BoxyCharm October 2018 Spoilers – All Product Variations!

I received a variation with a product that isn’t even in these spoilers. I am a new subscriber, and it is the end of October so maybe I am receiving leftovers from previous months as they start to run out of stuff. It is a weird makeup product–an eyebrow cream by a brand called Chella beauty. This was in place of the skincare that you posted here on MSA (you posted that every subscriber would receive one of 6 skincare options. So, heads-up–not true). I was honestly looking forward to ANY of the skincare, so this was really a disappointment. I also got Kat Von D liquid lip in Crucifix. Very dark. Halloween is coming up. Maybe I can wear it then. Hoping for better in November box.

I liked the box but didn’t like the KVD shade I got – which was the whole reason I signed up 😒…anyone want to swap Crucifix for Hawkwind?

I signed up to get the Farmacy balm, and so naturally I got the crappy box with the crappy Briogio garbage, the eye patches, and of course, the ugliest KVD lip color in brown (to give your teeth that golden yellow tinge.) $21 completely wasted. I threw it all out. Absolute garbage. Boxycharm should stop advertising one box, then pull a bait and switch. Funny how SEVEN variations weren’t advertised initially, eh? A good lawyer would have fun with a class action suit.

I ended up with the wander eye masks and the briogeo. While it’s a skosh disappointing, I’m not too bummed cause I love the eye masks and I could pass the brio onto my brother so he stops stealing my full size one haha. And I did of course end up with a brown lip, but it’s surprisingly wearable so I’m actually excited because I never buy brown lipstick so it’s better than a pink or red of which I have many! The palette it pretty and the mascara is okay but getting passed on because I got a full size of my holy grail in the ipsy plus lol

I canceled after receiving 2 sample-sized products (Box #3 with the Ahava hand cream and the Briogio spray). The Briogio Boxy sent out was 2 oz, and their full-size is 4 oz. The hand cream sent out was 1.3 oz, and the full-sized is 3.4 oz. I’ve received the same hair mask in an Ipsy bag (not dragging Ipsy – I know they send sample sizes). Boxy shouldn’t advertise full-sized items if that isn’t what they are going to send out. I’m over Boxy and the 15 brown lipsticks they’ve sent me that don’t suit my skin tone – including this month’s KVD, and I have enough eyeshadow to last me at least 5 years.

I’ve been a subscriber for a while and ended up getting a repeat this month. I just received the WANDER beauty eye masks a couple boxes back, and just got them AGAIN this month. I am not one to complain. I am grateful for what I get from a $21 sub box. However, I have to admit, I am a little aggravated. Considering I also got the South Maine eye masks and the Dr. Brandt eye gel! I don’t even use any kind of eye products either, but I never once complained about getting any of these things until now, the repeated items is a bit much.

Interesting to me that Boxycharm changed the wording on their site about the box value, and reduced it from 120.00 to 100.00.
All who were afraid they would reduce quality with BoxyLuxe, were right.

Hopefully this comment works now. But could someone please tell me when I should sign up if I want to start in November? Should I just sign up November 1st? Thanks!

Hello! Could anyone tell me when I should sign up if I want to start my subscription in November? Should I just sign up November 1st? Thanks in advance!

I keep trying to leave comments but for some reason they almost never show up… Liz, anybody, can you help??

What I’d really like to say, however, is that got variation #2 (boooo!) with the AHAVA hand cream, Briogeo leave-in hair mask, and the KVD liquid lip in Bow n Arrow. I’m not partial to any of those three. If anyone is willing to trade, I would love any red lipstick- I swear, just about ANY red lipstick would do- and would absolutely kill for the Farmacy Green Clean cleanser. If anyone wants to trade I’m down!!!

I got bow and arrow the lace mask and the hair care so I emailed them about supposedly not sending us duplicates. I’ll let you know what they say

sosososososoooooooooooooo upset 3 of the pigments in my pallet are crumbled to nothing im so upset and nope still no word from boxy charm…..

Listen charmers can I just play devils advocate for a second? I see a lot of complaints and everyone is entitled to their opinion but come on you guys…. this box is $21. We get &120$ to $150 worth of products every month! I don’t k ow another beauty sub that comes close to boxycharm. I mean I don’t know if it’s because u guys are spoiled but 99% of boxes out there usually have one hero item. Boxycharm delivers every month. Yes I agree the Lillie is too pink for me..(it’s Kat Von d I will give it as a gift)!! And the eye gels are a repeat! But look at the palettes we get! Look at the mascara and face products and brush she’s we get!! It’s insane!! We are so lucky in my opinion. Anyone I know that has canceled boxycharm comes right back because they realize the deal they were getting! Try walking into ulta and spending $20 u won’t even get one item!! So please try and be greatful. Not every box is full of diamonds but they are all gems. That’s for sure. I upgraded to Ipsy plus and they are 4$ more a month than boxy. But it looks amazing. I have not had to shop for makeup in years thanks to boxy and Ipsy!! So please think about what I said. We are SPOILED WITH THAT 21$ price tag for all the amazing things we get! And even the stuff that we don’t like can be swapped or given as a gift and you make someone’s day special.❤️ You know? ❤️

Got an email from boxy saying it appears I’m getting a repeat item and it was brought to their attention and next month they will be including an extra item in my box. Not happy really wanted the lace peel, and the makeup melt 😢 my box won’t be here till tomorrow

Got my box today! Got the farmacy & lace mask as pictured in my email spoiler. No repeats. I’m happy. Won’t use the mask after seeing yari g try it on the tube. It pulls similar to a biore nose strip if anyone is wondering. Maybe good for some ppl with acne that need that for all over the face, but just targeting your nose is a good idea if you want to use it!

Was hoping for the mask/Green Clean….instead, I got a brown lipstick, a freaking hand cream (are you serious, Boxy charm?) and yet another Briogeo spray….not the silhouettes shown in my preview. Boxy keeps getting worse and worse, only reason I’m staying subscribed is for Luxe, so between months I’m just throwing away $21, bc the last few boxes have been abysmal.

just got mine yesterday, i had variation #1 with the balm and lace mask, and got the lipstick in shade lovesick. i adore the palette, the shadows and face powders have a beautiful texture and colors. my only complaint is that the silver shimmer isn’t as pigmented as i’d like as thats my favorite shimmer color and i have a hard time finding one super pigmented.

I just got mine, it was farmacy and the mask. Box was 1lb. Definitely do not think the weight matters.

I received variation 1, which I usually get for good or for bad. This month it’s good! The lip is Mother which I haven’t tried before and I like. The balm appears to be quite solid but melts so easily. I haven’t tried the mask yet, but if it sticks tight, I’ll apply water rather than tugging. I’ll likely gift the mascara and palette.

Yay!! I literally just got my box. I got version 1 with the mask and balm – 1 lb. I did get the K-Dub as sneak-peaked. But I am very pleased at getting the balm!

I got variation 2 but instead of the hand cream I received the lace mask. I was hoping to try the farmacy but still a great box. It’s always worth $21

I got the variation with the lace masks and the melt off balm. Mine weighed .9 I don’t believe weight matters.

Just to clear something up the Farmacy is a little smaller than the full sized jar. I own the full-size and they are not the same.

I haven’t received my box yet but my sillouettes were the same but my box doesn’t way quite .9lb more like .875 or something like that!
Thanks for sharing!

I resubbed to Boxycharm last month and I think this is my favourite month so far.I received the following out of the variations on top of the mascara and palette; farmacy, lace and peel, along with the KVD lip shade in lovesick which is really pretty. I am tempted to update to BoxyLuxe for December. Great job Boxycharm!