Play! By Sephora July 2019 FULL Spoilers!


This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Play! By Sephora May 2019 Spoilers

We have FULL spoilers for the July Play! By Sephora box!

Here are all the products they are sampling this month:

  • Drunk Elephant Slaii Makeup Melting Butter Cleanser
  • Drunk Elephant Bamboo Booster Physical Exfoliant
  • Indie Lee Brightening Cleanser
  • Isle of Paradise Self Tanning Drops
  • REN Clean Skincare Ready Steady Glow Daily AHA Tonic
  • Dr. Dennis Gross Ferulic and Retinol Triple Correction Eye Serum‎
  • Caudalie Vinopure Natural Salicylic Acid Pore Minimizing Serum
  • Kiehl’s Ginger Leaf & Hibiscus Firming Mask
  • Korres Greek Yogurt Foaming Cream Cleanser
  • Wander Beauty Baggage Claim Gold Eye Masks

  • Bite Matte Creme Lip Crayon in Glacé
  • Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Primer
  • Lancome Bi-Facil Double Action Eye Makeup Remover
  • Shiseido ControlledChaos Volumizing Mascara Ink
  • Becca Shimmering Skin Perfector Pressed Highlighter in Champagne Pop
  • Clinique Take Take The Day Off Makeup Remover For Lids, Lashes & Lips
  • BeautyBlender blendercleanser solid pro

  • Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Triple Detox Shampoo

  • Prada Candy
  • Juliette Has A Gun Not A Perfume
  • Marc Jacobs Daisy Love Eau So Sweet
  • Atelier Cologne Clémentine California Cologne Absolue Pure Perfume
  • Dolce and Gabbana Light Blue

And here’s one version of the box some subscribers will receive:

  • Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Primer
  • Drunk Elephant Skin Care Slaai Makeup-Melting Butter Cleanser + Bamboo Booster
  • Indie Lee Brightening Cleanser
  • Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Triple Detox Shampoo
  • Marc Jacobs Daisy Love
  • Becca Shimmering Skin Perfector Pressed Highlighter in Champagne Pop

What do you think of the spoilers? Which ones do you want to sample? Subscribe by July 11th to get the July box.

Play! by Sephora is $10 a month. Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

How do subscribers rate Play! by Sephora?

552 subscribers rated this subscription
3.7
out of 5 stars
Shipping
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Curation
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to Play! by Sephora? Add your rating now!


Written by MSA

MSA

My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in Play! By Sephora Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: play by sephora | 118 comments

118 Comments

  1. Pics are so misleading. My MILK primer only had enough for 1 small pump. Def not full like the picture showed 🙁

  2. Allure sent out the Becca highlighter mini compacts a few months ago and I think all were crushed. Becca apparently doesn’t put a lot of thought into protecting their product.

    It’s really not Sephora’s fault since so many of us had broken compacts before now in the Allure box, IMO.

    • I received broken Becca highlight too from sephora.

  3. My box arrived, and the Becca highlighter was smashed and all over the box. Was the only thing I was looking forward to. Contacted
    Sephora and they gave me 150 points. That’s it? Really? I have 2500+ points because they are always sold out of all of the rewards that are any good. This was my second month back after canceling, and I just canceled again.

    • That’s how I felt. And they only gave me 100 points lol

  4. So I was an original subscriber but I cancelled about a year and a half ago because of so many repeats. The spoilers for this month showed 2 Drunk Elephant products so I signed up again and got NO Drunk Elephant, 2 repeats, and the Becca came broken. I cancelled again 🙁

    • Same. Very disappointed. Canceled again.

  5. So now Sephora has changed what I am supposed to be getting in my play box on their webpage. I am not a happy camper to be getting 3 repeats in this box and a shampoo and perfume that I do not want. I will have to wait until I get the bag in hand to see what I really received.

    Why can’t they get it together? I thought that it was suspicious that multiple bags had the exact same contents.

  6. Box #973 is:

    Clinique Take the Day Off makeup remover
    Living Proof Perfect Hair Day triple detox shampoo
    Dr Dennis Gross Ferulic + Retinol Triple Correction Eye Serum
    Caudalie Vinopure skin perfecting serum
    Bite Beauty lip crayon in Glace’
    Juliette Has A Gun “Not A Perfume”

    Kind of annoyed about the Glace’ lip crayon. This is the fourth one I’ve gotten, and the color doesn’t look good on me.

