Allure Beauty Box Review + $5 Coupon – September 2019

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Allure September 2019 subscription beauty box review

Allure Beauty Box is a monthly beauty subscription from Allure Magazine. Each month they send out a mix of deluxe and full-size samples from mostly high-end brands. (It was named one of the best beauty subscription boxes by MSA readers in the 2019 Subscription Box Awards.)

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Edited 9/4 to add booklet photos!

About this Box

The Subscription Box: Allure Beauty Box

The Cost: $15 a month. Save with a yearly subscription.

The Products: Deluxe and full-size beauty and makeup samples.

Ships to: The US and Puerto Rico

Allure Beauty Box September 2019 Review

  • 1 of 7

  • 2 of 7

  • 3 of 7

  • 4 of 7

  • 5 of 7

  • 6 of 7

  • 7 of 7

    Let’s see what products are inside!

    • metallic tube of dewy highlighter with black writing

      1 of 4

    • open packaging showing domed head of stick

      2 of 4

    • 3 of 4

    • 4 of 4


      • white and blue tube and box

        1 of 3

      • back of packaging with info

        2 of 3

      • creamy white texture on glass

        3 of 3


        La Roche-Posay Lipikar Eczema Soothing Relief Cream, 5 ml – Estimated Value $0.37 (Buy 200 ml for $14.99)

        I doubt everyone will be thrilled with this product, but as someone who suffers from eczema, I was overjoyed to see it. I have these spots on my legs that literally stick around for years! I have to be very careful using lotions on them because they get easily annoyed and vengeful. This gentle cream was non-irritating, hydrating, and actually super affordable if I choose to buy more. I didn’t notice any redness reduction and it certainly didn’t make my spots start to fade or disappear, but it hydrated them without bothering them, so I consider this a win. Any other eczema sufferers out there? Have you discovered a holy grail for your patches?

        • acure scrub in white and yellow tube

          1 of 3

        • back of tube with info

          2 of 3

        • green textured scrub on glass

          3 of 3


          Acure Brightening Facial Scrub, 1 fl oz – Estimated Value $2.50 (Buy a full-size 4 fl oz for $9.99)

          Acure is one of those brands I like because the products are effective, affordable, and accessible. My local Target has a nice selection! This scrub looks a little unappealing when you first squeeze it from the tube, but turns a more pleasant green as you rub it onto your face. I like weirdly colored masks for some reason, so this just added to its allure for me personally. Unlike so many clay products out there I didn’t find it excessively drying, and my skin was really soft after I washed this formula away. This is a great choice for someone with sensitive or super dry skin who wants to exfoliate without being too abrasive.

          • clear bottle of shampoo

            1 of 2

          • back of shampoo bottle wth info

            2 of 2


            NatureLab Smooth Shampoo, 1 fl oz – Estimated Value $1.22 (Buy a full-size 11.5 oz for $14.00)

            Mmmmm! This shampoo smells like my favorite Japanese treat: yuzu! Think delightfully bitter citrus with an edgy bite. This shampoo works well too, and make my scalp feel super calm, but also very clean. This smooth collection is targeted towards dry hair, and as someone with exceptionally dry strands, I can verify that my hair was absolutely less frizzy and markedly shinier.

            • clear and white bottle of conditioner

              1 of 2

            • back of conditioner bottle

              2 of 2


              NatureLab Smooth Conditioner, 1 fl oz – Estimated Value $1.22 (Buy a full-size 11.5 oz for $14.00)

              This conditioner was stellar, just like the shampoo. The amazing scent was a little more demure in the creamy base of the conditioner, but it still smelled delightful. I used this exclusively on my ends because I do not condition my scalp and I loved the smoothness it added to my hair after I let it air dry. I tend to be a Davines enthusiast, but this pair might make me branch out to a new brand for my daily shampoo and conditioner, especially at this great pricepoint!

              • nars lip pencil and box

                1 of 2

              • lip pencil with fresh tip

                2 of 2


                Nars Velvet Matte Lip Pencil in Dolce Vita,  0.08 oz – Full Size! Retail Value $27.00

                (Subscribers will either receive this or Laura Mercier Translucent Loose Setting Powder

                I own a few of these pencils and I already know I love them. My fave by far is ‘Dragon Girl’, a vibrant and glamorous red that sometimes leans neon depending on what I am wearing. This color is a little more subdued, but still magical on my face. It is kind of like my natural lip color but oh, so much better! The beauty of these pencils is that they are more of a sheer formula, and very buildable. They also have this powdery matte finish that is somehow not drying at all. If you are a fan of the Korean cloud velvet lipstick trend, these are probably worth a try for you too!

                I love you.

                Verdict: This Allure box has a total value of around $58.31, which is great for a $15 box. I was so tickled with the NARS lip pencil that would have been enough to justify the whole thing, but I am glad the shampoo, conditioner, scrub, and cream were also big hits for me. I am less enthused about the glow stick, but perhaps I am using it wrong or maybe it is just not built for my makeup style. All in all, I really enjoyed this month’s box and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a well rounded and very fun beauty box subscription.

