MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyLuxe September 2020 Spoiler Round #3!

BoxyLuxe December 2019 FULL Spoilers!

We have FULL for one variation of the December 2019 BoxyLuxe box!

Your December 2019 BoxyLuxe may include:

  • Storybook Cosmetics Fairy Tale Book Club – Little Briar Rose – $55
  • Elemis Pro-Collagen Rose Facial Oil
  • Fresh Soy Face Cleanser
  • QMS Lip Line Corrector
  • Ciaté Confetti Highlighter
  • Kat Von D Beauty Dagger Tattoo Liner
  • Too Faced Melted Matte Liquid Lipstick
  • IGK First Class Charcoal Detox Dry Shampoo
  • Daily Concepts Daily Hair Wrap Towel

Here’s a look at more spoilers:

  • IGK First Class Charcoal Detox Dry Shampoo
  • m.greengrass Dry Oil Spray – Beach Air
  • Kat Von D Beauty Dagger Tattoo Liner
  • Ciaté Confetti Highlighter
  • Ciaté Marbled Light Illuminating Blusher

In case you missed the previous spoilers:

Too Faced Rich & Dazzling Lip Gloss OR Too Faced Liquid Lipstick (colors will vary)

In case you missed the previous spoilers:

Fresh Soy Face Cleanser

Cosmedix Face Roller (in red or blue) OR QMS Lip Line Corrector


Elemis Pro-Collagen Rose Facial Oil OR Saturday Skin Waterfall Glacier Water Cream


Source: BoxyCharm

Storybook Cosmetics Fairy Tale Book Club – Little Briar Rose – $55

What do you think of the spoilers?

FYI – BoxyCharm boxes have many variations so it is not guaranteed you’ll receive the items from the spoilers. 

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, the regular Boxycharm box is $25 a month. BoxyLuxe is a once-a-quarter upgrade option you can add to your existing $25-a-month Boxycharm subscription. So for an additional $28.99, you’ll get the Luxe items, and be paying a total of $53.99 for that quarterly box. 

If you haven’t signed up for BoxyCharm yet:

For a limited time, click here and use coupon code JOLLYCHARM to get a free Tarte Be you. Naturally. Eyeshadow Palette (valued at $36) with your first BoxyCharm box!

Details: Valid for new subscribers only, or those who canceled before November 1st, 2019. Must use coupon code at checkout. Valid while December’s box and Tarte gift supplies last.

FYI – From Boxycharm: “Don’t worry, NEW members that participate in a gift with purchase promotion still have a chance to receive a box variation that includes the sneak peeks of the month for existing members. Although they can’t guarantee which variation NEW Charmers will receive, you can rest assured that the Boxy Team all variations will be equally amazing.”

Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in BoxyLuxe Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 70 comments

Comments (70)

  1. I can tell you. It freaking sucked. I was missing items then the only reason I signed up was for the tarte pallet. Do u think I got that? NOPE!! I want to mail this crap back and get my 50 bucks back.

    • You should email them and request a replacement for any missing items. You have to do it within 2 weeks. I’ve requested many missing items. It’s annoying but they will absolutely send it to you. 😊

  2. I received my BoxyLuxe today and love every single item in it – and I had actually been planning to purchase a few of them after the holidays, so it’s just perfect!

    I received the following items:

    Storybook Cosmetics | Fairy Tales Little Briar Rose palette | MSRP: $55

    Saturday Skin | Waterfall Glacier Water Cream | MSRP: $39

    Ciaté | Confetti Highlighter| MSRP: $32

    Fresh | Soy Face Cleanser | MSRP: $48

    QMS | Lip Line Corrector | MSRP $200

    Inn Beauty | Power Up: Dual-phase Setting Face Mist | MSRP $32

    Kat Von D | Dagger Tattoo Liner | MSRP $20

    Too Faced | Rich & Dazzling Lip Gloss | MSRP $21

    Rituals | Ritual of Sakura Shower Gel | MSRP $9.50

    Total MSRP value: $456.50

    I had intended to purchase the Rituals shower gel, Too Faced lip gloss and Ciaté highlighter if I didn’t receive them in my box, so I was beyond thrilled to see them!

