My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
No results matched your query
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

BoxyCharm Premium November 2019 FULL Spoilers!

ByMSAOct 17, 2019 | 214 comments

4.3 overall rating
1980 Ratings | 226 Reviews

We have the full spoiler for the November 2019 BoxyCharm Premium! FYI – There may be variations. 

One variation of the November 2019 BoxyCharm Premium will include:

Natasha Denona Bloom Blush and Glow Palette – $55
Dragun Beauty Dragunfire Skin Perfecting Potion – $25
Becca Cosmetics Glow Gloss in Champagne Creme – $22
QMS Medicosmetics Intensive Eye Care Cream – £109 ($140)
Kopari Beauty Coconut Rose Toner – $25
BoxyCharm 5 Piece Brush Set

What do you think of the spoilers?

Here’s everything you need to know about BoxyCharm Premium:

  • It’s $35 a month
  • 6-7 beauty items a box
  • $175+ Value
  • You get to pick one of the items
  • The items will be different from BoxyCharm/BoxyLuxe – you can subscribe to both with no product overlap.

The BoxyCharm Premium waitlist is open now! Click here to sign up for Boxycharm Premium!

Good to know:

  • You will be billed an additional $35 every month, in addition to your existing subscription(s)
    (Additional $5 per month will be applied for shipping outside the contiguous U.S.)
  • Every month, you’ll receive a BoxyCharm Premium box in addition to any of your regular BoxyCharm or BoxyLuxe subscriptions
  • No refunds or exchanges and you may cancel at any time; subscription renews automatically
*You will be billed an additional $35 (on top of your existing subscription(s)), prior to, or during, each BoxyCharm Premium shipping month. Subject to availability and depending on your placement on the Waitlist. For all terms and conditions, CLICK HERE.
BoxyCharm ($25 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 4-5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and established brands, with a total retail value of over $100 in every box. The beauty item... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.

At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



Did anyone get a different variation than pictured here?

Jess D

I received the items pictured above. Also curious if there were variations!


If anyone wants to buy the entire box minus the eye cream I’ll sell it at cost I’m not looking to make a profit off of anyone. Sorry if this is a repeat comment. Thank you


I’d be interested in purchasing your box. I was so disappointed I didn’t make the cut as I signed up within an hour of the waitlist sign-ups opening. I’ve been so sad I didn’t get it! If it’s still available please let me know. Thank you! 🙂


Yes I need your email


I’m super sad I didn’t get the premium box, I didn’t want regular boxycharm. Only wanted the Natasha Denona 🙁


I have a fedex label created for the premium. It could arrive this week.
1.8 lbs 11x10x4”


Me too!! 🙌🏻 I’m excited that my premium is coming first 🙂 it makes sense though because I was charged for premium first before my regular box. Premium was charged at 12:11am and my two regular boxes at 1:51am and 2:48am. They are on top of their game this month because just yesterday I ordered the rainbow eyelash curler from PUR Because the I didn’t get one in my box before, and they’ve already shipped it! Label was created around noon today for my regular box. Can’t wait!


Hmm. I canceled my regular BC account a week ago thinking that would remove me from the waitlist. Apparently I got charged and am getting the premium. Did this happen to anyone else?


Yes same thing happened to me


Sorry, didn’t read comments before I posted. Apparently I’m not the only one, oh well. My 17 y/o daughter and I will enjoy everything, but I do wish someone got in there who really wanted to.


Well didn’t get off waitlist .. meant to be .. mostly my product overload ..

Now next month idk if I do get off waitlist for December I have to get regular boxy? Premium? And Bixyluxe ? That’s a lot of money and product –

Please clarify it said you had to get regular boxy to get premium for November , so does that apply for December ?

Thanks for anyone’s help 🥰🥰


Yup. Boxycharm is greedy AF


so if my account still says waitlist and my card has not beeen charged does that mean I will not get premium this month? OR is there still a chance some are getting charged?? Thank YOU


You’re definitely not getting the November Premium. Neither am I. I strongly dislike FB but went on there super early yesterday to obtain any info that might help once I saw that I was charged for only the regular box. I learned that they put the Premium charge through before the regular box for most people. This odd choice resulted in at least one person being charged for the Premium that didn’t even want it. She’d canceled her regular subscription and didn’t think she had to cancel Premium since they told us over and over you MUST be subscribed to the regular box to get Premium. So she tried to get a refund because she didn’t want it and saw so many people that did want it and didn’t get it. This includes people that signed up mere minutes after it opened up. So since I didn’t see the announcement until 3 hours after it opened, at this rate it will probably be February or later before I get off the waitlist. Unless of course this first Premium is like the first Luxe and it’s the best collection of products they’ll ever have in one box. Anyway…Boxycharm refused to give her a refund. Personally I think that’s MAJOR BS. But they have a long track record of doing unfair things because money is so much higher of a priority than customer care.

Pardon my rant. To finish answering your question, someone IM’d Boxy quite early yesterday and she posted the response signed by Yosef. It stated that all Premium billing had been completed and that no one else would be taken of the waiting list for the November box.