  7. What’s going on with the play pass this month? Usually it’s included in the shipment email so I’m able to use it like a week before my box arrives. This month I got no email with the play pass and it’s not anywhere in the app either. So I guess I have to wait for the box to arrive and use the printed play pass in store. Annoying.

    • I just got my email on my box this month and the Play Pass code is PLAYISLAND, hope this helps!

  8. Am I the only one with box # 834? Anyone else?

  9. Hi, anyone know what box #822 is?

  10. Hello, does anyone know what is in box #694

  11. 🙄 my box #965 will be:

    Clinique makeup remover
    Bite Beauty crayon
    Caudalie pore minimizing serum
    Drunk elephant makeup melting butter
    Living proof hair detox shampoo

    • I have the same box. May I ask if you have pores or acne listed in your play profile? I don’t and I consistently get pore smoothing items or drying clay masks. If it’s an option, I’m guaranteed to get it. I have dry skin listed in my profile, so I don’t understand why I never get moisturizing items.

  12. I’m getting Box 005 for July 2019. I just saw in my account that it contains the following:

    Milk Hydrogrip primer
    Shiseido ControlledChaos mascara
    REN Clean Glow Daily AHA tonic
    Indie Lee Brightening Cleanser
    Living Proof Perfect Hair Day detox shampoo
    Atelier Cologne in Clementine California

    Honestly I’m just glad I got the Hydro grip primer I’ve been wanting to try; and the detox shampoo which I NEED. Everything else I’m not into…

    • I am getting 005 and my Sephora account says I am getting the following:

      BECCA Shimmering Skin Perfector® Pressed Highlighter in Champagne Pop
      Lancome Bi-Facil Double-Action Eye Makeup Remover
      ISLE OF PARADISE Self Tanning Drops in Medium
      Kiehl’s Ginger Leaf & Hibiscus Firming Mask
      KORRES Greek Yoghurt Foaming Cream Cleanser
      DOLCE&GABBANA Light Blue Eau de Toilette

      • My act. show s the exact same thing as yours! Excited to try the self tanning drops!

    • I’m getting box 005 too, where do I go to see what’s coming in my box? It just shipped today, this is my first box

      • I just go onto their site and in the search box I typed play and search and then on the left-hand side it says see current box and it will show you if you’re logged into your account

        • Thanks! That worked! I had seen someone list the spoilers for my box earlier and they matched the photos shown on the site! I hope I remember this for future months (which probably doesn’t matter anyways, since I always forget what I’m getting by the time I actually receive my box. lol).

        • Thank you! That worked for me on the app! My box #005 is the exact same as EmKays with

          Milk HydroGrip Primer

          Shiseido Controlled Chaos mascara

          REN Clean Glow Tonic

          Indie Lee Brightening Cleanser

          Living Proof perfect hair day triple detox shampoo

          Atelier Cologne in Clementine California

          I’m super excited for everything in this box!

          • wish i got this oneeeeeeee

    • Sounds like my box! 742!

    • There must be some variation on box 005. I am also getting:
      BECCA Shimmering Skin Perfector® Pressed Highlighter in Champagne Pop
      Lancome Bi-Facil Double-Action Eye Makeup Remover
      ISLE OF PARADISE Self Tanning Drops in Medium
      Kiehl’s Ginger Leaf & Hibiscus Firming Mask
      KORRES Greek Yoghurt Foaming Cream Cleanser
      DOLCE&GABBANA Light Blue Eau de Toilette

      I’ve been a subscriber for a couple years now and I think this is probably one of the worst boxes I’ve ever received. Lot’s of repeats.

    • We got the same box!

  13. Anyone have box 013?

    • I’m looking out for the same. I tried what someone else did by selecting current box after searching Play By Sephora on the website both on my phone and laptop but different items show up

      • Finally got it out of CS lol. Clinque remover, living proof shampoo, daisy marc Jacobs, dennis gross retinoid eye cream, bite beauty lipstick, UGH lol was totally hoping for drunk elephant or the isle of paradise

        • Ugh…and I just resubbed. I’ll be giving everything away expect the dennis gross 🙁

  14. Mine ends in #330 and I haven’t seen any of you mention that. Hmmmm.

  15. That’s my box. It appears that the box includes:

    Shiseido Controlled Chaos Volumizing Mascara Ink in Black Pulse
    Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Primer
    Ren Clean Skincare Ready Steady Glow Daily AHA Tonic
    Indie Lee Brightening Cleanser
    Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Triple Detox Shampoo
    Atelier Cologne Clementine California

    Not a bad box for me- I haven’t tried most of these items (I could do without the Living Proof shampoo). I was hoping to get either the Atelier perfume or the Marc Jacobs daisy.