    All in all, I couldn’t have put together a better Christmas present for myself if I’d tried. I hope everyone else gets their holiday wishes in their boxes, and I wish you all the blessings of the holiday season!

  3. I did get my box yesterday I never get what I want Well must say I got everything i will use List- Little Briar Rose Palette, Saturday Skin Glacier, Ciate confetti Highlighter, Fresh Soy cleanser, Too Faced Melted, Inn Beauty Setting Mist, M.Greengrass, QMS,Daily concept Hair Towel I do not go by the MSRP I always think what would i spend on that item if I had to! $180 I would pay I am very happy

  4. My box is 4lbs and supposed to arrive today. I don’t have a clue what the face rollers do but I hope I get the other thing.

  5. wow, this looks like a cheap box. I’ve received several boxyluxes before and they were worth it. This is not. Glad i am not getting this!

    • Once I saw the spoilers I immediately skipped my box! These items are so similar to what I receive in my monthly box. Very disappointing

  6. Hi! Anybody got a box that’s 3.3 LB and can provide a list of what they received? Or what they chose? Thanks!

  7. I still haven’t received my boxyluxe, I got my premium box yesterday and I got the kat von d eyeliner and the ciate confetti highlighter so I hope I don’t get that on the boxyluxe

  8. I got rituals body wash, power up makeup setting spray, Fresh facial cleanser, cosmetic facial massager, ciate confetti higher, too faced melted terrible brown lipstick, Saturday skin facial cream, kvd eye liner, and story book cometics. All in all price wise the box is worth the money. I am unhappy about the lipstick that they keep sending me. I expressed numerous times in the quizzes that I want pink or red lip colors and they keep sending me ugly browns and concealer pales.

    • Sounds like we got the same box. My lipstick looked pretty in the tube. It looked mauve. It’s called “Suck It”. I swatched it on my hand and the color turned a very dark brownish red. I have very fair skin. 🙄 I also received the highlighter, which is a tan color. The power up spray has witch hazel in it, so be aware.

  9. I’m guessing I’m one of the few that is really excited for this box.

    • I’m very excited to receive my box! It was supposed to be delivered today but we had a sub and now I have to wait until tomorrow 🙁 I’m hoping that I receive the items that I chose. All the boxes I’ve seen unboxed are 3.8 lbs and contain the Elemis oil. My box is showing 3.8 lbs and I chose the Saturday Skin 🤞

    • This was the best box yet! I love everything!

  10. I am super disappointed in this boxyluxe ESPECIALLY considering it’s Christmas time. Perhaps my expectations were just too high but it seriously feels like they threw this together in a hurry and put no real thought into at all. There were no big brand products that are hot on the market and everyone is dying to try right now…it was all just random items. For what boxyluxe costs, it definitely wasn’t worth it at all this time. I’ll give it one more chance but if the next box is as thoughtless and lame, I’m going back to my normal boxycharm subscription and dropping the luxe. I’ve been wanting to try some different monthly beauty box brands anyway.

    • I feel like this is a very luxurious box! The storybook palette is exciting to me, and not something I would ever spend $55 on; likewise for the $79 elemis facial oil. All the other spoilers are things that I would be happy to use, so I am anxiously awaiting my tracking email!!

      • But where were the lifestyle items? I miss those even if some of them were kind of lame.

  11. I havent seen a really good Boxy Luxe since March of 2019…. I feel like all the sub companies are losing there sparkle. Ipsy kept sending my friends and I products that in reality were way to out of budget (like 111skin… um 110 for eye cream in an 11oz bottle… noooo). Now Boxy still gives me the ulta/Macy priced items and I loves them for it I can always rebuy an item if I love it, sadly… I cant really “Love” anything they have been sending, I always end up with the crap variation box or luxe box since June… that’s 6 months of things I dont like… not one. Maybe time to unsub till they get there glitter back… if.