                To Wrap Up:

                Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Yes! Scroll down this page to see what items you will get when you first sign up.

                Value Breakdown: At $15 for this box, here’s what you are paying approximately per item:

                • Ciaté Dewy Stix $6.69
                • La Roche-Posay Cream $0.10
                • Acure Scrub $0.64
                • NatureLab Shampoo $0.31
                • NatureLab Conditioner $0.31
                • NARS Lip Pencil $6.94

                Alternatively, each of the 6 items has an average cost of $2.50.

                Check out all of our Allure Beauty Box reviews and some more of our other favorite beauty subscriptions. 

                Swap for any item in this box from the Allure Beauty Box Swap page!

                Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

                What do you think of the September Allure Beauty Box? What was your favorite product in the box?

                How do subscribers rate Allure Beauty Box?

                613 subscribers rated this subscription
                out of 5 stars
                Customer service
                Retail value
                Quality of products
                Ease of canceling

                Do you subscribe to Allure Beauty Box? Add your rating now!

                Written by Megan Kirkland

                Megan Kirkland

                I love natural/vegan beauty products, Korean skincare, unique jewelry, and weird candies from far away places. When I am not waiting for my next exciting box you can find me painting or taking photographs of interesting people. I never leave home without pug hair somewhere on my shirt and a bold lipstick on my smile.

                Posted in Allure Beauty Box Reviews, Beauty Subscription Boxes, Makeup Subscription Boxes, Subscription Box Reviews, Subscription Boxes for Women| Tags: allure beauty box | 47 comments


                1. I got my box today and, yay, got the powder!

                  Now if the Amazon box has the pencil, I’m golden.

                2. Has anyone received theirs from Amazon yet? I ordered it on the 2nd and haven’t received anything which is odd because it usually comes quickly from Amazon. Then I got an email today saying my subscription was cancelled. But I didn’t cancel it? I really wanted the Nars lip pencil, but I think this is the universe saying I don’t need it.

                3. Glad to see they’re back to a box. Much more useful and eco-friendly. I’m looking forward to trying the Dewy Stick. I do minimal makeup on the weekends and think it will be a nice addition. I hope I get the Nars pencil since I’m getting a full-size finishing powder in my Glam Bag plus. But if I do get the Laura Mercier, can’t really complain about having that as a backup.

                4. Megan have you tried the LXMI balm in your legs? I hate the smell but fir some Reason that stuff worked miracles on my eczema yet any other Shea butter makes my legs very vengeful and angry as you put it…And thanks to multiple Epsie subscriptions I have enough tubes of that stuff to last a lifetime

                  • Oh! I haven’t! I think I have ever only tried their lip balm, and I did love that. Adding the actual balm to my shopping cart now. Thanks for the rec! I will try anything at this point!

                    • Megan,
                      I have eczema on my back. My dermatologist suggested CeraVe and it has worked better than any prescription I’ve tried. It’s packed with ceramide’s. You can get it at any drug store.

                  • I have really bad eczema-like dry patches on my hands one winter (never got it diagnosed, but no regular lotion would help) until someone suggest Eucerin fro eczema and it worked within days.

                5. Still never got my July “free mystery gift” which was the F.A.B product. I called in twice and they promised to send but I never got it. Probably pointless to call back in September, though.

                  • I never got mine!! Almost a year ago. I called every 3 months and finally gave up lol

                    • I paid for 2 subscriptions and never got one

                6. Really skimpy box, in my opinion, both in products and size of them (.17 oz for two of them? really??). Very disappointing with no great “wow” that I am used to feeling when I get my Allure box. Are they tired of curating boxes and want to get out of the business or what?

                  • The shampoo and conditioner are 1.0 oz apiece, as is the scrub.

                    The LaRoche Posay is .17, so that’s a little disappointing.

                7. Skipped and happy. October looks much better.

                8. I so want that NARS Lippie.
                  Does anyone know if the amazon boxes come with them or the powder?

                  • I believe someone posted on reddit that the amazon box comes with the NARS lippie.

                  • If you look at it on Amazon it says you will receive the Nars lippie.

                  • If you get the powder, and I get a lippie – I’ll trade you. I have way too many lippies (this color looks beautiful though!)

                    My swap profile should link through if you click my name.

                9. The ciate london dewy stick I’m extremely excited about! This stick is Allie Glines new obsession shes been using it like for the past few months and it looks stunning the way she uses with a full glam face! I can’t wait to try this out, and the nars!

