Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Looking for the latest spoiler for this box? Find it here:
BoxyCharm ($32 per month) is one of the most popular beauty subscription boxes that we review, with lots of loyal customers. They promise 5 full-size beauty products each month from a variety of both indie and... read more.
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Liz is the founder of My Subscription Addiction. She's been hooked on subscription boxes since 2011 thanks to Birchbox, and she now subscribes to over 100 boxes. Her favorites include POPSUGAR Must Have, FabFitFun, and any box that features natural beauty products!
Join the Conversation
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.
If anyone has the spray and wants to trade I’ll trade two palettes! This one and a color pop one from a cpl boxes ago! I’ll throw in other samples too!! I have so many products and really wanted to try the spray regardless of the bad reviews!! PLEASE email me jennifersparber33 at gmail
Reply
Sarah
I’m getting the spray but would love the pallet! I also don’t need/want the eyecream so I can throw that one in with it. I’m very lucky with that being 50! (Which I’m still getting used to turning! Ack! Haha)
If anyone wants to swap, let me know!
Reply
J
Does anyone have the spray and want to swap for the palette? I’ll throw in aanother palette and some samples?? PLEASE email me if so jennifersparber33 at gmail
Reply
J
Did you swap yet?
Reply
J
I’ll swap too and trade something else for your eye cream! Leave your email and if other swaps fail let me know.
Reply
Jamie
I’ll take that swap.
Reply
Lauren
Hi, I am pretty certain I am getting this box, and I absolutely would way rather have the mask than the eye gel. Is anyone interested in a swap?
Reply
annalily
I’m waiting to see my palette in person before I decide if I want to trade or not. However, For peeps who want it, I saw on the Crown website they’re giving it away free with the purchase of a $20 brush set. It’s not quite the same as getting it in boxy, but it’s still a good deal if you’re worried about getting it in trades.
Reply
Lucy
Hi! I just watched a SidneySmallsBeauty video and the palette looks gorgeous! The colors are amazing (no dulls browns at all!) She got variation 1.
Reply
Cami
I’m getting the tarte spray, which I already have. Anyone wanna trade for the palette?
Reply
Renee dishman
I’d love to trade the palette for the spray! You can contact me on Instagram reneedishman901
Reply
Sarah
I’m getting the spray, but I really want the pallet!
If anyone wants to swap, I’m totally up for it!
Reply
J
What’s your info to reach you for trade?
Reply
Amanda
All I want is the tarte, farmacy and wander mascara..I’d be willing to trade the entire contents of my box for those 3 things…
Reply
Cami
I’ll trade for crown palette. It’s really the only thing I’m interested in
Reply
Courtney
And by the way I know this is off-topic but did you guys know the Birchbox samples are showing if you’ve selected all samples instead of all boxes option for the random selections already just wanted to let you know
Reply
Tiffany
Wow, I’ve been subbed for 3 years and I have to say this is the worst box I’ve gotten. I’m getting the eyeshadow so I’m pretty sure this is my variant. Such a disappointment. I’m caramel complected so I won’t be able to use the blush or the brow stuff. I don’t have bags or puffy eyes so the eyecream is pointless plus I have tons i have received over the past 3 yrs that are unopened from other subs. I’m not impressed with the same old colors that are in the pallet. The only thing that is just ok is the mascara even though I have tons of tubes unopened that are waiting to be used… At least it’s something I can use eventually at some point though. Last month the best month I’ve had in the 3 years so for this month to be the worst is crazy and disheartening. I had such high hopes. We are def paying the price for having such a successful month in June. 😣😢
Reply
Jamie
If you get the eye cream and I don’t I’ll buy it from you. I didn’t get the email so I have no idea what I’m getting. It’s really the only thing I want tbh.
Reply
Renee Dishman
Yes I’d love to trade my Instagram is reneedishman901 if you get the Farmacy I’ll trade you the eye cream cause I think this is my box and I want the Farmacy so bad!! If so my Instagram is reneedishman901
Courtney
Tiffany… I will straight trade you box for box if you get this variant. I already know I’m getting the tarte spray and all I want is the eye cream and pallet.
Reply
Tiffany
Ok Courtney! Sounds like a plan!
April jk
How do you guys know what you’re getting already?
Jen
If she does not want to trade you then can I please trade you? This is my box too. If so send me your email.
Nicole
I’m not really feeling this box. Everything looks so boring and nothing is relevant for me at all. The best thing is that eyebrow cream
Reply
Melissa
I agree, I canceled Boxycharm 2 months ago…I thought the June box was great and was surprised that it was not their Birthday box… I will probably pick back up with them in a few months once I go through all of my stash… I do LOVE FabFitFun and am curious what the PopSugar Fall box has in store 🙂
Reply
Pink5
I usually get variant #1 boxes, so I’m okay with this.
Reply
Michelle Bross
I got the Tarte spray so I’m really really hoping my variant includes the Farmacy. I could care less what all the other stuff was it’s all just filler. Whenever they send a brow product it’s usually too light. My brows are almost black and I don’t wear pink liquid lipsticks. Which sure will be the second variant.