  12. I think this is proof that we all like different things and it can be difficult to please everyone. This is actually the most excited I’ve EVER been for boxyluxe- I love every single item and will use them all. I’ve canceled most of my ipsy subscriptions, and haven’t been blown away by the regular boxy or the previous boxyluxe in a while now. So excited for this box, I know others aren’t, but it’s perfect for me

    • Agreed! I love this BoxyLuxe. All of the products I see myself using. I super excited about the premium box as well. Both my boxes will be here tomorrow and I can’t wait to see which variation I get and can honestly say for the first time that I don’t mind which one I get because as long as I get my choice items (which I always have this far) the rest of the variations are great! I originally signed up for Ipsy Ultimate in October, I MADE them give me Ultimate for free in November which I ended up receiving BOTH serums (Murad lightening serum and juice beauty stem cellular serum) which made the boxes worth it to me, then I cancelled ALL my Ipsy subs because boxy came out with premium and though I can honestly say I wasn’t THRILLED with the first month of premium, this month has made a TOTAL comeback so I’m happy with my decision to go full force boxy (all 3 boxes) and quit Ipsy entirely. At least with boxy 95% of the items and brands I know and love, with Ipsy there’s always no name brands, off the wall products that don’t live up to their advertised value and dinky products they like to claim as full size but simply aren’t. As far as the QMS everyone likes to throw shade on, I freaking LOVE the eye cream that came in the premium last month and though I chose the facial roller this month for luxe, I can Bet that the lip line corrector will be equally as awesome. I probably would have chose it but I literally don’t own a facial roller (pathetic I know) and the cosmedix one is very similar to the nurse Jamie roller so I ended up going with that. I just can’t WAIT to get both my boxes tomorrow because I’m currently going through a prescription retinol overhaul on my face and could REALLY use the skinfix balm, glow recipe moisturizer (one of the best I’ve ever used hands down) and Elemis rose oil. Sorry for such a long response, just hella excited! I hope everyone enjoys SOMETHING from their boxys and quits complaining so much.

  13. I used to do ipsy but they just have disappointed me lately. I cancelled my ultimate subscription and I am so glad I did. I am still pretty new to all this but boxy has never let me down. Even when the brush set never came they were prompt in getting it out. I really enjoy boxy and I am always happy in the selection that they offer.

  14. Exactly!

  15. I just canceled. I order this box for makeup not skincare, I have skincare I LOVE and my skin is so sensitive I can’t really use it. I don’t need another eyeshadow pallet, I have fifteen in a drawer and I didn’t even open the celestial thunder one. And seriously another black eyeliner! Glad I saved my money. I’d use the hair towel but can probably buy one cheaper than a boxycharm.

  16. Pretty heated at the lack luster of the boxes lately. How did you go from extremely desired and pricey products to a 15.00$ face roller and hair towel box?? I’ll be cancelling my account after this month, and wasting 5500 charms bc hey… y’all never have anything in the charm room anyway 😔

  17. Thought that December would be a better box at least end the year with a bang ya know? Not sure how I’m feeling about this now.

  18. I knew that the original spoilers were too good to be true! It’s so frustrating. I’m guessing that we either get the dry shampoo or the “beach spray”, which is EXACTLY what we need during single temp weather and snow storms. 🙄 Did they forget that it’s cold outside? I can find cheap hair towels for $5 at Marshall’s any day (this one is around $15). I also saw a facial mist/setting spray that has witch hazel in it. I don’t know about you, but I don’t think the “Power Up” spray is for me.

