POPSUGAR Must Have x Neiman Marcus 2019 Box FULL SPOILERS!


This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

We have full spoilers for the 2019 POPSUGAR Must Have x Neiman Marcus Box

The 2019 POPSUGAR Must Have x Neiman Marcus Box will include:

Eve Lom The Moisture Cream – Retail Value $150

UMA Oils Pure Rest Wellness Oil – $85 Value

Alexis Bittar Long Leaf Earrings OR Alexis Bittar Studded Hinge Bracelet – $145 Value

(Your choice)

Skin Worldwide Vara Slippers

(Your size choice of Small, Medium, or Large)

Agraria San Francisco Lavender & Rosemary Scented Crystal Candle – Value $40

Vital Proteins Lavender Lemon Beauty Collagen Stick Pack Box – Value $34

ANNA Pedra Coasters Set of 4 in Natural – Value $80

Note that the coasters from Anna New York are made from a natural stone, so each set is unique and the size, pattern, and color may vary.

Godinger Lumina Set of 4 Double Old Fashioned Glasses in Smoke – Value $40

RMS Beauty Signature Set POP Collection – Value $44

Courant Catch:1 in Bone – Value $80

Londontown Laku Enhanced Colour Nail Polish in Starstruck – Value $16

$25 Neiman Marcus Gift Card

What do you think of the spoilers?

FYI the POPSUGAR Must Have x Neiman Marcus Box sold out weeks ago. The cost was $275 for the box.

The Winter POPSUGAR subscription box is still available. See my full review here.

POPSUGAR Must Have

How do subscribers rate POPSUGAR Must Have?

Shipping
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Curation
Ease of canceling

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about POPSUGAR Must Have!

Enable notifications (On switch) to get the latest POPSUGAR Must Have spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.


Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in POPSUGAR Must Have Box Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: POPSUGAR Must Have Box | 112 comments

112 Comments

  1. The Godinger glasses (different color) are on sale at Macy’s for $15. I picked up a set of amethyst color…. so freaking pretty. Another holographic set for $30 (regular $76)

  2. When will we see a review for this box?

    • I’m guessing never

  3. I won a POPSUGAR Must Have Box featuring Disney’s Noelle!

    anyone else?

    totally remember entering as I rarely do them, lol

    check your emails as PSMH sent info out on Jan 15

    have zero clue what’s in it, value $121 + arrives in 6-8 weeks

    yeah!

    • I won one too!

    • Hi! I won one too, but I wasn’t sure if I was eligible because I won one of the Popsugar × Campbell’s boxes the month before.
      I received the Popsugar inspired by Disney’s Noelle today. Here’s what was included:
      Stonewall Kitchen Peppermint Hot Chocolate 15.3oz. $9.90 (can’t wait to try this tonight)
      Wander Beauty Lift Off Purifying and Brightening Peel Off Mask in box 60ml $34.00
      Apotheke Black Cypress 13oz. Hand Poured Candle in box 60-70 hour burn time $28.50 (personally, I’m not a fan of the scent, but it will make a nice gift)
      Shashi Annabelle Snowflake Earrings ~ $48.00 (similar from brand website)

      I can’t believe I managed to win 2 of their contests. Congrats to the other winners and good luck to everyone on their future contests!

