Posted by My Subscription Addiction on in Play! By Sephora Spoilers, Subscription Box Spoilers | Tags: play by sephora | 66 comments

Play! By Sephora September 2018 FULL SPOILERS Box #715, #723, #772 & #780!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

Screen Shot 2017-02-18 at 9.12.22 AM

We have the full spoilers for four of the September Play! By Sephora boxes!

The theme for September is “Next Gen Beauty”.

Box #772 will include:

Sephora play september box 772

Box #723 will include:

Sephora play september box 723

Box #780 will include:

Sephora play september box 780

Box #715 will include:

And here’s a look at all the products that may be in your September box:

What do you think of the spoilers? 

Check out our Play! by Sephora reviews, and all of our reviews of Cheap Subscription Boxes to find more similarly priced subscription boxes!

Written by My Subscription Addiction

My Subscription Addiction

My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

All views in this review are the opinion of the author. My Subscription Addiction will never accept payment in exchange for a review, but will accept a box at no cost to provide honest opinions on the box. This post may contain affiliate/referral links. If you buy something, MSA may earn an affiliate commission. Read the complete My Subscription Addiction disclosure.

66 Comments

  1. Box #749 … someone?

  2. I have box 723… I already have the boscia gel, truth serum, hangover primer, AND grace in regular size. Dammit!! Lol. At least I love all those items already. I can put them in a travel bag I guess..

  3. I have box #: 731. Does anybody know what is in there?!?!

    • I am getting 731 too and have no idea what is in it, yet!

      • I have the same #731… nothing?

  4. The value difference in these box variations is ridiculous. And does anyone, ANYONE not have a sample of Porefessional already? It’d be nice if they retired the products that have been around for years and evened out the value. It’s my experience that they don’t take your profile into account when assigning you a box. I am happy with one product I’m being sent. I also thing it’s cheap to send Sephora brand samples.

  5. hey, does anyone else have this problem: I looked on my Sephora play website, it said I was getting this box, however when it came in the mail today, I got a totally different box, so I called Sephora, and they said OH WELL, sorry, that’s rude, I look for my box surprise, and get another type of box…Sephora play , your really going down hill….

    • I think you have to be logged in to be able to see the box you are getting, otherwise if you go to their website or follow the link on the email Sephora sends without logging in, you’ll see one of the many versions for that month at random.

      • my box number and what is showing up as what’s in my box are different. ugh, Sephora!

  6. How do you get on the waitlist for trades? Anyone know?

  7. How do you get on the waitlist for trades?

  8. I’m ok with my box #772 but I don’t care for make up items. Wish I could swap for the OLE serum cuz I really want to try that. On waitlist for swaps 🙁 so there goes that.

    • But if anyone wants to swap, I don’t care for the Make up forever or the Too faced. Wouldn’t mind swapping the Peter Thomas Roth as I have that on the way already for another set. I’m more interested in the other skin care items I didn’t get – OLE, Clinique and Sunday Riley.

    • How do you get on the waitlist for trades?

      • I dont know how I ended up on the wait list. I think I was browsing around on the swap page and it said sign in to swap, then it put me on the waitlist. bummer cuz I have product from Ipsy, Sephora Play, Birchbox, and Macy’s August and Sept that I would love to swap. I’m more looking for skin care than make up.

  9. How do you find out what box you’re getting?

    My order number is 21535647901

    So I’m guessing I’m box #901? Not sure though because I never see any spilers for my boxes.

    Does anyone know what in my box (and if I’m deciphering my box # correctly)?

    • Your box number is the last three numbers on your “item” number not your order number. To see your item number log in to your Sephora account from a computer or your cellphone’s browser. It will show there. Sephora’s app won’t show it.

      • Thanks!!!!!

        Okay sho I got box #681 – anyone know what’s in that one?

        • If you log in on Sephora.com and go to Sephora.com/play and click where it says “current box” you’ll see what’s in your September’s box. I was able to see mine today (#723)
          You have to be logged in to see YOUR box, if not you will see a random one for September.

          • Thank you!

        • I also have box 681! I have not seen the spoilers here, though!