    For the last year, we have received styling products that were worth $75+. This box doesn’t have anything like that. It has a lip cream for wrinkles by an unheard of brand, that is worth an outrageous price, yet has zero reviews. The other choice is a facial roller, which is worth about $15. The next option is a new facial oil by Elemis, which is worth twice as much as the other product offered by Saturday Skin.

    I have the feeling that the box worth over $300 will contain the QMS lip product and the Elemis oil. My other guess is that they’ll attempt to claim that the facial roller is worth some ridiculous amount, likely over $50. 🤯

    • Yep. No way will I ever patronize Boxycharm again. I’m just on these Boxy posts to see the mayhem from all the variations, lol!

    • I think they have the roller priced at $69 😂

    • Or you get both the dry shampoo AND the beach spray…and I got three different skin care products. I signed up for this for the makeup…Also the story book cosmetics eye shadow colors are nice, but is a bulky, cheap waste of space package is makes me want to toss it.

  19. OMG, how am I still on the waitlist for premium? I signed up within 2 hours of the post here and even emailed them asking last month. Ugh.

    • Don’t email them. That puts you on the bottom of the list >.<

  20. This box looks amazing. The only product I wont likely use is the beach spray. That black eyeliner is amazing, I know people hate getting them buy it is the perfect eyeliner. Plus amazing face products. I know a lot of you complain not enough make-up but skin care keeps you looking young. I am in my 40s and look like I am I my 20s. It is thanks to using great skin care products. Use them protect your skin it’s a long term investment. This box is so amazing!!!

    • Amen! I will NEVER complain about receiving prestige skincare products.

      • Yes! And if you have too much in your stash use it on your neck and chest and please don’t forget the backs of your hands!

      • Totally agree. Because the cost for products is so low, I use them everywhere as I don’t feel I have to ration out three drops or a small dollop.

        This is especially true if I don’t love a product for my face 🙂

      • And feet!

  21. OBSESSED with that Briar Rose makeup palette!!!!

  22. I think it looks great except… they just couldn’t freaking resist putting in yet another black liquid eyeliner 🙀

    • I know! Soooo tired of them. I’m considering taking up calligraphy so I can use them all.
      It could be worse. At least it’s not from Eyeko!

      I‘d love to get that pink lip gloss (on the left) which is exactly why I won’t get it. Or the dry shampoo as it’s the ONLY one in the world that works on my hair, the hair towel or even the dry body oil.
      Honestly I’m pretty happy with almost all of these variants except the eyeliner and highlighter. I have enough of those to sparkle up every dance team and cheerleading squad in my entire state.

      Of course, I also worry about some unreleased junk products showing up in our boxes. That seems to be the norm now, although it’s been much worse with the regular/base box. No matter what I find in my box the three skincare items I know I’ll get make it more than worth the $50 for me. Which is way more than I can say for that pile of 💩 I wasted $50 on from Ipsy Ultimate this month. Talk about a pathetic group of products. 🤬

      • Danielle. You are very funny. Thank you.😂

      • I am with you on wanting that dry shampoo. Isn’t it the best? It even works on my daughter’s super straight, fine hair. My box won’t arrive until Tuesday 12/17 and it’s killing me not to know what I’m getting. I didn’t get to customize. I had to laugh at your Ipsy Ultimate comment. I did the first month they launched just to see and was as underwhelmed as everyone else. I did like the hydrating serum I got but everything else I received is totally forgettable. As in, I actually forget what I got it was so meh. Fingers crossed Luxe does us both right!

  23. As with most BC boxes they have some amazing products. But also way too many variations. Every time I cave in and resub I end up with a not so great box. None or just one of the really nice products that sucked me into subbing. And a lot of their not so great things are so bad that I wouldn’t/couldn’t give them away. I always end up feeling like I got cheated or the short end of the stick with boxy. Sometimes their sign up bonus is worth taking the chance. But not often. Even those are sometimes this or that and not worth the risk for me.

