My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

BoxyCharm November 2019 Full Spoilers For Five Variations!

MSA
ByMSANov 5, 2019 | 165 comments

Boxycharm

BoxyCharm
4.3 overall rating
1980 Ratings | 226 Reviews

We have more spoilers for the November 2019 BoxyCharm box!

One variation of the November box includes:

 

 

Here’s a look at two other variations:

Source: boxycharmsneakpeek

Source: boxypreview

In case you missed the previous spoilers:

Some November boxes will include:

Becca Cosmetics Complexion Pack OR Pretty Vulgar Concealer Complexion Pack

BoxyCharm 2 Piece Brush Set

According to Yosef, if you are a BoxyCharm Premium subscriber, you will not get the brush set (The Premium box includes a 5 piece brush set). Instead, you may receive:

Farsali Rose Gold Skin Mist

In case you missed the previous spoilers:

Dose of Colors Liquid Lipstick

Or

BECCA Shimmering Skin Perfector

 

Dominique Cosmetics Celestial Thunder Eye Shadow Palette

AND:

Juice Beauty Stem Cellular Anti-Wrinkle Eye Treatment or Kypris Antioxidant Dew Quench & Glow Serum

What do you think of the November spoilers? 

(If you aren’t familiar Boxycharm is a beauty + makeup subscription box that sends 5 full-size items each month for $25. It was voted the #1 Makeup Subscription Box by MSA readers, and won places in many categories in the 2019 Subscription Box Awards!)

Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

BoxyCharm ($25 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 4-5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and established brands, with a total retail value of over $100 in every box. The beauty item... read more.
MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

MSA
MSA
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.

165 comments

Amanda S

I got a crazy variation for the second month in a row. Chose the Kypris, and got the palette, DOC, Wonder sheet masks, and GlamGlow instamud. Overall, I’m a little disappointed I didn’t get the brushes, I also wanted the Farsali, but I’m still very happy 🙂

Ruth

Gosh, I hate this palette. Who over the age of 30 wears those colors? For that matter, my daughter is 24 and none of her friends want to take this palette off my hands.

Tabby O

So I’m one of many never off the waitlist. Then after letting them know on EVERY review and profile that I prefer “natural” colors, I get a never mentioned anywhere Milk Holographic Highlighter and no brushes just the knock off sponge. I emailed them that after I can finally redeem my charms I’m out. I haven’t been able to add new reviews for October or November yet. But, this box was a joke and full of wasteful items for me. I’m a long time subscriber and I with the recent price increase announcement, coupled with the sharp decline in profile matching and quality…I think this is the end of the road. I’ll just use that money towards extra add ons with my FFF or Ipsy boxes.

Brandi

I haven’t seen anyone with my box! It had two products I have not seen in anyone else’s, but I am happy with them. I got the Kypris Serum, Dose of Colors in Date Night, and eyeshadow palette, and then the other two items were GlamGlow InstaMud and two Wonder sheet masks.

Amanda S

I got this variation too!

Christina B.

Does anyone know his people are getting multiple premium boxes? There have been people posting 6 up for sale on the Boxycharm but sell trade Facebook group! That’s really disappointing. Maybe I’m a little salty but this is definitely not fair. I know people make multiple accounts but I thought boxy was going to let loyal customers get the boxes first? I’m confused. I emailed for an explanation. But I doubt I’ll get one.

Ashley

Yes, people have gotten multiple boxes and it was only first come first serve. Unfortunately, it didn’t matter how long you had been subscribed. It only mattered how quickly you signed up after the waitlist opened.

Alice R

Boxycharm is a shady business. As soon as I receive the products I’m owed, I’m gone. I can’t believe how they continue to be supported.

Eastof18

Anybody else having an issue where they receive their brushes and they’re boxy premium and they came with white powder all over them? I responded to their post on Instagram and have heard nothing back and I just emailed them and they said almost a week before they can get back to me. This is concerning because if they were made in China, China is known to use Asbestos and unsafe practices just to reduce their costs. For example the Claire’s make-up over a year ago had been found to have butts bestest in the even though they said they didn’t pissed I’m very concerned and very weird at all about the quality of boxycharm label products at this point

Mimi

What????

Alice

Thars very concerning.

MARLENE RIVERA

Has anyone completed the complexion quiz? I just did mine and I am having issues where it let’s you choose the foundation you currently use. Out of all the colors you can choose from, my color is missing!!! For example, I use “Too faced, born this way”in light beige and that was not an option. I also tried makeup forever ultra HD in Y245 that was also missing! And last Shiseido synchro refreshing foundation in 330 Bamboo was not an option. Those are my exact shades and they are not an option I can pick. I dont know what’s going on but that’s a bit off putting. Is anyone else having this problem?

