MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:

BoxyLuxe September 2020 Spoiler Round #3!

BoxyLuxe March 2019 FULL Spoilers!

We have FULL spoilers for the March BoxyLuxe box! 

One variation will include:

AND here’s a closer look at the color variations:

Becca Ultimate Lipstick Love – Retail Value $24 (Colors will vary)

CoverFX All in One Perfector Face Palette – Retail Value $45

What do you think of the spoilers?

If you sign up now, the FOMO box here will be your first box! (You must be a regular Boxycharm subscriber in order to upgrade to BoxyLuxe.)

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, the regular Boxycharm box is $21 a month. BoxyLuxe is a once-a-quarter upgrade option you can add to your existing $21-a-month Boxycharm subscription. So for an additional $28.99, you’ll get the Luxe items, and be paying a total of $49.99 for that quarterly box. 

Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in BoxyCharm Spoilers, BoxyLuxe Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 100 comments

Comments (100)

  1. Hello,
    I don’t think my post went through , but does anyone want to trade, I want a blonde eyebrow palette I’ll trade an Large
    Osea face wash or something else ? I really wanted that blonde eyebrow palette from boxyluxe .

    Thanks 🙂

  2. Hello All new here, but love sub boxes 🙂 I did enjoy this boxyluxe though , anyway I received the Iconic London Sculpt & Boost Eyebrow Cushion in brown way to dark for my blonde hair and skin, if anyone has the fair of cool fair color to trade I’d appreciate it 🙂 I also have nail polishes from several boxes and other stuff if anyone can trade me for a lighter eyebrow palette ? New to trading here if anyone can help thanks 🙂

    • same here but i’m pretty sure they only sent out the medium shade =/

  3. I’m so p***ed off!!!! The only reason I kept my subscription was for that Cover Fx palette. I’m in love with it and of course you can’t get it anywhere else. I just received an email from Joe that they sent the wrong color for my skin tone (I’m very, very fair) and that they don’t have any leftovers to replace it. There’s not a single thing I can do with the deeper palette. It really looks way to dark to use as anything other than maybe an eyeshadow and who doesn’t have a million palettes with those colors in them? I want to cry. I wanted that palette so badly. </3

    • Wow. Did he offer you something else instead to make their mistake right?

      • They are supposedly giving me charms on my charm balance so I can go pick from the two products they stock in the charm room that they couldn’t get rid of that also probably already came in a box I’ve already received. As of it, there are no charms added.

    • I’ve read where a lot of folks received the dark palette even though they are fair skinned. I haven’t received my box yet but I’ll be disappointed if I receive the dark palette.

    • Did you want the IT cream? That’s what I most wanted but I downgraded — I couldn’t cancel outright because I was locked into a 3 month sub. If you aren’t attached to the IT cream and I get the fair palette, which I should, I would totally swap with you.

      • Apricot, I’d be willing to swap it. 🙂

      • Yay!! I haven’t received tracking which I usually do but I expect my box will arrive in the next week per its usual timing. I will let you know when mine arrives if we are a go. My email addy just in case is Apricot Tarte @ gmail dot com.

      • I got my Boxyluxe today. If you got the fair palette and still want to swap for the IT cream, let me know! 🙂

      • Hi, Beverly. I still haven’t received mine nor any tracking. I did see the palette is now available on the brand website. My daughter expressed interest in the palette regardless of the shade so I’m torn. She spends more time outside than me so she thinks she could make either work. Hopefully this posts. I tried posting the other day but it didn’t take, maybe because I included a link.

      • No worries! I don’t blame her for wanting to use it. I will say that the colors in the darker palette are stunning in person. Thanks for the tip on it being available! Boxycharm had me under the impression that it was exclusive to them. I’ll still swap if you like, no pressure at all though, I can use the cream as well. Just let me know for sure either way. Thanks! ^_^

      • Oh Beverly, thank you for understanding. I’ve actually been pretty stressed about it and have been secretly hoping I just get the darker palette too so I don’t disappoint anyone. Definitely, don’t wait on me; I hope you can find someone else to swap with if you are still wanting to.