    • This is what stops me from signing up with Boxy. They should at least be upfront about it, instead of acting like the spoilers will be in everyone’s box in some variation when they aren’t. I really like the Premium, but I want to see if people actually receive what’s in the spoilers, or if a bunch random crap starts showing up in that tier too. I wouldn’t hesitate to subscribe to Boxycharm based on their advertising and that’s really the problem, considering you don’t generally get exactly what they advertise. One of these days the word of mouth will catch up with them…I know not to touch this box with a 10 foot pole and I’ve never even been a customer. It’s really, really disappointing too, I can’t tell you how many times I had to stop and remind myself that even if I sign up, I probably won’t get the items I’m interested in. My rule of thumb with BC is, if there is something in one of their boxes I can’t live without, I save myself the frustration and pick it up next time it’s on sale. I did that with the Dose of Color palettes, just bought the ones I wanted.💁

      • Yep. Don’t ever sub to Boxy. I’m speaking from burned experience. I hung on until I received all the products they were supposed to send to me. I still haven’t gotten the Dose palette that was promised to me in my October box. I’ll never get that. So, I have to be content to get what they offered as a consolation for not sending my promo gift for that month, and my choice that they DIDN’T send to me in the November box. I just got it yesterday. I cancelled my subs just as soon as I got the tracking number on my Kypris. Just under the wire to avoid being billed for December. Boxy will NEVER see a cent of my money again.

      • They shipped my November box on 11/3. They emailed me on 11/7 to let me know that they “forgot” to include my choice item, which was the Kypris serum. My box arrived on 11/9. I have emailed them back and forth 4 times, as recent as last week regarding my missing item. Two of the reps told me that I’ll receive it 5-10 days after I receive tracking info. 🙄 The third person told me that she’ll pass my “complaint” along to the team, but offered no info as to where my item is or when to expect it. The 4th person stated that they had to hire extra help for the “back orders” and that they’re working 24/7 on it. That person STILL didn’t offer a time frame as to when I can expect my item. At this point, I think it’s safe to say IF I can expect my item.

        There was also an issue with my October box. They let me select a second item for November. I selected the DOC lipstick. In their email they stated TWICE that the lip color would match my beauty quiz, which is set to pink. I was excited to receive the pink color. Instead, I received bright red. I emailed them about it and sent them the original email, where they told me it would match my profile. The rep wasn’t exactly friendly. I was told that it takes months to “customize” products for us and the lip color wasn’t one of those items. Basically, I was told “Oh, well”.

        Their customer service has always been slow, but it has been horrendous lately.

      • I had the exact same problems you just stated. This company is a joke and could care less about the customers. I haven’t cancelled yet, because unfortunately my December amt. was drawn. Will wait until I get the tracking number and cancel.

      • I had the exact same issue you that you mentioned Alice R, but I have yet to receive the Becca highlighter (for the October screw up). So no Dose palette or Becca highlighter. Unfortunately, my December payment has already come out, as soon as I get shipping confirmation, I’m going to cancel as well. I’m sure I’ll get a box of left over crap as I did in October and November as well. I feel totally scammed:( Boxy Charm may have the worst customer service I’ve ever experienced.

      • That’s interesting! I’ve been with them going on 5 years. They didn’t send me my choice item in November, which was Kypris. They knew that it wasn’t there when they shipped the box. They emailed me before my box arrived (11/7) to let me know that it was missing. I’ve emailed them 4 times about the Kypris and they won’t tell me when I’ll be receiving it. I ordered from the PopUp and I received that very quickly, but I can’t get the product that they owe me! They charged me for my Luxe and it’s scheduled to be here tomorrow, yet my November item is still missing.

        If they think I’ll just “forget”, they’re crazy.

  24. I feel like it’s better than ipsy ultimate but I’m so happy I stuck to boxy and boxy premium and didn’t upgrade to luxe.

  25. I hope the hair turban is in all boxes. We use the heck out of these in my house!

    • No it wasn’t in mine. I got a Rituals shower gel.