I’m disappointed but I shouldn’t have gotten my hopes up anyway considering how late I was to the sign up. Although personally it really seems asinine to sign a list to be alerted to sign THE list. How about we sign the list saying we want it and you take that data and enter it the same way you do with the second list? Oh I know. To drag it out and create a bunch of hype and people have to constantly visit your FB and Insta waiting until you suddenly blow the whistle and watch us all race to sign up knowing less than 5% of us will make it off the list. If that many.
But I feel much worse for some people who had the funds in their bank or credit accounts but because Boxy sent 2 charges through in a short time only the money for one charge was released. They assumed it was flagged as possible fraud. Some of them reached out to Boxy but of course they weren’t willing to do anything about it.


Everything you said is exactly right it happened to me where they took two charges so closely in time my bank only let one go through it doesn’t matter how long I’ve been with boxycharm they do something messed up like this to me with every lunch so I cancelled I don’t need it and it doesn’t matter because any palette that I have ever wanted from them I have always had to buy on my own from a greedy person who gets multiple boxes that uses those for Revenue and I’ve always had to pay over box value so it doesn’t change anything boxycharm never sent me the stuff they advertise I always had to buy it myself from a crook I don’t need Cosmetics that badly I’ll just buy the stuff I really want


This is weird. I signed up for the waitlist, but then canceled boxycharm three days ago because I didn’t want to spend $60 on both the premium and the regular box. I thought that would automatically cancel being on the premium waitlist. But I was charged and got the email saying I’m getting premium this month. I guess I’m not complaining, but I thought I wouldn’t get either box.


Me too!

Shabbyfab Shan

I’m in, yippee! Woke up to a couple boxy emails saying I’ve been charged and I’ll be getting a premium. Only got it for the ND and the hopes of getting the Farsali in my regular haha.


I just checked my bank account and got billed $35 from Boxycharm and my status changed to active now.


Me too, excited!!

Dani G.

Do you remember how soon you signed up for Premium once you got the email or saw the post here? I’m just curious to see how many people got in based on how quickly they signed up.

I didn’t see my email or the post for three hours. I signed up immediately but knew I would miss out considering how fast BoxyLuxe sold out. I really wish we had known what date they would open it up so e could’ve planned to look out for it better.

I’m so disappointed. I left Ipsy Plus hoping this would be much better. And it would have been if I had been able to sign up in time. I was so looking forward to that ND palette, the luxury eye cream and even that brush set that a lot of people don’t like. I knew with those brands and the retail values they wouldn’t be taking many people off the list. I kind of doubt the future months will be as good as this one. I still think the very first BoxyLuxe was the best they’ve ever had. Of course I knew exactly when sign ups opened for that and was ready on time, tried for 3 hours and still didn’t get it.
Oh well I shouldn’t have gotten my hopes up considering I was 3 hours late signing up. But honestly I thought (or maybe just hoped) when we signed that list the first time they would use that and as long as you were a current subscriber you wouldn’t have to do anything else.


And I signed up within 2 minutes of receiving the email, (I have them set to VIP notifications) and I got bills at 12:11am.


I signed up 10-15min after someone posted on here and then I got email from boxycharm about waitlist open. I come here regularly to check on any new information. MSA pretty fast sharing the info that I need. Thanks to that ladyand MSA let us know when waitlist open. I’m so sorry ,My friend’s didn’t get it either. I know she’s so disappointed right now. I’m skipping Ipsy GBP Nov and I kinda want to give another chance to GBP Dec before I cancel. I think if you’re stay in premium waitlist you’re more than likely get in Dec. I thought I may not getting premium and I signed up FFF and Causebox last month to fill up my addiction. I’m not big fan of that huge makeup brush set so willing to swap.


I signed up about 10min after the time the email was sent and about 15min after it was posted on msa.. I was billed for it at 12:14


I guess I’m one of the few to be bummed about the Natasha Denona palette. I was really excited until I found out half the palette is creams. Why not an eyeshadow mini instead?


Yeah I really really wanted that palette. I like cream blushes. And I don’t own any in palette form, just singles. I have dozens of eyeshadow palettes in every size you could possibly need.

I checked my account and sadly I didn’t make it off the list. I think the sign up opened around 3:30 EST that day but I didn’t see it and sign up until 6:30. I knew it was super unlikely I’d get off the list but tried to think positively and hope for the best. Guess I should’ve been more realistic. 😄


My willpower is not good! Just finished spending two hours sorting my beauty box hauls from the past several months and decided I needed to cut back on my subscriptions, then logged in to Boxycharm to leave some reviews and see what my daughter received this month ( I have a regular and luxe subscription for her – she’s an only child and into beauty products as she has an a Esthetician License) and ended up putting both of us on the November waitlist. Might have something to do with the iPSY Ultimate disappointment. Might have been that ND palette. Might have been the wine. Might have been the fact that the fall Sunday Riley Box was Meh.

The struggle is real.