        I wish Boxy would have just got it right with people’s profiles. I’m thinking tho since CoverFx has officially released the palette that the other major retailers will carry it soon and everyone who missed out on their shade match will be able to catch it on sale and such. Best of luck and thank you again for understanding. <3

      • Hi Beverly, no news on my boxy other than it is delayed, however, my daughter has expressed interest in the cover fx palette although no telling which one I will actually get. I also wanted to let you know that it looks like it is now available for sale on the Coverfx website. Here is the link (hope it posts):

    • I’m right there with you. I very light also and got the email and received the dark palette. I also got a Red Becca lipstick which also conflicts completely with my color profile. What is the point if we receive unflattering and unusable products.

  4. Unfortunately, I have opted from the luxe box. I’ll still receive the regular $21 box. 😌 Hopefully, the next luxe box towards the summer, will WOW me!😝

  5. This box looks really great. I will so bummed if my palest fair skin self gets the warm palatte though. There’s no way I could pull off any of the shades in the darker FX palatte and 2 of the 4 Eye palettes. I already expect to trade the lipstick but I have too many already. I will be thinking happy thoughts and crossing my fingers for the fair/cool shades!

    • Be sure to fill out your beauty profile. They will be using that to determine which FX pallet you get. There is a question in the beauty profile about your skin tone/color.

      • I have been a member for over a year with BC and then BCLuxe. I filled the profile but wasn’t sure if they really use it. Some of the colors I have received have been for medium Caucasian complexions. I have always had an extremely fair complexion thanks to my Britain’s Isles , German & Swedish Ancestry. I dveloped severe anemia due to kidney failure a few years ago and went from fair to palest pale. I’m really hoping for the pale Cover FX and Brunch Babe palattes. Otherwise this will be a total bust for me. Keeping my fingers crossed & thinking happy thought!

    • They finally have customization for this product! Take the ‘quiz’ under The Box tab on their site and it’ll allow you to pick your skin shade for the face pallette 🙂

  6. i have searched and searched, how on earth do i find the REGULAR boxycharm spoilers???
    I’ve only been subscribed for one month and i’m eager, this sucks 🙁

  7. I am actually excited about this box. The only thing I may not use is the lipstick because usually their lipstick colors are complete crap. But I am so down for the rest of it! I love Lily lashes, IT cream, eyebrow shadow, nail polish, etc. I wish the colors were actually customized to us, because then I would be happy for the lipstick too, if I got red or neutral colors. This berry stuff I have been getting, or the nasty burnt orange is just not my thing.

  8. Currently rethinking my decision to opt out of March’s Boxylux….. 🙁

  9. I wonder how many of these products will go to the regular box. December made me feel like there was not much difference as a lot of the products went to the regular box.

  10. I’m pretty pleased with the items as long as there doesn’t end up being a last minute variation addition. It sucks when you get excited for spoilers , but last minute variations pop up. The spoilers can be misleading when that’s not the items you receive.

    I will say while every item is worth my money and will get use , its not as exciting as the previous two.

    I’m excited for the moisturizer , brow product , mask and nail polish.
    The eye shadow and lip products depend on which one I end up with.

  11. I have been subbed to Boxycharm for over a year now and I was able to get boxyluxe when it first launched. There has been months that I would have skipped if possible but instead I gifted the items I didn’t use to someone who would. I feel like no matter what they put in the box there are always going to be people who can and can’t use different things. Makeup is all personal preference so just because you don’t like something doesn’t mean someone else won’t love it. I personally can’t wait to try the things in thi specific box. I also really enjoyed February regular Boxycharm. But I also know there are people that aren’t as excited or didn’t love this months regular box. Every single subscriber is not going to be ecstatic every single month… I don’t understand why people are complaining so much. For the price you pay if you enjoy even 2 things out of the box it makes it well worth it. Just my opinion!

