MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyCharm April 2021 Full Spoilers

BoxyCharm September 2019 FULL SPOILERS!


We have spoilers for two versions of the September 2019 BoxyCharm box! (Thanks, SquirrelyGirl, for the heads up!)

One version:

Another version:

Source: caro_vlsz

We know all subscribers will receive one of these palettes:

Violet Voss Essentials Eyeshadow Palette


Tarte Clay Play Face Shaping Palette


Too Faced Natural Face Palette


Image: hankandhenrybeauty

Hank & Henry Beauty Liquid Liner in Blickity Black


M·A·C Cosmetics Frost Lipstick in CB 96

What do you think of the September spoilers? 

(If you aren’t familiar Boxycharm is a beauty + makeup subscription box that sends 5 full-size items each month for $21. It was voted the #1 Makeup Subscription Box by MSA readers, and won places in many categories in the 2019 Subscription Box Awards!)

If you haven’t signed up for Boxycharm yet:

Click here and use coupon code GETMYBECCA to get a free full-sized Becca Hydra-Mist Set & Refresh Powder with your first box!

*Valid for new subscribers only. Ends September 12, 2019 at 11:59pm ET or while supplies last.

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in BoxyCharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 74 comments

Comments (74)

  1. I used the code when I signed up but did not receive it with my first box.

  2. I’m not very thrilled about the v. V palette so I’ll be gifting it and canceling Boxycharm.

  3. Does anyone want to trade the TooFaced palette for the Violet Voss ? I don’t use eye shadows outside of neutral shades, and i really like contouring, blushes, and highlighting, but not too much outside of natural eye makeup. Please lmk!!! I’m sure we can work something out!!!

  4. I just received my confirmation email today for the Becca hydro-mist setting powder

  5. I hope I don’t get either one of those chalky a$$ Tarte palettes. I HATE Tarte as much as I hate TheBalm. It’s as if they think everyone in the world is a fair, cool toned, pink blush wearing blonde. As a bronze goddess, those palettes are total trash to me.

    • Lol! Well, I am blond, fair skin, cool toned! Lol! I would LOVE either of the two palettes but I got Violette Voss and the DARK eyebrow pen!! Up for trades!

    • Exactlyyyyyyy!!! Thought it was just me. I just restart my subscription for the Becca powder. If any Tarte products are in there, I’ll cancel again!

    • I am a fair cool toned blonde and they gave me the darker highlighting palette. Seems you can’t win around here. LOL

  6. I cancelled my subscription last month and even have a screenshot. I just got an email that my September boxycharm just shipped out. I was also on the boxyluxe but when I cancelled it removed me. I’m still being charged and sent the September boxycharm box. It’s not about the price, it’s the principle! Boxycharm has almost no customer service. I’m gonna dispute the charges against them if they don’t handle things correctly, which they never do.

  7. I actually know I’m getting the violet voss pallet if there is anyone that wants to trade 😩 I can mail

    • How do you know what you are getting?

      • When you ho into your email the contains your shipping bar code when you click your bar code and scroll all the way down it has the shipping contents and it said it.

      • Mine email just has a tracking number, not a barcode.

      • Tracking number bar code same thing. But ow it also shows you what your box is if you log into your account

      • Please explain!! I’m new and I’m dying to know!! Where exactly do you find this info out at. I’m very internet savvy, just can’t find where you are talking about. Thanks!

      • Go to your email that has your tracking number and click it. You should now be on the Apc Postal site where it shows all the movements of your package scroll down to the bottom and it should say which eye palette you got.

      • Delanet do you still want the Violet Voss?

      • I’m not sure what these posters are talking about. When I go to view the tracking info, it tells me things like the dates, locations, the size/weight of the package, and when I can expect it by. Nowhere does it say what the exact contents are.

  8. I just couldn’t say no to this one, so I resubscribed even though I’m still mad about the Boxyluxe fiasco from last year lol. I really want those brushes!

  9. I’m an eyeshadow palette addict! I have way too many face palettes, and if I get another black eyeliner I am going to cancel. I’d rather have that ugly orange lipstick than another black eyeliner. I really want the VV Palette, and I can always use the brushes. I love Dr. Brandt although I wish it wasn’t another mask. They do nothing for me. I recently found a site where I can just buy whatever makeup I want at a great discount. But I have to check it daily cuz the popular brands sell out super fast. Why settle for stuff you don’t want? Laura Gellar would be nice to get in this box.

    • Do you mind telling me what website you are talking about? I would love to go check it out!!

    • Anyone that wants this Violet Voss, please take it!! I need me Taste. Delaney, you still interested?

    • Does anyone want to trade the TooFaced palette for the Violet Voss ? I don’t use eye shadows outside of neutral shades, and i really like contouring, blushes, and highlighting, but not too much outside of natural eye makeup. Please lmk!!! I’m sure we can work something out!!!

    • Kathleen, if I get the mac lipstick I will gladly trade u for the eyeliner. And if I get the Laura Geller highlighter I will gladly trade u for the brow pen. I’m really excited to try both of those I’m just really hoping I get them. Fingers crossed lol.

