MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

FabFitFun Winter 2019 Box FULL SPOILERS!

We now have the FULL SPOILERS for the FabFitFun Winter box thanks to FabFitFun’s unboxing by FabFitFun Editor in Chief, Katie Echevarria Rosen Kitchens!

Previously, we had 7 of the 8 items in the box revealed, and now we have the 8th item confirmed. This last item is a surprise item. FabFitFun will send you either NailsInc Thirsty Hand Mask OR Cuccio Somatology CALM + CLEAN Epsom Salt Hand and Body Wash:

If you haven’t signed up for FabFitFun yet, use coupon code MSA to save $10 off your first box! (Regularly $49.99 a season).

And in case you missed it, here are all the other spoilers for the box:

FYI – Quarterly subscribers will be able to pick their items on November 15th.

Choice 1: Pick Kate Somerville® Goat Milk Moisturizing Cream, UnHide Lil’ Marshmallow, Jonathan Adler Fleur De Sel Ceramic Candle, Rebecca Minkoff Marled Beanie & Armwarmer Set, or R+Co TELEVISION Perfect Hair Shampoo + Conditioner.

Here’s a closer look at each item:

Kate Somerville® Goat Milk Moisturizing Cream ($65 value)

UnHide Lil’ Marshmallow ($65 value)

  • 50” x 60
  • faux fur

Jonathan Adler Fleur De Sel Ceramic Candle ($48 value)

  • Satin finish stoneware with a removable lid
  • Notes of an aquatic breeze, marine salt, orange blossom, mimosa, and driftwood
  • 50% soy wax, 30% palm wax, 20% paraffin for a cleaner burn
  • Comes packaged in a gift box

Rebecca Minkoff Marled Beanie & Armwarmer Set ($70 value)

R+Co TELEVISION Perfect Hair Shampoo + Conditioner ($64 value)

Choice 2: Pick PJ Salvage Faux Fur Trim Cable Slippers S/M & M/L, Erno Laszlo Pore Cleansing Clay Mask, Bluetooth® Shower Speaker, OR Lashes M.D. Eyelash Conditioner

Here’s a closer look at each item:

PJ Salvage Faux Fur Trim Cable Slippers S/M & M/L

Erno Laszlo Pore Cleansing Clay Mask Bluetooth® Shower Speaker

Lashes M.D. Eyelash Conditioner

Choice 3: Pick Karuna Face For All Face & Eye Mask Set, Battington Lashes Monroe 3D Silk Lashes and Glue Kit, Adore by Swarovski Organic Circle Bracelet, OR Rodial Beauty Soft Focus Glow Drops.

Here’s a closer look at each item:

Karuna Face For All Face & Eye Mask Set

Battington Lashes Monroe 3D Silk Lashes and Glue Kit

Adore by Swarovski Organic Circle Bracelet

Rodial Beauty Soft Focus Glow Drops.

UPDATE: Choice 4 and Choice 5 are options for annual (Select) subscribers only. If you are a seasonal subscriber, FabFitFun will pick for you.

Choice 4: Pick Beauty Bakerie Proof is in the Puddin’ Palette, LXMI Pure Nilotica Melt 1.7 oz, Paper Source 12 Month Rose Floral Planner, OR Vooray Sidekick Crossbody Bag

Here’s a closer look at each item:

Beauty Bakerie Proof is in the Puddin’ Palette – Retail Value $38

  • 4 matte and 5 shimmer shades
  • Cruelty- and paraben-free

LXMI Pure Nilotica Melt 1.7 oz – Retail Value $28

  • 100% organic vitellaria nilotica fruit butter
  • Can use as an overnight mask or throughout the day
  • Made in USA

Paper Source 12 Month Rose Floral Planner – Retail Value $27.95

Vooray Sidekick Crossbody Bag – Retail Value $17.99

  • Features reinforced stitching, made with weather-resistant neoprene
  • Easily carries keys, phone, wallet, and other items

Choice 5: Pick Vera Mona Color Switch Solo, Frank Body 200g Original Coffee Scrub, OR AHAVA Salt Bag – 11 oz

Here’s a closer look at each item:

Vera Mona Color Switch Solo

Frank Body 200g Original Coffee Scrub

AHAVA Salt Bag – 11 oz

And here are the two items that will be in every box:

Drybar Prep Rally Prime & Prep Detangler

MakeUp Eraser Makeup Eraser – Original Pink

What do you think of the spoilers? What are you picking?