Ruth

I got the BECCA samples, and the BECCA shade I normally use (and just got again at Ulta last week) wasn’t even a choice. Take from that what you will.

Alice R

No, i haven’t yet. This doesn’t surprise me at all. Boxycharm can’t get boxes right. They can’t get choices right. They can get customer service right. There is no way they’ll get foundation and concealer right. As soon as they send my owed products, I’m gone. They’re not getting any more of my hard-earned money. I refuse to support a shady and poorly run busness.

Reya

If I start the subscription now will I still get to choose one item or is that for people who have a continued subscription?

Steph H.

You won’t be able to choose a product for the November box, but you should be able to choose for the December box if you sign up now 🙂

Ashley

I got the Dose of Colors Lipstick in Date Night. Anyone willing to trade for a Becca highlighter? Thanks!

Ves

Received my box today, it was 1.2lbs and Variation 21.
*Farsali Mist (screw on top was loose so about half of product had leaked out and soaked box it was in
*Juice Beauty (Picked during selection time)
*DOS of Color Lip in Date Night
*DC Eyeshadow
*2 Starry Eyes eye masks

Happy with this box because i really wanted the Farsali. I did get Premium but was afraid I was going to get the beauty blender and holo highlighter variation like some boxes with Juice Beauty and no brushes.

A bit bummed about the Farsali being about half empty but have sent Customer Service an email and see what happens. At least I still have some product to try since it wasn’t broken just the top unscrewed enough that it leaked.

Vicky H

Oops, I actually want Charm 🙂

Vicky H

This is the exact box I hope to get down to the lip color! I don’t know if everyone who is getting premium is getting Dose instead of Becca though let alone that awesome dark red color. Fingers crossed!

Laura

I got variation 1! Juice eye serum, d c palette, vanilla quartz Becca highlighter, brushes, and 2 google eye masks. I’m so happy. They really went by my profile. The Becca color swatch was off

Shari

I got the last variation Krypis, eye shadow Palette, masks, brushes and highlighter compact. It was exactly what I wanted and followed my profile to a T. I love Boxycharm.

Elena

Just got mine, variation #4

Kypris
Becca shimmering perfector
Celestial thunder
Boxy charm brushes
2 x Tula mask

Also received Becca foundation tester pallet

Alice R

I got mine today. Variation 8:

BoxyCharm 2 Piece Brush Set
Dominique Cosmetics Celestial Thunder Eye Shadow Palette
Juice Beauty Eye Serum (NOT my choice. I chose Kypris.)
Dose of Colors Liquid Lipstick in Nude Mood, which is on the brownish side (I was supposed to get a Becca highlighter as my second choice item as a courtesy for their failure to send my Tarte palette in the October box.)
Tula Star Bright Nourishing & Brightening Cosmic Hydrogel Mask – Quantity 2

So, I get two emails from Boxycharm. One addressed the incorrect choice item, and said that my Kypris will be shipped separately. The second email addressed the Becca item. They said that it also would ship separately and that I should keep the Dose of Colors Lipstick ‘on them’.

I haven’t received any shipping notification on those two items. I suppose it may take a while because of the rollout of all these November boxes.

While I’m not surprised that there are two errors in my box, I am surprised that the emails addressed the problem at about the same time my box arrived in my mailbox. I wonder what triggered them to know that the errors were there?

I’ll try to remember to update on this.

As an aside, I like the other items overall. I’m thrilled that I didn’t get the false lashes. The brushes are nice. I’ll definitely use the Juice Beauty although the other products in their line that I’ve used seem too dry. The eye serum is new to me and I’m looking forward to using it. The lip product color is a little too brown and seemed a little drying, although the application stays wet and the color is uniform. It’s kind of a strange sensation. I topped it with my Ofra Sugarcup lip gloss which helped the color and also the feel. I can make this work for me. Will definitely use the masks. The eyeshadow colors — although some are very bright, I will be able to use a couple of the shades. The others will be good if I ever do some costuming! I was going to gift this; but, I will keep instead. This box was nice and such an improvement over my October ‘pencil’ box, lol.

Belle B

was everyone supposed to get the brush set? i never got one, but i did get cover fx glitter drops in addition to the celestial thunder palette, juice beauty anti-wrinkle eye treatment, dose of colors liquid lipstick in nude mood, and the tula skincare star bright masks…i’m too young to need the juice beauty item (gave to my nan) and don’t use face masks…would have totally preferred the brushes 🙁

Melissa

I didn’t get the brushes, I got the palette, juice beauty, a faux beauty blender, milk makeup highlight stick, and dose of colours lippy!