  12. Pretty meh here. The money value is there so the items in would buy on my own at Ulta or Sephora cover the cost easily. Still deciding if this is a fit for me. The first box was great and then each luxe has been a little less each time

  13. WAIT…where are those 2 brushes on this list? Are we actually getting both?

    Overall, I’m actually pleased with the contents this month and since it is my Birthday Month…that means a lot to me. Here’s to, long may you live (even when I leave due to product overload).

    • I was wondering the same. I hope we get the brushes too😊

  14. Do we know yet what is going to be in regular Boxy? I wonder if the IT cream will be in there.

    • They usually release that info the day or day after payments go through…

      • Good to know, thank you.

  15. Cancelled completely. I loved the September and December Luxe boxes, but this one isn’t for me.

  16. Fingers crossed I get Brunch Babe palette and Blaze lipstick.

  17. I’m excited about the IT Cream, the brushes (even tho I have a gazillion already) and, the BoxyCharm Iconic logo bad, I think its cute. The rest will go into the reproducing gifting stash. And, I will be over the moon if I actually get a lipstick color that works for me. I’m ever searching for the hg my-lips-but-better shade.

    • bag* lol

    • The Iconic is actually the brow cushion we are receiving as opposed to the logo on the bag. It’s kind of an odd choice of product placement!

      • Oh! I see it now, thanks for pointing it out, lol.

      • No worries lol!

    • I just canceled my BoxyLuxe. This edition looks to be a great Instagrammer compilation box but not a good fit for me personally.

  18. The nail polish is a variation… the other variation is cuticle oil and a nail file instead valued at $30ish.

    There aren’t even words…

    • Oh no…I hope I get the nail polishes. Those are shades I LOVE!

    • 😆😆😆😆
      So glad I opted out of this one!

    • Liz, I haven’t heard of the variant in this. I thought all Luxe boxes got the nail polishes. Can you clarify?

      • They announced the variant on their youtube unboxing.

  19. Is there something in the bag or is it an empty bag? Also, I keep seeing people say they will get Ipsy GlamBag Plus. Isn’t there a huge waitlist or even a closed list now? If I knew I could potentially get it without getting months of $10 bags I’d consider getting it with regular Boxycharm instead of boxyluxe.

    All that being said, it does seem like the boxyluxe value is going down hill even if it’s similar $ values. There are some things I’m excited about and others meh. I’m pretty unhappy about lashes and brow products in the same box as well as single brushes. I also have way too many bags from previously subscribing to Ipsy and Macy’s. I even gave a bunch away! I keep getting them from Ulta too! I’m meh about Morphe but I will regift it. I’m meh about the cover fx palette. Since it’s an exclusive I don’t know the quality yet. The highlights seem too dark even on the pale version. It could be great for travel or mediocre like the pur one.

    Things I’m happy about… Wander face mask will be fun to try. I always like masks! It moisturizer. Becca Lipstick is it is those colors. I am excited and happy it’s a 2 pack of nail polish. One is a pretty mauve… I am wearing a similar color that I need to replace because it’s old so that works out really well. Btw it looks ugly in the spoiler photo but is really pretty if you look at it out of the bottle on the website. I hate Essie bottles too because it distorts the color… even if it’s pretty you wouldn’t know!

    Also what happened to the other 4-5 spoiled items… I thought for sure we’d be getting that green tea scrub or face mask roller!

  20. Not excited about the makeup bag lol,however I haven’t tried any of these brands except deb lippman polish and some moda brushes that came in boxy.
    I’m still not sure that I understand the value though,if you don’t count the bag it’s 9 full sized makeup/skincare items and it’s $50 bucks but I could just buy 2 boxes and receive 10 full sized items for $42 plus tax?
    Oh right that’s probably why they have started giving us trial sizes in regular boxy.

    • and the chances of repeats would be greater…

    • I don’t feel they are trial sizes because you can buy them at Sephora in those sizes. Just my opinion.

    • Boxy promises 4-5 full size items in the regular boxes. The “travel sizes” (which are still pretty greatly sized, in my opinion) are bonuses to me. As long as they meet the 4 full size and $100 promised RV- they are giving us what we’ve signed up for. But, like someone else said- you would also get 3 repeats since every box has 3 items that everyone gets.