Seasonal subscribers will get to pick on November 15th at 9 a.m. PT.

If you haven’t signed up for FabFitFun yet, use coupon code MSA to save $10 off your first box!

Check out our FabFitFun reviews to see what you can expect with this quarterly subscription box for women.


How do subscribers rate FabFitFun?

Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about FabFitFun!

Enable notifications () to get the latest FabFitFun spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in FabFitFun, FabFitFun Box Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: fabfitfun | 161 comments

Comments (161)

  1. Any one want to switch the palette for either the color switch or LXMI Mask?

    • Or planner!

    • I want to switch the my LXMI mask for the palette.

  2. Did anyone else forget to customize and get their box yet? Mine shipped on 11/21 and it’s making me crazy that i forgot to customize. wondering if anyone else made same mistake and what they received?

    • If it shipped, you can reveal your whole box on your online account to see what you’re getting!

    • Yes I did as well. However it’s kind of glich of some kind on their end.

      One email says that I couldn’t customize until Nov. 15. When the day came, it wouldn’t let me customize because it was closed for customize and the add one.

      I’m not happy and I’m hopeful I will get a decent box. Im waiting for its arrival.

      • This is what happened to me as well. I can’t view anything either like I normally can. Apparently it is at my house, but still can’t look and it still says awaiting shipping?

  3. I’m just here to say I loved the blanket so much that I put a full size one on my Christmas list. My husband has pretty much claimed the one I got in my box as his now. It’s the perfect weight and it’s so soft and comfy. I was also so grateful to finally see a makeup palette as an option again. Great job on this one FFF.

  4. I got my box, complete with all of my add-ons ons, a few days ago. I am very happy with my selections, especially the blanket, which is just perfect IMO. It is so soft and cozy and just the right weight. I didn’t think I would really like the slippers, but I always need slippers as I go through them quickly, and they are so warm and cozy that I am glad I got them. The candle, IMO, is better suited for summer, so I am saving it. I haven’t tried the goat milk moisturizer yet, but look forward to trying it. (I got all of the 1st category options except the beanie and arm warmers). I have really been loving the Korres jasmine shower gel and body butter I got as add ons. Haven’t tried my Spongelle in jasmine and blue iris yet…or the coffee body scrub that came as a selection in the box.

  5. My box just came and I’m thrilled with the blanket (very nice weight) and slippers. This box is kind of hit or miss with me but there is always one or 2 things that are just perfect. Also I got the hand soap and it’s really small. How they came up with a RV of $40 is beyond me but whatever, it’s soap.

  6. Finally! My Winter box has shipped! I know they estimate further out, but this close to Christmas… I must admit I’ve felt like an impatient child waiting for it to ship. #^_^# There is something about being charged on November 7th that made the projected ship date starting Dec. 1st seem far away.

  7. I just got the following email about a mini box with promo code TAKETWO..supposed to be worth 150 dollars.

    BOGO | use promo code: TAKETWO
    Double the Fun | Get the Winter Box plus a free Mini Box
    Customize your Winter Box
    The Winter Box plus…
    the Mini Box!
    Over $350 Value
    BOGO | use promo code: TAKETWO
    Customize Now
    Customize Now
    *You will be charged either $49.99 or $179.99 for your first box (which will be the Winter Box) depending on which subscription you enroll in. Offer valid for new customers purchasing a Seasonal or Annual Subscription. In addition to the Winter Box, you will receive a free Mini Box with mystery products valued at $150+. Cancel anytime. All prices are in USD. Foreign exchange or transaction fees may apply. Price does not include taxes, where applicable. Shipping fees apply to orders shipped to Canada, Puerto Rico, AK, HI, and the United Kingdom. The specific items you receive will depend on product availability and the choices you make when customizing your box. Offer expires on November 24, 2019 at 11:59 p.m. PT. Cannot be combined with other offers. Offer only available while supplies last.