  4. I LOVE this box! Perfect timing of items for me, personally. We are just moving into a new construct home decorated with mostly white and neutrals. the coasters are so stunning on our white marble countertops. The soft blue really pops. I’ve had numerous compliments already. Maybe its just me, but I cannot have enough luxe face and body oils. I use them 2x daily so they get used up fairly quickly. I always wear slippers on our hardwood floors all year round. Was happy to receive these comfy lightweight slippers. They fit well and are high quality materials. I have far too many earrings and am still NEVER bothered by receiving a new nice quality pair. Fun color and shape. I have received several compliments on them over the holidays. The makeup pallette is nice to have in my travel bag or purse as an extra hydrating color boost throughout the day. I would never buy this, but am intrigued to try it, which is the exact reason I subscribe to subscription boxes: to try and learn about new-to-me products and enjoy more of those I already may coincidentally use. The nail polish is not my taste preference, but can see me trying it as a top coat. I have been pleasantly surprised over the years at how much I end up liking some of the products that I was not too excited about at first. The blush is fun and looks nice with pale or tanned skin. I already use a collagen product daily, but it’s fun to try a new one and a new flavor. I liked this one. I am quite pleased with this box and even if I did happen to see an item discounted at TJ maxx or marshals or wherever, I would not be sad because often they don’t have the full set still available, it’s not the same color, or I’m not in the actual stores frequently enough to find them. Also, for me it is a perk because the subscription boxes provide me products that if I did see I probably would not think to choose them because they are out of my comfort zone. I like the surprise element. I have enjoyed this box of items tremendously. I normally shop at Neiman Marcus full price so I find these surpise boxes for the same brand quality that I already purchase are well worth my dollars at a significantly discounted price. And, I do think that when I feel tired of receiving too much inventory I have narrowed down the number of boxes I get for a year so that it becomes fun again. I think most people complain because they genuinely don’t care for the item or items available (sign it’s time to stop subscribing for a bit or switch box brands), or they are bored with receiving too many different boxes. I myself have experienced the same at different times. I value all opinions unless it seems that someone crabs just for the sheer sake of being negative for no real particular reason on multiple different box posts. If you basically hate every box, it may be time to stop the subscriptions. lol

  5. I received my box today and am really happy with everything except for the coasters. 3 of them are oval but the fourth is MUCH larger than the others and is a weird sort of diamond shape. It looks like it belongs to an entirely different set. I know it is a natural item but it is really off so I can’t give this as a gift. I buy this every year and give most of the items as gifts.

    • Ohhhhh! It may take a minute due to the holiday rush and year end corporate accounting/inventory for most businesses, but I would most definitely contact PS about your defunct coaster. I am quite sure they would make that right for you.

  6. I received my box yesterday.
    I love it- but I feel like we receive the same brands from the NM box every year. Three times we’ve received agate pieces from the same brand (cheese plate, clock, coasters). Twice we’ve received items from Alexis Bittar (gold cuff and bangle/ earrings). Also, this year I already own the RMS palette and I drink this exact Vital Proteins Collagen powder in Lavender every day already. (It’s available at Whole Foods).

    I still love this box, and I think it’s the best PS box of the year, every year, I just feel like the curation is getting a bit stagnant.

    Does anyone else feel this way?

  7. Oh! I forgot to mention the gift card. Someone had asked what people will be buying. I’m not sure, but I love to shop the Neiman Marcus Last Call site. $25 will go a lot further there and they often have site wide 30% off flash sales.

    • I am going to use mine at NM Last Call too!

      • I just ordered a pair of classic Ray-Ban Wayfarers for 60% with the discounts and gift card plus free shipping with Shoprunner. I’m super happy!

    • Angela, I was the one who asked about the gift card. Thanks for posting about The Neiman Marcus Last Call site. I didn’t know about that site! Love it. 🙂

      • You are so welcome! It’s amazing for designer sunglasses, Burberry accessories and beautiful housewares & gifts. I’ve had such good luck on there over the years.
        I hope you find a little treasure that you love! I mis-typed my other post. I actually got my classic Ray-Ban sunglasses for 60% OFF with the discounts and gift card. I received them super fast and they are gorgeous.
        Happy Christmastime!

        • Merry Christmas Angela! I hope you get some good deals in the new year.

  8. I received my box yesterday and went through it slowly with an open mind and a good attitude.
    It’s a beautiful box over all and some of the items are stunning.
    I’m still disappointed that there are 4 beauty items and 2 other consumables that aren’t fancy chocolate, but I love everything else.
    My husband and son are thrilled with the charger and I love that it eliminates some clutter since they leave their cables out.
    I’m always most excited for home goods and I wish there were more.
    The coasters are absolutely beautiful and go in my lounge perfectly.
    I collect dishes, mostly vintage, but I love the Godinger set for my bar. They are beautiful and classic collectibles. Love the grey.
    The candle is lovely and I will always be happy with a full size candle in a neutral color.
    I collect Alexis Bittar pieces and this bracelet is a classic style that I didn’t have.
    I couldn’t give a rats a about the nail polish. It’s a filler and not a luxury brand in my opinion.
    The collagen, although I currently take collagen and will use it, did not feel luxurious. It was like getting vitamins. Not exciting at all.
    The Eve Lom, UMA oil and RMS are very nice and I will use them all, but there was just way too much. One of those would have been plenty,
    The slippers were a surprise to me. They are actually gorgeous in person and are packaged beautifully for gifting, I was going to just use them around the house because I wear slippers all the time and they exist, but they are actually super nice and I know the perfect person to gift them too.
    This is a lovely box in many ways and I hope that everyone who purchased it finds some treasures. I feel like half of it was amazing and the other half felt cheap because of the nail polish, supplements and endless beauty products.
    I would have rather had one real wow item and 1 or 2 beauty, food, candle type items instead of six consumable fillers that will be gone and forgotten.
    Still glad I got the box. I hope everyone else is pleasantly surprised too!