                  • Jamie, curious about how this Allie applies but admit I like to boomerang beam as light hits my cheekbones and sends signals across the universe. I am not seeing how this works based on the Allure email video for this month’s unboxing. Thanks

                10. Cancelled a couple months ago and don’t regret it one bit. The boxes just aren’t what they used to be anymore.

                11. I am not impress with this months box neither,and the value of this months box is so low….So far this year all of the boxes have had a value of 75.00 and up,this months box does not even hit the 60.00 mark…And the products are not that great neither,the two full size products are not for me,as I can not wear any shades of red in lippies,and the Ciaté London Dewy Stix is not foe me neither….I do like all the little sample products but they are little and not worth much….Oh well I guess you have to have 1 or 2 boxes a year that is not that great,hopefully next months and the the rest of the year will be amazing boxes to make up for this one.

                12. This an okay box! Nothing grand and nothing bland. I hope I get the translucent powder. Because of subscription boxes I have over 100 lipsticks. I’m always excited for shampoo and conditioner because I travel a lot for work.

                  • I’m actually in quite the opposite situation i have way too much setting powder so another one would just go to waste i could never have enough lipstick.

                13. I am pretty new to Allure (this will be my 4th box) but so far I’m happy. At the price point I feel like if I receive two items I like then it’s worth it – especially love the full size items. The Huda box was a miss for me (if only I were glam enough for red lips and falsies) but otherwise I’ve found most of the products to be useful or at least fun to try so not a waste. I use to get Birchbox and found that I was using very few of the samples and also felt like a sucker paying for a box of (exclusively) samples every month – the cute boxes were my favorite part of each month’s package and they alone are not worth the $10/15.

                14. I’m glad that Allure sends basically the same box to everyone. That way I know to pause after I see the spoilers. I skipped September. I wish I could tell what I was getting in the Sephora box, in time to skip.

                15. I have the shampoo and conditioner from a previous Ipsy offer and now I am super excited to try it thanks to this review! I have frizzy hair so hopefully this makes a difference.
                  I do wish allure wouldn’t do variations, that was why I selected this box in the past; good brands and no variation to be disappointed over.

                16. I am glad I skipped only thing I like is Nars pencil. Bring on more October spoilers!!!

                17. this looks ok to me…can’t wait to get it..

                18. Love the look of the pencil. Always up to trying new shampoos.

                  • The pencil was the highlight for me. It is so easy to wear and I already knew I loved the formula.

                19. IMO this is a ‘meh’ box. Not terrible, not wonderful. Still more useful for me than false eyelashes and bright red lipstick.

                  I do wish that Allure would quit the variations though. I remember back when they didn’t do them! Ah, those were the days. I’m not a fan of being bummed because I was unlucky and got something I didn’t want. I’ve got Ipsy for that lol.

                20. I’m happy to see a different box and no plastic bag. I have no regrets on skipping this month though.

                21. Hope I get the lip color and not that powder.

                22. I love the dewy stick! I have it in gleam so I’m happy it’s the glow in the box. I think it’s better suited for someone who likes a more bare face. It gives a nice dewy/wet look. If you’re applying over powder try swiping the stick with your fingers and rolling it over your cheekbones. I like to wear mine over my Nudestix and apply it to my eyes as well for a gloss look. I wore it all weekend and got so many compliments that I looked really pretty lol.

                  • I like the idea of using it on my lids! I will have to try that. Patting it on with my fingers still wasn’t ideal for me. I need to quit the powder!

                    • Haha, You could also use it on your shoulders and collar bone.

                  • Thank you Kay for a great tip! I will definitely try it on my eyelids.

                    I don’t have eczema, but will never complain about receiving a gentle moisturizer. This looks like a solid box to me. Thank you Megan for the review. I can’t wait to receive the box.

                23. The spoilers had me excited but the review makes me sad. The Dewy stick seems like a pointless product can’t be seen can’t be used. The color of the Nars lippie went from a usable for me dusty rose color to another red to add to the giant pile of red lip products that won’t ever be used. The little eczema cream I was actually excited about for my daughter but it’s the tiny sample size that you can get at Walgreens for free, still good to throw in my purse but I was hoping it was a decent size. Welp looking forward to next month’s Sunday Riley etc 💙

                  • I’m confused because I own dolce vita and wore it on my wedding day and it was definitely a mauve! Maybe a bit warmer than some mauves but not reddish like it looks here. 🤷‍♀️

                    • Exactly on sephora it also looks mauve, hopefully a lighting issue maybe .

                24. Man I miss the 2018 Allure boxes! This year has been a complete letdown. I used to have up to FOUR subscriptions to Allure, and have not wanted a single box this year.

                25. Wow. So glad I skipped this one.

                26. Yay! No more plastic bags? Wahoo.

                  • I was thinking the same thing! Thank God they went back to the box! This box looks great. If the Ciate stick doesn’t work on the face, try it to highlight your collar bone and cleavage 🙂

                27. This box is just OK to me. I will pass. Too bad dewy stick doesn’t work. I will skip yet another month. Think I skipped past 4. October is looking promising with the bum bum cream.

                28. My allure ways ships so late. Amazing how you got yours already. Nor very impressed by this boxes. Previous months were better for me.

                Post a Reply

                Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

                Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

                Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!



                Get alerts on your desktop for the best deals and spoilers!