  21. This is such a well rounded box imo, especially figuring in what we got for Feb. I’m happy I’m getting it.

    That being said, it is my grand finale of getting Boxycharm (and all boxes). I have hit the threshold of too much product to ever go thru in a lifetime.

    …I probably hit it 6 months ago, but I’ve been in denial 😉

    • Actually, I think that’s the Luxe box….

      • Yea I am aware 🙂 thanks

    • Kim, I think I love you! 💖

  22. Yaaay big brushes. I’m officially in and happy for this one. The It cream and brushes are things I am excited about and needed, so that covers the $30 luxe upgrade right there and makes it worth staying for.

    The rest fall into three categories

    Fun things to try:
    Iconic eyebrow cushion
    Cover FX Palette

    Useful, if not fun:
    Wander Beauty Peel Off Mask
    Deborah Lipmann polishes

    Seriously Can’t Use:
    Fake eyelashes
    Becca lipstick (just assuming it will be a garbage color on me)
    Morphe palette
    Makeup bag

    So, all in all, this works out. There’s even a chance I won’t get a garbage color of lipstick and can actually use it, but I’m not getting my hopes up.

  23. Another bag ? We got a.bag in December lux box didnt we ? With that phone charge that didn’t charge anyyhing lol . Most of us need another bag like a hole in the head .. not hating by any means just think any of us could of thought of anything other then a bag for the lifestyle item .

  24. Will everyone receive these items ( I know we will receive different shades for some) or will there be multiple variations like the regular box?

  25. Love it! It’s been over a year since I’ve received a large powder brush!

  26. I was not excited at all about the December luxe but here I am excited for this one. We are all truly unique people with different preferences, I love it! 😜

  27. Hard pass.

  28. I’m really happy MSA posts the spoilers. I debated trying to sign up for Boxy Luxe and I have yet to feel as though I should try based upon spoilers and reviews. This “upgrade” would do nothing more than upset me about how I spent extra money. I continue to be pleased with my regular Boxy sub box. This upgrade does nothing for me. Thank you for making me feel like I actually am making a good decision for myself and wallet.

  29. You have to go to their website and fill out your beauty quiz in order to get the right shades for you. There is a link under the tab labeled box. I also just saw another variation on IG couldn’t make out what it was though.

    • They don’t actually use the quiz info. My experience is that they send mostly medium warm shades. I need cool shades, so most of what I get is completely worthless. Receiving the appropriate tone would be a tremendous improvement

      • They are using the quiz for the first time in March. Yosef announced it.

      • They are using it for the face palette only, I believe. I’ve asked them on different social media platforms if they’ll use it for other items, and they won’t respond… so I take that as a no.

      • Yup, they are using the beauty quiz this month, specifically for that palette

  30. Decent variety, but I can’t stand how many variations there are; there’s only one Morphe pallet I would use, two lip colors I’d wear, and no telling what color eyebrow thing I’d get since they don’t know my eyebrow color…. I cancelled. If they ever offer customization in the future, I’d consider signing back up.

    • This box was supposed to be the one you do the quiz for. I have to admit I’m skeptical that it won’t be a crap show based on the LE box and Luxe launch. Hopefully they tested this before roll out.

    • Same. I cancelled as well.

  31. I canceled this and will just be keeping my regular Boxycharm…there’s nothing that I can’t live without. It’s still a good value for others…just not for me.

  32. I just upgraded to boxyluxe and on the site it said I was added to the ‘line’ and after I received an email saying I’m at the front of such line. Does anyone knows if I’m getting the box or do they send another email confirming that? TIA everyone!

    • They don’t actually update your account to “subscribed” until you are billed. It sounds like you are all set!!

    • When I got moved from the waiting list but wasn’t billed yet it said “front of the line” too and then I got the box in December.

    • They wont send you e-mail with notification that you are off the list, but, you will know when they do the billing (at the beginning of the month). You will get e-mail with invoice.