  10. Does anyone know what the brushes are for? I tried to google it with no success!
    Thank you!

  11. I will be getting the boxyluxe this time. Will my box have all the things shown here in it?

  12. I just subscribed to Boxycharm for the first time and I’m super excited! I really hope I get the box with the Violet Voss eyeshadow palette because I absolutely love the color selection in it. I’d love to get the Tarte palette too. I don’t really want the Too Faced Face palette though, I’m trying to build my eyeshadow palette collection and I know I won’t use a face palette except for maybe once or twice. I am so so so excited to get the free Becca Hydra-mist Set and Refresh Powder. I do wish I hadn’t missed out on the Butter London Palette and brush set though

  13. Oh, wow, boxy! Excellent curation! Way better than my GBP.

  14. Billion dollars brows makes great products. I am hoping for the violet voss pallette as well, the colors look so fun and adventurous without being too ” out there”.

    • I’m hoping for the Violet Voss Palette too, the colors are absolutely gorgeous!

  15. Ooh, yay! I was worried, but they finished strong. I’m pretty excited about the brow pen! Great box!

  16. If anyone gets two faced I’ll trade I really want that one I love to highlight so much fun !!! Thanks

  17. Looks like a decent box 🙂 glad I’m not getting Luxe just don’t need a water bottle or curling iron – saving my money for IBU <3

  18. I used the code for resubscribing and it worked!

    • Me too- yay!

    • If I Resubscribe Ed ,do They Give you Anything Extra,Not Being Petty

    • Same!

  19. Does anyone know the rest of the spoilers for the BoxyLuxe? I’m super excited for this month’s box! 🙂

  20. I just got my box today. Best box EVER!!!! I received the VV palette, Dr. Brandt sleeping mask, Moda brush kit, Mac lipstick, and Laura Geller baked gellato swirl illuminator. Love my Boxycharm!!!

    • That sounds like great box!

    • That sounds like a great box! Mine has not even shipped yet….!

    • Nancy,
      That is the box I’m hoping for. What was your weight? I haven’t received a shipping notification yet but when I do hoping to compare 🙂

  21. Am I the only one that doesn’t want the Violet Voss palette? The Tarte one looks gorgeous. Wouldn’t mind the Too Faced one either. Why hasn’t my box shipped :’( Has anyone’s Luxe shipped yet?

    • Very few have shipped out since it’s only the 5th and there was a holiday in there, but some labels have been created. If you have Fedex Delivery Manager you can see if one has been created for you on the Fedex site

      • True. I’m forgetting it’s only the 5th. Just really want my box lol. I will try the FedEx thing. Thanks!

      • Haha I feel ya! The FedEx thing works really well. I get my label several days before Boxy sends me one

      • Just got my box today.
        It’s ok. Not thrilled with VV palette. Would rather have the Too Faced face palette. Anyone interested?

      • I’m with you, the tarte palette looks beautiful n even though I have so many I’m hoping I receive it. Also, agreed I don’t like the V. V palette either. My boxyluxe hasn’t shipped yet either And I’m hoping what I’m wanting I get because I’ve got so many brushes I’d like some different stuff. Hopefully the next boxyluxe (December) is a good Christmas for us charmers.

      • I will swap anyone who gets the vv palette I tend to get tarte

      • I already know I’m getting violet Voss and am not happy cause I wanted tarte

      • Delaney, I’ve seen quite a few people wanting to trade for that one if you scroll through the comments. Hope it helps.

      • I got the vv and would love to swap with someone

      • And who knows how the hurricane will effect the shippings now. So many canceled flights and stuff on the east coast. When I see all those poor people on the coast it puts my wait time in perspective ya know ? I’m not going to complain about my boxes. Hope everyone waiting for their box on here is safe 👍

      • Thank U:-) as I wait patiently for my box I thank the lord that we here on the east coast of florida was spared. My heart goes out to our Bahama friends and the whole east coast of the US as well as Canada! Dorian for not suppose to amount to much sure did leave a lot of damage in his wake!!!!

      • I got mine today was in perfect condition and i hot the vv

    • I don’t want it either VV :/ if I get it I’ll trade

    • Depends on which post you look at, lol. Some of the other BC spoiler posts are filled with “Violet Voss has less retail value than the other palettes!” & things like that.

      I hope the fact that some ppl really want the VV palette & some ppl really want one of the others means that a lot of ppl will end up getting what they want OR that there will be easy swaps to do.

    • My Luxe shipped out on the 2nd. It says expected delivery date is Thursday the 12th! Can’t wait!

      • Now THAT’S a box I’d love to receive! Oh, please let me get what you received! I usually get things I don’t use (and I filled out my beauty quiz too).

    • I don’t want the violet Voss either 🙁

    • No, I don’t want it either lol

  22. I have more eyeshadow than I could ever use. But that Violet Voss palette is so pretty! I’ll probably end up stalking the swap site for it.

    • What is the swap site?

    • Ugh i ended up recieving my box today and I unsurprisingly got the Violet Vox eyeshadow palette. I was reallly hoping for one of the two face ones. Ill swap with you if your one of those folks that got a face palette.

  23. I used the promo code for the Becca but there is no mention of it in my confirmation email. How do I know if it went through?

    • It should have told you that it was successful. I would email them.

    • Same here!! I contacted cs and they said I was getting the powder. But no mention of it on the confirmation email either, so I just hope they will send it! Fingers crossed!!

    • I used the promo code too and after I applied it it said it was succeeding. It doesn’t mention it in my confirmation email either but I’m guessing that since it said it was successful it worked.

      • I meant successful lol not succeeding 🤦‍♀️

  24. Thanks for posting it Liz!!! I am hoping for the brown pen, Hank and Henry and Violet Voss palette in my luxe. Fingers crossed

    • Definitely hoping for the VV, brow pen and liner in my boxylux!!!!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.


Get our newsletter

Be the first to know about MSA exclusive deals, news, and reviews