Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Use this link and coupon code JOLLYCHARM to get the Too Faced Just Peachy Eye Shadow Palette with your first box!
Valid for new subscribers only, or those who canceled before November 1, 2019. Must use coupon code at checkout. Valid while the box and gift supplies last.
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
I Soooo Want that Too Faced Diamond Highlight!!!! Been wanting it foreverrr and it would be worth the cost of the box right there!! This will be My 2nd month 🐞
Reply
Lauren
Same exact thing happened to me. Its been so frustrating
Reply
Dot
I need to go to the container store to hold all my products .. it’s insane , but I can’t stand things not being in a easy accessible place . I too cut back to pay off credit cards – it is hard , but I do want to pay things off before I buy new stuff
Reply
Emily e Hawes
I have been wanting to try this brand. super excited ! I just hope its in all the boxes, I guess you never really know until you get your box. 🙂
Reply
Dianne
I’m broke. I miss Boxycharm. I bought a vanity desk It takes up my budget for next month’s allowance. I only allow myself 50 a month. The desk was only 50. I also paused my Ipsy bag. I’ve got to put a sofa on layaway also. So my allowance it spent for 7 month’s. Why is this so tempting. 😭
Reply
Jess
As pretty as makeup is nothing beats a good couch. I heard that there is a Boxycharm FB where people swap and sell. I’m not on FB so I havent seen it. Checkout maybe someone will one for dirt cheap…..???
Reply
cc
Hold strong, girl! You’re doing great
Reply
Ruth
I love boxycharm to. I have not received my boxes to. It said the same thing that they delivered it . but have not received anything and I was so excited to get the products but now I’m so sad I have not received anything😔😢
Reply
Anna
If this is on my boxycharm it is going to be a party. Hourglass is so expensive and I have not gotten my hands on any of their products yet, so I hope we get to try it!
Reply
Svetlana7e
I love the spoiler, but I just canceled my regular box and left with Premium. I wish they would add this blush to Premium as well.
Reply
Amie
Hourglass would be awesome except that only like 5 influencers will actually receive it and the rest of us will get crap.
Reply
Reidy
I’ll probably get a bogus Starlooks eye pencil and a BTS mascara…. you know- for the 1,350 time.
Reply
Alyssa balmas
Exactly
Reply
Crystal
Exactly!
Reply
Beccah
I really wish you could get boxyluxe and the premium without having to get the regular box. I like the premium box better than the base box but still want get luxe too!
Reply
Marcie
I agree! I would do that too.
Reply
Kimberly
One thing you can do is only sign up for the luxe box during the luxe month. This was a workaround that Joe (Boxy CEO) suggested. The issue I see with that is that I do not know if you would then make it in time for the choice window.
Reply
Dani
This is what I am going to try but I am not very confident it will work. I’m actually surprised Yosef suggested it considering that there is always a waitlist for Boxyluxe. Every time I have ever unsubscribed and come back it’s taken me at least 2 months to get off the waitlist which means I wasn’t able to get the current luxe box even when I resubbed the month before (and therefore purchased two regular boxes and still didn’t get Luxe.) There’s a huge chance you’ll end up paying for the regular box for no reason because you won’t make it off the waitlist. I’m going to try anyway because I just don’t need the base and Premium boxes every month. Well I don’t “need” either in truth but I just can’t keep spending so much money on beauty subs/products when I already have so much.
I wish I could keep both mainly because I do feel like you get a better Premium box when you have both simply because they can’t send you duplicates so you wind up with the more popular items in Premium because they’re already sending you the less appealing products in your base box. I guess I’ll find out soon since I’m about to cancel my regular/base box. This is painful…😄
dcmiess
Ugh I have more than enough blush to last a lifetime right now
Reply
Chelsea
I feel like we hardly got any spoilers for January! Now we’re already on to a possible February spoiler.