          • Someone called Maria posted this comment on a different post :

            Just got my 681.
            Sephora Lashcraft mascara
            Peter Thomas Roth Hungarian Thermal Water mask
            Nudestix Lip Cheek pencil
            Too Faced Hangover primer
            Sunday Riley Tidal cream
            V&R flowerbomb perfume

          • Thanks Chiara! I’m excited about this box – I’m getting 681 too. The Sunday Riley stuff is spendy so I’ll probably love it, ha. I’d do anything for another sample of the Lancer Method Polish stuff…it’s so good, but expensive enough where I’m probably not going to purchase. But I do love it.

        • Yes. I got the same box anc it arrived yesterday. If you want to see a picture and have Instagram my user name is pammy709.
          PTR Hungarian thermal water mineral rich atomic heat mask. Sounds super interesting.
          sundayriley Tidal brightening enzyme water cream.
          toofaced hangover replenishing face primer.
          nudestix intense matte lip + cheek pencil in the shade Kiss.
          sephora lashcraft big volume mascara in black.
          viktorandrolf Flower bomb nectar perfume sample.

  10. Well, I thought most of the August Sephora boxes were fantastic, and I almost resubbed, but I decided to wait and see what the September variations were. Glad I waited, cuz they’re just not that appealing to me. I don’t think I’ve ever received a foundation/tinted skin product that actually matched my skin in any of my sub boxes (not just Sephora), so I’m never happy to see them. (I’m between Porcelain and Beige, pale in the winter and a couple of shades darker by the end of summer, with a definite pink undertone.) I do select the foundation samples with multiple colors when I order from Sephora cuz I can blend two of the blister samples to try if they’ve actually included a really light shade. I’m always happy to see lippies, eyeshadow and blush (not highlighters!) to experiment with. Over the last couple of years highlighters seem to be trying to make people look like disco balls which is not something I aspire to. Some products labeled illuminators are more to my liking, so I’m happy to see them. I do have a pet peeve with Sephora: including their house brand as one of the subscription box items. I would be much more receptive to trying their house brand if they were included as a bonus item and not one of the regular items, especially if there was a name brand item in the box to compare it with. So for now I’ll stick to their Favorites collections and their newer one time purchase boxes which I’ve been very happy with .

    • I completely agree. I don’t think they should include their brand in the boxes unless its for a bonus either! Or if they do it should be a full size not a sample size. I’m abt to give up on them 😒😒

  11. i don’t know what is going on with Sephora play….they just don’t say anything about the boxes anymore, I found out what my box 715 is going to be on my website today….but 2 of the items are not the same as this site says, so be careful gals, these may not be the same as you get….look up these items on your website first..

    • tammy g,

      I noticed the same thing. I am getting box 715, too. I think what you see on the website is what you get…
      We will see!

  12. Does anyone want to swap for 723?

  13. No FOMO here. Lots of repeats.

  14. This month is pretty boring

  15. I have #707… anyone know what’s in that?

    • #707 is the following:
      Peter Thomas Roth – Hungarian Thermal Water Mineral-Rich Atomic Heat Mask
      Sunday Riley – Tidal Brightening Enzyme Water Cream
      Too Faced – Hangover Replenishing Face Primer
      Nudestix – Intense Matte Lip + Cheek Pencil in Kiss
      Sephora Collection – LashCraft Big Volume Mascara in Black
      Victor&Rolf – Flowerbomb Nectar

      • I just got my 707 today, all the things I was excited about (the Sunday Riley, Nudestix, and PTR) are not in the box, instead it’s Clinique moisturizer, Marc Jacobs eyeliner, and Ole Henriksen serum.

    • truth serum, clinique dramatically different hydrating jelly, too faced hangover primer mark jacobs eyeliner in earth, sephora collection mascara
      belif true cream moisturizing bomb
      🙁 🙁 🙁
      worst box I have received

  16. My box # is 681 anyone else have that box #?

    • I do. Tracking says I should get it today. I’ll post what I got if it’s not up yet.

    • I’m #681 too!

    • I have 681 too and it just got delivered-it’s the same products listed for 707 above (also I think the same one that was reviewed by MSA).