    • I meant my box is 973 this should up under the wrong remark.

      I’m finding it curious that at least 3 boxes have the exact same items

  16. How do you find out your box number?

    • is your box # the last 3 digits of your order #?

      • Yes. Last 3 digits

        • Thank you. It looks like I am getting box # 161, anyone know which one that is????

      • It’s the lAst three of the item number not the order number. Usually you can’t see it on mobile and have to go to the website!

        • Anybody know what’s in box# 964

  17. Saved! I cancelled in May took the June box cuz it looked good but had a feeling they’re not worth a subscription as they’ll disappoint again so I cancelled right after and here they came up with trash once again. Glad I cancelled on time! Sephora has lost the game

  18. Does anyone know what’s in box 981? I haven’t seen anyone else post about having 981 :O

    • I’m wondering the same! I haven’t seen anyone but you with it

      • So I’m not 100% sure if this is accurate but I saw on the Sephora forum that we’re getting the Korres Greek Yogurt Cleanser, Bite Beauty lip pencil in the shade Glacé, Dr. Dennis Gross retinol eye serum, Caudalie Salicylic Acid Serum, Wander Beauty Baggage Claim gold eye masks, and a sample of Prada Candy perfume. If this is true I’m pretty happy with it, what do you think? 🙂

        • It seems to be a bit more skin care heavy than what I had hoped, but maybe it will be a pleasant surprise!

  19. Anyone know what’s in box #965? I’m really hoping for that living proof shampoo because I’m considering buying the full size and would love to try it first. Overall I’m liking the selection this month.

  20. I thought I was box #021 when I first checked, by my item number now appears to end in 973? Do they change the items mid-month?

    I’m fine with not getting #021 based on the spoilers (already have three Bite crayons, hated the Becca highlighter the first time they sent it), but any news on #973? (With my luck, I’ll end up with the Lancome makeup remover, which I already have about a dozen of from my GWP collection, the tanning drops for my not-capable-of-tanning self, and the Clinique remover, which Sephora sent me a few months ago. 🙂

    • That’s my box. It appears that the box includes:

      Shiseido Controlled Chaos Volumizing Mascara Ink in Black Pulse
      Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Primer
      Ren Clean Skincare Ready Steady Glow Daily AHA Tonic
      Indie Lee Brightening Cleanser
      Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Triple Detox Shampoo
      Atelier Cologne Clementine California

      Not a bad box for me- I haven’t tried most of these items (I could do without the Living Proof shampoo). I was hoping to get either the Atelier perfume or the Marc Jacobs daisy.

  21. Yikes! There are a LOT of repeats here…. more than usual. Entirely possible that majority of my box could be all repeats(that I still have).

    These are all great items, just depends how they are curated. However, it’s always more than worth the $10. Especially with summer traveling it’s nice to have smaller travel beauty items. Hoping for some new items next month.

  22. Box #005 – This is what I was able to find out in an online chat:

    We have to keep some of it a surprise! What I can see is you will be getting some really amazing skin care products. Including the Isle of Paradise tanning drops and Kiehl’s firming mask.

  23. I hate second guessing myself. I should’ve cancelled when the first spoilers came out. I waited too long and it automatically renewed. There’s so many new and exciting things that could be in these boxes. There are multiple items that are repetes recently.

  24. This whole spoiler thing is starting to really upset me. I have called, emailed and live chatted with different Sephora Customer Service Reps and they all tell me that they can’t tell me what’s coming in box #703, it’s extremely messed up that they tell some people what they are getting and then other people like me just don’t get to know. They either need to tell everyone what they are getting if they ask or not tell anyone

  25. So I called Sephora customer service and asked her if my box was #222 and she had no idea what I was talking about and that I got the “I” (“i” as in “India”) box. And this month it has:

    – Bite matte lip crayon (ugh)
    – Becca shimmering skin perfector
    – Living Proof perfect hair day triple detox shampoo (which will probably strip the artificial red coloring off my hair)
    – Kiehl’s ginger leaf & hibiscus firming mask
    – Korres Greek yogurt foaming cream cleanser
    – Prada Candy

    So basically I need to update my profile so they don’t know i’m in my 40s and maybe they’ll start sending me good stuff then, lol!

    • I’m getting the same. This is box #021!

      Excellent box!

  26. How do I know what my box # is? I looked at the item number on my last two Play boxes and the numbers were 2228021 and 2229061 so is my box # 222?

