FabFitFun Winter Editor’s Box – Now Customizable for Current Subscribers!


This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

The new FabFitFun Winter Editor’s Box is now customizable for current subscribers! You can find it in the shop section for $49.99 and you will be able to make all 4 product selections!

And if you are a new subscription and sign up for a subscription now, this will be your first box! Click here and use coupon code MSA10 to save $10!

Here are the full spoilers:

All new subscribers will be able to choose one of the following:

All new subscribers will be able to choose one of the following:

You can pick one of the following if you upgrade to an annual subscription (if you don’t upgrade, FabFitFun will pick for you):

You can pick one of the following if you upgrade to an annual subscription (if you don’t upgrade, FabFitFun will pick for you):

And everyone will receive:

Check out my review of this box and all the choice items to see exactly what you will receive!


If you haven’t signed up for FabFitFun yet, use coupon code MSA10 to save $10 off of your first box!

Check out our FabFitFun reviews and FabFitFun Spoilers to see what you can expect from this subscription!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.

Posted in FabFitFun Box News, Subscription Box News| Tags: fabfitfun | 50 comments

50 Comments

  1. This shipped fast! I ordered on 1/9, the day this was posted and received FedEx notification this morning that my box is out for delivery!

  2. Yay!! I got that fabulous scarf (love my other two donni scarves), essential oils (use the WoW Eucalyptus in my diffuser now), Exfolikate, and the wallet. What a great box! The only things I don’t need are that darn highlighter (have two already) and another Exfolikate (I have a full one right now), but at least I love both of the products. I just hope they don’t get bad while I use up what I have now. 🙂

  3. I just sent this email to Katie at Fabfitfun:

    ‘I, like so many others, bought the Editor’s box in the edit sale. I knew I could not customize the box. Now, I see it is available and with customization, and for the same price I paid.

    This was a dirty trick to play on a loyal customer.

    I’m not going to ask for a refund, but I will be canceling my subscription. You took all the joy out of your box with this nasty little move.

    Please let me know what I need to do to cancel my FabFitFun membership.’

    I’m tired of supporting these boxes that don’t support us back. There are enough others out there for me to spend my money on. Yes, I know I could have called their customer service and asked them to fix this, but the fact is, I shouldn’t have to.

  4. I was on board until I saw that the wallet is out of stock. This makes the box not worth it to me at $50. No way is that throw thing worth a comparable retail value.

    • The wallet is in stock.

      • For me, anyway.

    • See comments below. You can change other items and the wallet will appear in stock.

  5. I’m so excited! I got the scarf, hand cream (loved your description of it, Liz, in your review – trying it out over the KS because of it!), wallet, and masks (which I LOVE so
    much – worth it). Glad I held off from the Edit Sale, but I’d be frustrated if I purchased it.

    • I almost got the hand cream, too, based on Liz’s review, haha! But I have sooo many and I LOVE the KS.

  6. I had the box as an add-on in the sale and obviously was a bit upset to see that current subscribers can now get this box and customize it. I chatted with CS and they refunded the box from the sale so I could buy one now with customizations. I got the whole “As per our policy, all our sales are final and non-refundable. As a one-time courtesy, I will refund the money back and it will settle to your card within 3-5 business days.” which makes it sound like they are doing me a huge favor when really the way they went about this was actually kind of unfair to us current subscribers and I think we have a right to get a refund in this instance. But in the end, they did give me the refund so I am happy. Hope they learn from this though because I know a lot of people aren’t happy.

  7. Why do I want this when I don’t need any of it?? I already have almost all the items. I think it’s a great box if you get to customize. My only hesitation about Edit boxes is “old stock”. I’ve been happy with almost all my add on purchases in the past but during the Fall sale I purchased a This Works lotion that was bad. It had an off smell and the ingredients were separated. It had to be trashed. I hope everyone ordering gets exactly what they want.

  8. It was full price in the shop! I just checked my invoice and it says $49.99! This really upsets me. I wonder if I could cancel the edit sale one and actually choose my options?

    • I know- I paid full price and didn’t get to customize everything and now it’s too late. Irrr

      • I just talked to C’s and they canceled my box from the edit sale and let me repurchase with the ability to choose. Talk to them. Now if it all works out, we’ll see. 😬

        • Ugh. CS above.

  9. I am so angry right now. I didn’t purchase other things in the edit sale so I could afford the box! Now I feel REALLY cheated.

  10. Omg, I literally removed this box from my Edit Sale cart at 11:40 pm the night of closing, because I knew not being able to customize meant I’d end up with everything I didn’t want (each category was a definite want vs. DO NOT want for me). Way to go, FFF, for listening to everyone about including annuals! I sincerely hope all of you who ordered in the Edit Sale either get what you want or are compensated satisfactorily. I’d be upset.

