MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyCharm April 2021 Full Spoilers

BoxyCharm December 2019 FULL SPOILERS + Coupon!

BoxyCharm November 2019 beauty and makeup subscription box review

We have full spoilers for one variation of the December 2019 BoxyCharm base box! ($25 a month.)

Here’s one version of the December box:

What do you think of the spoilers?

If you haven’t signed up yet:

Use this link and coupon code JOLLYCHARM to get this tarte palette free with your first box!

Valid for new subscribers only, or those who canceled before November 1st, 2019. Must use coupon code at checkout. Valid while December’s box and Tarte gift supplies last. December’s box with new subscriber gift value shown. Box contents vary. Sample of items featured in past boxes or in current boxes shown. Promotion valid while December’s box and gift supplies last. You will be charged $25 plus applicable taxes and shipping. Free shipping to continuous US only. No refunds or exchanges. Monthly subscriptions will automatically renew each month. Prepaid subscriptions will automatically renew in the first month of the next subscription period. Cancel at any time by logging in and editing your “Subscriptions” in “Account Preferences” under “My Account” on

Boxycharm is $25 a month. Check out our reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in BoxyCharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 42 comments

Comments (42)

  1. I received this exact box! The rose face oil is so heavenly. This is one of my absolute favorite curations. No plans to upgrade here. I also get Ipsy glam bag and Allure. I love all of my subcriptions so much. Sometimes I get items that don’t suit me. I simply give them to friends that appreciate it! I work very hard and my subs are my gifts to myself.

  2. If I sub today, will I get to make a choice, or is that closed?

  3. I recieved this exact box just this morning and I LOVE it. I’ll be gifting the storybook pallet but I’ll be using everything else. Solid, awesome box.

  4. I absolutely LOVE this box. Got exactly what I wanted and the quality is superb. The blush is perfect, the brow bar is classy, but the Elemis is so lush, and was $75 retail. I love the storybook palette and will use every shade. I’ve only been disappointed once getting a florescent orange lip matte. Other than that I haven’t been let down once. So many complaints, gosh get in the car and go to Ulta and pick out your own stuff if you don’t like what you’re getting at such an amazing price. You won’t walk out of the store with well over $125 product for $30. Be grateful for Heaven’s sake.

  5. I got both my premium and luxe boxes today and I am so disappointed. They sent me the big Storybook palette in each box. That was a major item and I can’t use two so I feel like I wasted my money. Plus I wanted the Ciate blush so bad and I got the highlighter which I won’t use and then they also sent me the highlighter trio. That’s too much highlighter. I would have loved the brow stuff. I’m going to email them and complain about the eye shadow palettes but they’ll probably just give me charms which I don’t want because there hasn’t been anything in the charm room I’ve wanted in ages. Sometimes I think it would be better to cancel the subscriptions and if they have anything I want just get it on ebay. I’ve been thinking about selling on Mercari. Right now might be a good time to start. Rant over. Thanks for listening.

    • I also got the duplicate Storybook, which is automatically in the Luxe box, in my premium box instead of the ND Cranberry or DC Hidden Treasures.

    • I received an email today regarding this!
      It has been brought to our attention that you received a Storybook Cosmetics Fairy Tales – Little Briar Rose Palette in your BoxyLuxe and BoxyCharm Premium. We are so sorry and are making it right!
      I hadn’t had a chance to email them yet. I have to say, that is definitely an improvement and good customer service!
      Thanks BoxyCharm!!!!!

  6. My December box is on the way. I planned to quit for a while anyway since I soon got way more products than I needed with the subscription boxes. However, I am not sure if I’ll ever sign up for BoxyCharm again.

    I bought a three month subscription and only got to pick an item the second month. I may have signed up too late for it the first month, not sure, but this month I was not notified of the choice window. That’s one strike.

    The other strike is that one of the main items each of the three months was/is an eyeshadow palette with crazy colors that I would only wear if I joined the circus.

    I much prefer FabFitFun and BirchBox, where you get far more choices.

  7. There is a review by BoxyCharm for this box. It says you will get the Brow Bar or an IBY Beauty Matte liquid lipstick duo. I really hope I get the Brow Bar product. My box shipped a couple days ago and it should be here on Monday

  8. If I get the box shown here I will be 100% happy.

  9. Any way to see what variation we get before it actually gets to us? I thought I read somewhere that once it ships you can see the items but I haven’t been able to.

  10. So happy I’m getting luxe this month instead of regular 🙂

  11. I as well have cancelled due to the fact of feeling the same palettes piling up and lots of face products i still have yet to use, wish you had the ability to customize more your box, plus dont even wear colors or face or blush makeup therefore I agree with others just save my money till something WOWs me enough to feel like okay the Boxes are worth it. I loved it when i was getting a lot of Tarte , Dose products now its just a lot of brands or items i really have no use for .