Alice R

Belle, I’m seeing more people saying that they didn’t get the brushes, so they must have been a variation item. That’s so nice of you to give her the eye serum.

Kelly

Hi! So I got a similar email from Boxy a few days ago prior to receiving my Nov Box tracking notification.

The email : “ We are reaching out to let you know that the item you selected after contactingCustomer Service (BECCA Cosmetics vs Dose of Colors) is shipping in your November box, while the item you selected for November’s Choice (Kypris vs Juice Beauty) is shipping separately.

You should receive your Choice of Kypris or Juice Beauty within 5-10 business days after receiving your tracking email. Please keep the extra item on us.”

I wrote back right away because I was super confused by this email and wanted to know why my Kypris (choice item) isn’t coming in the Nov Box and what extra product am I getting on the house…… I just got a email from Boxy today but they didn’t answer my question . They just restarted what was in the 1st email….
After reading your comment , I think the extra item im getting on the house is the Juice Beauty …. So far the only tracking numver ive received is for the Nov Box and Im praying they will follow through and send me the Kypris within the stated 5-8 day timeframe.

Alice R

My extra item is the lip product because I was supposed to get the Becca because they missed up my October box. I don’t understand, either, why they didn’t get our selection items correctly. I’ll get to keep the juice beauty. I’m hoping they send my tracking number for both items soon. I didn’t email them again…yet. I’ll try to remember to update here.

Alice R

I also got a Pretty Vulgar concealer sample.

Summer

My “2 lb” Ontrac November Boxycharm arrived today. It actually weighs 1.3 lbs (about 1 lb 4.5 oz).

It’s Variation 10 and contains:

BoxyCharm 2 Piece Brush Set
Dominique Cosmetics Celestial Thunder Eye Shadow Palette
Kypris Antioxidant Dew Quench & Glow Serum (my choice)
Dose of Colors Liquid Lipstick (the Neutral shade they mentioned in the email is Nude Mood)
Tula Star Bright Nourishing & Brightening Cosmic Hydrogel Mask – 2 masks

Kate

I got a Milk makeup holographic stick in mine instead of the brushes! I’m not mad about it, but I was very surprised to see it. I think my box was somewhere in the 1.5-1.6 range as far as weight goes. Here’s my box:

Dose of Colors lipstick in Date Night (very happy because I already have the Becca Vanilla Quartz highlighter and DOC is my favorite liquid lipstick formula!)
Milk Makeup Holographic Stick
Kypris Serum
Celestial Thunder Palette
HaruHaru Wonder Maqui Berry Antioxidant Sheet Mask, 2-Pack

I always read spoilers to get excited, so it was really fun to get something completely off the wall! I got the Pretty Vulgar concealer sample too and I love trying new concealers. Overall I’m pretty happy with this box!

Samantha

I just received my box today. Was 1.3 lbs.

Eyeshadow Palette
Dose of Colors lipstick in Nude Mood
Tula face masks
Kypris Serum
Boxycharm brushes

Shannon

Exact same, down to the color. Mine was also variation 10. I was pleasantly surprised by the brushes!

Leslie

Mine is also 1.3 lbs and has identical contents.

Yessy

I have 1.02lbs and not quite sure what variation I am having in my box. Has anyone got the same as me?

June

My box weighed 1 lb. exactly and I received:

Juice Beauty eye cream
Dominique eye palette
Dose lip color in Flirty
Brush set
Vitamasque eye mask set (1 daytime, 1 nighttime)

I am loving my box this month…it’s just what I wanted!

Julie B

Exactly what I got! I can’t believe Boxy finally sent me a lip shade I like! I started using the eye cream which I would never pay retail for…and the brushes aren’t bad! By the way, my box did say 2 lbs in the shipper info so it’s true that they just round it up.

Ashley

Received my shipping notice. My box is 1.3lbs and the dimensions are 6x6x3. This seems like a very small box?!? Anybody receive one with these dimensions?

Alice R

No, but these are my dimensions: 16×7×1.??!!

Ashley

That’s a big box!

Lauren

My box is 9X7X3 and it’s the base box. Does anyone else know which variation this might be? It says 2 pounds, but I saw a comment from someone that OnTrack shipping rounds up.

Staceymarie

My dimensions are the same but box weight is 1.3lbs? Did you ever find out anything??