  33. Downgraded. Nothing impresses me. Remembering why I canceled Boxycha rm last year. Depending on the March spoilers for the regular box, I may be canceling again. I think Ipsy GBP is a much better option for me. Grateful for the spoilers so I didn’t wind up with a disappointing box.

    • Same. I’ve been subscribed to Boxy on and off for 4 years. Sometimes I cancel for financial reasons or because I don’t care for the products in the box. I just cancelled Luxe. There’s nothing in the box I really want except the brushes and IT Cosmetics cream. I have way too many palettes. I don’t need anymore. I’m going to give the regular box a couple more months and then I may cancel. I’ve been loving Ipsy Glam Plus. I think it’s a lot better and there’s products that I’ll actually use.

  34. I want that Wander mask so bad, but not enough to re-subscribe. Anyone looking to trade let me know.

    • I would. I don’t think I would use it

    • I’ll be swapping mine

  35. There is not one thing I want from this box. The IT moisturizer would be ok but it’s so rich it makes my skin break out. Everything else is generally so brown- ugh:(
    Going to downgrade or cancel.

  36. Not to exciting I like a few things not sure if I want the luxe this time around.

    • Same. I really like the brow item, the lipstick, the Morphe palette, and the nail polish. I’ll use the face moisturizer. I don’t mind getting another makeup bag, even though I have too many of them (mostly thanks to Ipsy). I was happy to get the December Boxyluxe, but I’m not sure if I want the March Boxyluxe or if I want to downgrade back to the regular Boxycharm.

      • Never mind. I just downgraded back to the regular Boxycharm.

      • I agree with everything you said except the part about the makeup bag…IPSY’s are all too small for my stash, I need the larger EXTRA varieties. lol…I need volume!

  37. Looking forward to it! My first boxyluxe- you get so much stuff! Looking forward to the moisturizer and brow products.

    • This will be my first Boxyluxe too, and I’m super excited! (well, that’s assuming I get “in”, but from the comments it seems like I will). I’ll definitely be gifting the eyeshadow palette and lashes, and may gift the face palette (depending on how shiny the colors are), and most likely I’ll gift the mask only because I just received it in an Ipsy offer. Now I’m wishing I would have waited on the Ipsy offer because it included the mask and a set of Wander Beauty’s eye masks, and I just found out I’ll be getting a pair of those eye masks in my Play! box this month. Lol!

      • Luna, I will trade your palette

      • Hey Svetlana 🙂 I was actually going to gift it to my mom. She was swatching some Morphe palettes in Ulta a while ago, and really liked how they looked, but she didn’t get any. Based on all of the variants shown, I know she’ll love any of them…. plus, I already told her she’d finally have one in her hands in the near future. 🙂

  38. It’s not terrible but meeeeehhh not worth paying $51 for nothing I love or will use.

  39. Do we know which items are the variant items?

    • I want to know which ones are variant items too how do we find out?

      • The variant items are ones that have different color possibilities. Just read the entire article above.

    • Also, instead of the nail polish you might get cuticle oil and nail buffer of the same brand.

  40. I liked BoxyCharm ok, but I feel like they’re steering everyone to a very specific look, which ends in similar product colors and choices every month. I didn’t need anymore beige everything or fake lashes, so I switched to Ipsy GBP.

    • I have felt like that, for most of the time I was with them. (nearly 3 years). Their MUA all do their make up about the same. They send those items, a LOT. Not everyone needs or wants to do the same look, every day. They’re not very inclusive with who they have working there (as MUA) – who probably has a lot of input in what they choose to send.
      Anyway, that’s my 2 cents.

      • That brings much needed sense to the oft repeated neutral eye shadow palettes and brown lippies, highlighters, etc. Hmm.. BoxyCharm is a great value but perhaps not the best fit for me. On the other hand, I have been very happy with Ipsy and Ipsy plus.

  41. Liz, what of these products will also be in the regular March box besides the CoverFX palette?.. There is only a couple things I want and if they’re in the regular box then I’m going to cancel my upgrade LOL

  42. That’s a well rounded box. I am tempted, but cannot upgrade until I get rid of a subscription or two.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.