    • Thank you so much for your thorough review! I am dying for mine to arrive! This is making me even more excited. 🎉🎈🎉💯🎁

      • You are so welcome. I hope you love it! The PS NM boxes are my favorites of the whole year. Enjoy!

  9. This really is just a collection of junk that would normally go to TJ Maxx at 50-75% off the Neiman Marcus price. Don’t get me wrong, I love me some TJ Maxx, but, I’m not paying anywhere near $275 to get this stuff there.

    In addition, PopSugar gave my email address to Alexis Bittar when I had opted out from marketing emails. I’m not at all happy about the box but I’m even more upset about the email address being distributed to Bittar and who knows what other companies. Not cool!

    • One woman’s junk is another woman’s treasure <3

    • I swear popsugar has an actual deal with TJ Maxx. I ALWAYS see their stuff in TJ, at the same time, for MUCH cheaper. I think they’re sourcing from them. I just saw this Kevyn Aucoin blush there.

    • Is that why I’m getting constant emails from Alexis Bittar? I do receive the quarterly boxes. I didn’t however buy the box this year and rather happy about that but nice that others liked it.

      • Hi Christine. Same here. I thought maybe I checked something in an email or giveaway, but now I’m sure it has to be from PopSugar.

    • I so agree with you. Am totally disappoint at the contents of this box. A big waste of $275.00. I probably will never buy another Neiman Marcus Popsugar box again even though I have bought them since they first came out years ago. This is the worse box they have ever had. Definitely not worth $275 and a really really big stretch for $800. Just really bad. So very disappointment.

  10. I really like this box it’s the money I don’t want to spend😊.

  11. I personally love Popsugar and I always want to love their NM collabs but every year they miss the mark for me, hey I’m trying to give them my money 😂 I was afraid I was going to have major FOMO, but when I saw the final spoilers I was super happy I didn’t buy, I subscribe to over 20 boxes and have already gotten slippers, face oil, a palette that I actually do like. I am happy for the people who do like the box kudos to you 😁

    • 20 boxes? Good lord, what do you do with all of that stuff?

      • 😆😆😆 to MissJ. I sometimes surprise myself when I keep ordering boxes, but I don’t plan to do it forever. At some point, I think I’ll only have two or three monthly and one or two quarterly at the most.

      • Hi MissJ,

        I rotate stock lol my daughters pillage what they can when they come over, I gift things but I try to use everything, subscription boxes are such an addiction lol I have different varieties of boxes, beauty, lifestyle, keto boxes, I just like to get treats for myself in the mail besides bills 😂

  12. LOL, good morning Everyone,

    Patience has never been a strong suit and waiting for my boxes to arrive, this one included has me stalking my neighborhood mail carrier, heart racing when I see a UPS truck and oh my, DHL, you had me at sign here………

    I truly enjoy the thrill of receiving boxes and I choose items to keep for me, gift and swap.

    Out of this box, the bracelet and slippers are mine and I am excited by both. Everything else is SwapBait since I am practically done with gift acquiring at this stage. I am delighted to have items to swap with on MSA and to find a good home to someone who will cherish more than I would. In turn, I am able to find my unicorns, treasures and heart’s delight through others and make SwapPals while doing so……

    So thank you one and all, Liz and Eric, everyone that contributes to your site on your behalf, vendors, readers, swappers and those who post.

    Merry Christmas to all!

