Play! By Sephora September 2018 FULL Spoilers for All Box Variations!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2017-02-18 at 9.12.22 AM

We have the full spoilers for all of the September Play! By Sephora variations!

The theme for September is “Next Gen Beauty”.

FYI – There seems to be discrepancies with the box numbers this month. Multiple box numbers have been reported for some variations so these are the full spoilers without the corresponding box numbers.

Box #A will include:

september sephora play box 707

Box #B will include:

september sephora play box 699

Box #C will include:

Box #D will include:

Box #E will include:

Sephora play september box 723

Box #F will include:

Box #G will include:

Box #H will include:

Box #I will include:

september sephora play box 764

Box J will include:

Sephora play september box 772

Box K will include:

Sephora play september box 780

Box L will include:

What do you think of the spoilers? 

Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

How do subscribers rate Play! by Sephora?

540 subscribers rated this subscription
out of 5 stars
Customer service
Retail value
Quality of products
Ease of canceling

Do you subscribe to Play! by Sephora? Add your rating now!

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in Play! By Sephora Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers| Tags: play by sephora | 38 comments


  1. I finally got my box yesterday (outside of the week sephora says it should arrive to me), and I got box #c. I finally pulled the trigger and cancelled sephora after almost 2 years of it. Just tired of it.

  2. Ugh, I got truly the worst box for what I’m interested in (Box C). Literally any other box would have been better – I don’t wear eyeliner or non-waterproof mascara, the Too Faced primer is TINY, and the the Belif Aqua Balm is just a foil packet. No lip product or perfume even though I said I liked those products? Does Sephora even pay attention to the quiz you take? And I really wanted to try the Tidal Creme and/or the Boscia moisturizer. Glad I got the Ole Henrikson, but that’s the only thing I’m excited about. This was my first box, and I think it’s going to be my last one.

    • Same got box c and nothing I can use.

  3. A bit disappointed with this month’s box… The cactus cream seems a bit sticky to me… tried the ptr mask last night and it broke me out….. I guess im gonna cancel…

  4. I received box C. After November (bday month yay!) I’m done.

  5. I got box E. I usually receive at least 1 or 2 items I really like, if not more. But this month was a total bust for me. 😡

    • Wanna swap for box C? E would have been perfect for me.

  6. Oh Sephora….I was hoping with each passing month that the next month would be better. But then you took away our cute re-usable tie pouches to give us a plastic ziploc baggie? I didn’t want to but that was the last straw…..I had to cancel 🙁 I decided I would rather use my $11.98 on 2 Happy Hour Margaritas instead.

  7. This bag was awful. The foundation is too dark, am not a fan of the plastic bag. It looks like a decorated ziplock baggy. This was the final straw. Too many repeats and the samples seem to be getting smaller. The plastic bag, did it, I have canceled my Sephora. Not worth even $10 anymore.

  8. If we sign up now, will we still qualify to get the September box? I’m new to this. Any information will help. Thanks.

    • No, the 11th was the last day you could subscribe and receive this month’s box. If you subscribe now, you’ll have to wait for October’s box.

  9. I got box A, and am happy with every item.

  10. I got box I. How are people finding out their numbers? Is it in my profile somewhere?

  11. Ugh I always get the crappiest boxes…I wanted the truth serum or belif moisturizer….instead I get ANOTHER lip product in the same boring colors that I always get…the Tom Ford perfume which smells horrible on me…and the cactus moisturizer that I already have…. I think it’s time I change up my profile to something COMPLETELY OPPOSITE

  12. I got box C and this was not at all what I thought I was getting based on item #… what a blah boring box… this might be the biggest disappointment ever for me in Play… and I would have thought the cloth bags were more eco friendly as my kids repurposed them constantly!!!!

    • Me too about the bags! I even sent an email saying the bags were part of why I signed up and all I got back was how they were excited to be more green with the new bags and how the play pass was here to stay. I didn’t even mention the play pass and I just joined so I didn’t know they went missing…

  13. I had the shade IQ foundation finder service in-store at Sephora, and it was stored in my beauty profile. Ever since then, they have been perfect at matching my Play! foundation samples to my skin tone. Its worth a shot if you have a store nearby with access to that free service.

    I also really, really loved that Chloe Nomad perfume sample in Box J! This was a good month for me.

    • Thanks for the tip about the IQ, I had no idea!❤
      I wanted to sample the Chloe, but got Philosophy’s Ballet Rose, and I really liked it, it’s a dupe of Stella on me, so that was a nice surprise.

  14. I got E even though the email indicated I was supposed to get something else. I’m pleasantly surprised. I’ve been wanting to try the Marc Jacobs creme lipstick and that’s what I got. It’s a gorgeous deep rich pink. I also got the truth serum, which I use daily and since I’m going away for the weekend I can take the sample I received in the box.

    • I got that box too. I had been hoping to try the PTR mask, but I’m still happy with E. I’ve never sampled any of these items before even though I’ve been with Play for almost a year and am excited to try the truth serum, moisturizer, and primer. I tend to be more of a neutral lip kinda girl but who knows, maybe I’ll be pleasantly surprised with the lipstick in person, the color itself looks really pretty.

  15. To remove a reusable fabric bag and replace it with more trash hardly seems eco friendly! I’ve only been a member for a few months and feel like the value just fell a notch.

  16. what was with the plastic ziploc bag this time?? 👎

    • That will be the New recyclable bag from now on. They have done away with the fabric bag to become more eco friendly

      • Crazy they think that more plastic is more eco friendly.

  17. I had I. The plastic bag it came in was worthless. The foundation was way too dark and the lip pencil was a no. The rest was fine enough.

  18. i had one of the boxes where my account said one thing but i received something else, so while bummed about not getting tidal, i kind of like that there are fewer products/variations between the boxes this month. there’s usually only 2 or 3 items i’d be excited to get, and i have a better chance at getting them when there’s only 10 items instead of 50.

  19. Anyone else get double of two of your samples? I received two hangover primers and two belief moisturizers. Plus everything else I was suppose to get. Not complaining but was curious if this happened to anyone else.

    • Woot! Score, girl!

  20. I got box #I and I love everything in it! Best month ever!!

  21. I got box A and while I was really happy with it my lipstick was all in the cap. Sad about that but not really as I like to carry my lipstick in my pocket and don’t like crayons as a rule.

  22. The Peter Thomas Roth in box K is the mask not the moisturizer. I’m very happy with it!

  23. I will trade anyone that wants to trade for mine? According to this I’m getting E…

  24. Mine is 699 and according to my email from Sephora last night and this post my box is B. Tracking shows delivery for Saturday. I always get my box late.

    • I always seem to be one of the last to get my boxes, too. I just assume it’s because I live all the way over here in the Best Coast. Oops, West Coast. 😜

      • Same girl. California here.

      • Same, I live in the Bay Area. I always feel like I get my box a few days before they charge me for the next one.

  25. They did a horrible job with sending out foundation shades. I’m fair and received tan, so what was the point of sending it to me.. And it was the only thing in the box that was new to me so its disappointing.

    • Same here, I am very fair and getting dark sand or something along those lines. Seems not very well thought out and kind of random. I was really hoping for foundation if it was a good match.

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!



Get alerts on your desktop for the best deals and spoilers!