  8. I just checked my box today because I forgot what I chose for my customizations and there’s a 6th customization that I didn’t get to choose. Is it like this for anyone else? I’m not gonna complain if they wanna give me something for free but I just wanna know where this came from.

    • Mine is showing the same thing! I was wondering about that as well.

    • There were only 5 custom choices, then 2 items everyone got (makeup eraser and dry bar prep). The last one was a variant between two products that FFF choose for you : a hand mask or hand wash

    • Every box receiving two free gifts

    • The sixth is a surprise no one gets to customize the 6th

  9. I just reactivated my subscription and it didn’t give me an option to choose items. What does that mean? 😭

    • Go to live chat and see if they cam help you customize. Take screenshots of your choices though and ask if they can send you a confirmation of your choices if they won’t be posting to your online account so you can verify that they did it. Hope that helps.

  10. Wow. Their site is confusing. I have no idea if I am still a subscriber or not.

    • I know the feeling. I went through this for awhile, wondering when it would all be over. Just logged in to check and it says “you have no upcoming boxes”, which means my subscription is over. Personally, I am relieved. I know that some people love the boxes. It is a fun gift to yourself with the odd useful item here or there but I wish I could go back in time and slap myself. $200 a year to have my house filled with crap I don’t need. Still haven’t opened half of it, or else put it up on ebay. You can only go through so much hand cream! Subscription boxes seem to be a great way for companies to ditch overstock and clearance items nowadays. Why is nobody else catching on to this?

      • Exact same way I feel. Although I love receiving the box and going through all the great products, seems real redundant with what I receive from month to month, face masks, face lotions, hand lotions, makeup then trinkets or things I prob will never use. I as well think it is a lot of money as well to just really enjoy a few products. I Keep reactivating this every year for 2 boxes then cancel.

  11. Just got my box and it’s fantastic! The slippers are ugly, but comfy and warm. The blanket it soft, warm, and plenty big. The planner is awesome. I love everything. Thank you, FFF. As for the last item, we all get A LOT of stuff for a little money. Maybe trade the hand mask for the soap, if that’s what you want. I’m sure those that don’t love lavender would like to trade.

    In any case, I loved my box. I hope everyone can find worthwhile items in theirs as well. I didn’t love the Fall box, but those Nassif pads are amazing.

  12. I just picked up the Aldi candle “first snow” and it’s awesome! Love the scent and $4 for a three wick?! Burns just like the expensive ones. Get yourself one! Minty, vanilla deliciousness.

  13. Finally!! It’s back up – just got in and made my picks, hope everyone is able to get their #1s! 🙂

    • I still can’t get in……..

  14. I am genuinely happy for all that have already received their boxes.
    So……. I guess it IS the new warehouse that has it together! Their IT hasn’t fixed a damn thing because the site has been down for 35 minutes already, so we haven’t been able to customize at all yet! I am really losing my patience!!!!!!!!

  15. As I suspected, the FabFitFun site is down immediately after customization started. Everyone is trying to get that throw!!!

