Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I loved this popup sale. I got an Ace Beaute palette I’ve been wanting for a long time (Oceanic) for $9, and I also got the Becca/Kardashian palette (celebrity names mean nothing to me but it is a pretty palette and I love glowy face palettes.) I also got a great deal on three R+Co hair products, and lip gloss from Kopari and Iconic London, both dirt cheap.
Reply
Marion
The Oceanic palette is really pretty I was tempted, but I have so many palettes that I was able to resist it.
I hope you like it!
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
I love SnowFox, but I was able to resist. I have a lot of stuff I need to use up. I think the prices and stock was slightly better than FFF add on sale, this quarter but I did get coco floss from that sale. If they had a really good SPF face moisturizer I probably would have bitten on the BC sale, especially since there haven’t seemed to be any crashes this time around.
Reply
Alice
Did you see the FRE with spf 30? It was $9.
Reply
Lori
Is that stuff good? I have it from Test Tube, but haven’t tried it yet…
SquirrelyGirl
I did, but I need spf 50 on my face. I have very Irish looking skin [pale, red, freckled] and am in the sun all day for my job so I need stronger than 30. Thanks though!
Del
Do items come back in stock like fff? I really want the amika brush😭
Reply
Jraewebb
I am in shock, I was able to place an order and then go back and place another order with no issues! Just spent a bit too much, and have another cart full again. I need to be stopped! Lol
Reply
cynthia
Purchased…
4 sets of the glamglow essentials (all Christmas gifts)
Girl Boss frame…my daughter is a girl boss
Saturday Skin Essence
Mytagalongs hair tools caddy
Metallic spiked BKR bottle in Moondust
Tula mask set
Becca anti fatique under eye primer (this stuff has great reviews)
Reply
Marie
Did anyone get the skin fridge? How much was it? So bummed I missed it 😏
Reply
Alice
Why not just place your cosmetics in the regular refrigerator?
Reply
Apricot
That’s what I do, a beauty fridge is wayyy too small.
Sherri
I didn’t get it, but it was $70-something. Maybe $79? $75?
Reply
Marie
Thanks Sherri! Now I don’t feel
so bad, I thought it would be cheaper.
CHANEL DOSS
If I order pop up items, and then cancel my base box, will i receive my pop up items? March is not looking good to me
Reply
Alice
You should be. If in doubt, email them.
Reply
Cindy
I’m confused, it says Choice is open. I get the base box, premium box, and luxe box. I sign in and nothing loads. I tried Chrome and Explorer, both on a PC and my phone. Anyone else having issues??
Reply
daj
If you get luxe then you won’t get base next month which nullifies your base choice. Gotta wait until next week to choose luxe options
Reply
Beccah
If your getting the luxe then choice isn’t til the 17th
Reply
Chelsea
Thank you! I completely forgot the Luxe box replaces the base box on Luxe months.
Dani
Aahhh! That explains it! Thanks, Beccah! I was also concerned. I guess that means I made it off the waitlist.
Cindy Mckinley
Yes I’m not getting s choice either if that helps.
Reply
Regina
I purchased
Glow Recipe Avocado Sleeping Mask
Hello Charmer tank top
Swig Life Stemless Wine Cup
SweetSpot labs coconut wipe 30ct
Glam glow insta mud
No choice today because luxe replaced base box.
Dot
Spent way way to much !! $300
+ did I need it yes , we’ll not that much , but it’s done so be it plus some are gifts 🤣🥰
Reply
Holly
I’m a Premium subscriber with a Luxe waitlist and I get the base box. Choice did not come up until I pulled the plug on my Luxe waitlist. Very frustrating. But I had been wavering anyway so now I just won’t get the Luxe at all. Doesn’t make sense. But glad I got to make my two choices.
Reply
Lesly
It probably meant you were off the waitlist for Luxe since Luxe replaces Base on Luxe months. Once you cancelled it went back to Base.
Reply
Beccah
Choice today is only for people not getting luxe who are subbed to premium. If you are getting luxe then choice is the 17th. It says all the dates on the website
Reply
Marion
Woo hoo! I’m waitlisted for Premium, so I got to shop!
For my $40:
– IGK Antisocial hair mask
– Kaja gloss stick in Too Hot
– Daily Concepts mother of pearl soap sponge
– Klorane date leave-in cream
– Clean Skin towels 50 pack
– Kaja cushy lip stain in Plush
– Popband popmask 2 pack
– Touch in Sol liquid shadow in Spotlight
These will be my first Kaja & Popband products & my first Touch in Sol cosmetics product.
Reply
Danielle
The Kaja lip stain is AMAZING. It’s been on sale on Sephora for a while so I managed to get almost every color. I even bought 2 of a few shades. It’s rated so high and I didn’t understand why they were getting rid of it. I just figured it out the other day. Every single one I bought expires sometime this year. Some in just a few months. I’m really disappointed because while $9 is better than $18 it’s still not cheap. Now I’m stuck with way more than I can use before it expires even if I wear it exclusively. Oh well, lesson learned. But it really is a great product and I am sure you’ll be pleased!
