Butter London Mystery Bundle Available Now!

This post may contain referral/affiliate links. If you buy something, MSA may earn a commission. Read the full disclosure.

There’s a new Mystery Gift Bundle from Butter London is available now! (Thanks for the heads up, Luna!)

The Box: Mystery Gift Bundle

The Cost: $25

The Products: Includes 7 products, a $101 value

Are you grabbing a box? Want to see this reviewed?

Written by MSA


My Subscription Addiction is the #1 site for all things subscription boxes. Check out the most Popular Subscription Box posts, our coupons, and the List of Subscription Boxes you can try for Free!

Posted in Subscription Box News| 19 comments


  1. I received mine in the mail today for those interested, this is what I received.

    * A curved floral emory board
    * Stroke of Wow mascara 4ml
    * Weightless Matte Plumping Lip Colour in Thrilled 3g
    * 2 nail polishes in Ruby Murray & Yummy Mummy (full size) 11ml ea
    * Glazen Eye Gloss in Moonshine 5.5g
    * 5 Nail Scrubbers (prep and nail polish remover wipes)

    • My eyegloss was dried out, making it unusable.

    • Great colors! I hope I get the same!!!

  2. I got a set of their eye glazes, the free gift thing and the mystery box.
    Their Oil Slick eye glaze ( which I will likely go back and purchase once I see the intensity and properties of the lighter 4 shades I bought in the special offer) has the look of the classic UD oil slick duochrome shadow. Hope it’s similar ( but not made or tested in China like UD is now).

  3. Ugh lol..got the mystery gift along with the free gift set and a 6 piece polish set that was on sale for $30. Great deal!!

  4. Butter London is my fave nail polish! I have too much polish, but this is the only brand I still keep buying. I love their basecoat and topcoat, but it’s sooo pricey!

    I like the mystery gifts to try out their make-up, too. so I also bought a set and a $5 fashion size polish to get free shipping after the 20% was taken off.

    The 20% off code doesn’t look like it has a minimum, so that will take $5 off the shipping cost if anyone just wants the mystery gift.

  5. There’s a nice free gift bundle with $50 purchase. Oh no, I’m tempted.

  6. There’s a black and white silouette of seven items on their ‘offer’ page for the mystery items – not sure if it’s an exact representation or not.

    But is so, looks like two polishes; a mascara; a satin matte lipstick?; a curvy thing that is likely a file and buffer; a rounded corner small square thing the right shape for a glazen eye gloss, and a larger square compact I can’t place (maybe a eyeshadow duo clutch or blush or highlighter?

    • Large square thing actually could be scrubber/remover wipes.

  7. Code 20Welcome18 got me 20% off. Not sure how much you have to spend, but I spent over $50.

  8. Tempting! Less than $5 an item isn’t bad, and they have some pretty polish colors and other interesting makeup. But I might not end up liking the shades…so tough!

  9. Maybe with some spoilers I may bite, but not comfortable going in blind.

    • Same! I love their polish and want to try their makeup, but I have a lot of boxes so Ill wait for spoilers. I tell ya tho, at my age, 43, Macy’s has been awesome! Their makeup bags I actually use and get compliments if someone around me sees me pull one out of my purse. This month was this gym bag sting tote, super cute! Ok im rambling now lol!

  10. Shipping is 6.99 FYI, or add 15$ more to get to the 40$ free shipping threshold.

  11. Ooooh, does anyone know if these are good?

    • IIRC, the last one I bought from them had 2 polishes, a lip gloss, an eyeshadow duo, mascara and … something else possibly? I was happy with it for the price. The colors weren’t the most subtle (very red lip color, silver glitter polish and red polish).

      • Thank you!

  12. Pass shipping is $6.99…ugh

  13. Oooh if I knew they would include their new peel off glitter polishes I’d buy it in a heartbeat!

Post a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments may not appear immediately. More info here.

Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content!