  16. My box arrived today and I love evrything in it! The throw is so pretty, soft and such a nice cozy weight; great quality. I am a size 9 shoe and got the M/L slippers and they fit great, are comfy and cozy. My feet are wide and they are just right! I have a little FOMO for not adding the candle but since it was $15 and not $10 I found some way to talk myself out of it, lol. I decided to add that $5 beautiful umbrella which is gorgeous so I can’t wait for rain now and I added the $9 Ahava foot cream because I love that brand and it smells super awesome so probably will use on hands, not my feet. I did the $1 Alzheimer donation to hit the $15 min and got the free shampoo and wireless card so that was awesome too. My other choices were LXMI balm and it does smell a little odd like reviews said but don’t care because I need something for my cuticles, I am obsessed with masks and too cheap to buy them so stoked I got the Karuna set, and I always get anything Ahava so bath salts were my last selection and…..I lucked out and got the Cuccio salt wash and it smells so wonderful, but lavender is my fav scent. I had planned to swap the makeup eraser and prep rally spray, but am keeping it all. The makeup remover I will use for a wrap when I need an ice pack or steam cloth for my face because it is so soft and the dry bar detangler smells great! 110% happy bliss! I skipped the fall box which I am thrilled they let you do now so glad to have some credit for add ons later. Happy happy joy joy! 🎉🌈💃🏻💗

    • Just FYI if you live near a Kirklands, all of their candles are $5 tomorrow! Also ALDI has some great ones for $3.99 always. I couldn’t justify the $15 for a candle either but I’m sure it is wonderful. Also, if you don’t love that cuticle stuff, try Burt’s Bees. It clears mine up overnight. Miracle worker.

      • Thanks, Julie!!

      • I just picked up the Aldi candle “first snow” and it’s awesome! Love the scent and $4 for a three wick?! Burns just like the expensive ones. Get yourself one! Minty, vanilla deliciousness.

    • Thank you for your donation to Alzheimer’s. My grandfather is currently battling it. ❤️

  17. OK ~ one more question for those in the know…… if I buy this box on Friday, do I get to customize right away?? ….. and what are the chances of the choices still being available?? I would only buy this box for the Lil Marshmallow throw…. thanks for any help! 🙂

    • Fabfitfun has a live chat feature on their website. They should be able to let you know if the choice item you want is still available when you’re ready to purchase. Hope that helps.

      • Helps a lot Jessica!!! Thank you…. 🙂 I will use that option before I buy….

    • I think you will be able to buy it. The 15th is the first day for customization and they always have full stock. Just get in there fast!

  18. Why are they so crazy about acrylic yarn? It’s not soft. It feels terrible against the skin. They really need to offer products with natural fabric not synthetic.

    • I am allergic to lanolin so the acrylic yarn for me is wonderful for my feet. There are so many like me who can not wear wool so kuddos to FFF for thinking of everyone’s enjoyment!

  19. How easy is it to cancel this box?? Can we do it by ourselves or do we have to email?? I won’t buy a box that I can’t cancel a subscription by myself…… thanks for any info!! 🙂

    • You cancel online through your account, no interaction with CS needed! I’m the same way 🙂

      • Can you cancel if you were Annual and they renewed you without you knowing? My last box is Spring 2020 and they already charged me for the next year.

      • Whoa, what? Winter 2019 is my last box on my annual membership so my annual is set to renew at the billing date for Spring 2020. It’s set in the agreement to automatically renew so they don’t technically have to tell you, but if they’re billing you for your annual renewal now when it shouldn’t be until Summer 2020, I’d be filing a dispute with my bank ASAP.

      • Say what? Thanks for posting this – my last box is spring 2020 and I just cancelled.

      • This is obviously a mistake. You should chat in. I just looked up my billing history and they renewed my annual on August 7th with the Fall box being my first in the series. I have never, ever been charged that far in advance.

      • Hi Jodi! you can call them directly at 855-313-6267.

      • Thank you Victoria!!!

  20. I just got my box yesterday and the faux fur throw is AMAZING! So soft and lightweight without feeling insubstantial. I got the S/M slippers and I’m a 7.5 and they barely fit… Nothing else in the box really wows me but it’s a nice mix of items and I’m more excited by the few add-ons I got.

    • Wow that is quick! Glad you liked the add ons! Hoping for some good things when they open up!

