Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
We have a new spoiler for the July 2019 BoxyCharm! (Thanks for the heads up, Bev!)
(If you aren't familiar Boxycharm is a beauty + makeup subscription box that sends 5 full-size items each month for $21. It was voted the #1 Makeup Subscription Box by MSA readers, and won places in many categories in the 2019 Subscription Box Awards!)
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Not so excited for the palette, that’s a more fall color scheme. Would have been better to get something in the summer spectrum. Elemis I’m excited for though.. we will see with the next spoilers if I skip or not. I’m new to boxy and I’ve been told I came in at the wrong time because boxy has gone down hill in the last year. My friends have said before last year boxy is where it was at. Not to mention the horrendous customer service quality.
Reply
Helene Hansen
I ABSOLUTELY love the tarte palettes that’s why i joined boxycharm!
Reply
Nikki
I will re sub when I know what’s a variation and what’s not. I’m not getting my hopes up about the Elemis. I would be satisfied with that palette. If that palette is for sure. I’m signing up
Reply
Sandra
Oh my goodness… that green eyeshadow is exactly what I have been looking for. I really hope I get it! ♡♡♡
Reply
Britney
No NOMO here.
Reply
Audi
The palette seems okay.. but I do love Elemis products.. the 2 Elemis products we received in December Luxe and May Skin care box were amazing.
Reply
Luna
I’m still using the Elemis night cream that came in the Skincare box, and I’m in love! lol
Reply
Vicky H
Has anyone gotten the extra 125 charms Boxycharm promised for doing that survey?
Reply
Vicky H
Got my points today!
Reply
June
No! I’ve been checking my account lately. Wonder how long it takes to add them?
Reply
June
I feel like we could be getting the face halo makeup remover in a box soon. They’ve been on the boxycharm Instagram page recently and that would be a fun addition to the box in my opinion.
Reply
Tonya
Is this either or both in next months box I’d love both
Reply
Mary Holland
I’m not feeling this box so far. Unless the next spoiler is super awesome (which these are obviously the highlight items so I doubt it) I think I’ll be canceling for July and getting Ipsy GBP instead-I really want that Huda pallete they have for July. This eye pallete looks ok and decent quality and thank god it isn’t abother PUR palette but it isn’t cohesive, you would need transition and deep shades from another pallete for a lot of looks I think (depending on skin tone and desired look of course) and the mask is nice and a good brand but just isn’t enough to sway me.
Reply
Tammy g.
I feel the same way Mary…I have only had boxycharm for two months now but I’m not getting what I want…I’m so tired of eyeshadows..ugh..
Reply
Nikki
I’m gonna wait to get excited to see if those are variant items.
Reply
Chrissy
This is my birth month so I am excited for this box. (:
Reply
Nikki
Mine too!!!
Reply
CHEYENNE
The hairdryer in FabFitFun was the same size and less powerful. Boxy Luxe – 1200 watts, FabFitFun only 1000 watts.
Reply
tif
how about the glow mask?
Reply
Yessy
I am sooooooo excited for July box. This is giving me happy joy because the colors gives me a scream and I’m sure the palette is what I am looking forward too. The second spoiler is another great item to try. I think this box is gonna be a plus for me. 🙂
Reply
Holly Hansen
The palette looks pretty and I’m excited to try more butter london stuff because their power up mascara was good. Are these variation items? Or do we get both?
Reply
Nikkim
Love Elemis I have a couple of products by them but their veggie line smells terrible lol I’ll still use it though!
Reply
Deanna Whisman
Im obsessed with the palette. The blue and shimmery green are colors that i dont already have and I think its so pretty! I have ton of masks already definitly not a veggie mask! How fun!!! Cant wait to get the box!
Reply
Jerri
I wish we could get eye shadow palettes that weren’t predominantly shimmer shades. Mature eyes need mattes. There is only 2 matte shades in this palette.
Reply
Twyla
Who says mature eyes need mattes? I have mature eyes and prefer pretty shimmers 🙂 Then again I never was good at following rules that didn’t make sense to me, especially apparently random beauty and clothing rules (white before Labor day, or after or whatever anyone??)
😉 I think it is more a matter of personal preference than an age preference.
Reply
Nina
Shimmer shadows accentuate wrinkles more. While I still wear them sometimes I try to stay with the more matte shades. I guess if you’re older and are lucky enough to not have wrinkles, go for it! 🤷🏻♀️
Stephanie T.
I agree with Jerri and Jean. We’ve had far too much glitter and shimmer recently. I can’t carry either of them off.
Reply
Rainbow Moonchild
Says who? 53 and I always wear shimmers..to hell with the “beauty rules.”
Reply
Rainbow Moonchild
Says who?
Reply
Jean
I hear you. I do use shimmer a little but it has to be subtle. I have had success using some shimmery shadows as liner, using a wet angle brush. But it will probably take me a thousand years to use a palette using it that way!
Reply
Holly Machi
Love the Elemis but not a fan of the eyeshadow palettes lately. I am ready for some cool-toned palettes for a change! You can only have so much rust, peachy, and warm brown and gold shades. They don’t look great on everyone…especially me!! Let’s see some cool plums, grays, taupes, etc!
Reply
Janine
Amen! Bring on the cool toned palettes!
Reply
Zsu
Agree completely. If I get another warm nude palette, I might go ahead and cancel.
Reply
Angel
What happened to the glow recipe everyone was spoiling? Im assuming this and glow recipe will be a variation?
Reply
tif
yey~ same questions here! Glow is the only reason for continuing the subscription!
Reply
Irina
Elemis is always a win… if it’s not variation Nr239🥴
Reply
Dot
Elemis <3
Even though boxy drowns me in eyeshadow palettes I’ll never use and end up giving away bc no one will buy them even for cheap :/
I won’t leave boxy … 💕
Reply
Mc
Was going to cancel boxycharm this month since Ipsyplus has been stepping up its game but now that I see elemis I might just stay let’s see what else comes in the Box also not too thrilled about the palette shades but since is Butter London I’m willing to try if the rest of the box is a good one. 🙏
Reply
Jessica Harrison
Don’t get too excited I’m sure it’s a variation item. I’m so upset with them right now especially with the changes, 3 month wait on charm room orders. Making mistakes and blaming you for it. They used to be amazing
Reply
Miranda
Right and what’s up with the charm room items. There’s hardly anything ever anymore. When I joined boxy they had pages of good items. I have over $100 worth of charms sitting there because nothing I want is ever in there or the room is closed foe a month at a time with no items. They announced that it’d open on the 6th with new exciting items yet there wasn’t much in there at all and I checked as soon as it opened. My charms just keep building up. When I first joined I couldn’t get enough charms because there were a bunch of items I wanted. And they shipped them right away when I did get something. It’s ridiculous now. Really disappointed in them lately. Nothing like when I first joined.
Reply
Dani
I remember a while back they announced they’d add new items to the Charm Room every Friday afternoon. But then again, they say a lot of things….🤥🙄
Malia
I agree with not getting too excited. I was super stoked about getting to try the m.greengrass lotion and out of nowhere there’s all of a sudden a variation 😢
Reply
Cb
I have been so disappointed with them and it seems like they only care about getting new subscribers and not keeping their loyal customers
Reply
just.gretchen
Agreed! I have ordered from the charm room five times in the past two years and FOUR of the orders were either not sent, over a month late, the wrong item, or my debit card was charged instead of using charm points. Customer service is always very nice but the repeated issues really say a lot about the company.
Reply
Steph H.
What’s the 3 month wait on charm room orders? I didn’t know about that.
Reply
Laci
I might need to get this box 😍
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.