MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

2 Tarte Mystery Boxes – Available Now!

Tarte has two mystery boxes available now! (Thanks, Amanda, Nikki, and Christa for the heads up!)

The Box: Tarte Skincare Mystery Set

The Cost: $56

The Products: $112 value. 1 makeup bag, 2 full size items, 2 travel size items, and 1 mini skincare item.

The Box: Tarte Makeup Mystery Set

The Cost: $48

The Products: $122 value. 1 makeup bag, 4 Full size makeup items and 1 mini makeup item.

Are you going to grab a mystery box? Want to see them reviewed?

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in Subscription Box News| Tags: tarte | 31 comments

Comments (31)

  1. Any news on what is in the Urban Decay Halloween Mystery Box for $75?

  2. I got the skincare one and I’ve never been so disappointed with a mystery bag. I got a full size setting spray and mask and travel lotion soap and exfoliating cleanser.

  3. Review of both bags: positive happy! Both were good amount of product, arrived quickly, good selection of items, doesn’t feel like the bargain bin cast offs to me. Very excited and happy with both. I’d say this is a buy!

    Full size tight and bright face mask
    Full size 4-1 setting spray
    Travel size drink of h2o moisturizer
    Sample size makeup remover
    Sample size Exfoliating stick

    Full size eye rainforest of sea vol 2 shadow pallet
    Full size lip paint in front row shade
    Sample size makeup remover
    And I think these last two are full size but not sure
    Lights camera action mascara
    Kitten liquid eye liner

  4. I ordered two and got the same exact thing I was hoping they would be different

  5. Well I got Rainforest of the Sea eyeshadow palette vol II, Sex Kitten Eyeliner, Lights Camera Lashes, Lip paint in Front Row, and Deluxe Stay and Spray. Not Bad

  6. Well I got Rainforest of the Sea eyeshadow palette vol II, Sex Kitten Eyeliner,Lights Camera lashes,Lip paint in Front Row and Deluxe Stay and Spray. Not Bad

  7. Okay I got the skincare one and I’m not that impressed tbh I got a full size clay mask, full size facial spray, mini rainforest of the sea cleanser, mini frixxion stick exfoliator, and a travel size drink of h2o moisturizer.

  8. Anybody get one? What’s inside? I’m hesitant to drop $50 if it’s junk.

  9. I wish I could buy just the bags. I’m on a product buying blackout since I’m going for all three Ipsys every month but oh those bags….😍

  10. Ordered one of each

  11. Okay I caved and got the skincare one. I love Tarte’s skincare so hopefully I get some good products. I’m on the soul mate tier of Tarte’s rewards, so I got free two day shipping. I’ll comeback when it arrived to say what was inside of the bag

  12. OOOOO! I ordered one of each!

  13. the last time I got a mystery bag from them was terrible so I’ll have to pass. It’s always a toss up. Good luck to everyone!

  14. Naturismo discovery is available now too.

    • I got one earlier this morning. 🙂

      • I did too Luna, there’s so many good products.

      • I know! It’s always hard to pass one up. 🙂

    • I got one.

  15. Its weird that the cheaper bag, has the higher value than the more expensive bag. Very weird.

    • When I was looking at the price & contents I even had to scroll between the two again because I was thinking something didn’t add up, but after reading your comment I see what it is now…. I just woke up, so my brain’s only at about 1mph on the treadmill right now. lol

    • I ordered the makeup bag! Hoping for some good stuff. Yes review them please

      • Me too! I’ve never ordered an “mystery bag” from Tarte before. 🤞

  16. I am going to pass on these but do you know will they do the custom bags in Nov?

    • I have November in my calendar 🤗

      • Idk on specific day tho

    • What are the custom bags?

      • Search MSA for “Create your own Tarte beauty available now” to see what was offered in June

      • Oh man! I can’t believe I have been missing out this whole time!

      • The create your own custom kits are my absolute favorites. I think I will always order those, forever xD

      • Now that I know about them, I will be ordering one every time from now on. I don’t like mystery bags because I usually wind up with stuff I won’t use, but if I get to pick the products, I’m all for it!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.