    • Oh no, I am between 7 and 7.5 so I went with the S/M because I figured the M/L would be huge! I’m hopeful that I can wear the S/M!

      • I got the M/L for my mom and they are big on me, so I think S/M is best for our size.

      • I usually wear an 8 in pumps/boots, but a smaller size in sandals or wider shoes-the s/m fits me perfectly, even with socks! Love this box, the amazing throw, snuggly slippers, and the Kate Somerville skin cream, it’s the best in awhile. The only drawback for me is that the Ahava salt bag arrived ripped and it got all over everything.

    • Hi, can’t wait to get my box! I’m debating getting a second one…is the first in the slippers very soft? Did you get the candle too?

      • The slippers are really SOFT and cozy. I didn’t get the candle, sorry!

    • How did you get yours so fast? The first batch of winter boxes isn’t supposed to ship until early December?

      • Mine is scheduled to arrive Friday, it shipped a couple days ago. Looks like the new warehouse is just really on top of it?

      • That’s awesome!

      • I got my add ons last week and my box is due to arrive this week. The shipping is much faster than it was in the past.

    • I didn’t pick the slippers for that reason. Unsure if they would fit. I liked how they looked and I did want them but didn’t want to risk it!

    • I’m a big 7 and they fit perfect!

  21. I like most of these options. However, the small wearable items are still bugging me. I wear a size 10 1/2 shoe (I’m 5’10 ) so neither will fit me. The cross body bag is really small. It would look like a fanny pack on me, so I really hope I don’t get that. I liked everything in group one and if they had XL slippers, I would have liked all of group two. Everyone is complaining about the the secret 8th item, but I think a hand mask is cool. I am happy to see the lashes too. There were no fitness items this time, which is kind of odd. But overall, seems like a great box. I am looking forward to it.

    • they said the slippers are until size 11, in case you wanted them. I’m 5 11 and I hear you: slippers, socks, hats (my head is -I suppose and hope- proportioned to my body so a bit on the side compared to others).
      For the fanny pack, I am against the category in general, but I think that little bag was meant to be versatile and to be used as fanny pack or like a small purse one can go to the gym with or using while running. That was their fit item -I suppose – along with the salts (recovery post gym). Not my cup of tea.

  22. Does anyone know if they normally do a Black Friday sale?

  23. Liz – sorry for the tangent but just wanted to let you know that full spoilers for Popsugar are out on R e d d i t!

    • Oooh thank you!

      • I am tempted to resub seeing these spoilers. I really like most of them and need some slippers.

  24. If I switch to annual today, would i be able to customize today or would I have to wait until seasonal opens?

    • I switched over the weekend to annual and i still have to wait 😒 i think its cuz the annual choice window already closed

    • I read if you upgrade to annual, you have 60 minutes immediately to customize but confirm with FFF live chat to be sure.

      • Be careful with live chat though, that’s exactly why I went on live chat last week. I was considering upgrading to pick my daughter’s items right away & I was given completely false information by my live chat rep Angela about everything. The information was literally the opposite of the truth. I believed the rep of course, since I had no reason not to, then posted it here & on the FFF community as information from FFF that I thought was pretty important for others to know too …and it turned out to be completely false.
        Just my experience… in case it helps.
        Oh, and screenshot everything they tell you…people were asking me for my screenshots to prove I wasn’t lying so I guess that is a thing when you talk to live chat, lol.

      • They lies to me on several occasions with my summer box! I got annual just for the picks! I’m fixing to cancel as soon as I get my box in! I should already have my box, but they had a hiccup with billing add-ons I should have just emptied my cart! But live and learn oh well! I’m set to renew in July! But I have seen numerous comments that they billed them way before it was time to and their last boxes are spring 2020 like mine is. But like I said I’m set to renew in July! But doesn’t look that way! I absolutely hated both summer and fall! Which had a lot to do with customer service and their lying! So I am not getting anymore after spring! I wished I didn’t pay annual but I wanted the picks! This is by far my best box yet!