Reply
Brooke
I didn’t get an email to check my variation. Does anybody know what the message line stated?
Reply
Chrystal
I already know I’m receiving the palette, but now I may be getting the Dr Brandt as well? I’ve been subbed since March 2015 and this is easily the most disappointing variation I’ve seen!
Reply
Jamie
I’m so close to cancelling. Brie cream in taupe? My brows are so dark they’re almost black. The last brow product they sent me was also in a too light shade and useless. The palette is ugly imo. The Tarte spray is a skin mist and not a setting spray which would have been useful for summertime. I know other ppl are excited for the mascara, but I have a literal pile of mascaras waiting to be used. Another blush that I find boring. The only 2 things I’m really interested in are the farmacy and Dr Brandt and if course I can’t get both in one box lolol. The curse of the variants!
The only reason I’m staying subbed right now is bc I want to see what boxyluxe is going to be like – mainly the pricing and the extra items included. If luxe is double the price of the regular box I’m going to be so done especially with all these variants! Ugh!
Reply
Christine G
It’s going to be quarterly
Reply
Nicole
I’m on the fence about resubbing. If the mascara and brow cream are in all boxes I may go for it. Really would want farmacy (like everyone else) and don’t care about the spray vs palette.
Reply
Dani
Kind of confused about the Road trip theme, none of these products are something I would affix to that description. The palette looks like it belongs in a Fall box.
Reply
Michelle
Take their “themes” with a grain of salt, they never really go along with the actual items in the box.
Reply
Lexi
I got the email saying the Tarte spray will be in my box. Hope the other variations have a lippie instead of the brow cream.
Reply
Ms peaches
I will be canceling again after two years . Since I have dark skin a brows I won’t be able to use the blush or the brow stuff because its in Taupe. Lately I have been giving away more stuff then I keep.
Reply
Kailene
I like when hey announce the major items that everyone is getting and those are all the same and then the cheaper items are the variants. It seems weird they would put the highest value items together considering the price difference between both variant was 4 dollars each so it just makes sense they would have mixed them together to even the price. But I guess if everyone likes their items they wouldn’t really care about an 8 dollar difference in value. I don’t think they will do this type of box again it seems like it’s nothing but negative response.
Reply
PaulaG
I have been feeling like the boxes have been containing more of the Cheever brands and they just aren’t as good as when I signed up over a year ago. If next month doesn’t look more exciting I’m canceling. This box is all going in my junk drawer!
Reply
Lexi
Also the dr Brandt eye cream is dry and horrible. Sucks that people getting the mist get the two better products of the bunch.
Reply
Lexi
That crown brush palette is free on their site with a $20 eye brush set 😳. Still love boxy but hate crown shadows.
Reply
Sandy
I seen that too, $19 brush set and get this palette free gift with it. Maybe people who don’t get it could buy on the crown site.
Reply
Danielle
I know several people have already asked this but I don’t see any responses.
***How ae people figuring out which version they got????***
In previous months I’ve seen people mention the package weight on their shipping confirmation. On this thread someone mentioned getting an email confirming they got the Tarte spray? My box hasn’t even shipped yet. If there is some way to tell please share. If I am not getting the farmacy mask I am going to try ordering a second box. Thanks to anyone who can help!
Reply
Sarah
You could always trade. Many will prefer the Dr. Brant. Like me! But that could work for you too.
Reply
Renee Dishman
I’ll trade u the dr. Brandt I think this is my variation! If so my Instagram is reneedishman901
Kristin
I’ve already ordered a second box in hopes of getting the farmacy mask in at least one of them! Maybe this is why sub boxes do variations lol. I’m not sure why I want it so bad! I’ve never even tried it, but I LOVE mask!!
Reply
Danielle
I feel the same. As I mentioned above I’m considering ordering a second one as well. If I end up with 2 Farmacy masks, all the better! It’s rated 5 stars on Sephora and I hear so many good things about the brand. Hope you get one!
Adri
Some people have received emails saying click here to find out a product in your box but not everyone has received it. I haven’t received it but my friend did and us getting the tarte spray.
Reply
Lacey
I received an email saying I’m getting the palette… super bummed 🙁
Danielle
Thank you for answering!😀
I used to get my box pretty late but I recently quit and resubbed so maybe I’ll find out sooner in case I need to get a 2nd box for that Farmacy mask. I doubt many people will want to give that up if they receive it.
katie
Thank you for answering her question! I also saw quite a few people ask and hadn’t seen an answer.
Jo
Really hoping for the Farmacy and Tarte!
Reply
paulag
Me too! I love the Farmacy brand.
Reply
Our reviewers research, test, and recommend the best subscriptions and products independently; click to learn more about our editorial guidelines. We may receive commissions on purchases made through links on our site.
Please do not enter your email address in the Name field or in the comment content. Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *. Remember to post with kindness and respect. Comments with offensive language, cruelness to others, etc will not be approved. See our full comment policy here.