New MILK Makeup Mystery Box – Available Now!

Comments (10)

1. CMB

   2 years ago

   I received the same as others posted. I am not as disappointed as others since I am still a MM newbie and have tried only the blur stick and holo sticks in the past. Also, I have legit NEVER seen any MM products at TJMaxx or Marshalls-type stores (and I go a LOT), so I’m happy to receive new items I never tried before.

   I feel like I got a lot for my money since I added the Deluxe intro set (I think it said $26 RV) to my order for $6 more, taking the order to $65 which allowed more bonuses/dupes that I wanted to try. So for about $55 pre-tax (with the 15% coupon) I received:

   Mystery Bag:
   Holo bag + larger Milk Makeup bag
   full size: Eye pigment – hotel lobby
   full size: Cooling water stick
   full size: Glitter stick – techno
   full size: Blot papers (bummer that this little $10 thing was considered full size, but they fit in my clutch for emergencies & at least it’s useful)
   deluxe: Lip and Cheek Stick in WERK
   deluxe: Kush clear brow gel
   deluxe: Kush High Volume Mascara in Boom

   Deluxe intro set ($6):
   deluxe: Highlighter in Turnt
   deluxe: Lip and Cheek Stick in WERK
   deluxe: Grip Primer

   Bonus items:
   deluxe: Kush High Volume Mascara in Boom
   deluxe: Grip Primer
   sample: Flex Foundation pod

   Overall I’m happy that I spent the extra $6 to get the bonus items and also that I had the 15% off code. If it were just the mystery bag at $59 plus tax, I may feel like others especially since the summer box seemed a bit better? Oh well, with any sub box YMMV.

   reply
2. dany

   2 years ago

   Full size holographic glitter stick ($6 at t.j.maxx)
   Full sized cooling water stick (the best!)
   Full size eye vinyl

   Blotting paper/ rolling paper

   Deluxe Lip cheek in Werk
   Deluxe clear brow gel
   Deluxe kush mascara

   Foundation sampler.

   reply
3. Krista

   2 years ago

   I got my bag today and I’m pretty disappointed. 🙁

   reply
   • Mary

     2 years ago

     What were the contents? My bag is arriving on Monday. Nervous about this now…should’ve known better with a mystery bag.

     reply
     • Emily

       2 years ago

       Mine gets here tomorrow and I’m nervous as heck now!!
   • Lindsey

     2 years ago

     Same

     reply
4. AshKay

   2 years ago

   Link says it’s expired. 🙁

   reply
5. DawnS

   2 years ago

   I want the bag but have not had much luck with Milk products.

   reply
6. Mary

   2 years ago

   I bought this, as I’ve never tried anything from their brand. Curious to see how this goes. Thanks for the promo code!

   reply
7. Adeline

   2 years ago

   I just want that bag. It’s so cute. Click on my me if you want to swap 🤩

   reply