Facebook PixelGolden Tote 9 Clothing Review + Add-ons – October 2018 | MSA
My Subscription Addiction
My Subscription Addiction
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.

Golden Tote $149 Clothing Review + Add-Ons – October 2018

Haley Faye
ByHaley FayeOct 27, 2018 | 8 comments

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 box

Golden Tote
4 overall rating
72 Ratings | 8 Reviews

If you aren’t familiar with Golden Tote, here’s a really quick intro: Every month, a new "collection" of seasonally appropriate, trend-conscious clothing is added to their collection. Depending on the subscription level you choose, you can pick out 1-2 pieces from those options, and Golden Tote will surprise you with the rest. The surprise items are completely different from the collections you pick from. Golden Tote also offers a Surprise Tote, where you choose your preferred size but leave all the picking up to the stylists at Golden Tote.

Golden Tote offers a $149.00 Golden Tote (5 clothing items), or $59.00 Mini Tote (2 clothing items). Both allow you to pick at least one of your items. There's also a Surprise Tote (3 clothing items all picked by Golden Tote) for $89.00.

This is a review of the 5-item Golden Tote, which is $149.00. This month, I selected 2 items for my 5-item tote, there are 3 surprise items, and I selected two add-on items because I loved this month's selection so much.

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 tote

And for those of you asking, yes, everything does arrive in a literal tote!

This box was sent to us at no cost for review. (Check out the review process post to learn more about how we review boxes.)

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 all items

About This Box

The Subscription Box: Golden Tote 5-Item Tote

The Cost: $149 + free shipping

The Products: The 5-item Golden Tote includes 2 clothing items that YOU choose from their catalog, plus 3 items that Golden Tote's stylists choose for you based on your preferences. The 3 additional items don't typically come from the catalog, so they're complete surprises. Golden Tote releases a new "collection" of items to add to its catalog. The items are a mix of trendy and timeless looks, including dresses, casual tops, blouses, bottoms, denim, and third pieces like cardigans and jackets.

Ships to: The US for $5.95 or free on orders $149.00 and over. International for $30.00.

Delivered via: UPS or USPS

My Review

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 packing sheet

Here's my invoice. Now onto the items!

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 Red peplum top

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 Red peplum top back

Falling Leaves Peplum Top - Retail Value $40

This top was the first of my two chosen items. I really like the length, color, and print of this top. This top is so close to being great but the fit is just off enough to make me uncomfortable. I got it to work fine in the photos, but when my hand is not on my hip the top runs a little oversized, and that plus the peplum just add a lot of volume and shapelessness in my torso.

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 wine cardigan 1

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 wine cardigan 2

City Stroll Sweater Cardigan - Retail Value $42

This cardigan was my other chosen item. This is made with a super cozy sweater material that is very comfortable and warm. I like the length of this, too! I really think I could have sized down to a medium because I feel like there's a little extra fabric, but for a cozy Fall/Winter piece, I don't think I mind. I love the wine color, too, and I can see it pairing well with many different tops I own.

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 star top

Maronie Star Top - Estimated Value $40

This star-printed top is my first surprise item. It is SO soft and comfortable! Unfortunately, I think every top I've ever tried on that has a tie front or twist-front or fold-over front is just way too short on me. Even with a cardigan underneath it just hits me so high on my torso. The quality and comfort of this top were winners otherwise!

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 olive pullover

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 olive pullover 2
Be Cool Pullover in Olive - Estimated Value $40

This pullover sweater is one of my best items this month! The fit is perfect, I love the design and ribbing details, the fabric is soft, and I have been wanting more olive in my wardrobe!

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 tie waist dress 1

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 tie waist dress 2

Peppermint Tie Waist Dress in Charcoal - Estimated Value $40

I can see myself wearing this plenty this winter! Pair it with some leggings and boots and it'll be an easy outfit. It has a tie-waist front detail, but you can just as easily tie in the back for a smoother look.

Now for the add-on items!

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 floral dress 1

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 floral dress 2

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 floral dress back

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 floral dress close

All Dolled Up Dress - Retail Value $42

I owned a maternity dress that was very similar this one, but maxi. I loved it. When I saw this dress offered in Golden Tote's October collection I knew I wanted to snag it. The fabric has a nice weight and is soft and silky and drapes nicely. It feels a little more Spring/Summer to me but some booties and a jacket could still carry it through the season. It's very comfortable and I feel it's flattering - I'm happy with this one!

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 mustard top 1

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 mustard top 2

Golden Tote 149 Tote October 2018 mustard top back

Stroll Through the Meadow Top - Retail Value $40

I'm smitten with this mustard floral top! The fabric is too cute, and the design of this top is flattering. I feel really good in this and I don't own much mustard, which is really trending right now. I also love that the sleeves are 3/4 length and that the back has this ruching detail that adds some extra fabric to flow flatteringly around the bottom.

The Verdict: Golden Tote is one of my favorite subscriptions. Many of my favorite clothing items over the years have come from Golden Tote, and I think this tote adds to that list! This month's tote had some great items that I'm excited to add into my Fall wardrobe rotation. This is the first time I've ordered add-ons and the two items I added are some of my favorite in the box, so I'm glad I snagged them.

To Wrap Up:

Can you still get this box if you sign up today? Sign up now to start shopping regular totes! There's no telling what pieces Golden Tote will pick for you, but each month's new collection is launched at 12 EST the first Monday of every month.

Value Breakdown: My estimated retail values (based on similar items from Golden Tote’s boutique) add up to $202, not including the add-on items. This box costs a total of $149 (plus $38 and $35 for the discounted bundling prices for the add-on dress and top, respectively). Averaged out, for the 5 main items in the tote you’re paying about $29.80 per item. 

Check out all of our Golden Tote reviews and the Women’s Clothing Subscription Box Directory!

Keep Track of Your Subscriptions: Add this box to your subscription list or wishlist!

What do you think about Golden Tote

Starting at $59.00
Subscribe Now
Golden tote is a surprise shopping spree bundled up in a cute, canvas tote bag and delivered to your door without doing any of the work. It's a great assortment of ready-to-wear clothing and accessories curated just for you. Select one or two items, and the Golden Tote stylists surprise you with the... read more.
Haley Faye
Haley Faye
Haley Faye first discovered the wonderful world of subscription boxes in 2012 and began writing for MSA in 2014. Over the years, she has found many subscriptions to love. Now a mom of three, her favorite boxes are ones that dress her kids, help her get organized, feed her family, send her snacks, and offer educational fun for her children.

Join the Conversation

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.



I got that burgundy cardigan too! And I loooove it! It is so cozy !! I love that surprise dress you got – wish I got that. I had to exchange my surprise item because I hated it

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike


I love that star top on you! You have such a great figure and where it hits at your waist is very flattering. I would style it just like you have here, with the black cami underneath.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Erin Wright

I have never left a comment on one of these reviews but I too wanted to say the star top was great. I feel like it was the most form flattering too in the bunch!!! Thank about it!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Haley Faye

Thanks, Erin! I’m definitely thinking about it!

Like This CommentLike

Haley Faye

Thanks so much, Annie + Danni!!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Dani G

I agree 100%! Looks and falls perfectly on you! And the star print is so cute and unique!

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Lynn m.

The crop knot top is cute and flattering on you. You should just later it over a tank. As a whole great tote for you

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike

Becca S

The crop top is my favorite item! It looks perfect how it is layered. I want one now too.

Reply ButtonReply
Like This CommentLike