    • I just purchased my first box and then upgraded to annual. The live chat guy took my selections for the additional item choices.

  25. Maybe if they run the $25 special later. Until then, not budging. Whew.

    • So many people are ordering 2 and 3 boxes, so I really do not think they will sell this for a discount over the $10 off they already offer.

      • Then I’ve saved $25.

  26. I’m receiving the Hand & Body wash. I don’t know but I just feel like most will receive this.

    • SN: My box is already on its way to me, that NEW warehouse must be up and running smoothly!!!

  27. Hi does anyone know if it was still possible to add an additional option for the first selection for $15 when the annuals finished customizing the box?

    • It was when I was reviewing my choices right before the window closed so I think you should be good. None of the options were unavailable for additional selection.

  28. Ordinarily I don’t complain too much but this latest update is ludicrous!! That hand mask is $4! The hand soap is $40!!! HUGE DIFFERENCE IN VALUE! Why would they say either or? It should be both or nothing! This is going to frustratingly upsetting to those who wanted the more expensive and useful item if they get the single use hand mask instead! Obviously the box value is already there minus these two items, but this is definitely going to be contentious in some circles!

    • But honestly, how is a hand soap reasonably listed for $40? I mean really they both should have a similar “actual” value. No matter what the retail value is listed for, they are fairly equal if you bought something similar in any store. I think the hand mask was $8, and that is fairly average price for a small bottle (it is really small) of hand and body wash. I do think they should have had at least 2 pairs of masks though.

      Lots of people are willing to trade, so that is an option too.

      • I think people may be angry because they can get more by swapping if they receive the hand soap instead… 😉 Altjough I don’t know who would want to swap for the soap for the RV of $40…

    • Ive seen a lot of ladies in the FFF community say they can’t handle lavendar n r actually hoping for rhe hand mask. Im happy my box reveal showed me as receiving the hand n body soap tho personally so I unserstand. My box (or at least SOME of it) has already shipped so im excited to receive my box + add-ons. ❤

      • I’d be happy with either of the two, but give me ALL THE LAVENDERS. I can’t get enough.

      • I’m actually really hoping I get the mask! I don’t care for the smell of lavender and I have more hand and body wash than I need

  29. If we subscribe after choice on the 15th, so we still get to choose some items?

  30. I hope I get the body wash.✨

    I am annual but have no label yet!!

    • Last item is pretty disappointing.

  31. I can’t wait! I really want the blanket (but I’m fine with anything in the first section) and I’m really excited for that shower speaker! It’s hard to hear my music in the shower sometimes lol and it’s so pretty! I think I’ll pick the bracelet too if it’s still available for seasonal subscriber picks. But I generally like all of it!

  32. I like bith the wash and the mask but agree the rv should be comparable. That said I just subscribed and went for the annual. I agree it’s not especially exciting but I find their boxes consistently good value and solid in their contents.

  33. I’m an annual subscriber and my box is shipped so I was able to reveal my box on FFF. Just FYI, in case anyone else wants to. It says I am getting the Cuccio soap. I have to admit I would have been pretty pissed if I’d gotten the mask.

    • I am betting there are going to be a lot of ticked off subscribers who get the hand mask. For me, the monetary listing doesn’t matter, what makes something worthwhile for me is the usefulness of the item. This is my last box, so I honestly don’t care which I get. I have a ton of body washes already.

      • I totally agree but in this instance I think the body wash is really giftable so I wanted it for Christmas. I think my MIL will love it.

  34. Most of the items are decent, but those slippers…uggo.

  35. Thanks so much for the spoilers! I have been unsubbed from FFF for a year, but this box is definitely interesting to me so I just reactivated. Looks like I’ll be able to choose 3 items and access add-ons as well, which is great!

  36. I just may go for this winter box. What I like best about it and the real selling for me is that I like all of the possibilities I would have picked for me.

