take the cheap filler and horrible customer service any longer.
Reply
KK
Has anyone else with Luxe received no info about their box, and has had a very hard time finding spoilers? It’s like they forgot that there was supposed to be a Luxe in March…
Reply
Lesly
Add-on shop has opened for Premium and Luxe. They had the Ciate powder for $6 so I had to grab a few!
Reply
Cat
Cant wait to get my hank n herrrr hopefully!!#
Reply
Bethany
I wish they would consider those of us who only wear neutral colors with the eye palettes. It’s like I’m getting junk I can’t use when I get an eye palette with bright colors only.
Reply
Tiffany
Agreed! I’m a neutral shades woman myself. I’m sick of all the bright colors. Every palette I’ve received this year has been given away.
Reply
Joyce
Is March still available?
Reply
Alice
Yes
Reply
Kenley
I want variation 2 🤞🏼
Reply
Alice
Where are the April choice item spoilers? Choice is next week.
Reply
shari
I want the box just for the Farmacy. I love that stuff! FYI… If you ever run out of Farmacy Physicians Formula has one that seems to be the exact formula but is unscented, I could not tell the difference in performance it is 14.99 a jar.
Reply
WiWah
Thanks for the tip, shari! I prefer unscented, so I will try that.
NannyNancy
I chose the QMS lip line cream. Spongelles are welcome. Either palette is fine. No real preference on those. Like many previous posters, I want the Farmacy cherry balm. The Kat Von D highlighers look interesting as well. I’d rather have lipgloss than any more black liners or mascaras please! We will see………..
Reply
tammy g.
just give me the skincare and lipstick, and keep the rest,,,please i’m begging you no more eyeshadows…
Reply
Laurie
He he he. I hate the pallets. I don’t get why there always hast to be a garish pallet in every box. I’m in for the skincare, which usually makes the cost of the box worth it. Anything I can’t use gets given away, but honestly, I. Any think of anyone who would wear these colors.
Reply
Jamey
I love eyeshadows and trying different brands. I’ve started collecting them and even buy from the brands I’ve tried and liked !! Lol. That’s what I Love about boxy is all the eyeshadow pallettes
Reply
Jenn
Boxy has helped me grow my collection also. Keep the palettes coming! Between Boxy and my purchases, I have 118 palettes now. Lol.
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.