Cassie

Mine was the same dimensions. 1.3 lbs. Variation 10 — 4th pictured here. Kypris serum, celestial thunder palette, 2 brushes, dose of colors lipstick in nude mood & 2 Tula masks.

Lauren

I hope you are right 🙂 I know I’m crazy but I don’t care about getting the Becca

LaylaB

I received variation 15 it was 1.3lbs

-DC Palette
-Kypris Serum
-2 Popband Starry Eye Masks
-DOC Lipstick in Date Night (was supposed to be Becca Highlighter, because I was sent a used product in a previous box & the lipstick doesn’t match profile)
-Farsalli spray (came shattered and underneath other items, foam was only wrapped around the lipstick and eye masks, ☹ the 2 things that won’t break)

Definitely not my favorite month!

NurseJen

Did you get an email stating that the Becca product would be coming separate? I got a broken palette in Oct and chose the Becca product, but I got an email yesterday stating they would send it separately. I got the lippie and they said it was on them. 🤷🏻‍♀️ I guess they are trying to improve customer service…

Ashley

Do you know what your dimensions were?

LaylaB

It’s 9x7x3. I’ve seen a few with these dimensions though.

Shawna

Mine came today! Variation 18, I guess (It’s the number next to the heart on the bottom right of the card, right?):

– DC palette
– Kypris Serum
– DOC Liquid Lipstick in Date Night
– 2 Brush Set
– Haruharu Maqui Berry Sheet Mask x2

Amy M

I got my box! Variation #10

DC pallets
Kypris (my choice)
DOC lip in Nude Mood
Tula masks
Brush set

I also got the Becca 24 hr foundation samples. I’m confused about where to report which sample matches my skin. The e-mail says go to the website to let them know, but what website is that? I’m seeing nothing on Boxy website and e-mail didn’t have a link? Any ideas? It would be nice to get foundation once on awhile!

Lisa Marie

I also received box #10. That lipstick is a horrid color for somebody like me who is fair with blue undertones and blonde hair. Nobody in my office wanted it so I chucked it in the trash. The eyeshadow palette is ok but I’m only going to be able to use two or at the most three colors. I’m glad I received the brushes and I will use the masks for sure. I tried the Kypris but I guess I will need to wait to see if it does anything for my skin or not.

SquirrelyGirl

Box twins!

Shawna

You log in on Boxycharm and go to boxycharm.com/complexion. There are instructions on the card but they are small.

Tracy

They just posted all of the items for review on the Boxycharm website, but I noticed again, like last month, they didnt put ALL of the items you could get- such as the blender sponge Ive seen a youtuber get.

I was pretty upset with my box last month because they made it seem like EVERYONE was going to get a DOC palette but I received the Tarte pro glo that was pretty much just the one I received a couple months ago & that was the WHOLE reason I wanted that box.. I also received a Becca under eye powder. Neither one of those were listed on the site for review (they had a blur Becca under eye product but not the white powder I received). I felt like I got leftover scraps in my box. This month my box only weighs 1,1 lb and I picked the Kypris- I hope I get the brushes instead of the highlighter I have millions of.

I hate to rant but I just wish they would be more honest about other items you could get in your box! They always make some items to appear like everone will get that (like the brushes this month) when thats not the case. they didnt even put that beauty sponge the youtuber got in their video showing “all” the products you could get and if they have 20 some variations who knows what else theyre throwing in there.

Christina

i just wanna know how you all have your information on shipping already? 🙁
i havent got a sneak peak or anything 😫

SquirrelyGirl

I didn’t get any emails this month but if you sign up for FedEx delivery manager they notify you way before Boxy does. Works for all FedEx packages

Alice R

I don’t have a sneak peek of contents, but when you get your tracking, go to travel history and click on shipping information. That will give weight and package dimensions.

Kylee

I got an email with shipping confirmation & tracking number this month. The previous 2 months though I didn’t get any kind of shipping update or sneak peak.

You Might Also Like

Sephora Black-Owned Beauty Set Lets You Stock Up and Support a Great Cause
Sephora Black-Owned Beauty Set Lets You Stock Up and Support a Great Cause
September 15, 2021
Ipsy Glam Bag X November 2021 Curator + Product Spoilers
Ipsy Glam Bag X November 2021 Curator + Product Spoilers
September 20, 2021
BoxyCharm October 2021 – Choice and Add-Ons Open NOW!
BoxyCharm October 2021 – Choice and Add-Ons Open NOW!
September 13, 2021
Essentials Crate August 2021 Subscription Box Review + Coupon
Essentials Crate August 2021 Subscription Box Review + Coupon
September 12, 2021
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.