    …….and now Santa, please release my boxes LOL

    • Hey!
      Nice to see you on here. I hope yours comes soon and that you love it! I will check your swap account as I might want doubles of some items for gifting. I always think I’m going to buy this box for gifts but then I end up keeping almost everything.

  13. What’s everybody getting with their $25 Neiman Marcus Gift Card?

    • Wondering the same. How far does $25 go at Neiman Marcus? 😂

    • SwapBait 😁

  14. LOVE the glasses and the slippers the rest is kinda just meeeh for me. I’ll probably end up gifting most of it but that works for me!

    HauteBeautyGuide.com

  15. The people complaining about others complaining… seriously think about what you’re saying.

    People comment because they like or don’t like a box. Either way it has exactly nothing to do with you. It happens on the FFF forum every season and I find it very odd.

    If you enjoy this box, that’s great; some people don’t like it and they have just as much of a right to say what they think as you do.

  16. I didn’t order this one, it’s just not in my price range for a box. I really like it though, and wish I had this box coming to me.

  17. Thank you to everyone who took the time to comment. I enjoy reading all of the comments, both positive and negative. If I knew that I’d be excessively upset if I read a comment, I’d take my own advice and stop reading the comments…because it’s my own fault if I allow myself to let some stranger’s opinion ruin my day.

    • Lol right!

    • Hahaha..amen sista!

  18. I am quite happy with the box! I liked the bracelet and slippers and bought based upon those spoilers. Now that I’ve seen the whole box, it is one of my favorite PSNM. I think the palette is a good neutral item that most people can use or gift. The decor items, the glasses and coasters, are also neutral and the Anna New York is a designer well known at NM and loved in past boxes. The whole box works, and I am happy it is smaller items because they are easier to swap or gift if they aren’t a perfect fit for me when I get them. For example, last year’s curling iron would have been a total miss for me, and it made up a large portion of the box.

    I’m not sure why a few people love to hate PS. I’m also a bit amused by people who don’t understand the RV – this is a very high value box, so it certainly would never have been a $75 quarterly box! If you’ve been around the sub game for a bit you know we are never paying 8% of RV for the items, lol.

    I hope everyone that gets it will find a number of items that they like and those who didn’t will be able to swap or buy the items they like inside, as well!

  19. I can’t wait to get my box! Unlike past years I will use almost everything. I will swap the collagen and probably the polish and glasses, but will keep and enjoy everything else. I’m excited to try the Eve Lom. Love their lip products.

  20. I always feel like when people say they are glad they didn’t get the box it’s because they are having FOMO. There is no reason to knock a box especially if you didn’t buy it. I’ve bought this box every year except the first year and the two things that stand out to me is there isn’t an awesome dessert item this year. I love the treat they send. Also, although I like eve lom usually they send a skincare item that I consider pretty luxe. The one item that bothers me is the collagen. RMS I consider ok but it is better than the ysl palette of a couple years back that was too bold for me to wear. This is much more neutral. I love the coasters. I have a set and am excited to have more. The currant charging pad I’ve been debating buying their large one but haven’t want to spend the money so this will be a great test.

    • Nope, no FOMO here whatsoever. Glad for those who like it, though.

      • Thank you for being gracious and not insulting those of us looking forward to this box 🙂

      • I second this. I had ordered the box, but after seeing the oil I knew this wouldn’t be for me this year and canceled. Very happy with my decision.

        Maybe next year…

      • I feel the same!

    • I agree! I get so sick of the negativity. I would have preferred a holiday snack instead of collagen but I see how it fits with the theme of skin care.

      One person in particular does NOTHING but trash Popsugar.

      I loved my winter box and I love this one too! I can’t wait to use the nail polish, the palette and wear the earrings.

      The entire box decor wise is neutral. The candle, coasters, charging pad, and the smoke colored glasses are well curated neutrals. I love agate coasters. I have one blue set that has lasted for ages and I am excited to get more 🙂

      • Why does my personal opinion matter so much to you?

    • The same argument could be used against people who bought this box: they are raving about it in order to justify their purchase and feel better about spending a nice chunk of money. I personally never care about comments whether they are positive or negative. I know what I like and that’s that.

