Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
Dermstore offers professional-strength formulas from top skin care brands (otherwise only available at a dermatologist’s office), hard-to-find spa care and natural beauty brands, professional hair care and makeup products, and specialty brands from around the world.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
Reading about this item…apparently it conditions the lashes when used on the lash line, has skin conditioning mango seed, ingredients include vitamin C, vitamin E, antioxidants…making more sense as an inclusion for BF. It’s makeup and skin care! I’m looking forward to trying it.
Reply
Dea
Wish it was a crayon and not a pencil, which tugs. I like that with Beautyfix, I subscribe if I like the spoilers for that month, and then cancel once they ship it. Thanks to MSA, I know exactly what the products are for the month, and decide whether I want that box. MSA really provides a public service!
A full-size moisturizer would be nice… Hint hint… I like Juice Beauty… Hint hint…
Reply
Alex
If you’re on the swap site I’ll happily swap out my juice beauty
Reply
SrirachaSara
How do you get on the swap site?
Tanya M
So funny you should say that Dea. That had a full sized Juice Beauty Stem Cell Moisturizer in April with their natural box…I purchased 2… it last for so long…. I love it.. too heavy for summer but wow for right now. My skin loves it. I wouldn’t mind a brow or lash grow/enhancer or don’t shoot me, a nail polish for the season… YIKES…But I did just purchase two of the holiday boxes so maybe that’s why I asked for nail polish. I don’t see past August so don’t know if the box sold out. But hey, I hope you get your wish.
Reply
Dea
Thank you Tanya!!!
Jill M
I think it’s nice they are adding in a little makeup for the holiday season! Most of us end up getting a little more beautified than usual this time of year for parties and such. I am a skincare addict, but I think this was a great idea and the perfect item to put in the box!
Reply
Tamara
I’ve loved every box since I signed up 6 months ago, but this might be the first let down. My makeup routine is pretty basic, I wouldn’t have a use for that eye shadow. Hope the rest of the products make up for it. I’ve had my eye on a couple other subs I’d like to try but can only afford one at a time. Maybe this is the month to switch things up for a bit!
Reply
Melissa W.
So far, it’s not looking good to me. I sub to BeautyFix because I don’t like/use makeup. It’s more of a skin care box to me. I really dislike when they throw in makeup.
Reply
Melissa B.
Me too! I don’t like getting makeup samples, they don’t usually work out for me. I re-subscribed to beauty fix in November, which I loved! But so far this is disappointing.
Reply
Mel
Ooh! I’m actually pretty excited about this. I’m positive it’s not the hero item, but is a good item. I’ve never received anything like it in my Boxycharm, Sephora, Ipsy, or FabFitFun (although I believe we are getting something similar this season?), so it’s a winner to me.
Reply
Michelle
Noooo I hope there is a hero Skincare item. It’s not over yet ladies just wait.
Reply
TK
While this first spoiler is not a big hit for me, I wouldn’t consider canceling. BF is always my favorite monthly box. I’ve discovered some amazing skincare from this sub over the past couple years! Dermstore also has good sales, great brands and excellent CS.
Reply
Angela L Brown
holy smokes we have makeup this time finally a little something
Reply
Resa
I’m excited for this. It says it can be used along the waterline, as a base for eyeshadow and the shimmer end for highlighting above the brow bone. Looks like a new product with natural and nourishing properties. I’m in! I was needing to buy a light colored pencil for my waterline anyways – and BeautyFIX has read my mind!
Reply
Cai
I’m interested. Not excited, but interested! Looking forward to more spoilers
Reply
Joy
It seems like most Beautyfix customers subscribe for the skin/body/hair care items, not makeup so it’s weird for them to pick a makeup item for their first spoiler.
Reply
Courtneu
Not the most impressive spoiler but beauty fix consistently provides a high value box with great items some months are always going to be better than others. Personally I’m always looking for a new eyeshadow base so I’m perfectly happy to give this one a try on my maturing eyes. Who knows it might just be my new holy Grail. I’ll never know if I don’t try
Reply
Danielle
You don’t have to call customer service, you just have to cancel your subscription (super easy online in the”your subscriptions” section) and sign back up again month-to-month. You’ll still get the $25 price, and whatever rewards you “cash out” will be applied to the transaction
Reply
Danielle
((this was meant to be a reply to a question below. Whoops))
Reply
Pamela
Well I don’t like this, but I am sure not gonna sub/not sub based on this one item. They usually have like 7-9 items I think. I hope we get another spoiler tommorow though, one that looks good 🙂
Reply
Nan
Beautyfix is one of my favorites boxes. Hoping for more skincare.
Does anyone know if I can use my reward dollars toward payment of my monthly Beautyfix box and, if so, how to do it?
Reply
Danielle
You don’t have to call customer service, you just have to cancel your subscription (super easy online in the”your subscriptions” section) and sign back up again month-to-month. You’ll still get the $25 price, and whatever rewards you “cash out” will be applied to the transaction.
Reply
Nan
Thanks for the info!
Reply
ColleenT.
You can use your rewards dollars toward payment. The last time I used them, I called customer service, and she couldn’t figure out how to apply them. So I cancelled my subscription , and then resubscribed the next day, and the rewards dollars were automatically applied upon checkout.
That’s how it worked for me. You should call customer service if you have any questions, because the reward dollars expire 14 days after converting them.
Reply
Leah
Sorry, it would only work if you buy it one-time ($34.99) . It won’t count toward a subscription
Reply
Tammy g.
This will be my second month of bf….hope this is a good one.
Reply
Gina
I hope this isn’t an indication of December’s box. November was a little disappointing compared to previous months. I have subbed this one since June with no break. So far November was the least impressive, but I read somewhere other reviewers said it’s because December will be amazing. I’ll keep hoping for the best.
Reply
Edith
I’ve used this pencil in the past and liked it, so I would like to receive it. But I hope this is not the main full-size item for December’s box
Reply
Jennifer Crawford
This is my first month back, hope I didn’t make a mistake! :/ Not impressed so far!
Reply
Kimberly M Sifford
Nope, I cancelled this month too. Love BF, but not a great start.
Reply
Barbara
Canceled for now. My wallet is ready though. I hope there is some cool hero item waiting.
Reply
Reese
Hmmm, I hope there is a second full size item. This one doesnt seem high end and I mostly get BeautyFix for skincare since there are 101 different makeup boxes. Plus it’s the Christmas box so they can’t let us down this month!
Reply
Sarah
Looks interesting. I will look forward to trying it!
Reply
Miranda
I loovvee beautyfix, but if this is the star item this month…I’m out. Absolutely not impressed.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.