  26. Everything in the box I’ll 100% use, so I’m pretty happy with what we’re getting!

  27. I was going to cancel luxe and just stick with the base box, but 1st I was going to skip my Ipsy accounts, yes accounts plural. I go on to my Ipsy account at 7am on Friday and I had already been charged for 1 reg, 2 gbp, and 1 ultimate. So as I’m freaking out and trying to deal with that I figure I’ll get to Boxy. At 12:01, no joke I get a congratulatory email from premium letting me know I was off the waitlist. I completely forgot about premium and all I wanted from boxy was the oil. Oh my lord, I don’t want an 8th of any of the items I’m getting this month.

    • Congrats on getting off the waitlist! I know, so much product this month, I’m getting boxyluxe, boxy premium and glam bag plus. I need to cancel boxyluxe, it’s just too much.

  28. I am glad that I canceled Luxe. It just doesn’t feel Luxe to me. I wish I hadn’t purchased an annual subscription as the regular box doesn’t thrill me this month either.

  29. Charm Room alert!! Just redeemed some of my charms on a Colourpop The Zodiac Pressed Powder Shadow Palette!!! So freakin excited! 🙂

    • I clicked on the Colourpop Palette and boom it was sold out! Oh well I did get the Dose of Colors lippie ; it looks like a nice shade.

      • That is an absolutely beautiful color! 👍🙌

  30. Meh. I still get my money’s worth. But some of these product options….makes it easy for me to unsubscribe. I’ve been on the fence and knowing I need to save money. I think this will help me with my financial goals of 2020

  31. I cancled boxyluxe on November 30th, because I had a feeling there wouldnt be a “wow” item for me. The too faced lipgloss would be nice, and the elemis oil as well but that may come in my regular boxy. Its December! It should be a bit more festive. Glad I canceled the luxe.

    • I did, too. I canceled regular as well. I can’t wait to see all the variations.

    • I did too. The only thing I really wanted was the face wash and dry shampoo. I got the shampoo on a discount from Sephora 🤷‍♀️

      • Michelle, that’s what I’m doing…buying exactly what I want and shopping the discounts/sales. I haven’t been subscribing as long as most (and I don’t have that many subs), and I already have way-too-much. I don’t want all this product expiring. I’ve given away a lot and am gifting a lot, and I STILL have more than I can use. And…I use my skin care liberally! I see so many people with all these multiple accounts and I can’t imagine what they’re doing with all that stuff! I would rather contribute to my IRA!

    • I canceled on the 30th as well. All 3 boxes. They cant get pop up to work right. They cant even get you your redeemed charms sent out to you and have to give you back your charms. It’s ridiculous. I’ve been a very loyal customer since 2016. They took on way more than they can chew. Many ppl cancelled. Only thing I would have wanted was the Saturday skin. But I still have elmis moisturizer and confidence in a cream I have yet to touch. I have so much. Hard for me to sell. In fb groups bc everyone selling same or already have. So I stuck with ao much. Like many palettes ect. Glad to not have to give them anymore money. Especially luxe bc it’s the worse luxe box since they had it.

      • Try the Reddit groups makeupexchange and BBExchange. Lots of people swap and sell beauty box items on there!

  32. Honestly, for a December Boxyluxe, idk how I’m feeling about it🤔

    • We shall see when it arrives though…

      • Mine came missing two items one was the dry oil spray or whatever it was and an item called faking it but I can’t seem to figure out what that is do you know what it is they said they get right on it with the companies to get me a the item sent out to me I told him if I didn’t hear anything in the next month I expect it items of at least equal value in your place but like I said you know what item they’re talking about when they said one of the items I was missing was caught Faking It

    • Feeling the same they have done MUCH better in the past, not feeling this box that much.

    • I totally agree with you I figured it would be grand for the holidays but as everyone is saying we shall see🙄

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.