Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($30 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
At My Subscription Addiction, we believe in better living through subscriptions. We help readers discover new and exciting products and services that will help deliver the best version of their lives.
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Boxy has been a miss lately with me!!! I never get any of the items I’m interested in and none of the palettes work for people of color.
Reply
clusby75
Oooooh I would LOVE to see the PV Setting powder in our next box ❤️ I so hope it’s not a variant, that would be my luck, I always seem to not get the variant items I want
Reply
Just.gretchen
That looks like same the Wander Beauty palette packaging that is in the December Boxyluxe full spoilers. I doubt they’d give us the same palette twice, right?
Reply
Rachel
I love the sizzle palette. The highlighting one isn’t bad either. I don’t care for the last one.
I don’t know what’s going on with the pretty vulgar powder. It’s not in the luxe box and it should be. Everyone wants it and if we are spending extra money on the luxe box, why isn’t the most wanted item included?
Reply
Michelle
Not everyone
Reply
Nicole McCollum
Oh please Boxycharm let me get the Sizzle palette!!! I need some color in my life from these boxes!!!
Reply
Allie
Didn’t we get a round tarte rainforest of the sea palette like, last year? I wasn’t a huge fan-maybe these are better.
Reply
Chandra
The Wander Beauty palette was in a spolier picture for December BoxyLuxe, I saw it on IG/FB today.
Reply
Jen
Total l♡ve! I love getting the pallets, they make wonderful gifts when I dont like them, so it’s always a win!
Reply
Breeana
Looks similar to the one we got in August of last year.
Reply
Koreen
I have so many warm palettes, that I hope I get the sizzle one if they do these.
Reply
Teresa
I’m the opposite. I have all sizzle bright colored pallets (which I give away) and No natural neutral color ones.
Reply
Jennifer
Was thinking about cancelling as I have been disappointed the past two months. I am sick of palettes but these look decent and ones that I would actually keep instead of try to swap. Keeping my fingers crossed!
Reply
Lucy
The three palettes are beautiful and I don’t have any of them!
Reply
Jessica
I *love* tarte products so much, so I am all about this spoiler. I just hope to get any but the Rainforest of the Sea III because I already have it. However, my luck in this regard is not great lol… I didn’t want the box with lashes this month since I don’t (and can’t) wear them, and sure enough I got lashes.
Reply
Katie S
Oh no, I have all 3 of those palettes! Looks like I’ll be swapping if they’re in January’s box.
Reply
Kimberly Sifford
I really think its for January..I made a remark in a FB group and Yosef like it! I was excited! Sorry, I’m a dork..haha.
Reply
Irina
Funny:))
Reply
JustJese
I’m on palette overload and am seriously thinking about cancelling. As much as I appreciate the opportunity to expand my collection for such a low cost, Boxy really needs to think outside the box instead of dumping palette after eyeshadow palette on its subscribers.
Reply
Victoria
Agreed
Reply
GingerLynn
Boxycharm does an amazing job, and the palettes are fantastic!
However, for every person who loves and needs another palette, there’s a person who is on palette overload! It would be so great for those who have been longtime customers and, as such, is possibly on palette overload, to have a customizable choice; palette or “something else”. Exactly like the choice in December’s BoxyLuxe, choice between the hair straightener or the palette, except it would be for Boxycharm. It was fantastic to actually have a choice! It’s definitely more work for Boxycharm, but hopefully it would be worth it to them because people wouldn’t cancel for being on overload. Just a thought…
Reply
Geena
I like this idea! The option to pick “something else” (especially if the something else were things like skin/body care maybe that a lot of people also seem to have a love or hate thing for?) would really bring a lot of value back for longtime subscribers/those on overload!
Jill M
Now thats the way to complain lol…I know you weren’t complaining, but I like the way you worded everything instead of bashing the company and sounding entitled. Constructive criticism goes a longer way than the other bickering and ranting if you know what I mean. It was actually refreshing to read your comment!
Yana
Yes!! I am so with you in this one! I really like boxy, but I am seriously considering cancelling because between my personal palette collection and the ones I’ve been getting since signing up in the spring I have no where to put another palette!!! Would love it if the cooled it with the palettes a bit. I think the December Luxe box has like THREE palettes!! 🙈
Reply
SquirrelyGirl
Dec Boxyluxe has a wander cheek palette and the VV eyeshadow palette. 3rd palette was an option to choose. I’m assuming people who are on palette overload would have picked the straightener instead. I personally enjoy getting palettes, even though I have a ton of them. They are easy to swap if I don’t want a particular one.
Linda Novak
The Sizzle Eyeshadow palette is GORGEOUS! I’d love to receive that one! But, anything we receive is awesome!
Reply
Sarah
I think I like the spoilers for the regular, more than the Boxyluxe. 🙁
Reply
Marisa
I completely agree! I’m so confused with what’s going on with boxyluxe and it seems like they aren’t addressing anyone’s concerns in a direct way
Reply
Just.gretchen
Absolutely agree. I’ve been quite unhappy with Boxycharm customer service for the last couple months. But I LOVE the box so I can overlook it. For now at least.
Tanya
So glad I cancelled boxyluxe bc I’m with you!
Reply
Jessica Blevins
Me too!
Denise
I got the purple one last year. They better start figuring out a repeat system
Reply
Jessica Harrison
Yeah that’s what I was thinking I didn’t get it but I know I don’t want it they shouldn’t send things twice
Reply
Nichole
That’s not the same purple one as last year. The one we got last year was the rainforest volume of the sea 2 which featured mostly cool tones. The purple one shown in the picture has more pinky/warm tones
Reply
Denise
Oh yeah. Thanks guys I looked it up you’re right !! I feel better now because any of them I’ll like now 👍👍
MzBev
I thought so too. Its a different one. Look closer at the cover, its not the same design nor the same colors. If I got to pick one, I’d go with the first one MSA has listed.
Reply
Jessica Harrison
Didn’t they feature one tarte eyeshadow palette before?
Reply
JA
Yep but it’s not a repeat. If you do a quick MSA search you can read the old review.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.