FabFitFun Upcoming Box Poll – Pick This or That Round #2!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

If you aren’t familiar, Katie Kitchens is the Co-Founder of FabFitFun, and she often shares potential future products on her Instagram feed to get feedback! Here are the latest potential future box items. (FYI – these are not confirmed products, they may or may not be in future boxes, and they also may not be in the same box.)

Which would you prefer in an upcoming FabFitFun box:

Source: Katieakitchens

Manna Kadar Sea Minerals Champagne Charcoal Scrub or Curie Natural Deodorant

Let us know which item you would prefer in the comments!

And if you haven’t signed up for FabFitFun yet, there is 1 day left to get their $20 off coupon!

Use coupon code CHILL40 to save 40% off of your first FabFitFun box! Your first box will be the Winter Editor’s Box. This box is regularly $49.99. This brings the cost down to $29.99! (This offer is for new, seasonal members only.)

Check out our review of  the Winter Editor’s Box to see what you’ll get!

How do subscribers rate FabFitFun?

658 subscribers rated this subscription
out of 5 stars
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to FabFitFun? Add your rating now!

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in FabFitFun Box News, Subscription Box News| Tags: fabfitfun | 233 comments


  1. I think they are both good options, though the scrub retails for twice the deodorant. I would choose the deodorant because I try to avoid perfumes and weird ingredients in my bath stuff.

    • Same, deodorant over scrub. RV hardly means anything these days, or at least cannot be relied upon, but ingredients definitely mean a lot.

      • I agree. deodorant for me.

    • Same, I won’t use the scrub because of the perfumes and weird ingredients. I’d go with the deodorant.

  2. I don’t want either, but if I had to get one I’d want the deodorant.

    • My sentiments exactly.

  3. Scrub

    • Agree! Scrub!

  4. Neither 😔

    • Yup. Duds.
      More likely to gift the scrub tho…

  5. Deodorant

  6. Not too enthused about either but if I had to pick, it would be the deoderant. I hate body scrubs and prefer a dry brush, Spongelle, or a scraper.

  7. Neither for me. I don’t do well with charcoal and white tea scents give me a headache. If the deodorant came in a different scent, I’d probably choose it though.

  8. Ooooh a scalp scrub… that would be great!

    • Scrub for me

  9. Neither. Scrub if I have to

  10. Neither

  11. Neither. Please don’t put these in our boxes .

  12. The deodorant, for sure! No Manna Kadar, please!

  13. dont like either. would pick scrub if i had to pick.

  14. scrub!

  15. Neither, please! Really! These are so uninspired and overplayed (sorry to be blunt). There have to be better options out there!

    • Agree.

  16. Scrub

  17. Scrub

    • Neither

  18. If I had to pick from the two i would go with the scrub but i would rather these be added to the addons instead if possible…sorry…..

    • Yes add-ons, good call. I feel like the natural folks don’t get a ton of things in this box, but at the same time, I want nothing to do with that deodorant. Add-ons would be a nice middle ground.
      I’m happy with the scrub I use, and only use it on my legs before shaving. Really not interested in anything else, other than more of that Lalicious one from a while back. 😍

      • Neither….just my opinion but the deodorant seems more like it should be a special extra or freebie as opposed to a box value item. When I’m spending $50 on a box, I don’t picture deodorant in it. Not excited about the scrub either, it’s been overdone. Plus weren’t there sugar scrub cubes in the last “this or that” survey? I 2nd the Lalicious sugar scrub though… Love that stuff!!

  19. Neither one – tired of charcoal stuff and scrubs in general and sadly allergic to baking soda in my deodorant (or I would have said that)
    Hope neither of them makes it cause that would not be great for my household 🙁

  20. Scrub, if either.

  21. Don’t like either. 🙁

  22. Charcoal scrub, for sure.

  23. Neither. I see no fun in deodorant, and I prefer a loofah or brush.

  24. Body scrub

  25. Of the two, I would choose the deodorant.

  26. 100% Manna Kadar Sea Minerals Champagne Charcoal Scrub

  27. Can I choose the mystery item instead?

    • Hahaha! This made me LOL.

      • Haha same here

    • Lol!! Yes please; mystery all the way!

  28. Deodorant. I’m trying to find a natural one that lasts all day.

    • The best one I have found is Schmit’s Charcoal and Magnesium. It is amazing and lasts all day and more. Smells great too.

      • I agree Anna that is the best one I have found too.

        • Thank you to both of you! I will try to order it=)

  29. Scrub! Many deoderants have a tendency to cause skin problems for too many people. I would for sure cancel if deoderant was one of the main box items.

  30. Neither really but the scrub, I guess.

  31. Definitely scrub. The baking soda makes me break out…I’ve switched to Lume and LOVE IT!

  32. Deodarent. I love getting things like that in subscriptions that way I don’t habe to go to the store to buy it haha. What was the first this or that?

  33. Deodorant. Love all the naturals lately

  34. Charcoal scrub please!

  35. Deodorant would be my first choice but really either option would be fine.

  36. The baking soda that so many natural deodorants have in it makes my underarms burn. I will go with the scrub. As I was typing the song No Scrubs came into my head, lol

  37. Scrub

  38. Not excited about either. But of the two, definitely the scrub. While I really want to love natural deodorants, and some of them even seem to work…the coconut oils/shea butter/other oils that they seem to use as their base HUGELY stain my cotton t-shirts…I ruined quite a few of them before I figured out that was the cause. Oh and the baking soda in natural deodorants gives me a rash if I use it more than occasionally. So sadly, the naturals are a fail for me.

  39. Definitely NOT the deodorant! The last natural deodorant FFF sent me went directly in the trash after trying it. It was gross! Not a fan of the scrubs either but wouldn’t hate it.

  40. I did not care for the charcoal scrub we had before. Body scrubs are an obsession of mine too. I can’t use plain deodorant either. Wow I can’t even pick one to gift. Bummer.

  41. scrub.

  42. Deodorant

  43. Good God, neither.

  44. Unfortunately neither. Charcoal scrubs are messy and natural deodorants don’t work. But if I have to choose the scrub b/c I can gift it. Plus I use indoor tan and need scrubs, just wish it wasn’t charcoal.

  45. Don’t really care for either one but I definitely don’t want the deodorant.

  46. I don’t really care for either items. I liked the diffuser that was in the other survey.

  47. Definetly the scrub

  48. I would love to get the deodorant!

  49. Umm… neither?? 🤦🏼‍♀️

  50. Wow. Neither. FFF has done body scrubs recently, both in boxes and in add-ons. How about a scalp scrub instead?

    • Oooo, yes, it would be great to get a really nice scalp scrub!

      If I had to choose between these two, I would pick the body scrub.

    • I would LOVE the Christophe Robin scrub! I received a service sample from sephora a while back and used up every last drop.

      • Yep fff should have that in the box for sure!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I love his scrub and mask…

        Oh yeah I hope I dont have to pick :/

      • Yes, that scalp scrub is the absolute best!! I bought the full size and it lasts forever because so little is needed. I also have the volume paste and it’s amazing too.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!