I grabbed the pink shade of the heart lipstick. I can’t wait to try it! The only other Kaja product I’ve tried is the heart stamp blush and it’s high quality as well. They didn’t have it at the sale but I’m sure the regular blush they had is just as good. Enjoy your lip stain!
Reply
Marion
Thanks, Danielle! I definitely keep my lip products way past when I’m “supposed” to, so that doesn’t worry me too much (as long as it smells & performs the same, I’ll use it!)
Jacki
So many things in the sale this time! It worked seamlessly
Reply
svetlana7e
I spent $80. Got two Perricone product (I love him or his product), Tula gel, Fox oil, 5 set brushes, and Fre serum.
I am still waiting to receive items I bought last pop up sale. They send one at the time and it is getting frustrating.
Reply
Lori
I got:
–Perricone MD Instant Blur
–Perricone MD Firming Evening Repair
–Perricone MD Vit C Ester Eye Serum
–Perricone MD Vit C Cleanser
–Teami Focus Blend
–R+CO Gemstone Color Shampoo and Conditioner
–Playa Beauty Endless Summer Spray
–Daily Concepts Charcoal Soap Sponge
I’m super excited!
Reply
Anna
Sigh…. 100$ the first time, then went back and spent 40 more. Did I need it? No. Did I want it? Hell yeah. Bonus: none of it were spent on make up, but things I wanted but did not want to spend too much on. A good haul, and the popup did work just fine!
Reply
Debbie
Was at TJ Maxx last night. Almost all the same stuff for less $$$ the Luxie brushes are not at Marshall’s or TJ. Neither is the Becca powder. Otherwise it’s all at the discount stores for less.
The regular sub box is a good deal but the rest? Nope.
Just wanted to add a different voice here so the popup peer pressure doesn’t cause someone to bust their budget. And maybe some people don’t live near a Marshall’s or TJ Maxx but I swear I have seen every item for less excluding the two I mentioned.
Reply
Lori
You make a very good point and this is the time people start to fall off their resolutions. I appreciate the reminder.
That being said, I like these sales because I’d rather spend a bit more (I think they are FANTASTIC deals, personally plus free shipping!) and have more time to do other things I love, like reading and sex instead of sifting through TJ Maxx . I get that some people enjoy that, though. Just MHO :).
Reply
Alice
Agree. I’m not near any of those stores; but, still, none of this stuff is tempting. Saving my money.
Reply
Tamichiko
I got the Luxie 30-brush set and the PYT mini flat iron. Ended up spending only $111, as nothing else really caught my eye.
Reply
Sara
I just placed an order; it will come before March right? I’m thinking about canceling my premium for March I’m not a big fan of any of the spoilers so far. But also if you cancel is it easy to sign back up for premium?
Reply
Jackie
It says items will ship separately through March, so I’m not sure. Premium is supposed to have a waitlist that isn’t the easiest to get off of, so I heard. But others SAY they got off the list within a week, so again, not entirely sure.
Reply
Luna
Checked out a little over a half hour ago and no issues. This is my first pop-up experience, so I feel I got incredibly lucky or it’s too good to be true. lol! I dare not list the damage I did, but I’m very happy and excited with everything I got! With the exception of maybe only two products, I stuck to items that were less than $10, so I still had plenty to choose from. 🙂 Now that I feel like I jumped one hurdle with no issues, now let’s see how the shipping & receiving of what I ordered go. lol
Reply
kaleena
Does anyone know how long boxypop up will be open?
Reply
Christa H.
Nothing is really pulling me in. I have sooo much of everything that I’m skipping this popup…
Reply
Tracy
Isn’t choice for the base box (for premium and luxe subscribers) supposed to be open? I signed in and out, but wasn’t offered any choice items.
Reply
Sherri
Yes, choice is open for base box: Sutra beauty mini curling wand, Murad Hydro-Dynamic Ultimate Moisture For Eyes, or QMS Medicosmetics Lip Liner Corrector.
Reply
iamkarisee
I am so disappointed. I am on both premium AND Luxe waitlists, but do not have access to Choice. 🙁
blondie1021
Ouch, 200$ later lol, but very happy!
Reply
Vicky H
No issues! Got my 30
Piece Luxie set and 2 glam glow sets… $103 later 🙁
Reply
Vicky H
I was able to get a third glam glow and added some shampoo and conditioner. No issues again! I think they let you get up to a quantity of 4 on some items based on the drop down.
Reply
Rachel
Same, no problem checking out. I whittled my $100 cart down to $35 after tax. I’m please with what I got, though prices seemed slightly higher to me this time around. Tons of items to scroll through.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.