MSA is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read the full disclosure.

BoxyCharm October 2018 Spoilers – All Product Variations!


We have the full spoilers for all the products sampled in the October Boxycharm box!

First, all subscribers will receive:

Next, all subscribers will receive one of the following:

Lastly, all subscribers will receive one of the following:


And here are 2 confirmed box variations:

Box #2 Variation:


Box #1 Variation:

boxycharm october box

Source: Instagram user cosmeticosalpormayor

Box #1 Variation:

What do you think of the spoilers?

If you sign up now, the October box will be your first box!

If you haven’t signed up for this box yet, it is $21 a month. Check out my reviews of Boxycharm boxes, our posts of Boxycharm Spoilers to learn more.

PLUS Special Offer
PLUS Special Offer


How do subscribers rate BOXYCHARM?

Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Created with Sketch.

Never miss a post: get email alerts about BOXYCHARM!

Enable notifications () to get the latest BOXYCHARM spoilers, reviews, deals, and news delivered to your inbox.

Written by Liz Cadman

Liz Cadman

Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She’s been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!

Posted in BoxyCharm Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: boxycharm | 148 comments

Comments (148)

  1. I received a variation with a product that isn’t even in these spoilers. I am a new subscriber, and it is the end of October so maybe I am receiving leftovers from previous months as they start to run out of stuff. It is a weird makeup product–an eyebrow cream by a brand called Chella beauty. This was in place of the skincare that you posted here on MSA (you posted that every subscriber would receive one of 6 skincare options. So, heads-up–not true). I was honestly looking forward to ANY of the skincare, so this was really a disappointment. I also got Kat Von D liquid lip in Crucifix. Very dark. Halloween is coming up. Maybe I can wear it then. Hoping for better in November box.

  2. I liked the box but didn’t like the KVD shade I got – which was the whole reason I signed up 😒…anyone want to swap Crucifix for Hawkwind?

  3. I signed up to get the Farmacy balm, and so naturally I got the crappy box with the crappy Briogio garbage, the eye patches, and of course, the ugliest KVD lip color in brown (to give your teeth that golden yellow tinge.) $21 completely wasted. I threw it all out. Absolute garbage. Boxycharm should stop advertising one box, then pull a bait and switch. Funny how SEVEN variations weren’t advertised initially, eh? A good lawyer would have fun with a class action suit.

    • Hey Katy! So…
      1. You are a new subscriber. Others have been subscribed for months and years and are mad they got repeats. While I understand your frustration at not getting the items you were hoping for, it was NEVER a guarantee. Boxy clearly tells people there will be variations. Them releasing SEVEN variations…? Yeah, that’s a bit much! I usually only see 4 at the most. I wish they hadn’t done that.
      2. You threw out makeup? You couldn’t swap it? Or gift it? Or idk… give it to the less fortunate? Women shelters are always in need of UNUSED beauty products! While they were garbage to you, the could have been an exciting treat to someone else.

      • Seems like new subscribers received this variation (I did) but I knew going in I probably was and thank goodness I can wear pretty much any dark lip color….so to each her own! She bought the box, let her do with it as she wants!!

      • I’m not new and received variation #7, to me this was a slap in my face.

      • Yup, I’ve been slapped to many times. My face hurts. I was years subbed to this company. No more!

      • I understand both views , I’ve been a subscriber, have also never complained till this month. I got variation 7 which is the wonder baggage claim eye masks (I won’t use) disgusting brown lippie (again wont use) AFTER they sent me a spoiler that I was suppose to receive mother, then to top it off a deluxe sampler of a hair mask. What joy lol. I’m upset due to 3 bull crap items in just one box. I always say you might receive an item you don’t like oh well gift it, but 3 items that are crap well that’s crossing a line with me. Especially after sending me a spoiler of a pretty lippie color (mother) I couldn’t wait to try, then send me crucifix like wtf boxy. I did email them, and ya that was a joke. An apology is all never addressing the problem at hand. I’m willing to send the entire unused box back for just that lippie color, instead customer service says yep oh well I’m sorry. Like I said if it was one or two items fine, but to make an entire box of just whatever’s , that’s a slap in my face. I can’t beat the value of the boxes usually so I’ll stay subbed but to be honest , this month I would of rather just took my money and bought the lippie or lace peel myself.

  4. I ended up with the wander eye masks and the briogeo. While it’s a skosh disappointing, I’m not too bummed cause I love the eye masks and I could pass the brio onto my brother so he stops stealing my full size one haha. And I did of course end up with a brown lip, but it’s surprisingly wearable so I’m actually excited because I never buy brown lipstick so it’s better than a pink or red of which I have many! The palette it pretty and the mascara is okay but getting passed on because I got a full size of my holy grail in the ipsy plus lol

    • What hg product did you get in your Ipsy + ? I honestly feel like my ipsy + beat my boxycharm this month by a landslide. I mean, I actually even love the full sized makeup bag (crazy, right?). The boxy palette and mascara were better than the smashbox and man eater mascara though. I love tarte’s mascaras typically too. Overall though, ipsy + was just more exciting this month. November’s box is incredible! I am receiving rodeo drive?! I have 2 ofra highlighters and they are SO good and highly pigmented. Even the morphe highlighter in ipsy was gorgeous! It’s hard to say if ipsy will keep up with these great products but if so, I’d probably consider just subbing to ipsy + & dropping boxy.

  5. I canceled after receiving 2 sample-sized products (Box #3 with the Ahava hand cream and the Briogio spray). The Briogio Boxy sent out was 2 oz, and their full-size is 4 oz. The hand cream sent out was 1.3 oz, and the full-sized is 3.4 oz. I’ve received the same hair mask in an Ipsy bag (not dragging Ipsy – I know they send sample sizes). Boxy shouldn’t advertise full-sized items if that isn’t what they are going to send out. I’m over Boxy and the 15 brown lipsticks they’ve sent me that don’t suit my skin tone – including this month’s KVD, and I have enough eyeshadow to last me at least 5 years.

  6. I’ve been a subscriber for a while and ended up getting a repeat this month. I just received the WANDER beauty eye masks a couple boxes back, and just got them AGAIN this month. I am not one to complain. I am grateful for what I get from a $21 sub box. However, I have to admit, I am a little aggravated. Considering I also got the South Maine eye masks and the Dr. Brandt eye gel! I don’t even use any kind of eye products either, but I never once complained about getting any of these things until now, the repeated items is a bit much.

    • I agree I’ve never complained but I feel very deceived this month. I fought to the end just to get a luxe box last month 9 months pregnant at that and got completely stressed out for 2 1/2 hours. Finally I was able to snag one all for the head band from vi gage so I could wear it during my c section! Now I received an email saying I got a repeat and they will make it up next month. I feel so deceived by this now, like seriously you show these great spoilers and never warn anyone of repeats , until it’s too late. People were always complaining about this product or that and like I’ve always said , I usually like 4 of the 5 items and regift the one I don’t like, but this, this is ridiculous I don’t even have a chance to like the item because all 3 repeats I’ve gifted! Maybe if it was a good repeat but these are lame repeats ugh boxy just why

  7. Interesting to me that Boxycharm changed the wording on their site about the box value, and reduced it from 120.00 to 100.00.
    All who were afraid they would reduce quality with BoxyLuxe, were right.

    • Hummmm. That doesn’t sound good.

  8. Hopefully this comment works now. But could someone please tell me when I should sign up if I want to start in November? Should I just sign up November 1st? Thanks!

    • Yes wait until November. You get the box for the month your card was charged. If you sign up now, you will get October

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.