    • It’s whatever the last 3 digits are in the item number. SO whatever you see there is the box you’re getting this month.

    • Like someone else said, it’s the last three digits. So you had boxes #021 + #061

    • Your #021 is:

      – Bite matte lip crayon
      – Becca shimmering skin perfector
      – Living Proof perfect hair day triple detox shampoo (which will probably strip the artificial red coloring off my hair)
      – Kiehl’s ginger leaf & hibiscus firming mask
      – Korres Greek yogurt foaming cream cleanser
      – Prada Candy

  27. Loveee my box this month! Box #940!

    Products:
    *Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Primer. (Happy-Havent tried this yet)
    *Shiseido ControlledChaos Volumizing
    Mascara Ink. (So happy)
    *REN- Clean Skincare Ready Steady Glow Daily
    AHA Tonic. (Love this)
    *Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Triple Detox
    Shampoo. (This is just ok to me)
    *Indie Lee Brightening Cleanser. (Glad to try this)

    Bonus:
    *Atelier Cologne Clémentine California
    Cologne Absolue Pure Perfume. (They have really good smelling Cologne)

    • Both mine are 940 – thanks for the heads up!
      This is a bummer box for me. The milk makeup primer broke me out really bad, the shampoo & perfume I’ve gotten 100 times before. I’m already getting 2 roller lash mascaras from ipsy, and the cleanser & aha toner are kinda meh.

    • This is my box as well, and it’s supposed to arrive on my birthday. 😉
      I hope it does.. I really like everything, even the Living Proof shampoo!!

      Yay for fun months with Sephora!

    • You’re gonna love the hydro grip. It’s amazing!!

    • Ugh. I’m happy you’re happy, but #940 is another bust box for me. I really wanted to try that DE cleansing balm to see how it stood up to Farmcy Green Clean, but since I wanted it, of course I didn’t get it. So bummed, again. Looks like I’m canceling.

    • This also appears to be Box 973

  28. Is there a way to skip a month?

    • No. You’d have to cancel

  29. Im actually okay with the products this month… Just hoping that I don’t get a few of these products but other then that… Im happy!!!

    • Loveee my box this month! I am getting box #940!

      Products:

      *Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Primer. (Happy-Havent tried this yet)
      *Shiseido ControlledChaos Volumizing
      Mascara Ink. (So happy)
      *REN- Clean Skincare Ready Steady Glow Daily
      AHA Tonic. (Love this)
      *Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Triple Detox
      Shampoo. (This is just ok to me)
      *Indie Lee Brightening Cleanser. (Glad to try this)

      Bonus:
      *Atelier Cologne Clémentine California
      Cologne Absolue Pure Perfume. (They have really good smelling Cologne)

      • OMG this is my box – and I couldn’t ask for a better one!! Only one product I;m not interested in (the Milk Hydro primer -I have freakishly oily skin, tyvm), but I was MOST interested in the Shiseido mascara since I haven’t tried it and the LP shampoo and I’m getting BOTH! WOO! Thank you for posting! 😀

    • Soooo I literally just found this out && I loveee my box this month! Box #940!

      Products:

      *Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Primer. (Happy-Havent tried this yet)
      *Shiseido ControlledChaos Volumizing
      Mascara Ink. (So happy)
      *REN- Clean Skincare Ready Steady Glow Daily
      AHA Tonic. (Love this)
      *Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Triple Detox
      Shampoo. (This is just ok to me)
      *Indie Lee Brightening Cleanser. (Glad to try this)

      Bonus:
      *Atelier Cologne Clémentine California
      Cologne Absolue Pure Perfume. (They have really good smelling Cologne)

      • Sorry for the multiple posts… When I first post this, I didnt see my ad & tried posting it a few times. Thennn saw this morning, that it was actually posted. Tried to delete the second post, but couldn’t find out how to do that lol. Sooo sorry!!! 😉

  30. I cancelled a long time ago along with Ipsy & Boxy Charm.

    I save what $50 a month? I’ll buy from Sephora 1-3 times a year now.

    Bottom line is, at the moment I have too much make up.

  31. That is A LOT of duplicate products in the makeup section (plus the Wander eye masks were in Play! just a few months ago).

    That said… I LOVE that Bite lip crayon and the beautyblender cleanser. I actually bought two Play! boxes that included both in the Memorial Day sale. The BB cleanser is the best, and it goes for something absurd like $40 retail now, so I stocked up on them when they were basically $2-3 as part of a Play! box. And the Bite crayon is my favorite lip color out there right now – I wish it wasn’t Glace as I already have three of them, but I’ll use it.