  21. Can’t wait to get my box. What I don’t use will make beautiful gifts. I have agate coasters in my living area and my backyard they look fantastic and I have no issues with them. Looking forward to another set

  22. This box is really sad!! I am so very disappointed in it. That RMS palette is garbage and not of use to me at all. I would never wear anything like that. This box seems like a Neiman Marcus is trying to get rid of tons of rejects and I can’t begin to say how I WILL NEVER BUY ANOTHER POPSUGAR NEIMAN MARCUS BOX again and waste my money. I just literally threw away $275. Thanks Popsugar Neiman Marcus!!! NOT!!!!

    • Meoowwwww

  23. Where do people post to sell/trade this mistake????

  24. I like the glasses and nail polish. Glad I skipped this – this year’s box seems exceptionally heavy on beauty.

  25. Very happy I didn’t buy this box. For $75 I’d be all right with this assortment, but not $275.

  26. So, on a whim and out of character for me, I purchased this box. I admit to being regretful afterward, but it was my choice and I didn’t fight Popsugar on it or do any sort of chargeback, because their terms were clear upon purchase. (BTW, for those that did chargebacks and still got a box shipped, Popsugar can win that fight if they work their chargebacks and you will end up paying for this box).
    That being said, I actually like this box. The only item that’s not for me is the RMS palette. No biggie there. I think the regret came from all of the negativity posted here, but I’m now looking forward to getting this in about a week.

    • Well said! If you don’t want to be surprised by a box’s contents, then you shouldn’t subscribe/purchase it! I am also excited about this box! I wish I had never read all the negative posts!

      • I don’t understand it one bit. Buy a surprise box, yet be irate when you strongly dislike the contents. Lol! I too wish I hadn’t read the comments. I’m excited for the box and read on another site that the slippers are super comfortable! Enjoy yours 🤗

        • Amen. It’s all about the $$$$$ . I know that some sell most and if it doesn’t have a amazing resell value they make at the company. I think this was amazing box. Would i spend 200 plus on just one box…NO! If I could I would. I love Popsugar and their boxes.

    • I agree about the charge backs. PS may indeed win over any dispute people make when “they cancel their orders left and right”. 🤣🤣🤣

      On the positive side I really like the box. I like last year’s better but this one will get a lot of use. Do I regret buying this? No. I am quite pleased with it.

      I am not fond of the slippers but they already have a lady who wants them.

      I am not sure I have a use for the sleeping oil and I may not use the collagen water because it has bovine collagen in it.

      I have the money and I do not go out of the house at all unless I am traveling, going on date night with my husband, going to the doctors, or hair, sports massages and mani pedis. I can’t wait to use the nail polish as a top coat! My personal hell is to go into TJ Maxx, Marshalls, Ross or Target. I pay for the convenience of nicely packaged items that arrive to my doorstep.

      Those glasses, the palette, earrings and agate coasters are fab. For those of you who consign things at The Real Real they will accept both the jewelry and coasters since both are luxury brands. When I have grown tired of items from PS I have consigned the things they take. They love Alexis Bittar and those leaf earrings stay sold out.

      I have to wait until next Saturday for my box to arrive. I wish it would speed up but due to not enough employees, possible inclement weather or the holidays I may have to wait a day or two extra for the box to arrive!

      • I really hope someone there works those chargebacks. They definitely should and would win. They shipped by the date they said they would, the RV is there as stated, and it clearly said all sales were final, no refunds. I think some folks think a chargeback cancels their order, but there’s no way their order system is connected to stuff like that and I think people know they’re screwed and that’s why they’re mad the box still shipped. Big duh! Or maybe they don’t know chargebacks aren’t final because the other side can fight them.

        I’ll use all of this box except maybe that palette. I also loathe going to actual stores, so this is fun for me as well. I hope you enjoy! Mine isn’t due here until the 14th. Ugh. lol

        • I predict tons of crying when people get their refund reversed lol

    • I actually agree with you about the chargebacks. I don’t think most people realize that the box was probably already ready for shipping before the refund and they will either be charged again or need to send the box back. It’s not cool to ask for a refund and then keep the box. At least refuse the box and have it sent back. I’m more curious what lie they told their credit card company to get a refund lol

  27. I’m glad I didn’t splurge on this box. While the items are nice, I agree with others who stated that this seems like a random assortment without a true hero item. That said, I’m glad that those who ordered this are happy with the contents! Most of the items seem useful.