  11. Too bad the wallet is already out of stock. I definitely don’t need another one of those blankets.

    • It shows in stock for me.

    • It’s still in stock with some variations. If you really want the wallet, choose that one first and then the rest of your choices to see what other item you may have to change in order to get the wallet.

  12. My first reaction was all these people who purchased the winter edit box in the edit sale are going to be so mad. I hope they make that right for you all.

  13. Okay, so FFF comes out 4 times a year BUT in-between those times they sell other boxes that contain old stock from their previous boxes? Is this correct?

    • Technically when they “sell out” of the regular quarterly boxes they introduce Editor boxes in between for new subscribers to get immediately. But they are usually available for additional purchase by current subscribers too. And, yes, alot of the items in them are old stock (or “editor favorites” hence the name) with some new items mixed in too.

      • Thanks LB for the clarification. 🙂

  14. Well I’m kinda peeved that I bought one in the Edit sale that was totally uncustomizable now…. I did that because it sounded like FFF was no longer going to ever allow customization by existing subscribers (only for new). Ugh. Guess that’s the last time I believe rumors.

    • Same here 🙁

    • A CS rep specifically told me that this box would never be editable for current subs so I am not happy about this at all.

      • They told me that too.

    • Same here.

    • I’ve noticed they’ve done this the last few edit box times.. learning my lesson!

    • Same. I reached out to attemp to cancel the one from the edit sale but they said that was impossible… I’m frustrated mostly because the question regarding possible customization was asked and answered, informing my purchase, and the immediately reversed.

  15. I just opened my 4th and final tube of my back stock of Exfolikate.I am so happy waiting for the arrival of the BF MSA special which is a new tube and now the Editor’s box allows me to choose another. Woo Hoo! I am so happy not to pay $75 full price, although I definitely would. Yes, Exfolikate is that good!!

    • Looking at the picture, it looks like it is the small size.

      • The closeup photo of the individual items in this box on the FabFitFun website shows the 1.7 oz version, which is the $75 one (the $24 version is only .5 oz)…fingers crossed anyway.

    • Believe me, I ‘ve been around long enough to know FFF sends the 1.7oz./$75 tube ( KS does sell a larger $85 version too, but this is still a true deal.

  16. I got this mostly for the scarf… hoping to be able to resell enough items to make up at least half the cost of the box.

    btw – so who’s picking up another color block blanket? lolz

    • Believe it or not I actually picked the color block blanket! My dog totally loved shredding the last one, so I know I’ll make her year when I appear with a new one she can rip to pieces. She’s pretty tiny and doesn’t have the ability (or opportunity) to truly shred much of anything but that soft, fragile blanket was perfect for her. She barked and growled and violently whipped it around like an attack dog in the K-9 unit! It was hysterical for such a pampered puff ball. So now she has a second chance to feel super tough again, like all her big tough doggie friends!

      So I was actually thrilled when that blanket was an option in this box, but it’s quite possible I was the only person on the planet to feel that way! 🙂

      • haha omg, this is great, thank you! My dogs’ (multiple) MANICURED nails get stuck in this thing so yeah, have at it!

      • 😂😂😂 ❤️ I’m imagining your little dog feeling so proud of herself. You’re a good dog mom.

      • Sweetest post on MSA ever! I’m picturing your little dog so happy! She is lucky to have you!

      • I put the blanket on the back of the couch because our cat likes to lay up there and I didn’t want it to get dirty. It’s soft and she loves it.

  17. Are new subscribers able to pick all 4 options?

  18. Finally!!!! I don’t mind paying full price if I get the same customizing options as the people getting a deal! That’s what always kept me from grabbing a second or editors box!

  19. As a seasonal purchasing it in the shop Monday I was able to pick all four choices. I did have to pay full price, $49.99, but getting all the items I wanted was huge.

  20. The scarf is nice but there are more things I don’t want than do, no FOMO here.

  21. I ordered one just because I wanted this scarf so badly.

    • Me too! Just the scarf alone for $50 is a great deal. Add in the exfolikate, the glam glow masks, another spondgelle, those cute prep bowls…the list goes on and on…how could I NOT order this??? Yay!

      • Those cute bowls go for 6 for $18 at Anthropologie, and they have more color choices. That is why I am hesitating on this box.

        • Nice catch! Thank you…I just pulled them up online and you’re right – they look identical. (It’s one of the rare times when the Anthropologie is lower!).

          Thank you again for the tip. 🙂

          • I saw them during an after Christmas sale – everything was 30% off, but I couldn’t find enough to get free shipping, so I didn’t buy. But! I am going to keep an eye out — those latte bowls are mainstays, though colors may change sometimes.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!