Facebook PixelYarn Crush Subscription Review + Coupon - December 2018 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Yarn Crush Subscription Box Review + Coupon – December 2018

Krista Moore
ByKrista MooreJan 28, 2019 | 7 comments

Yarn Crush December 2018 - Closed Box Review Top

Yarn Crush
0 overall rating
0 Ratings | 0 Reviews

Yarn Crush is a monthly yarn subscription for knitters and crocheters! Each box features a different indie-dyed yarn, a pattern booklet, and a bonus extra item.

They offer two different subscription options:

  • Yarn Crush: $44.99 per month (save with longer subscriptions), for a full-size skein or a set of mini-skeins from an indie dyer, a pattern booklet containing knit and crochet patterns, and a fun extra item
  • Sock Crush: $34.99 per month (save with longer subscriptions), for a full-size skein or a set of mini-skeins in sock weight yarn from an indie dyer, two sock patterns (one beginner, one intermediate/advanced), and a fun extra item

This review is of the Yarn Crush box, $44.99 per month.

Yarn Crush December 2018 - Opened Box Review Top

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes).

Yarn Crush December 2018 - Open Box With All Items Top

About Yarn Crush

The Subscription Box: Yarn Crush

The Cost: $44.99 per month

ACTIVE DEAL: Save $5 off any subscription!

The Products: One skein of hand-dyed yarn, a pattern booklet (contains 6 patterns!), and a bonus extra item

Ships to: the US and worldwide

Yarn Crush December 2018 Review

This is my first month receiving Yarn Crush, and so far I am loving this box!

Yarn Crush December 2018 - Booklet Cover Front Top

Yarniverse December 2018, Issue 9 - Retail Value $9.99

The mini-magazine included in the December box isn’t for sale yet, but you can look at past issues for sale here. Inside the front cover of the booklet is a download code so that you can add these patterns to your Ravelry library - I love this, as it’s a great way to keep track of which patterns you own!

 Yarn Crush December 2018 - Info Pages Top

My favorite feature of the Yarn Crush subscription box is that you get to choose your color family! You have the ability to choose between cool, warm, and neutral, and you can switch your color preference month-to-month. This page in the booklet shows the three choices for each of the color families for this month.

The yarn sent this month in Yarn Crush was a set of mini-skeins from dyer Yarn Indulgences in the Zed Merino base, which is a DK weight. Each 100% superwash merino skein contains 140 yards, so we are getting a total of 420 yards with the three skeins.

 Yarn Crush December 2018 - Hat Pattern Side Front Yarn Crush December 2018 - Scarf Pattern Front Yarn Crush December 2018 - Mitts Pattern Front Yarn Crush December 2018 - Bag Pattern Front

The mini-mag contains a total of six patterns - four patterns that go along with the Yarn Crush box (two knitting, two crochet), and two patterns that go along with the Sock Crush box. I love the variety in the projects that they included - each one is unique from the others. I also like that no matter what your experience level, you are able to find a pattern that suits you!

The Yarn Crush box advertises itself as having on-trend designs, and I think they have really tried to do that. This month they are featuring color blocking and slipped stitch patterns, both of which are trends in both fashion and in the knitting world right now. I do notice that the designs tend to skew towards the younger side, especially with the bright colors featured in the pattern photos. Not to say that people of all ages can’t enjoy patterns like this (everyone has their own preferences!), but I would think that a younger knitter might really be excited to make and wear these designs.

Yarn Crush December 2018 - Booklet Cover Back Top

The back cover of the booklet shows where you can find Yarn Crush on the internet and follow along in their groups!

Yarn Crush December 2018 - Wool Skeins

Yarn Indulgences Zed Merino DK yarn, mini skeins - Retail Value $33.91 (on sale in different colors for $31.65)

I received the color family “cool,” which contained a skein each of pink, turquoise, and purple. Yarn Crush reports that the purple color is a brand-new colorway from the dyer, and was created just for this box!

This yarn is SO SOFT. I could not believe that it’s really 100% superwash merino, because I have never felt a superwash merino yarn that is quite this silky soft! It truly feels like a luxury yarn, and I am definitely going to take a look at the Yarn Indulgences website when I am picking out yarn for future projects.