  28. No regrets here, I have yet to be disappointed with a PSMH X NM box!! It makes my crazy job and schedule worth it! To: Me From: Me!! Well, so are all of my other sub boxes but ya know…..

  29. Looks like a great box, but I have no regrets for not ordering one. I do love those coasters. I hope everyone enjoys their boxes!

    • I only hear bad things about agate coasters, beautiful as they are. Not accomplishing the purpose of a coaster – absorbing condensation – and the vcondensation accumulating and spilling over the coaster onto the hopefully-not-wood beneath it. Agate coasters sticking to your glass as you lift it and then falling off and shattering. I’ve never personally used them, though, only read complaints.

      • FWIW, we use agate coasters regularly in our home and I have no complaints!

      • Yes, that is a good description of agate coasters…but you can get them inexpensively on Amazon, and so if you buy a dozen or so, you won’t be upset when one shatters (and shatter they will). $80 is not a realistic price for agate coasters when you can get them cheap on Amazon. I prefer blue ones, myself.

      • I have a set of agate coasters and they have given me no problem.

    • I’m happy to sell anything in this box, wrong size slippers, a lot of duplicate items, only thing I’d like to keep is the charging pad….

  30. Haha – I hated the spoilers but I like everything that wasn’t spoiled. Either way, I wouldn’t have paid $275 for this.

  31. I can’t wait for my box to be delivered now, thank you for the spoilers!

    I already use RMS cosmetics, and I own all of these products/shades separately, but having the same products that I use daily in one palette is amazing. I’ve used that polish brand before, and I already drink this flavor of Vital Proteins daily. It’s excellent.

    None of the brands are new to me, but these are my favorite brands, so it’s like shopping for my regular products and getting an amazing discount. 😉

    • I just realized I ordered the same vanilla balm from RMS today, lol, that’s at the bottom of the palette. I go through a few of those balms every winter here in downtown Chicago.

  32. I was like wow look at all the stuff in the box! It is amazing. Then I saw it was $275. Still a good box for someone but pricy.

  33. It’s not terrible, but it seems like a bit of a random collection to me. No one item is a real wow.

    I typically use sub box items as gifts, but nothing much here is giftable but the tumblers. The coasters and candle are kind of cliche gifts, and who wouldn’t love to receive a gift of some collagen (“you’ve been looking a little wrinkly lately…”)? I’m just grateful that palette isn’t supposed to be eyeshadows.

    • That’s what I thought too- the items in the background of the item pics (the pajamas, silver tray, etc.) seem much more luxe and special than the actual box products. I’m pretty sure they did those agate coasters in a previous PSMH box too. I’m absolutely thrilled that I DIDN’T order this box.

      I did just order two sets of the glasses though ($68 on sale with free shipping), so I’m even more thrilled that I just saved $207 bucks! I predict lots of the items in this box to hit the swap boards this year…

      • And then I just saw someone else’s comment about the glasses being on sale at Macy’s, so I’ve now ordered 4 sets at $16.79/set with free shipping, and cancelled my Neiman’s order!

        T

        • Hey thanks! The only thing I liked was the glasses 🙂

        • My fellow Macy’s shoppers, those glasses are $13.99 today! Ask for a price adjustment while you can!

          By the way, I ordered the glasses in blue, received them yesterday, and they are stunning. Love them!

      • The 2017 NM box had a small agate cheese plate and spreader, and a couple years before that a small agate clock, all from the same company.

        I probably would use most of the items in this box, but at $275- forget it. No FOMO here.

  34. I love this box and can’t wait to get it. It has a nice mix of items. I love getting skin care and trying new brands that I wouldn’t usually have tried The tumblers are adorable. I need slippers. The charger is great. I usually hate palettes but I can actually use this one. I hope Darlene doesn’t post about her displeasure AGAIN.

    • I wasn’t planning to. I’m flattered that you are thinking of me enough to publicly call me out on a public blog that asks for all opinions though.