I agree disappointed with Ipsy lately and their Collabs , also I too was looking forward to the SR box and was super underwhelmed a little blanket and dream catcher and pillow spray .. so I too signed for waiting list I need something to fulfill those loses and my addiction 🤣🥰🥳


I signed up for this, yet I own almost all of these products already LOL. Gifts?!

Christa H.

I just completed a Charmer Foundation quiz for Boxycharm!!! 😊🙌🤗 Did anyone else get this email?


No; I didn’t.


I’ve been subscribed to BC and so are my daughters. I cancelled all of our subscriptions because we are about to leave on our fall vacay and i did not want a lot of boxes to come while we are out. I decided to re-subscribe all of us in order to get the BCP box and i just received shipping notifications that we are all getting another Oct. box. I thought since we already received and Oct. box that it would just pick back up in Nov. What a mess and what a lot of boxes. One didn’t like her DOC palette and so i ended up with 2. None of us cared for the Iconic spray. One didn’t like her spongelle or Kohl liner.

Toni Marie

In December the boxyluxe will have a fairy tale palette by story book cosmetics. In little briar rose… I cant wait


I may be in the minority but this box excites me. I want the Natasha palette and I love love love Dragon Beauty potion ( it does work better when you use the powder with it which the powder is a staple in my beauty routine) and that right there makes the box worth it for me 🙂 I agree we should be watching where the products are made for sure but if you comment every month you dont like it WHY DO YOU HAVE BOXES. They arent supposed to customize the every want of someone lol its not a birthday choice box. I donate anything i cant use to woman shelter or my friends or resell or trade 🙂 I miss people being excited sometimes.


HAHA, I love all my subs for the most part, best part my sister and friends never need to buy makeup or skin care because I give them so much 🙂


Are any of you off the waitlist yet?


So the brush set is $73+?? Yeah right🙄. This isn’t worth the $340+ that was promised. “Bait and Switch” again😡 taking notes from Ipsy Boxy?


I received the exact same premium box as pictured, very glad I must say.
Now anxiously to see if I’m as lucky for the regular November box.
Meanwhile, Boxycharm still hasn’t sent out first timer subscriber gift for September. It has been in the status “ordered” for almost a month. CS just keeps on saying they have a lot of backlog of orders to send out…………


So disappointed with Ipsy GBP lately I’ll take my BC and on waiting list for ultimate … I need to feed my addiction somehow 🥰🤣


I got an email last night saying Im off the waitlist, yayyy. But no info about picking one specific item though.

Dani G.

I was reading the Premium FAQ’s or one of the promotion emails, I can’t remember which, but it said there would be no choice for November. The first month with a choice will be December.

I just wish I’d have gotten off the list. Not having a choice this time would be no big deal. I doubt I will get December’s box either. Lots of people signed up for Premium just minutes after it opened but didn’t get it this month. I didn’t know it was up until 3 hours later so I’ll probably be waitlisted for months. Unless of course the future bags aren’t nearly as great as this one and lots of people cancel.

Congrats to you though! Enjoy!


The boxycharm website says the premium box will have one choice item each month. Do we still think this choice is going to happen for the November box?


Choice begins in December.


I doubt it. Seems like choices would need to be made earlier if they were going to be applied to the November box.

Ashley Jean

Lol!! The whole time I have been reading the comments about the Nikita dragun concealer, I was wondering what product it was. I scrolled up agian to look at the picture and the item I thought was a liquid lipstick was actually the concealer!😂😂


Ok, kinda interesting…love the ND palette, noticing the lack of filler junk, not totally trusting the Boxy bait and switch, and not going to get burned on a new Boxy launch. Overall it’s clear our girl Boxy is upping her game after a very lackluster year, but for now Im gonna stick with the basebox, pay my extra 4 bucks, because Boxy clearly needed a raise, and see what they do with swatches for foundation and concealer.


I don’t think it has anything to do with needing a “raise”. Beauty companies are beginning to charge sub boxes more for the products they are including so they need to cover that extra cost. There is a youtuber the not so evil stepmother that investigates all things sub boxes and she talked about this in one of her videos.


Can you send me the link? I wanna see her YouTube videos.


I will be very surprised if any of the makeup samples are cool toned. Boxy seems to think warm is universal


We can only hope!


I agree with you 100%


I’m not subscribing but I will certainly keep my eyes peeled for the ND blush palette on the swap site 👀


I’m on the waiting list. I’m super excited for the Natasha pallet and the Becca lipgloss, plus the eye cream sounds like a dream. Hopefully they bill me for November premium 😍

You Might Also Like

New Improvements on MSA Today
New Improvements on MSA Today
September 16, 2021
Sephora Black-Owned Beauty Set Lets You Stock Up and Support a Great Cause
Sephora Black-Owned Beauty Set Lets You Stock Up and Support a Great Cause
September 15, 2021
Stitch Fix Plus Size End of Summer Dresses and Jumpsuits Review
Stitch Fix Plus Size End of Summer Dresses and Jumpsuits Review
September 11, 2021
BoxyCharm October 2021 – Choice and Add-Ons Open NOW!
BoxyCharm October 2021 – Choice and Add-Ons Open NOW!
September 13, 2021
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.