Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
So what are other spoilers for Charm, cause we got all the Luxe ones but I’m not participating in that this go around
Reply
Beth
I’ve been patiently waiting for the spoilers for the regular Boxycharm so I can decide to cancel all of my Boxycharm/Boxyluxe subscription, or just keep my regular. What’s the holdup? We need to know before the 1st in order to cancel before getting charged. Before the Luxe we would have had all spoilers for the regular Boxycharm by now 😡
Reply
Cheryl Brock-C
I cancelled Ipsy last month because it looked to me they were putting all of their attention into GBP and reg GB was just a dime store grab bag. All I was getting was miniscule samples of crap. I would have happily signed up for GBP but you need the golden ticket invite for that, can’t even get on a waiting list.
I guess I’m still at the stage where I am wowed by getting palates instead of tiny pans, but I am mostly happy. I wasn’t wowed by the BTS mascara, but I have ultra difficult lashes that hate anything that isn’t waterproof. Even with the waterproof top coat, it was a fail. My only complaint is the poop colored lips they keep sending me! I love Ofra and Smashbox, it’s such a waste that that they end up going to my niece for play makeup.
Reply
Annie
I didn’t think I’d be happy with this morning that box since it’s the first month they didn’t include a pallet (I owned absolutely no pallets except for cheesy drugstore ones before I joined BC) but I actually got the variation I wanted for the second month in a row.( So glad I didn’t get that tiny overpriced flat iron). I got the Farmacy face wash and the Trestique lippie in a pretty berry shade. I also got the PV highlighter in the shade I wanted. I’m finally on the list for the luxe, so mad I missed out on December’s. I’m not overly pleased with the spoilers for next month(I haven’t even used my lashes from November’s regular box) but the It moisturizer and the Morphe pallet have me still in. Hopefully there will be some better spoilers as we get closer to March.
They just announced on their Instagram that this will be for BoxyLuxe, doesn’t look like it’ll be for regular boxy.
Reply
Nicole
I just cancelled my BL last night😞But I still love em & still want(getting) my reg box, but now I wonder what’s in the reg BC for March🕵🤔, hmm!?!?!?
Reply
Chanise
Does anyone know if the Cover FX palette will be in the Boxyluxe box as well?
If not then I think I’d rather cancel my Luxe so I can get this palette! It looks so pretty! I’d rather have the Cover FX palette than the Morphe palette, the Morphe looks nice and I’d like to try the brand but the colours are very similar to the VV palette from December. And the Cover FX palette looks great for everyday and for travelling!
Reply
Nicole
When’s the last day we can cancel Luxe & not be charged…I’m STILL holding out for a few more spoilers???
Reply
Nicole
Scratch that, cancelled Luxe last night😩😢😞to open a spot for someone else but I couldn’t cancel the regular Boxycharm…I just can’t do it!!!!!!🤣🤣🤣I’m still in love with Boxy🤗😂😍It still does say “reactivate” in my acct so I’ll probably sign up for the next if it’s any better! & Joe does listen to us & I really believe in them & think it will only get better especially when they start to customize!!!!!! I have faith in BC🤗💗
Reply
Shelly
Canceling boxyluxe for march alsoon the verge of just canceling entirely
Reply
Jessica
Ouch! You can’t make everyone happy. These comments are hard to read. If this is for the regular Boxycharm I think this makes it a solid box.
Reply
Cady
Right ? I wonder what would make the majority happy ! Seems like no matter what we get there’s complaints.
Reply
Mel
Is it confirmed that this is for boxylux ?
Reply
Wendy
The first 3 spoilers for Boxycharm are in Boxyluxe… so yes, this would be in Boxyluxe.
Reply
xgirlmama
i just dropped luxe. They lost me with lashes.
Reply
Linda
Me to. Just canceled Luxe.
Reply
Merlisha
CoverFX and Lilly Lashes, I know it’s not everyone’s thing, but it’s mine! I’m excited
Reply
Melissa
Me tooo!!! I’m always happy with boxy…. no matter what we get it’s always a great deal!
Reply
Nicole
It is a great deal, yes, but how many shimmer shades & highlighters & red lippies can 1 have & not be using daily! With the GBP I’m using my products everyday & I feel like I’m getting my money’s worth with them & not so much with Boxy anymore! With that being said, I’d gladly give up my spot to someone who truly wants it & re-sub when I start to see things I’m going to use all the time as opposed to giving most of my items I get away!
Courtney
I actually feel kind of bad writing and reading these posts because if the people of Boxee are reading these they’re probably going OMG what can we do to make these people happy… So let me just say really awesome to see too faced in a box don’t really care about the primer but it’s a very nice change just really really tired of lashes bronzer highlighter and black eyeliner and sparkly eyeshadow pretty much everything else I’m fine with
Reply
LORI
I hear what you’re saying, but how else are they to know what their subscribers do and don’t want? I’m sure they’re well aware that they can’t please everyone, but if many people feel passionately about some products, I’m sure they want to know. Companies pay good money to get consumer opinions, we’re on here giving them for free!
Reply
NBW
You’re right Lori, It’s true!!!! 👏
Jessie Mendoza
I’m watching these march spoilers…I hope something phenomenal gets teased soon because it’s quickly looking like February is my last month
Reply
Wendy
Same. I’m still debating on getting the Boxyluxe, so far I’m thinking no. May be canceling at the end of February, awaiting more spoilers.