      • 😂

      • Darlene,

        When I first read the comment addressed to you specificallly, that hit a nerve. I found it to be rude to you. I bought the box and I am not sure how I feel. I noticed with PopSugar sometimes I need to see the box first. With that said, Darlene I appreciate all comments and please continue to give your opinion.

    • I will post about my displeasure again! I am yet again a popsucker! What a waste this box was. I will probably use the rms make up, the coasters and the neiman marcus gift card. Thats 80+40+25 does not equal the 275 I spent!

      Brown glasses make it look like you are drinking pee water

      Hopefully I will have learned my lesson

      • The glasses aren’t brown it is the liquid inside that is the pee water as you so eloquently described. 🤣🤣🤣

        • You are correct! They are not brown, turns out they are gray. So since drinking dirty gray appearing water is way better than the initial pee water I thought I would be drinking I feel a lot better about the box! 🤪

      • Spot on. I’m cancelling my subscription and not buying this box again. THanks but no thanks.

  35. i couldn’t afford the price, but wow are those some amazing spoilers!!!! those glasses are blowing my mind!

  36. Thank God I got a refund!

    • I agree! This would have made an awesome quarterly box. But for the $275 neiman Marcus box .. no way !!! The tumblers are crystal… aka plastic and the nail polish is not luxury at all. I hope I don’t sound crazy but they could have done a much better job curating this luxury box.

      • Crystal is a type of glass, so not sure what makes you think they are plastic.

      • I really like the box and can’t wait for LIz to give an in-depth review.

  37. Oh I really love those tumblers!!! Is anyone going to trade them? I have a crap ton of stuff (mostly beauty, some jewelry, lifestyle, accessories etc)….

    • Neiman is having 25% off now so at $40 would be $32

      • $30 I meant!

        • I found them at Macy’s for even cheaper!! I had to Google them right away. Now I am shopping for Godinger crystal. Goddess help me. Thank you, though! I appreciate the comment.

          • I know! I’m such a sucker for glass kitchen crap. I’m so glad you posted your comment about Macy’s having these on sale. I just ordered 4 sets for less than the cost of the 2 sets I’d just ordered from Neiman’s. (By the time I’m done loading up my cart with all of stuff they have on sale it would have been way cheaper to stick with my Neiman’s order though…)

          • Aww it looks like the dmoke glasses are sold out at Macy’s, now! Lots of other pretty Godinger crystal in sale, though.

          • Jennifer- Macy’s didn’t have the smoke colored ones. Only blue, violet and clear. I’m ok with that!

            Melissa hahaha about having too big of an order now. Glad you got the killer deal though!

  38. I would have been so upset, I am so glad I decided not to get this

  39. I’m gonna have to order me a set of those glasses…diggin’ em!

  40. Nice but absolutely not worth $275 to me.

    • I am thinking the same thing. It’s a great box, but I wouldn’t want to spend $275 for it.

    • agree – do love the coasters, feel like we rec’d something like them before, in blue?!

      it’s a nice box + hope many like it – a lot of times better in person

    • I’m absolutely thrilled!

      I’ve ordered every box from PS since June 2013. I’ve never missed one monthly, quarterly, or limited edition box. The bookends from the NM box from 2017 are still sitting on our bookshelf. Last year’s NM box was lacking in my opinion, I’m very happy that this year’s box is back up to par.

      My only regret is that I wish I’d ordered two, so I could break the second up for Christmas gifts. I wasn’t expecting such lovely home items. (The one I ordered is all mine! I won’t be breaking that one up for gifts, lol.)

      • My bookends are still in use too! 👍

        I think the past 3 years the boxes have been outstanding.

        • I gifted the bookends to my MIL. She still says it was one of the best gifts anyone has ever given her. She loves them.

          • In the interest of full transparency, I actually ordered two NM boxes that year, lol. I gave the bookends to my brother for Christmas and the cuff bracelet to his wife, lol. This year I didn’t order two boxes bc last years was lacking. My best friend still hasn’t mastered that curling wand. (I have given her a ton of lessons too, lmao.)

            I know these boxes are expensive, more than other PS boxes, but I’ve been using the NM box for Christmas gifts for years. When you think about the value of breaking them up for gifts, it’s actually a really good deal.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

*