  12. Wow, I’m so tempted to resub, even though I know I would inevitably receive something totally different than what’s pictured.

    • I am tempted to make a new account because I selected the glacier moisturizer but now also want the Elemis. If I got double of the moisturizer, I wouldn’t mind but it would defeat the whole purpose. Plus, if I got the same palette twice I’d be bummed. So far I’ve been happy with each box, of course there’s always one item you don’t care for but I use it anyways and sometimes realise I love it.

  13. Looks like a decent box but I’m still feeling good about my decision to cancel before December billing. My makeup and skincare stash is so large it’s a little embarrassing, actually, and I’d rather spend on my family this month. I’m taking a break until something really wows me.

  14. Agree with the comments about cancelling and now maybe regretting it. I wish they had released spoilers before December 1. I do not need or want another eyeshadow palette as they have sent one every single month. They only had that and the choice spoiler before December 1 so I cancelled. Not going to resubscribe though, even though I would have stayed subscribed if I’d seen this, bc now there is no guarantee of what I would get. Love the brow bar but I would need the light one and love the blush and lip exfoliator. Oh well.

  15. This is honestly a pretty nice box. I cancelled mine too and would have like the Elemis oil and lip thing, but I hate the palette, do not need the eyebrow thing and do not need another blush. I do have my premium but they have very little spoilers for it and I fear for the worst!

  16. I would LOVE to get the Ciate blush!!

  17. Very nice! I just signed up for boxy a few days ago with the code for the free Tarte palette and an overnight mask. Can’t wait to get November! Then December lol I’m so pumped for the story book palettes!

    • Hey there,

      DId you get your 2-piece? Cause i didn’t. only Nov box.

  18. Ooo looks good! Can’t wait

  19. Ugh! I wish they had released more spoilers. I canceled because they didn’t, meaning I lost my choice item (oil)and now it looks like it’s actually a decent box. Well, at least this variation is. If I resubscribe I’ll prob get the Saturday skin (which I like but have literally 20 moisturizers right now), the green pallet and some other odd variations. I also wish they’d release all possible items so we don’t feel so tricked by the ol switch.

    • I canceled, too. Remember, this is only one variation. I’m going to use up what I have. I figured by the time I could get to using the moisturizer, it would be beyond old.

  20. It looks like Storybook cosmetics also has a couple of other Boxycharm collaborations on their webpage. The Cinderella one is larger, but the Robin Hood is the same type/rv with some gorgeous greens and a knockout gold.

    Gorgeous palettes, but don’t really need either. I have so much makeup from subs! I do really like this box, though – would use every item. And a tarte palette bonus!! I’m very tempted.

    • Where is the Cinderella one? I only see the red, green and Briar Rose – would love to see the Cinderella one! What color is the box?

      • It’s Briar Rose, sorry. I hope they do more in the future though, it would be a cute set!

        Disney did some fun makeup sets a while back but the quality wasn’t the greatest. I remember getting some Jasmine eye pencils and loving the colors.

      • They actually have a monthly sub of the smaller sets that are based on books. This last one was Sherlock Holmes and January is Jane Eyre – love them! The Sherlock one came with a little mini magnifying glass that worked and actually had a blending shadow brush on the end – super cute stuff!

      • Briar Rose is Sleeping Beauty 😊😉.

      • Anyones box weigh 1.2 lbs with a 3 by 3 by 2 dimensions? I didn’t get my preview email.

  21. I wouldn’t say these are full spoilers. I don’t remember the last time that Boxy didn’t throw in like 10+ random filler items and not have about 30 variations, while promoting that people would get boxes like pictured…which is exactly why I cancelled.

    • Exactly! They try to make people think everyone will get the better items. This is the shadiest sub.

    • I meant to cancel before December 1st but got so busy over Thanksgiving weekend that I forgot. Wish I had, this box doesn’t interest me at all. I’ll keep the Elemis oil and the lip exfoliant but probably give away the rest. I am definitely cancelling now!

  22. I’m so glad I cancelled. Boxycharm should have released some variation of full spoilers long before December 1. There were only two given to MSA by November 13 – the first was the mini palette, then the choice spoiler. After that, nothing.

  23. Awesome box !! Happy with it all 🥰 glad I cancelled boxy luxe – bought stuff I wanted at Ulta today.

  24. I resubbed by I’m wondering if this is the best variation and I’ll get something else.

    • Was wondering the same, as they usually end up with 20 variations.

    • Rest assured, there will be PLENTY ofvariations, lol.

  25. Awesome box. I would use everything but the brow stuff and just because I just got my brows microbladed again.

  26. Well, color me impressed! This is a solid box! This variation is awesome! Skipped Ipsy Plus for this. Looks to be the right decision for me!

    • I did the same thing SunnyT. I’m happy with these spoilers and that I skipped IGBP 😃.

  27. I would love this box.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.