  37. Nice! I needed another Makeup Eraser and another one of those eye shadow brush cleaners. Those little cleaners are awesome.

  38. What’s funny to me about this reaction is that I don’t typically get FabFitFun because the products don’t match my interests, but I got this box from the spoilers because I love the majority of the content.

    Everyone is different, and maybe every box isn’t going to be a winner for you.. but that doesn’t mean this isn’t a good box. I’m more than getting my money’s worth, and I will actually use (and have to not gift away) all of the products. That’s a big win for me for this box.

    • I’m with you, Janet. I’m normally not very interested in FFF even though I know it’s wildly popular. But I like almost everything in this box. You’re right, everyone is different and this is why these boxes are so much fun. I think I might get this for the first time, I would be happy with all of it. I do wish that I could pick all of the items, but I think it’s great that they honor their annual subscribers.

  39. I better get the hand & body wash and not a one time use mask!

    • I hear you. I hate it when I get masks in my subscription boxes. I can get those on my own. Bottled face products go a long way.

    • I got the gloves and not the bottle! Is this the complete box or is this just some of it? This had nothing in it hardly at all!

  40. I’m satisfied with what I’m seeing. I’m sure we all already own a MakeUp eraser, but we also own multiple tiles/wash clothes so I don’t see the issue here?? That blanket looks so cozy and soft! Like to try the Glow Drops. Need a Color Switch. Love the bracelet, it’s cute and simple. The Lash Conditioner is talking to me. I don’t see the problem here. I mean, that’s why you have choices. I bet half the things you think you’d hate, you found that you loved. Glass half full over here. 😉

    • Happy to hear that, Ashley!

  41. This was a great box as a whole.

    In the real world hand soap *does* have a value equal to a hand mask so even if a manufacturer gives a “rv” of $40 for one bottle of hand soap does not mean that it is actually worth that. I am glad FFF has those two at a comparable level.

    • Completely agree! I love hand masks and do buy them, and I spend about the same on one of those as I do a nice smelling hand soap.

      • Seriously. I mean, who actually pays $40 for a bottle of hand soap? I don’t even like paying $4 for hand soap; I usually won’t pay more than $2.50 on sale.

    • Amen!!! The blind faith in RV astounds me. It’s the eighth item in a $50 box. That alone should tell you that the mark-up is insane and no one would actually pay $40 for it.

      • Lol!!! You are so right !! I dont think I’ve ever seen $40 hand soap – (not saying it doesn’t exist) but it certainly isn’t the norm. I recieved it in my box a couple of days ago and its nothing super spectacular. I do love this seasons curation and like everything I’ve received

      • Could it simply be a typo? Could the hand soap value be $4? Wouldn’t that make a lot more sense?

  42. My year ended after the previous box. I cancelled after seeing these spoilers and fortunately was able to cancel before I was billed for another annual membership. No regrets.

    • If I switch to annual today, would i be able to customize today or would I have to wait until seasonal opens?

  43. Liz are you going to be doing the review of this? I miss your reviews. 😥

    • Yes! I don’t have the full box yet, but as soon as I do I’ll be writing the review! 🙂

  44. Nothing interesting here.

    • I thought the same.

    • Very disappointed in the winter box 2019. Don’t waist you’re money for 49.00 I could buy better items myself. This I’d my 3rd box and last will be canceling

  45. Or they could just not give either. Why is there so much negativity? Think of it as a bonus. 🙂

    • Seriously. I think this box is great! My favorite since subscribing. There’s some positivity for you. : )

      • Agree. Excited about this box.

      • I agree. I love this box. A few stocking stiffer for family and the rest for me. I got the notification to choose as I am annual. No complaints here 🙂

    • To be fair, just because someone doesn’t like something doesn’t mean they are negative, they have different tastes.

      I’m not a fan of anything in this box and I don’t consider my self a negative person for saying so. There is always next time!