Reply
Anna G Barraza
I’m scared of getting boxyluxe and then regreting it for not getting the normal boxycharm 😑
Reply
Dani
I totally understand that. I strongly feel Luxe subscribers should get EVERY item in the regular box plus the extras. I don’t get why they can’t just do that. It kind of feels like a penalty for paying $30 more.
Reply
Denise
I could swear that’s what they said at the beginning but so much changes all the time I can’t keep up with the game anymore. And now since the wait list is gone and they have added so many variations there have been repeats and then they need to be fixed.. there needs to be a better system somehow. I have been with them two years. There’s no way I should have gotten more sheet masks. I would have been a prime customer for one of the other products. There’s no way they can look and say ‘oh she has gotten sheet masks everytime so send her a different product’. That’s what would keep it new and fresh to me. The value is there no doubt but month after month gets frustrating. I feel that is different than just saying a product stinks or sound snobbish. It’s not so much the products themselves as the repetition for me and the customization won’t work if you don’t want what is being offered in the box that month. Marches boxyluxe might be great for a lot of people but not me and I would rather give someone my spot that wants it than complain about what I get. A lot of people are complaining other sites about getting more mascara but at least you are supposed to use them within three months. Highlighters last forever. I just don’t need that many lol
Dianne
I’m not seeing anything interesting enough for this month’s and next Boxyluxe for me to reactived. January’s Boxycharm was so not exciting to me I don’t even remember what I got.
Reply
Cady
Lilly lashes are coming in march’s box too!! <3
Reply
Courtney
I’m definately out
Reply
Jessie Mendoza
yup. NO MORE LASHES PLEAAASSEEE
Maria
This is so disappointing. Not only do I not need this at all, but they only promised that ONE product would be based on our profile. So that means the brow product will be the same shade for everyone, most likely the medium brown. That’s way too dark for me and it’s the only product I like so far. I only liked one item in January, based on spoilers I’ll probably only get one or two useful things this month, and March Luxe isn’t even looking like it’s worth the $21, let alone $50. To me at least. I know the value is always there but it’s just not money well spent when you can’t use most things. Especially if you are already on product overload. I’m thinking Ipsy Plus will be enough to feed my addiction at this point. So far I’ve liked at least 3 products and sometimes all of them every month.
Reply
Vicky H
It’s not PUR 🙂
That’s positive and I don’t mind Cover FX.
I am a little meh about the BoxyLuxe so far… I don’t use brow products and don’t want Morphe (re-gifting) This cover fx is okay… the moisturizer I am excited about though. 6 products to go! I am hoping they haven’t spoiled the best stuff for Luxe. **fearful**
Reply
Wendy
Usually the best spoilers are the ones spoiled first, unfortunately. 🙁 I’m with you, only I am only liking the It moisturizer, and it’s just not enough to keep me subscribed. Here’s hoping something amazing is spoiled soon.
Reply
Arlena
Glad I’m not the only one who doesn’t use brow products . I don’t know why but those big bold brows just seem to look awful on me . At least I think i do .
Reply
Apricot
I’m right there with you. When I’ve tried to even slightly emphasize my brows I look like I have lost my mind. It looks so good though on other people. Maybe our features are pronounced enough as is.
Momo
Im glad its not PUR either-lol. March spoilers are not looking good. I have a Luxe sub and am looking to cancel at this point. All the complaints of brown lippies are reminding me of the 10 brown and 2 purple clearanced lippies Ive received (nvr used!). Im on overload and there’s no spoilers worth staying subbed.
Reply
Regina
Anyone else sick of the same old brands over n over?
Reply
Jill M
I definitely don’t see anything that’s gonna get me back on board. Been gone for two months now and IMO boxy can’t hold a candle to Ipsy GBP right now. I’m so happy and content with GBP and FFF right now.
Reply
pjatjdsmom
What’s GBP?
Reply
Maria
(Ipsy) Glam Bag Plus probably.
hippy4366
glam bag plus
Cady
This better be a palette everyone gets! I want it !
Reply
Tammy
So it has blush, countour, two highlights and a a finishing powder. This is a full face palette. I’m actually really excited to get this. It’s also Cover FX o I’m sure the quality is amazing.
Reply
Lori
Oh no, not another highlighter/contour palette. So tired of those. Ipsy is definitely winning me over, never thought they’d be so much better than Boxy!
Reply
Momo
Ipsy Plus was sending out morphe highlighter compacts and eyeko eyeliners 2 months in a row (Oct & Nov), needless to say ppl were pissed!!! The 1st Plus box was a complete bait&switch (nothing as advertised). Ipsy Plus is still advertising their subscription via email w/ products which in reality are not available to any Plus subscribers.
Reply
LORI
Trust me, I read about that fiasco every step of the way, which is why I’m surprised they were able to do a 180. I had bad luck with Ipsy last summer, cancelled and was very skeptical about the GBP. I was super happy with Boxy all last year, but boy, things changed quickly!
Rachael
I got an It Cosmetics Foundation brush, Maelle Bronzer, Tarte Eyeshadow, Purlisse Mud Mask, and Finding Ferdinand lipstick this month, all full size- no bait and switch travel size. My GBP has been awesome. Full sizes, great brands, personalization, and they really listen to feedback and survey us each month. Boxy just doesn’t care.
Michelle
Month 2 of the no buy and not sorry.
Reply
Barbara
Same here
Reply
Rachael
These are going to be entirely too dark for my fair complexion
Reply
MzBev
make sure you have completed your profile. They’re supposed to begin using those in March.
Reply
yvonne
where is the profile at on their site?
Jill M
Lol…they said they were gonna use them a month or two after we did the quizzes before the first Luxe box came out.
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.