Yarn Crush December 2018 - Yarn Label Top

Here’s a close up of the yarn label with each of the skeins. I think the three colors complement each other really well, and they look great as a set. My issue with this label is that it lists each skein as having 120 yards, while the booklet information lists each skein as having 140 yards. On the dyer’s website, these mini-skein sets are listed as each having 130 yards. This inconsistency feels like an oversight, and it’s a frustrating one when you are trying to plan out a project. If I chose a project that requires 420 yards (after reading the product info in the booklet), start making that project, and then run out of yarn because I truly only have 360 yards, I would be pretty disappointed.

Yarn Crush December 2018 - Alpaca Tote Bag Top

Alpaca Tote Bag - Retail Value $12.99 (the tote bag was available on the Yarn Crush website for sale, but has since sold out. The matching notions pouch is available for $6.99 here)

I have a slight (okay, maybe major) obsession with alpacas, so I was so excited to see this tote bag when I opened up my box! There were three different color options available - the purple I received, teal, or red. The tote bag is of standard quality and has long straps that work great for carrying over your shoulder. As a knitter or crocheter, you can never have too many project bags, so I think this was a great addition to the box!

Yarn Crush December 2018 - Scarf Progress Top

I thought that the slipped stitches and mosaic patterning of the scarf pattern were very intriguing, and I love how it played into the gradient of the three colors we received in the box. This pattern is marked as intermediate, but I would call it more of an advanced beginner pattern. It’s knit mainly in garter stitch, and the only techniques you need to learn are how to slip stitches (which is very straightforward), and having to keep track of your colors. The yarn feels like butter when you’re working with it - it glides through your hands and the resulting fabric feels like silk.  

Verdict: I really enjoyed my first month of Yarn Crush! I like that it gives me the ability to try new indie dyers, and I love the yarn base that I was introduced to with this box. The patterns included are fun and different, and I thought the box had an all over thoughtful curation. I think this box is mostly geared towards newer knitters and crocheters, and think it would be an excellent box if you are looking to expand your skillset and try new projects!

A few other things that are good to know: you can follow Yarn Crush on Ravelry to see spoilers of the upcoming colors for each month. This is especially helpful since the subscription lets you chose which color family you want to receive! The details of the dyer, yarn base, or patterns aren’t revealed, but as someone who tends to be a little bit picker with my color choices, I appreciate that I can choose my color each month!

For $44.99, we received a set of mini-skeins, six knitting and crochet patterns, and a tote bag, with a total retail value estimated at $56.89. I think the price of the box is on the high end, but I’m used to subscription boxes providing a value that truly exceeds the cost of what you pay for the subscription. That said, I’m still happy with the value of this box!

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? No, if you sign up in January, you will receive the January 2019 box.

ACTIVE DEAL: Save $5 off any subscription!

Value Breakdown: At $44.99, here’s approximately what you are paying for each item:

  • Yarn Indulgences Mini Skein Set - $26.86
  • Yarniverse Pattern Booklet - $7.88
  • Alpaca Tote Bag - $10.25

Check out all of our Yarn Crush reviews and the DIY and Crafting Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What did you think of the December 2018 Yarn Crush? Which color family would you choose? Let us know in the comments!

Starting at $26.99
Active Deal
Save $5 off any subscription!
Use Coupon Code HELLO
Subscribe Now
Inspire yourself with a monthly project-in-a-box. Yarn Crush delivers premium yarn (full-sized skeins, or coordinating sets of mini-skeins), and brand-new knit and crochet patterns designed to use them. All notions required to complete either project are included, and Yarn Crush usually includes a b... read more.
Krista Moore
Krista Moore
Krista entered the subscription box world through beauty boxes and quickly became hooked on boxes! She loves knitting, crocheting, all things crafty, and her cat! Her favorite boxes are KnitCrate, Allure Beauty Box, and FabFitFun.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



Is that really enough yarn for a scarf?

Reply ButtonReply


It actually is! I was wondering this as well since the skeins looked so tiny in the box! It’s knitting up to be quite long, actually – especially with this pattern, since the slipped stitches add length without eating up a lot of yarn.

Reply ButtonReply

Joanna Rankin (Yarn Crush founder)

It is! We always include enough yarn in each box to do one of the included patterns. If you’d like to do more than one pattern (or a larger project), members can purchase anything listed in our online store for 15% off, plus we include a 25% coupon code for that month’s overstock yarn in every issue of Yarniverse Magazine 🙂

Reply ButtonReply


Great, informative review. Gorgeous handiwork too. Thanks!!

Reply ButtonReply


Thank you so much for the kind comment! 🙂

Reply ButtonReply


Ditto! Nice review and your knitting is lovely.

Reply ButtonReply


Thank you so much! I’m glad you enjoyed the review!