    Overall, I’d pretty happy with most of this, preferably heavy on the skincare. I am unhappy that the bonuses are all fragrance as I can’t use those without sending my partner into an allergic fit, but I’m sure I have a friend who would use them.

  32. I’m glad I canceled! These are mostly all repeats ! I do like Sephora Play but they need to up their game a little bit more. Ipsy for the win!

    • I get both Sephora and Ipsy, and I tend to like Sephora just a little more. Sephora offers better brands and better quality products, but they don’t do much in the way of makeup (mascara, lip color, and primer) and are terrible with repeats (unless I like the product and then it saves me from having to buy a full-sized :). I get more makeup and variety from Ipsy, but I find the brands to be of lower quality and I get more things I can’t use at all from Ipsy despite the more detailed questionnaire.

      I get both to get the nicer skincare stuff from Sephora and the fun-to-try makeup and brushes from Ipsy.

      • I also get Ipsy and Sephora! I feel the same way you do about Ipsy having a better variety but lower quality products while Sephora has high quality products but usually only sends out the same brands and products. I tell myself that I have had it with both and I am going to cancel but I end up getting suckerd back in some How! Lol
        Hey, did you hear that people’s accounts on Ipsy was getting hacked some How? People are getting charged for items they didn’t order. I checked my accounts and it is fine but I am just giving a heads up so you can check your info and account.

    • I agree. I have found a lot of favorite products through Play but I am disappointed with the repeats this month. With all the product Sephora sells, it should be easy to avoid repeats.

  33. Mostly the same stuff again! Even the same lipstick shade…you’d think Sephora over anyone else would have the best variety and samples.

  34. I’m loving the skincare options this month. I was hoping the Juliette Has a Gun fragrance was Moscow Mule, because I just received a sample of that perfume (I can’t recall where though), and I LOVED it! It smells fancy to me so I want more. lol

    • Yesssss… Same here! Beautyfix thus month! 😉

  35. My perfect box would be:

    Drunk elephant cleanser or korres cleanser
    tanning drops
    Dr. Gross eye serum
    beauty blender cleanser
    milk primer

    I REALLYYYY want the milk primer and the eye serum- i love retinol and LOVE milk!

    also the bonus i would LOVE Juliet has a gun!

  36. I would love to try the Indie Lee cleanser, but I might just buy a small size (for $10) on their website, or on Follain. This subscription (which I haven’t tried yet) seems very perfume heavy. Is there a way to opt out of perfume?

    • Unfortunately, there isn’t a way to opt out of perfume.

      I recently purchased the $10 size of Indie Lee’s Brightening Cleanser as a filler item to get to the buy-in for the latest Detox Market bundle, and it’s actually a really decent size! It’s larger than the samples of Indie Lee cleansers I’ve received in boxes or gwps before (and what looks to be the size in this month’s Play box). I was pleasantly surprised by its size. 🙂

      • Thanks Luna, good to know! So far the only Indie Lee product I’ve tried is the CoQ10 toner, and I love it.

  37. A lovely CS rep named Carl gave me my spoiler. He was so pleasant! I’m getting box #759 :

    Bite Beauty Matte Crème Lip Crayon

    Clinique Take The Day Off Makeup Remover

    Caudalie Vinopure Natural Salicylic Acid Pore Minimizing Serum (excited for this)

    Kiehl”s Ginger Leaf & Hibiscus Firming Mask

    Drunk Elephant Slaai Cleanser deluxe + Bamboo Packette (Heard alot about this brand, first time trying it)

    Marc Jacobs Daisy Love Eau So Sweet ( was hoping to get prada candy or d&g light blue as i already have a marc jacobs daisy perfume)

    • Nooooo… I’m getting box #759 too.
      I’ve already got 3 Bite lip crayons in this shade. 1 like a Sephora birthday gift (on December) and 2 from Play by Sephora (this year). It’s not funny at all. I don’t need 4 same crayons…

      • I’m 759 too. Not thrilled about this at all. Really only going to keep this sub for the mo they points.

