MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

ColourPop Limited Edition Mystery Grab Bag – FULL SPOILERS!

We have full spoilers for the sold-out ColourPop mystery bag!

The Box: ColourPop Mystery Bag (SOLD OUT)

The Cost: $25

The Products: What’s inside? We’ll never say! Some best sellers? New stuff? You’ll have to get this bag to find out! Over $50 worth of product for only $25, get the goodies we KNOW you’ll love for 50% off!

Here’s what’s inside:

Source: mgmakup

  • Lux Lipstick
  • Super Shock Shadow
  • Super Shock Shadow
  • Lippie Stix
  • Ultra Blotted Lip
  • Ultra Glossy Lip
  • BFF Volumizing Mascara
  • Pressed Powder Shadow
  • Super Shock Highlighter

Colors may vary! What do you think of the spoilers? Did you get a mystery bag?

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in Subscription Box Spoilers| 19 comments

Comments (19)

  1. I just got mine today and I am so thrilled with it!

  2. I had never tried the Ultra Blotted Lip before, wow, it is my new favorite formulation.

  3. I ALMOST jumped on it, but the last mystery boxes I got were pretty monochromatic – brown, champagne, mauve… basically, matching the color of this packaging. haha
    I really wish they’d do a “weird ones” mystery bag with some of their stranger shades.

    • YES “WEIRD ONES”!!! Like Slave 2 Pink, my fave Super Shock Shadow.

      I decided against buying a bag because once in a while they have savings of 40% or so, and then I can buy exactly what I want. Also, they carry sooooo many neutral colors that it wasn’t worth the risk for me that I’d get a ton of shades I’d never use.

    • I am sure they are trying to cater to more people by adding more neutral shades. Most people don’t wear brighter colors, but, I get what you’re saying!

  4. I am always so curious about these mystery bags, and they seem like good values BUT…if you like the brand, you probably already have all or most of the things you would like that come in them. After trying once or twice and coming up with repeats of things I have, I stopped doing mystery bags and just buy the things I want.

  5. So glad I didn’t bite. I only use Moody Sister Skincare eyeshadow and don’t wear lip color.

  6. I got the best variant for me, I think. Pinch Me Super Shock Highlighter, Snake Eyes pressed powder, Champagne Mami Ultra Glossy Lip, Sequin Super Shock Shadow, & Solo Lux Lipstick, in addition to the other base products everyone seems to have gotten (Ziggy, Party of Five, Doozy, & Black on Black) .

    Pinch Me & Snake Eyes were 2 of the products I considered adding on to get free shipping, but didn’t. 👍

    • Twins! I received everything you got-exactly. Loving the new mascara, and am so happy I got to try the different lipsticks.
      This was definitely worth it for me.

  7. I got two mystery bags.

    Lux Lipstick – Y2K and SOLO
    Super Shock Shadow – Sequin x2
    Super Shock Shadow – Party of five x 2
    Lippie Stix – Ziggie x 2
    Ultra Blotted Lip – Doozy x2
    Ultra Glossy Lip – Champagne Miami x2
    BFF Volumizing Mascara – Black on Black x2
    Pressed Powder Shadow – snake eyes x2
    Super Shock Highlighter – Mr Wind & Pinch Me

    • I would love to trade my Pressed Powder Shadow in Pinky Promise for Snake Eyes, if anyone is interested. I did not open it- it is brand new, un-swatched.

      • I can send it to you for shipping costs. My email is the above at g mail

  8. The highlighters come in different shades for sure. I have seen at least 3 different ones. I wish the mascara came in different colors they have a rainbow of colors and they are sending black. Boo!!

    • Ppl would complain about not being able to use it if they sent any other color, unfortunately.

  9. Looks like a nice mix of colors and products for the price.

  10. There were variations on colors? All of the youtube unboxings I’ve seen had the same colors.

    • Oh, I wasn’t sure if there will be variation, so I wrote colors may vary just to be safe. Thanks for letting us know.

      • There is some variation. Check out the comments on your original mystery bag post. It looks like a few of us got different shades for a couple of things.

      • Thanks for letting me know!

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.


The Black Friday Box Deals We’re Actually Buying
See The Best Deals