BoxyCharm February 2020 Spoilers Round #3!

O wow that sucks! I’m sorry. I had my car broken into once & it’s just an awful feeling.

It’s a completely different box. I just got off the wait list this current month, so i can’t tell you if it’s worth it yet though!

Boxy says there is no overlap and your base box and premium box will be completely different. 😊

Ok help! I saw something a week or two ago about a curated Fenty makeup box coming. I thought it was boxycharm… but I could be wrong. Anyone remember it? Link? It was s post from my subscription addiction.

I absolutely recommend premium I have had the others for 3 years And premium when it started a few months ago and premium is by far my favorite it is a completely separate subscription so completely separate products

I have premium and the base box and they are different items between the boxes. No repeats in either box and I like the premium so far and I think it’s worth it!

Does anyone else think it’s strange that no spoilers at all have been shown for boxes including the becca foundation?

Log on to the site in the first week of the month , this month it’s the 11th actually. The info for when to make your choice is there.
I keep the page bookmarked so I just log in and it tells me what date the choices are and what day the add-ons and pop ups are.
So for premium and luxe and waitlisters it’s the 10th and for base box subs it’s the 11th for the March box.
It is I think too late for feb. The add-ons and pop ups are certainly closed.
😊

I most definitely don’t want the tanning drops 😩

I’ve never received an email either. That is poor customer service to just say oh well, you missed it.

They have not been doing emails for choice. I follow boxy preview on Instagram she makes sure that you do not miss anything. And always shows you the spoilers long before Boxy does. We always know the calendar of dates that we need to log in to our account to make our choice and for some very odd reason boxy does not put out that kind of information and does not remind people or keep them informed they expect you to search all over social media I guess. Boxy preview is also on Facebook and she is the only good one in my opinion.

Does anyone know if this may be offered as an add on later?. I chose the foundation because I am light olive and it’s hard to find that shade. I am hoping driftwood will match me.
I didn’t really look at the palette until it was too late to add it on so I hope I can buy this for march.

I received a confirmation email… I hope you get the item you want.

All I know is that’s not a good sign I hope you do get the item that you picked I also did not get a confirmation email and I know a lot of people were concerned about that and they emailed them and they said that they did not get their choice recorded and that their Box would be random and there was nothing they could do. Their computer systems are all messed up they need to get somebody that actually knows what they’re doing when it comes to this stuff to run their computer system.

I didn’t. I had contacted them about it and they did let me know they had my correct choice in their feedback. Hopefully goes same for you when you get your box.

I didn’t get an email after my choice either and I chose the palette which I hope is in my box.

100%!!! You should’ve seen the responses that Boxycharm were posting on IG…They were trying to tell subscribers with very deep skin tones that the tanning drops will be great for evening out skin tone etc. Like…come on 🙄 this product is a huge miss for a LOT of subs and they’re handling the negative feedback really poorly.

I feel the same way. I joined Boxycharm because they had better quality for the price. Now with their Luxe and premium box options, I feel like the base boxes are just getting meh items to encourage people to upgrade. I understand that is the point of business, but I cannot afford that at this time, but at the same time, I don’t want to be given items that are so-so to encourage people to upgrade.

On my… I love the cream. It is the size of any eye cream you get at the drug store. They are all small.
It is very very effective and I am an older woman.

So, about this, I read on Reddit today that if BC over-promises items, they simply buy the rights from original company to just make their own version. That may very well be why some tops fit better, some colors blend better, etc. Quite an eye opener.

The lid seemed very snug and difficult to seat. I’m pretty confident he spa jars are better quality. The product is very nice, though. Quality of the contents is the key.

Face wipes? Aw man that sucks for me. I have very sensitive skin and some of those aggravate my eczema so I only use what I know I can trust and those I get frankly for 3 bucks at Walmart! Like so many others, I’m just not feeling the tanning drops at all either. Guess it could be worse though —those damn SHEET masks (HATE) and recycled BLACK eyeliner (why I left IPSY for Boxy to begin with). Since I just re-subbed after some months, I’ve seen wildly different variations. I’m now very reticent about my decision. I only returned for the Iconic palette and a hope at the Hourglass blush (The first I understood would be in EVERY base which I know is not, and the 2nd is a variant/CHOICE/Premium item. I’m just not too thrilled by this month so I’ll probably cancel again. I’ve been pretty well pleased until now but the inclusion of face wipes? Boxy, Dont be IPSY!

I honestly wouldn’t mind the box you saw. At least I know I would use at least 3 of the items in it!

If there’s complexion items, they will just throw random products in. 2/5 products in my box last month we’re for a very dark complexion because I resubscribed, and their customer service told me oh well.

I know what you mean! If I really like a box I get two and in the beginning I had a lot of a different months of products. My coworker just subscribed and she is looking forward to February’s box.

Boxes vary. You’ll get a random box just like all subscribers, except you won’t have a choice item.

I just resubscribed and got the regular January box everyone else got. If you subscribe now you should receive the regular February box all members get.
I hope that helps

That is so weird how that works because I have been with them for almost 3 years and I get every Box they have and I have 3 accounts between myself my mother and my daughter so we get a lot of boxes every month and I have never received tanning drops I will gladly trade with anybody that does not want them. I have tons of choices. Brand new

I have been subscribed to boxycharm since last March and have never received a self-tanning product! LOL. I’m pretty fair, but would like to try one just for fun. Kinda hope I get it

I love my skin and don’t want any changes to my color. Hope I don’t get it.

From the boxycharm Instagram, it says every subscriber will receive one or the other. But we will see.

Could Be either, or, OR neither. Thats the BC way.

I got these in a Sephora Favorites box, and I love them! Apart from the usual “self-tanner” smell (which isn’t really strong after mixing with lotion, these worked so well, even without a mitt or anything

What differences did you notice? TIA.

The blush is in the premium box, not the base box, and was not a choice item.

Hourglass is in Premium.

My concern is more on Transparency side….I know many company make products in PRC….and I have many which are made there….but then when a brand is advertised in a box…I ought to believe that they are products as would be sold in stores or can be bought from the brand’s website…and not a knock off….
That’s what concern’s me most….

I love how when I make a comment of this nature it never shows up! Come on MSA! Anyone who’s interested in why this palette is made in PRC should go watch The Not So Evil Stepmother’s video from a couple days ago. Trust me, you’re all going to want to see this.

I saw a few full box reveals and ciate vacay powder, pur primer, a lip stain by queen?, and first aid beauty radiance wipes were some more spoilers.