      • Thank you Kathy

    • Just got it
      Sephora Lashcraft mascara
      Peter Thomas Roth Hungarian Thermal Water mask
      Nudestix Lip Cheek pencil
      Too Faced Hangover primer
      Sunday Riley Tidal cream
      V&R flowerbomb perfume

      • Thanks! I’m actually pretty happy with this. I want to try the PTR and the Tidal! 🙂

      • Thank you Maria

  17. #707 is the following:

    Peter Thomas Roth – Hungarian Thermal Water Mineral-Rich Atomic Heat Mask
    Sunday Riley – Tidal Brightening Enzyme Water Cream
    Too Faced – Hangover Replenishing Face Primer
    Nudestix – Intense Matte Lip + Cheek Pencil in Kiss
    Sephora Collection – LashCraft Big Volume Mascara in Black
    Victor&Rolf – Flowerbomb Nectar

    • This is my box. I would have liked to try the cactus cream but I am still happy with this box.

      • I’m happy with this box too 🙂 I wanted to try either the Ole Henrickson or the Boscia cactus cream, but I’m pretty excited about the overall items I’m getting.

    • I am 707 and the website shows I will receive – truth serum, clinique dramatically different hydrating jelly, too faced hangover primer mark jacobs eyeliner in earth, sephora collection mascara
      belif true cream moisturizing bomb
      🙁 🙁 🙁

  18. I am 749, anyone have any clues what’s in that box?

  19. Yay!!!!! I have 723. Can’t believe my luck. This is my first Play box after an eight-month hiatus, and they are totally getting me time time around. Ah-mazing. And totally makes up for the ipsy shipment this month (I got the not-terrific products, somehow – not even one of the exciting ones). So happy. Thank you MSA for making my day!

    • I have 723 too and am so excited. Play has been spot on for me with variations <3 <3 <3

  20. im 715 and pretty happy i already own the too face primer which is ok

  21. Of course I get the worst box! #780! I have gotten every single one of those items before!! I am done with play!

    • Do you want to trade for 723?

    • The hydrating jelly is a new product, which box did you get it in? I’m actually quite curious to try it. I can’t use Clinique’s Dramatically Different moisturizer because it has oil in it, but this appears to be oil-free.

  22. Any other 360s out there?

  23. Box #764 is the exact same as #772 exceot the “SEPHORA COLLECTION LashCraft Big Volume Mascara” is swapped out for the “NUDESTIX Intense Matte Lip + Cheek Pencil in Kiss”

    So Box #764 contains:
    MAKE UP FOR EVER Ultra HD Perfector Skin Tint Foundation SPF 25
    PETER THOMAS ROTH Hungarian Thermal Water Mineral-Rich Moisturizer
    TOO FACED Hangover Replenishing Face Primer
    NUDESTIX Intense Matte Lip + Cheek Pencil in Kiss
    BOSCIA Cactus Water Hydrated Cream
    CHLOÉ Nomade Eau de Parfum

    • Thanks for posting this. My box is 764. Excited to get it now.

  24. I’m 772 and I’m irritated. I’ve already received the Makeup Forever stuff a few months ago. What’s with the repetitive stuff?

  25. I am #699. I hope it includes the Boscia cactus water cream!

    • I have 699 too 😊

    • I have 699. According to my Play! profile we are getting:

      OLEHENRIKSEN Truth Serum
      CLINIQUE Dramatically Different Hydrating Jelly
      TOO FACED Hangover Replenishing Face Primer
      MARC JACOBS BEAUTY Shameless Youthful-Look 24H Foundation SPF 25 in Light Y210
      SEPHORA COLLECTION Lashcraft Big Volume Mascara in Black
      TOM FORD Black Orchid

      This may be my last box. Not a single product I’m truly excited about.

      • I don’t mind all of that except the mascara. I get a ton of mascara all the dang time. I’ve never tried any of the others.

      • Want to trade for 723?

    • I have 699 as well 🤩😎

      • I’m box#699 too! So excited to see what we get! Where’s the spoiler im so impatient🤣😋

        • This is what we get in 699

          OLEHENRIKSEN Truth Serum
          CLINIQUE Dramatically Different Hydrating Jelly
          TOO FACED Hangover Replenishing Face Primer
          MARC JACOBS BEAUTY Shameless Youthful-Look 24H Foundation SPF 25 in Light Y210
          SEPHORA COLLECTION Lashcraft Big Volume Mascara in Black
          TOM FORD Black Orchid

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!