  46. Total flop and I’m annual

    • Did you get a notice to customize your box? I didn’t and wasn’t prepared to see it ship already. I went annual as well to be able to choose

      • I am also annual and never got a notice to customize. I am cancelling. It is not with it. Go to TJMaxx instead😄

      • I’m been on the annual plan for years and this was the first time I never got the customization email either. Ieven checked my spam to see if I had somehow missed it. I got my box today and quite disappointed, I wouldn’t have picked what they sent me. I was looking for a reason to finally give up this box, I think this is it.

      • Ugh I thought it was just me!! In fact, I went online to cancel before the box rolled out but wanted to see what the select membership was about. I clicked On it thinking it would give more details – no! It enrolled me and charged my card right away for a year. I then proceeded to cancel and received confirmation email of cancelation. Then I get the email confirming annual sub. On 11/14, box shipped. Never was I notified to pick products and nothing they sent is what I would have chosen. It’s stuff I already have (makeup eraser which I hate, brush cleaner, lash md…) I did get the hand wash so I guess I’m “lucky” but overall so unhappy.

      • Also I’d like to add – when I inadvertently signed up for the annual select me membership – I never received notice to customize my box and it shipped on 11/14. YET on their website, it indicates “ All Access Customization window will open after Select Access closes from November 15th to November 18th…Please note – new Select Members will be able to Customize during the All Access window” So how could I customize between 11/15-11/18 if they shipped me the box 11/14. I received it today and do not like.

  47. I picked up one of those color switch things (generic brand) at the Dollar Tree. It works great, I would definitely recommend looking there if you are interested.

  48. Glad I cancelled! The only thing I’d be interested in is the R&Co shampoo/conditioner.

  49. Obvious they didn’t have enough stocked to give us both the hand masks and soap so now we get one, random luck of the draw.

  50. Sooo either a one-time use hand mask with a RV of $8 or a hand soap with a RV of $40..? Maybe there’s multiple hand masks? Call me a party pooper, but I went annual for the choices, so I’m not a fan of the surprise here.

    • Exactly. Makes no sense. I’ll hazard a guess that most of us get the hand mask. I’ll be cancelling after my year is up, anyway.

      • yeah i actually asked katie about this on instagram and she gave a very defensive answer that these were picked because they figured most people would like either and that RV isn’t always important. while i don’t disagree with that aspect I do think RV should be comparable on an item that is randomly selected for us. if there’s difference in values on choice items that’s our CHOICE to go with a lesser value. these should have atleast been comparable. even more than one pair of gloves or gloves and something else small from that brand would have been better imo. it’s kind of been the cherry on top of what’s i feel has been going down hill for close to a year now. i likely won’t renew.

      • Yes you’re quite right. Of course, RV isn’t the be-all and end-all, especially as it’s often ludicrously inflated – but there’s a huge difference here and it’s just not fair at all. FFF has indeed gone downhill, especially as I find that often you get a random assortment of stuff that isn’t at all pulled together with a seasonal theme (I’m looking at you, Fall 2019 box) and after all the box is called Fab FIT Fun, and they seem very low on fit these days. I’ve decided to go for the Space and Beyond Box and dump FFF, besides, I’m drowning due to product overload. Drowning.

      • Yeah… I renewed with this box and really like it overall, but it does offend my sense of fairness when the items sent to members randomly do not have a comparable value. The price itself might not be an object if the quality and number of uses were equivalent. This should have been a boxed set of three or four pairs of gloves vs. the bottle of wash. I also like your idea that it could have been the gloves with something else from the brand to even up the value.

      • So far, everyone I’ve seen (a lot of annuals already have shipping notices so we have the full box reveal available) has the hand wash.

        And it’s definitely only one mask, an influencer posted an unboxing a few days ago. They gave her both the hand mask and hand wash but everyone else only gets one

      • katie just said on instagram that it’s two sets but I have seen no mention of this anywhere else. seems like she was just back tracking on her argument to my valid point of significant value differences not being the best way to do fff picks lol

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.