Reply
Laurie R
I already have it 😞
Reply
Kimberly
This was an “accidental” spoiler given by Joe (Boxy CEO) during an instagram story in which he described how the box gets curated and why they are able to offer the full-sized products at such a steep discount. It was off schedule.
Reply
joannej_1974
Yup! It was a response to rumours Boxycharm has brands do cheaper formulations of their items for the box. The CIATE Blush we received this month had different ingredients and contained talc, which is something the company advertised they DIDN’T use. It was also made in China instead of Italy. Joe said CIATE reformulated the blush 9 months ago, changed manufacturers and forgot to update their website.
Amanda
Exactly my thought!! I even went back to the archive to make sure i didnt miss anything!
Reply
Michelle
Is this for sure in the base box? It wasn’t confirmed on IG if it was for base or premium…
Reply
Jen
Agree, Suzan who does Boxysneakpeek just said a Feb Boxycharm spoiler and hasn’t mentioned which one which she usually is super transparent about, so I don’t think it’s been confirmed yet. I’ve noticed that MSA tends to assume things about Boxy spoilers that are taken from other sites which turn out not to be 100% accurate.
Reply
Michelle
Yeah that’s where MSA got this spoiler, but nowhere does it say it’s confirmed for base box, so wondering where MSA got that part from cuz Suzan never confirmed which box it’ll be in.
Stephanie W
Hmmm….its pretty but extremely similar looking to the ciate blush that some of us just got. I wish they would put more space in between similar products and that there is an option to skip. I’m trying to get the Premium box and don’t want to lose my spot on the waitlist. Guess I’ll wait until more spoilers come out to see what may be best.
Reply
Shari
The Ciate blush is a dupe for Hourglass but not near as good. Hourglass blush has been my holy grail for a long time. Their Bronzers, blushes, highlighters and finishing powders literally can not be beaten. The Ciate is good but trust, Hourglass is special
Reply
Marion
The first thing I thought was that it looks just like the Ciate Blush, too !
Reply
dcmiess
exactly how I feel
Reply
Christa H.
I love Boxycharm, but I never received my Boxyluxe. I checked my “OnTrac” tracking # on 12/24 and it said delayed delivery, then checked the tracking again yesterday 12/25 and it says it was delivered on 12/22! Makes no sense. I’m devastated 😢😔 Why can’t they just use FedEx for all shipping??? Oh, and finally got an email regarding my Premium box and that delivery date was 12/28 and is now supposedly set for 01/02/2020…. The February box looks amazing. I pray delivery goes back to normal again…
Reply
Christa H.
OnTrac is investigating where the heck my Boxyluxe went. I should know by Monday 12/30. If they can’t help me, I’m emailing Boxycharm again. I would like what I paid for… None of my neighbors have seen it😳👀😢
Reply
Christa H.
*Update* OnTrac is giving me the runaround. They have yet to tell me where the heck my box was delivered. They keep telling me that they will call me…I wait…they never call to update. So I call them on a daily. They can’t seem to get ahold of the employee whom “delivered” my box to question him. I have emailed Boxycharm on my December Boxyluxe to see if I can get a replacement box. 🙏🤞🤞🙏
DeeDee McGee
I received my luxe box but somehow premium went to a non existing address not once but twice I don’t see how this is possible but upon reading different posts I think they charged everyone and ran out because they told me they ran out of premium products so I won’t receive December premium box.Other people got coupons product but not me I didn’t receive nothing.
Reply
Jess
I would prefer a bronzer from Hourglass. I dont think I have ever received a bronzer from #boxycharm
I can honestly say that I do not want that highlighter from Too Faced
Ruth
I love boxycharm to. I have not received my boxes to. It said the same thing that they delivered it . but have not received anything and I was so excited to get the products but now I’m so sad I have not received anything😔😢
Reply
Susie
Email customer service. I had a box not delivered last year, and they replaced it. Their terms of service states they will do that once a year. It took 6 weeks till I received it, but I did receive the replacement.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.