    • Did you call or email? I emailed for spoilers for box 730 and they didn’t tell me anything

      • Oops I meant box 703, I just tried calling and the woman I got connected to told me she has no way of seeing what’s in my box. Which is weird since I see people on here and other blogs getting spoilers from them all the time

        • I love when they tell you… I tried twice and they wouldnt tell me lol

          • I love when they tell me too. This is my second box. And this is the 3rd time ive asked for spoilers and all 3 diff CS rep tell me what im getting 😀

      • I messaged a customer service on the sephora site and they respond instantly

    • Actually happy with this box because I love trying new DE products. I bought the full size moisturizer after getting the sample for my birthday because it was so good. Also excited to try the other skincare products. Only one that I don’t care for is the Clinique.

    • I’m #759 too, and I’m super excited for this box. I love that it’s so skincare heavy, and that there’s two cleansing balms! (my most favorite skincare product) I don’t have that Bite Beauty lip crayon yet, so I really hope I like the color, and I’m sure I’ll love the perfume too since there are very few scents I don’t like.

    • Hallelujah I finally got the one item I was obsessing over….Hello Drunk Elephant come to Momma 🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗🤗! Thank you for sharing!!!! And Carl you rock for spilling the tea!!!!!🙊🙊🙊🙊🙊

      • HHa yasss! Carl is awesome

    • Loveee my box this month! I am getting box #940!
      Products:
      *Milk Makeup Hydro Grip Primer. (Happy-Havent tried this yet)
      *Shiseido ControlledChaos Volumizing
      Mascara Ink. (So happy)
      *REN- Clean Skincare Ready Steady Glow Daily
      AHA Tonic. (Love this)
      *Living Proof Perfect Hair Day Triple Detox
      Shampoo. (This is just ok to me)
      *Indie Lee Brightening Cleanser. (Glad to try this)
      Bonus:
      *Atelier Cologne Clémentine California
      Cologne Absolue Pure Perfume. (They have really good smelling Cologne)

    • #759, this is my box.
      Hello to my fourth Bite lip crayon in the same shade Glace. Sigh.

  38. Spoilers for #021

  39. I’d be happier about Bite Beauty if it weren’t the same shades over and over.

    • This. Totally.

  40. I wonder if ulta will every get into the monthly box game ? That would be interesting

    • I wish!!! I’d love it if Nordstrom’s would do it too as competition for Macy’s 🙂

    • I’d sign up for that in a heartbeat.

  41. I may be in the minority here but I am thrilled with the options this month. Newer to play (so none of them will be repeats for me) but I love the skincare items.

    • I’m thrilled with the products this month too! This is my first Play! box so it’s all new to me! I haven’t gotten any of these products in any of my other subscription boxes! I just hope I don’t get either of the eye makeup removers because I already own full sizes of both and want to try all new stuff

  42. I hope I don’t get the eye patches and the juliette perfume. It smells amazing, until it mixes with my skin. It smells terrible on me for some reason

  43. That Bite lip crayon in the same shade AGAIN?

    • I’ve already got 3 Bite lip crayons in this shade 🙂 1 like a Sephora birthday gift (on December) and 2 from Play by Sephora (this year). Hope not to get 4th 🙂

      • Same. I own three of those already, in that same shade, from the Sephora play boxes and Sephora’s Bday gift. I like lipstick and I have nothing against Bite products, but if Sephora insists on sending just ONE brand as part of their subscription boxes month after month, it’d be nice to try a different formula or at least a different shade, instead of the exact same product over and over.
        I hope we’ll get a good box with not too many repeats (I’m seeing lots of repeats for this month) and if we get the Bite crayon again I hope the rest of the samples will be new to us. 🙂

  44. I was thinking the same thing. Not much makeup but it’s summer and so many things get ruined in the heat. I wonder if that is a new strategy?

  45. Whoa, so many repeats. Urgh, i have horrible feeling im getting a whole bunch of stuff ive already had. There are some items i have not tried yet but the odds are against me.

  46. Wishing there were more “makeup” items 🙁 I may cancel this subscription

    • I might cancel too. Pretty much ALL these are repeats.

      • Hmm, I was thinking there were a lot of skin care brands I knew, but products I hadn’t tried. Only the last two skin care items on the list I’ve tried (and I like them both). I subscribe to try new things, so I’m interested .

    • I cancelled a few months back, and I’ve yet to regret it.

    • If you’re looking for makeup, I wouldn’t recommend Play!. I’ve gotten it for over a year now, and the “makeup” is mostly lip color, mascara, and primer. I think I’ve gotten two foundations and one tarte blush.

      • Typically, whenever foundation is an option, they always send it to me 🙁 I’ll take the lip color, mascara, primers, and blush any day though! 🙂

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

*

 
 

Get alerts on your desktop for the best deals and spoilers!